Ajay Kumar Gupta v. Customs Excise And Service Tax Appellate Tribunal And ANR
!! " # $%&'()& !!)* !' +
!"
# $% & "
# '# ,
- ( +-!+$$+ !! - ( .+(+ $$+ //// ()*+(,(-.( )+ !$! ( 0 +# !%&$ 1+$+2234+( 0+5 $1+$+ 25 23$6 +
1 & 783$ *+# $%&'()& !!)* !$94!+1 +$+2)* !23 "+$+ !! +* +!!*! ! +$;
! +& ( : + + + #
1 !3
01 & 703+* )+ * !;
!4+
!"
)+ !+ !! ++ ! 6 ! 4+6 +5 +62< &!(2$+++
4+&! 8$$ :=7-=+ *( , > ? +&
4 +4
+++ +&! + + + !* + + ;
+&4++++ * *+ !! )+ &4;
* *+ ( :0+ $ + !8+()& !$ 6!$ 4!!*!* + ! 64+ . 6+ ! ( :':8+ )+$
1 & 73$+ &8$$ :=74 *+ 6 + 4 + ! 4!!*!* + ! ( :8$::':
+ 4+!*4 $ ! 6 !
=7 @& +$4++4+6+$ 6 + + !!+ ! , !
=74! + !! ! 64++ !
8$$ :=7$
+ )+ !! ! !4+ +.+ !++ * &*! :
:
4 + & 4 !! * . + ! * + 4 !* + )+5 !! + ++ !6! ! +* * 6+ +
6+
:7
$&4 !*! !6! !
4 + + 4+ + # !
$+4+$ ( :0+ 6!$4+! ++ !!4 +6*!* 4+ 4+ +# ! +$ !4 !*!*
( :8':
+4++ ! ! ( ::
=4 +! +4$ 6!$ )+ ! !*+)* !. 6+ !+ + + * *+ !! *0
$( +* + $ 6++ ++ 6 + )+)* !!!4+ ! +6 + +&+* !!++ $4; * ( :013* 4 !!
A 4$ 6!$ +! + + 4 4! ! 4+ +& + !! 2 4*!+ + +* ! + + ! 4 ! ( :0 ++&4* +4+4++ +( 8 4 ! 4+++ * ! *+#
1 !3 6!$++ 6 + + !! ( :4$! 6+! 6+ ! :
)+ 4 ! * . + ! +
+ !! 6+&*! ( 8 )+
#$!%
& '
(
#$$)*
+
!
, +
(
(
-
& .
#
*/
1
02.
#$$)*
/
(
3* #% / 0
+
/
( !*"
( 8 ++ 6&*! +!! +&+ !$ ++ 4$+ !! 4 !*! +&+ 6++ +!!+ ( :013$+ 4++!! 4++4 ;
*!! + $ + +!!+4+ + !!++# !
( :013
#
+ .+
4 .
.
( .
+ / !"
)+ ! ( :8( 8 + !*! &$ + ( :8
# $!%
.
+
$ /.+
..
+
5. +
#
*
(+
#
* .
.+ (.
(+
( 3
/ %
# * !"
)+ $ + !! 4 !*! + ( 8 +4 6&*!+ $+ ! *! ( :846+!!*+#
1 !3 +4+++*. ++ ! ! + ! 6!
&*! )+ $+ $+ $+* 6+ &4++4 ! +!*!+ ! + + + + + * $ !!
4! ! 7 + +#+ + !4+ & ( :
# !%
(. !
&
- -
.
-
6
6
+ - 6
6
/ +
.
.
.
-
. .
. . .+ 4
- -
3 % +
.
-
3 % +
+
/ ' 1
(
0 .
+ - 3 %
+
%
+
7
(
(
(
.
!
/
.8
. . . .
.
. .7
3 %
+
/
.8
. . . .
-
& . .
.
+ -
4
+
. .
+
7 3 %
.
$
!" B +&4 !*! ( 8 + +!*!4 ! +& ( :013$4++ +*
$!$* +* 6 &*! +! 4+ + 4$4+ ++ 4 ! !! + ( :
. 6+ !$+* +!*+)* !
A4+6! + !! *+5 !! +++&+* !!* .$ + 4 ++
1 !! 4 !!;
4++ + 4+++ !+ +$ 4+ . $+ )* !4 $ +
$+!+ +44! ! $* 64+ + *( :
6!$+ * !;
!4 4 + !! +!++ !4 !*!* +
+++4+++4 6+ 6+4 &*! 0 6!$+ !!!4 ++ )* !
1 & 783 + + #
1 !3
01 & 703 C++** $+ ! !!4 $(2.
*(3 ()*+(,(-.( 45.)6+.7 895.47
8*67
9(.-79+