High Court of Punjab and HaryanaSAO/59/2014disposed of

Baljit Kaur And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-08-10Mr. Justice Krishna Murari10 pages

!"##$%&%'()*)&"+ !,-%".!)/!'0"1#/& 233#,,!'"& 4& "!"# )'-!5!'0"1#/& 2 #&3'0#'"& ( 67 88

/#&#'"(8 & /9%,!!%'+0:$!"# /"1#!33#,,!'"& /##/!-1!/9!++ )'-!5 &##3!,% )/%+0:$!"# /7 /#&3'0#'" //%1!'"!%'+0:$!"# //#&3'0#'"&;!'0 88 1# !33#,,!'"& %' "1%& !33#!, !/# "1# &)$$#&&/& !&<!'" %'*1+3,!%'"%<11!0%,#0!&)%"/0#$,!/!"%'!*!%'&""!"# )'-!5+ #3)"=99%&&%'#/!'0#1&%,0!/+5#&%0#&0##'0!'"8/#&3'0#'"& "> /!0#$,!/!"%'"1!",!'09#!&)/%'* ?!'!,& 9!/,!&9#'"%'#0%'"1# 1#!0%'*"1#3,!%'":#&"&%'"1#3,!%'"%!'0"1!"0##'0!'"8/#&3'0#'"&

"@<1!/#<'#/&%'3&&#&&%'!'00##'0!'"&"A1!:#*" '$'$#/'%#/%*1"+"%",#!'0%'"#/#&"%'"1#3/3#/"=!'0"1!""1#/#:#')# #'"/%#&3#/"!%'%'*""1#,!'0%'0%&3)"#1!&*"'##$"'"1#/%*1"&"1# 3,!%'"%!'00##'0!'"& "@ 1#&)%""1#3,!%'"%<!&0#$/##01,0%'*"1!""1#3,!%'"% <!&$8<'#/<%"1"1#/$8&1!/#/&!&3#/%:%,)/"-)0*9#'"!'00#$/## 0!"#0 #3"#95#/ + >@ <1%$1 1!0 !""%'#0 %'!,%"= 1!:%'* '" 5##' $1!,,#'*#05="1#0##'0!'"&"<!&)/"1#/1#,0"1!""1#0##'0!'"&!/#!" ,%5#/"="$,!%9"1#%/"%",#!&3#/,!<1#3,!%'"%%,#0!'!33#!,5#/#"1# 00%"%'!,%&"/%$")0*#+7)01%!')/%'*"1#3#'0#'$="1#!33#!,+!' !33,%$!"%')'0#/ /0#/ ),# <!&%,#05=1%'0#/3!

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

%,,#*!,!&"1#!33#!,"1#3,!%'"%8!33#,,!'"&1!&5##'</'*,=0%&9%&&#0 '"1#5!&%&!'!33,%$!"%'%,#05=/#&3'0#'"&;!'0)'0#/ /0#/

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

/'#0 $)'&#, / "1# 3,!%'"%8 !33#,,!'"& !'0 <%"1!'5-#$"%:#")'0#/&"!'0"1#$'"/:#/&=%':,:#0%'"1#$!&#!'0"1# %93!$""1#0#$/##<1%$1<!&3!&&#0%'!:)/"1#3,!%'"%8!&<!'" %'*1 5= "/%!, )/"+ 1!:# $!/#),,= *'# "1/)*1 "1# !$"& !'0 $%/$)9&"!'$#&"1#$!&#1#&)%"!&<!'"%'*1D3,!%'"%<!&0#$/##0 ""1##E"#'""1!"1#<!&$8&1!/#/!&3#/%:%,)/"-)0*9#'"!'00#$/## 0!"#0#3"#95#/+>@<1%$11!0!""%'#0%'!,%"=F%"1"1#!&&%&"!'$# $)'&#, / "1# !33#,,!'"& 1!:# *'# "1/)*1 "1# -)0*9#'" 0!"#0 #3"#95#/+>@+<1%$11!&5##'!33#'0#0<%"1"1%&!33#!,!&!''

8A+!'0%"%'0%$!"#&"1!"'#%/!%'*1!&3,!%'"%1!0%,#0!&)%"!*!%'&"

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

F #&"!"#0"1!" 5)'0!/%#&)'%$%3!,99%""##+7)01%!'!1!:#5##' #E"#'0#0+1#5/)*1""1#'"%%$!"%'"1#$3=<1%$1%& E FB .!/!9 1!'0

F 3/0)$#0 "1# $'&,%0!"%' /#$/0 :%,,!*# !%5<!, .!,!' 9%" 1!'0

FA &"!"#0"1!"%'"1#$'&,%0!"%'0)/%'*"1# =#!/;8!'0@+!$)"<!&!33,%#0""1#1,0%'*& "1#<'#/&"0#0)$",!'0/$99'3)/3&#& ,%&".!9% #&1%0)/%'*"1#$'&,%0!"%'<!&3/#3!/#0 !'0 "1# &!9# %& E FAB %& !,?%!" %'*1

!"<!/% # &"!"#0 "1!" $'&,%0!"%' %' :%,,!*# "? 3,!$#'"1#5!&%&"1#-!9!5!'0%#&/"1#=#!/8

A1#1!9,!"#1G%&&!!/!5!/'0/)' !"%&!&!"

!%9!'! !?%!"H <!& #'"#/#0 %' "1# '!9# /!9

!'$1!=!""#/"1#$'&,%0!"%'+"1#,!'09#!&)/%'*

@.8><!&/#$/0#0%'"1#'!9#/!9 !'$1!=!"+

F%/9!,%'*1+9/%?%'*1

F@ !'0%/!%'*1

F> <!&&"!"#0"1!""1#,!'0%&5#%'*)&#0/$99' 3)/3&#&"1#:%,,!*# ' "1# $'&%0#/!"%' "1# !5:# #:%0#'$#+ 3/0)$#05="1#3,!%'"%&+1,0"1!""1#,!'0<1%$1<!& "!?#')"/9"1#1,0%'*&+"1#<'#/&1),0/#:#/" 5!$? " "1# $8&1!/#/& !'0 "1# <'#/ ),# A "1#

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

&1!,,:#&"%'"1#3,!%'"%!'00##'0!'"&A"@;+<1 !/#"1#<'#/&%'3&&#&&%'"1#&!9##$/##&1##" 5# 3/#3!/#0 !$$/0%'*,=+ !'0 "1# %,# 5# $'&%*'#0 " /#$/0/9H 3#/)&!,"1#!5:#&!%0-)0*9#'"3!&&#0%'!:)/%/! %'*1<1%&'"!3!/"=%'"1%&$!&#%'0%$!"#&"1!"5=!'#E83!/"#0#$/##%' 1%&!:)/"1#%:%,)/"1!00#"#/9%'#0"1#/%*1"&"1#:%,,!*#/&:%&8I8:%& "1# ,!'0 <1%$1 <!& /#$/0#0 %' "1# '!9# /!9 !'$1!=!" !"#/ $'&,%0!"%'%'"1#:%,,!*#%'"1#=#!/8A"!33#!/&"1!""1#,!'0<!& 5#%'* )&#0 / $99' 3)/3&#& "1# :%,,!*#/& 1)*1 "1# /!9

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

0 1# ,<#/ 33#,,!"# )/" !33#!/& " 1!:# %*'/#0 "1# !$" "1!"

0##'0!'"& "@1%'0#/%'*1+!/5!'&.!)/!'0!/5!'&.!)/<1 !/# &)$$#&&/& !5) %'*1 1!0 !09%""#0 "1# $,!%9 3,!%'"% !&<!'" %'*1 !'0 0##'0!'" > 1!0 5##' 9!0# ! 3!/"= ' "1# 5!&%& 1%& !33,%$!"%')'0#/ /0#/ ),# ##'0!'">1!0$,!%9#0"1!" 1# <!& 5'!%0# 3)/$1!&#/ 1!:%'* 3)/$1!&#0 "1# 3/3#/"= / ! &!,# $'&%0#/!"%'!'0"1#3/3#/"=5#%'*J/!K%!"/)?!6%#"1#<'#/&1%3 "!"# )'-!5+ 1# 1!0 5#$9# <'#/ %' !' !)$"%' <1%$1 1!& 5##' $'%/9#05=&!,#0##00!"#0)'# +1#/%*1"&0##'0!'">

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

:)/ "1# 3,!%'"%+ %" <%,, '" 5# 5%'0%'* ' "1# /%*1"& ! 3#/&' <1 %& '" ! 3!/"= " "1# ,%"%*!"%' 1# ,<#/ 33#,,!"# )/" !33#!/&"1!:#%*'/#0"1#3/%'$%3,#"1!"3,!%'"%%&"1#09%')&,%")&"1# $!&#!'01#$!''"5#$93#,,#0"$'"#&"1%&/%*1"&!*!%'&"!3!/"=1# ,<#/33#,,!"#)/"1!&'"!//%:#0!"!$'$,)&%'"1!""1#3,!%'"%1!0 5##'$,,)0%'*<%"10##'0!'"&"A<1!/#"1#"!"#!)"1/%"%#&"%& !33!/#'"/9"1#-)0*9#'"3!&&#05="1#"/%!,)/""1!""1#"!"#1!0%,#0 !' !33,%$!"%' 0#'=%'* "1# "%",# "1# 3,!%'"%8 !33#,,!'"& " 0#& '" !33#!/"5#!$!&#<1#/#0##'0!'"&"A1!05##'$,,)0%'*<%"1"1# 3,!%'"%1#!:=')&,%#&'"1#"!"#!)"1/%"%#&"#&"!5,%&1"1#!$")!, <'#/&1%3"1#3/3#/"='$!&#!'=!""

#93"%&5#%'*9!0#5=!'=3#/&' "$,!%9!3/3#/"=:#&"%'*%'/!9 !'$1!=!"+"1#)'%$%3!,/3/!"%' /"1#"!"#)"1/%"%#&+%"%&"1#5)'0#'0)"="1#"!"

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

33#!,#E3#0%"%)&,=%'$!&# %"%&'"<%"10/!<'5="1#3,!%'"%8!33#,,!'"&"1%'*&!%0%'"1%&/0#/ <%,,3/#-)0%$#"1#/%*1"&0##'0!'"&;!'0"#&"!5,%&1"1#%/$,!%9%' !$$/0!'$#<%"1,!<%'$!&#"1#$'"/:#/&=%&,#"3#'/#*!/0%'*"1#"%",# /#&3'0#'"& ; !'0 " 5# #&"!5,%&1#0 %' !' %'0#3#'0#'" ,%"%*!"%' 3#'0%'*/"1#/<%&# )*)&"+ &!'-!