Surjan Singh v. Harjit Singh And ORS
!" #$%&'%()*)&+,- ./0#+)+12 344%55#+$ 6%/*.*
#/0)$)+12#+7&$2%/* 3-%*4&+7%+$*
&/#8,
&+9:5%!/-.*$)(%--;#5)# /%*%+$, !/-8)$/&/#<76&(#$%'&/$2%#44%55#+$- === --;#5)#<- /#5"
2#55%+1%)+$2%)+*$#+$/%1.5#/*%(&+7#44%#5)*$&0.718%+$#+7 7%(/%% 7#$%7 >- 4#**%7 :? $2% 5%#/+%7 775- )*$/)($ .71%< #/+ #/#+)+ )6)544%#5@>@ >)+(#*%$)$5%7#*A
9.42&57)+1$2%0.718%+$#+77%(/%%7#$%7- >4#**%7 :?$2%5%#/+%7775- )6)5.71% %+)&/)6)*)&+"<B2#7./#2):C2%/%:?$2% *.)$'&/7%(5#/#$)&+')5%7:?/%*4&+7%+$&-45#)+$)''C#*7%(/%%7<2&57)+12)8 $& :% &C+%/ &' %5%($/)()$? $.:%C%55 (&++%($)&+ :%#/)+1 &-
< - )+*$#55%7 )+ 2)* #1/)(.5$./#5 5#+7 *)$.#$%7 )+ D)55#1% #E)54./< %2*)5 B2#7./ #2):<)*$/)($ #/+ #/#+*)+(% >
<:%*)7%*/%*$/#)+)+17%'%+7#+$&*- $&'/&8)+$%/'%/)+1)+$2%.*%&'*#)7$.:%C%55@%5%($/)()$?(&++%($)&+:%#/)+1 &-
#* #5*& '/&8 7)*(&++%($)+1 #+7 $/#+*'%//)+1 $2% *#)7 $.:%C%55 %5%($/)()$?(&++%($)&+- F%#/+%7 &.+*%5(&+$%+7*$2#$0&)+$4/&4%/$?C#*4#/$)$)&+%7:? )/#+0#+)+12<'#$2%/&'#44%55#+$7%'%+7#+$&-#+7#+$&G2)+12'#$2%/&'
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
!! "
#
$ % I F%#/+%7 775- )6)5 .71% %+)&/ )6)*)&+"< B2#7./ #2): 7%(/%%7 $2% *.)$ :? $#G)+1 )+$& #((&.+$ $2#$ #+$&G2 )+12 '#$2%/ &' $2%
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
"< B#:#5 )+12 ;"< 8#/0)$ )+12 ;>" #5*& *.44&/$%7 #+7 (&//&:&/#$%7$2%6%/*)&+&'$2%45#)+$)''-F%#/+%7775- )6)5.71% %+)&/ )6)*)&+"< B2#7./ #2):#5*& 2%57 $2#$ %6%+ )' $2%/% C#* +& /%'%/%+(% &'
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
$2%'#$2%/*&'$2%4#/$)%*<#*#5*&$2#$$2%$.:%C%55(&++%($)&+&+$2%5#+7&' /%*4&+7%+$&-@45#)+$)''9*'#$2%/C#*$/#+*'%//%7)+$2%+#8%&'$2%#44%55#+$ 7%'%+7#+$&--4#/$'/&8$2%*#8%<$2%/%)*#+#1/%%8%+$ H-"1)6)+1 /%'%/%+(%&'$/#+*'%/ &'$.:%C%55 %H%(.$%7 :%$C%%+#44%55#+$7%'%+7#+$ &- #+7 /%*4&+7%+$ &-45#)+)$''- & 7&.
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
&.+*%5 '&/ $2% #44%55#+$ 2#* (#+7)75? (&+(%7%7 $2#$ $2% 5#+7 &' '#$2%/ &' #44%55#+$7%'%+7#+$ &- #* C%55 #* /%*4&+7%+$ &- 2#7 %5%($/)( $.:%C%55 )+*$#55%7&+$2%)//%*4%($)6%5#+7*#+7&+%H(2#+1%&'$2%5#+7*:%$C%%+$2% '#$2%/*&'$2%4#/$)%*<#5&+1C)$2$2%5#+7<$2%$.:%C%55@%5%($/)()$?(&++%($)&+ C%/%#5*&$/#+*'%//%7#+7C%/%:%)+1.$)5)E%7&+$2%5#+7*<C2)(2'%55$&$2% *2#/% &' $2% '#$2%/* &' $2% 4#/$)%* %6%/ *)+(% $2% %H(2#+1% &' $2% 5#+7 )+ J.%*$)&+)+$2%?%#/
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
> *.44&/$)+1$2%*#8%<7&+&$')+7#+?)+')/8)$?C)$2$2%(&+(.//%+$')+7)+1* &''#($/%(&/7%7:?$2% &./$*:%5&C- &&$2%/4&)+$2#*:%%+#/1.%7- +$2%1)6%+'#($*#+7()/(.8*$#+(%*<+&J.%*$)&+&'5#C8.(25%** *.:*$#+$)#5J.%*$)&+&'5#C<#/)*%*'&/(&+*)7%/#$)&+-
-
- &% '
()* + ,*-
+ ,*-