Suresh Kumar v. Partap Singh And ANR
!"
#$%&'%()*)&+
!"
"! ,,, ! -.! /0
/
1%*%+$ #$% &!'"( )" ****
2345)+6%1/#217 + ("!,) !,$ - )) ("( ) ! ("!!,$,"
." ,"/ ' !/ ( ))/! ! 0 ))( ") ( / ) !)" /)"! "$ #( ",$ - ))( ! 1 "2"3)"!)! 2" ( ."( &/ &"" $ ")4 -" 56
" ( "& ! / ( ") ($ / !$ 7( ! / !)! 2" ! (("! $ " " ! , ! '! " ( ))!, $$
"!)! 2"8)! 2""("(/ ($!/
$ !,")" "/ (/"!
$55 ! ")" $ &! " ) ")( ' ."
2/%! ( ."7&/, '9 :") ") ,"/"1 9 ;
/ ! ( 9&!)! 2" (" " / !)! 2" ( ."( &/ &! "
($
)! ,$1 ) "</ "
$55!/ (, " ' (" <' '$ " / "!)! 2" ) ($ " ! )'"")!)! 2"! ! "/' !,$ (" !( " &4 &46& ! 0 ;
./) !,$ )) !)! 2"&( $! ("(!.1") ( ."( &/ / (/! ." ") . ) %! ( & / + !/ !
) 7 !",
" ))( " "/)" !! ((!!!$ ,"! ")( ;
/" ! ) " ! !"
(")$ &
" )'"") !)! 2" ! / "
, ! " )) ! ") !)! 2" $") + ") ))/! !,$ ." &' ! #! ! !( ! ! 9 + )! ,$ )),)" = ." /"! !&' ! #! !!(! ! 6 5 4<(& ("!
9 ,) !,$ )) 3 >!(")" ))(" !!
." ,"/'"
"$!#! ( (" "'$ ! "
,!( !! / " "") !)! 2""' /' ))" / ("!") ( ."( " "
<"(" !! )("!")!)! 2"& " ! / )!)" )) "!)! 2"
($("!" , ") /" ( "&"/ ',$!)!
2"!!
!,$ ! / ' !(! ("!/ !$ ',$ ))/ (,( !,$
))" "! !/ "' / )" !!"( ( "!', ',$ ))< ! ! " ! #" " "")!)! 2"
!
!!"( ?7 @9-9& )) ( "!( ! " " ") ))"' " $") ! ! 7( ' " "")!)! 2""' ! , "
, $'& &/" ! ,, (" $ " )( & !
! ,$ !)! 2" ( " ?7 @9-9&/ ( , ") )") ($ ( ("!
)" )) "!)! 2"+! "")!)! 2" ))( //"1 / )) )) ( "!( ! ' ;
",(" !! ))(()$"'!
,)" ." ,"/,$7 7 & "
( "") )! )" !< ! ( !' !(") ))! ,
/" $,"
!",$"! "
! ,& " &/ (" )) '' !( ))!'! "! ' !( ,
<(" !! !/ , '
" "")!)! 2""' " $&/" "'! ", ));
!"" "")/ " "") ' " "")"/<",
,$! (" ' !(& , , !"("!,$ )) / " $55/ $566&"$ !
(" - ", !- !/ " ")"("A( 4 ; ' ! ! (" )" ! "
" ("! "" $
+ ))( ! ) ", "
! ! ! )!,("
!" !"
)") ($!,!,$ <"( ! ! ! " ?78@9-! !3556!"
,!!,$ 6 0 "! ""' ($"' &"
( !,(!"("!,$ )) ! ("7 "& ,!
!,$ )) !" ")!)! 2" & / ( $' /"
" ( +&!
"! 2" ( " "") &/!, "+ ))/ ""' "! 2"!,
3 " "") ! "$ ")9 :") ") ,"/"1&, , ! " !,$ )) @3&""
(" !("' ( ' !(,,"
"("! ))( <( " ($!
" ! , !" !,$"! 2"/ ( ."( !!'!" ( $ &/ . ' ." / ) "2/%! ( ."7<!
( ( $("( "! / ("( " ! /"
", !,$ !( ( $!/ ( /"
, !,$ <"("!"
") , !,$"! 2" ( ."( 5
"
!&"! 2"!(!"("! ( ?78 "?78 )"/ ( !"'! " ! (3566 ! /, !,$"!
2"8@/ . !8@9
& .1 '"!
/, $ !" !,$"! 2" + ( ("!"
, "!(!& / "! 2" , ("!! " , " "") ! ( ."( & ( $552"(' !(,!!(!,$ )) "' ))'( "" "") " ! ( $55" !,( ' :") ") )""! 2"" !' !" / ( ."( &/
4 ( $566 @4< >& ,"
") !"
!
!! ("7 " "! 2"!,!"
, )" 6$! !
$$+ =" ("!"!(!,$8@% !& .1") ")) (") , (< 8 !8@! & .1") 2 & "'! / !( ( ("( " /! ")"!
2"!"! 2"!,1 $ ( ( $ ! / , +&,"
." ,"/' $! " / !"( $' !("("!! ! "!,$ '"
!", "! 2"!, 7( ' " ""' ! ( ."( & / ;
", $! / /"
"'! , , !" "") " ! ")) ")
/"
! )")
#( " + )")! "$ #( ""," ,$ )))"! ( "! 2" ( ."( " " ( ("!/) + )( "
! /"
! ") "( "" 56 "" $ ") 4 - &!'7( ! !
3566?78@9- )'"")"! 2"!"! !"
1
$ "?7 @9-/ ( ."( &/ &"
) ($ ") )'"")"!
2"<( ! " ?7 @9-!
"?7 @9-',)" !,$"! 2"+"
"' !(" "& 7 ! @9 1! @5 ' #&<!/ != ?7 &/"
',
" ?7 @-!?7 @5-( '$ ))( A "! ") "
?78@9-/"
+"(" !' !( "! 2""7 !8@ 0$&<!/ !
= ?7 &/",
! " ! ! 9 ?78@-
))( A "! ") "
?78@9- $/ !! "&,"
7 ' '! )) ! (" " +/ /
! ' !(")<!/ !
= ?7 "
, ' (")' !(!("
, ( !" , $(""," !+7 / $ $ "!)! ( ") ! ") ." ("
, ,!$" , ")7 " "! ' !(" ("! ", ( !;
"/
! ( (") (" "")!/ - "
)( ( (" (&/ (" ! ( "$" ', ',$ 7 ,!"! )) " (/ ("
, ' " ' ,$ ! "
" ! !"( $ ' !(
6 "!(! ",( !)"( ("( ("( " 9 8@9 !8@6#>&
/ ")
?78@9-',7 !,$"! 2"+ ( ."( ("!!,"!(!,$8@/ ! 8@9
& .1&"!(!("! "
! ($") ;
, $",'! ' ! "
( ! !3566?78@3-/ ! ", / !"! 2"!"( "/!,$ )" )") ($ &' ("
,!
! )")! "$ #( "& )(
/ $ ( ("!/! $55 /$ ! )" "!")" 9$&,)") ")
2"
,," "("! ""' ") "! 2" ( "1"/ ! )") ($ ") ")"! 2"&"$ " ")( 92"' !(,! ""' !)!
("
!/ ( )! $& ( ,$")) ( ")
( ."( (")"! 2";
/
!/
)! 1$"
( A ! ", , !!# " ! ,$ "
)) ( " "' !
" 3 + ( ! ! "), 55 &!
! / "" ! / ( " ""1(0
5 / / ,"7&( ! !/ !"
" ! / 1" "( " ,$ ) @ ( ""(! ?7 @9-&"/"/ (")) ") ")( ";
,"'! ( " , $",'! )) "
!" ! "$ #( " 4 =" "("!!,"'& ("!
) !""
$A "")/(, A "")/ !! !, ,) ")$ 6 ! ( "& ) $& " ! ! "! ") (("! $ /0
/"
@ 1 -"!
C-2"
@ " , C-2"