High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24750/2024disposed of

Shubham Chaudhry v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-04-05Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj24 pages

#$%$!&'

(

)

(

*+ ( , (

# $

# !

% &

(

for the petitioner.

Mr. Rahul Dev, Addl. A.G. Haryana.

Mr. Ravinder Malik (Ravi), Advocate, for respondents No.5, 34, 50, 52, 84, 90, 97, 129 and 133. % !

% )*

) !

for respondents No.8, 20, 48, 73, 81, 93, 104, 109, 114, 116, 127, 128 and applicants-respondents No.314 to 327.

)

% !

-./0-/1-.

1 %

/20-/1-.--..1 .0////1/11.11112100//2 -10

-2

*30213*43 /

*32-13*43 / , ( -

*3//3*43/ !

++ +

( *31--13*43.7*30203*43.

*32-13*43/

' ) + 8# "

# 9"

( ) "

(

)

(

)

+ "

) . +

(

-2.'

! 8 +

+ :

( '

& ;

,- +:

& ' !

8 + '

* ( +2<+

/ '

( "

( )

8 "

" '

0 '

& '

8 :

+ 8 = )!

8 "

1--

) 2 +

( "

( ) (

/ !

5 +

" + "

(

" +'

-- ' ! + *"

( )72. ' ! + 6* "

( )

1 ' ! + 6*6"

( )> ' !

+ "

2.-

! !

(

! 8

- * "

"" +

.. :

( "

( )> "" +)"

(

+ '

//'

> ' !

*4 -1 1

+> )

+ 8 +

* %

(

/1. '

++ (

) '

( "

( ) +"

"%'

" "

( )

. > +

(

+ "

/1/

' 8 (

(

! / 8

*4 -131 '

) +8)

* !

08) "

!"#$!%&'%(%(!##%%#%&%)(! %

* %% !"#+#( %%!$( $$()(%+&%&,-$(%!$.%(! -/()%!%& (%# -!/(/ %!

0 %/!, +&! &) # " 1!12#%&%&#% (%(%&/ %/!, (#'!#%&%!*$$()(%%

*&#-$( -, &(

34+#&(* 1- %,* 5'%1%

%(! !11(%% "1 !#)%! !$ 6!#%# 7 /8 3)%.% %!$%&$$()(%(#'!" #"9 8:&%%& &($ %,%!!)1%!$;,)( (%#%%!

0<<<% %&="*&#(##" (#%" %(!#/(/%& (%#-!/(/%!

#)%(! >&( (% &# - #%% %&% ($ , 11-011-# -!/(/ %! &" #%#0 2+ ### (#0 # % ( %& !' !1'%(%(! $! ( % "(%1%!%&-#(#!$%&(!+1(%*%&,+(!%- !"% /(#% %& ?"!% $! #) $! &"

#%#0 2+ ###* %&, +( - %% # !' !1'%(%(! (%# ;!+)* #" & (%# #&!" $"$( !(%(!!$(/(-((%,/(//% -8 <% (# #"-1(%% %&% .%(!* ($ ,* +&( & (# %! - '!)(%!

0 %/!, (%#+&!&)# " 1!12#%&%&#% (%(%&/ %/!, !,-/%#'%&-!)1%(!%%!$ &($

%,%!!)1%!$;,% %&="* !"#$!%&'%(%(!##%%#%&%()(+!$%& #%%2!$%&#'!%#($$()(%%

*%& +(%'%(%(!-(#'!#!$-,( %(/%&#'!%#%!%2 %(!(%1#!$%&$$()(% <)(+!$%&#%%1%!$ !"#$!%&'%(%(!* %&+(%'%(%(!(#(#'!#!$-,( %(/%&#'!%#%! %2 %(! ( %1# !$ %& #% # %2 ( $$()(% %

*( ! +(%&+*+(%&(#(.+2#$!1%& %!$ ('%!$ %($( !',!$%&(#! @ 1 > "

(

)

/.'

.2-'

! 8

) .'

! 8

;

! "

(

+ +.

/0 &

(

)!/ % 1 #2$3 ( #$!&

/!24 ( /3$# 25 %- 6778 '

" 8

(

+ !

8 8

(

) !

9 ?3

(!(%,

(!(%,* (%# !$ 11-# !$ %& #)( #& - %1(-,%&/%&!$ !%("!"##)( !,'!#%(%& #)( !)( %&% +& %& ($$% # ( %&

)( *%&#(!(%,#&-%1(#'%,$! & !)($"%&%&%(%& #!$11-#''!(%-, ( % "(%1%* %& ! !$ 1(% %1( -, %&

!11(##(!*#&!%-(#%"-($(.(/%&#(!(%, !)($"%&%&%(%& #!$%+!!1!11-# ''!(%!%&#1%*%&(#(!(%,#&-%1( #$!!+#9 7811-''!(%-,( % "(%1%#&- #(! %! 11- ''!(% -, '!1!%(! ! -, %#$A 7-811-''!(%-,'!1!%(!#&-#(!%! 11-''!(%-,%#$A 7 8<%& #!$11-''!(%-,'!1!%(!!-, %#$* #(!(%, #& - %1( !(/ %!

#(!(%,!$#" &11-#(%&''!(%1%#$!1+&( & %&,+'!1!%!%#$A 78 <%& #!$ 11-#''!(%-, %#$$!1 ($$% #* %&( #(!(%, #& - %1( !(/%!',*'$ -(//()%!11-* +&!+#+(/&(/&%!$',(%&(#')(!"# ''!(%1%A($%&%#!$%&',%&+#! %& #1* %& -, %& /%& !$ %&( )( ( %& ''!(%1%#* ($ %& /%& !$ #" & )( (# #! %& #1*%&!11-#&-#(!%!%&,!"/ 11- B 2 > 8

9 "

(

! "

8 '

8 > "

+*4 .-0 +-

(

+ > )

)

" '

8 0 ;

' ! "

B$ !

C> )

/. !

:&% ( %& , * 5'%1% %(!

!11(%%!$6!#%5'%1%*;,+# !#%(%"%-, %&!)1% :&#( %(! !11(%%)%(#$! "(%1% !$ 6!#% "# ( )(!"# #)0"#) %/!(#)()%(#1%! %

:& -2"' !$ %& )%(# ) (# $! ($$% %/!(#+##"9

C 78 C 7 8 C 7 8 C

7 8 7 8 ::

''!.(1%, ''( %(!#+ ()/(#%%&# ) (# $% # "%(, !$ ''( %(!#* !

!$ ''( %#7 %(1#%&!

!$'!#%8+ $!(%)(+ '&,#( $$( ( , %#% :& 5'%1% %(!

!11(%% %& #"% !$ #" ##$" (%# !

:&1(%(#%%

+#''!%& -#(# !$ ' %/ 12# ( 1( #* 12# + ( (%)(+'&,#( $$( ( ,%#%*!%&-#(#!$#( 1(% (#%* ''!(%1%# + 1 >(%(/ (#% /(#% #' %() %/!(#+##!'' :& #"% %

# + # 1(% (#% %

+# &/ -, %& +(%(/ (#% (%# -, $((/ >!

!$ %(%# &1-&"!%& D# %%!$;,!%&# >!

!$ %(%##&E"1!%&#D# %%!$;, !%&#(%&;!F-;(/& !"% :&'%(%(!# !$%&# >F#/%&%1, (%# -!/(/#%!#) %/!,&# "&(/&12#%& %& (%# !$ %/!, %&$! # '

;,!)1%(#%" %(!#(##")(!%($( %(!! 0 0 <<<%

*#" & (%#!$#) %/!,#&!"&)-/()''!(%1%/(#%

%/!, ) (# !% /(#% %& ?"!% #) $!

0 %/!, :&'%(%(!# !%%&%($%&1(%(#%(#)(+%& (%+!"-$!"%&%1, (%#+&!&)-/() ''!(%1% /(#% %& &" #% ! 2+ ## %/!,+ %",(/(-%!- !#((%& %/!,) ,'!#%#!%&-#(#!$%&(1(%& * 1, (%#$!1%&+(%(/(#%( "(/%&'%(%(!# +!"&)- !1(/(-$!''!(%1%/(#%) (# !$%&(#' %()#)%(!?"!% :&$%* "(/ %& ' , !$ #( '%(%(!* )( ! %

*;!F-;(/& !"%( %%&#'!%# %!$($$()(%/(/%&.%(!+&( & -/() %!

0 %/!,+&!&)# "1!12#%&%&#% (% ( %& %/!, < !1'( !$ #( ( %(!#$$()(%%

+#$(!-&$!$ 5'%1% %(! !11(%%*+&((%+#1%(! %&% B3.%(!*($,*+&( &(#%!-'!)(%!

0 %/!, (%#+&!&)# "1!12#%& %&#% (%(%& %/!, !,- /%#'%&%%!$ &($ %,%!!)% !$ ;,%

< )(+ !$ %& #( $$()(%* > !

!$ +# (#'!#!$-,;!F-;(/& !"%)(!% +(%&( %(!#%!%2 %(!(%1#!$%&#%#%2( $$()(%%

*( ! +(%&+ :&% ( (' &($ !#)%! !$ 6!#%#* ;, )( ! %

& !#%(%"% !11(%% !$ $!!+(/ !1'!#(%(!$! !11(/ %(!$! !1',(/ +(%&%&!% '##-,;!F-;(/& !"% ( >!

!$ %(%# &1-&"!%&D#

%%!$;,!%&#9 & "#&5*<6

675)!'1%8

&(1 & D(!E"1*<6

671((#%%(!8 1- %, & "%1(*50!

6*;, 1- :& !11(%% $% .1((/ %& # ( %( #"-1(%%(%#'!%+(%&%&$!!+(/ !11%(!#9 78:&$()'%(%(!#7%+!( >!

!$ %&( >!

!$ :&,%! - ''!(% (11(%, +(%& !%(! !#?"%( -$(%#(1%%#!$',$(.%(!/%&!$#)( % %! )!( , !#?" # %&% 1, 1/ ($ %& ''!(%1%#!%1-$!$!"+2##( % -,%&;!F-;(/& !"%((%#!% %&"/"#%*

78:&$! ! %(!!$!#(%&1(%(#% -##-,$!!+(/%&"1%(!'%&+, 7(8:& 6!#%"#+&!+''!(% /(#% ) (# !$ #)%(! %/!(# +( !+ - !#( /(#% ) (# !$ %/!, :& (%#+&!+(!+- /() ''!(%1% /(#% #)%(! ) (# 1, - ' ( ! +(%& %&( 1(% # "(%& !1'%(%().1 7((8:&1!)1%!$%&6!#%"#%!/ %/!, ) (# $!1 #)%(! ?"% +( $!%,6!#%"#4!-##*#%&,#% '#%,( %/!,+(%&!"%) ,# +)%(#$!%&'"'!#!$%&(# "(%1% :&$%!$%&#6!#%"# - (+(%& $!!+(/%+!!'%(!#G 78 <(%(% %& '! ## $! %1(%(! !

$ %&( #)( ! 7-8, !#(!#,1'%&%( /!"#( ! +(%&%&'( ('#!$%"4"#%( %! %( %&1 /(#% %& )(- ) % ( % "(%1%'!#%#!$/ %/!, :&#! !$ #,1'%&%( !#(%(! (# ! $!!+(/ /!"

H:&(''!(%1%(/!)1%#)( +#" %!!(# %(!'! ##%&!(#!% %%(-"%-%!%&1 H:&,&),#)(%&5'%1%$! 1!%& ,#%1(%(/%&(#)( #% %&(##%/+!" "#.%1&#&('%!%&1 - "#1,!$%&1+!"&)- !1!)/ %&, 1(/&% !% - - %! # " $#& 1'!,1% !!)*(%(#!%%& #%&%%&, &#"-1(%%,+!/($!1%(!!! "1% $! /%%(/ %&(# ''!(%1% 6"%&* %& '%1%&#,()#%#"-#%%(,$! %&( '!$##(! %((/ %&, !+ .'( 6!#% "# :& '%1% &# #"$$( (% ) (# !$ ( % "(% 7

%/!,8(%& !$6!#%"# :&%%&$%*%& #+##%-,%&!)1%$!%& )( %!0!)! %*;,/(/%%(! !$-!)1%(! 6!#%"#(#)( $%%&%%& 0!)! %*;,)(!'((!%

!'(%&%()(+!$4"/1%#!$%&;!F- "'1 !"% (D(2#&%' (/&!%&#D# %%!$ &&%%(#/& !%&#* 78

1!E"1:(+(I# D#

%% !$ =&2& !%&#* 7 8

* %& !)1%1,%2 (#(! !11!%%&# 6!#%"#/(#%%&( % "(%1%'!#%# <)(+!$ %&)( %-,%&0!)! %*;,* !11(%% +# !#%(%"% !$ %& $!!+(/ !1'!#(%(! %!

!11 '!'!# %! !11!% 6!#% "# /(#%%&( % "(%1%!#,1'%&%( !#(%(!9 7(8 & "#&5*<6

676!#%,8 7((8 & D(!E"1*<6

671( 8 7(((8 & (%( &1 5 6"%&*(%+# (-,%& !11(%%)('!%% #"9 :&#( 6!#%"#1,-' (#(!(%,-!+ %&4"(!1!#%6!#%"#(%&)(##(!(%,(#%%

<< :&(%##(!(%,!$%&#( 6!#%"#(#%!-( ! +(%&%&(%()1(%# "(%& !1'%(%() .1 <<< :&( % !$ ''!(%1% +( - % '(/ ! )(-((%, !$ ) , !$ %/!, 7-, $!!+(/ !#%8 :&%(%(# $!1-!)%&%%&'%(%(!#+!%) %(%$!%%(!(%&#)( %&,+%($% !#((/%&( ##,1'%&( ,%&"#%&,+' (#(!(%,-!+%&4"(!1!#%6!#%"#(%&)(# #(!(%,(#%%

:&"#*(%(#+!/%!#,%&%%& '()%#'!%#+&!+!+(1(%&)-#&!+ #(! %! %& '%(%(!# ( %& %%%() #(!(%, (#% # %& #(!(%, (#% +# )(# " %& ( "1#% # 1%(!

-!) (% &# - %($( ( )(+ !$ %& '!%# !$ %& !11(%%#1%(!-!) :&$!*%&'!'!#%%%() #(!(%, (#% '' -, %& 5'%1% (# )(* / -((/"'!%&'%(%(!#

:&% %& $((/0'!% !$ , !11(%% &# #%( !% &/-,%&'%(%(!!)1%(!-,%&'%(%(! ( %& '#% '%(%(! :& $ % !$ $((/0'!% !$ %& !11(%% (# (%%(!, !% (# !# -, %& '%(%(! ( !%!#"''##%&1%($ %#%!1(#%&(#;!F-

!"% @ +

! "

) (

)

9 "

% 8)

( "

(

! "

( '

) "

(

! "

( )

(

( )

+ "

' "

(

( "

( ) ' =

8 "

(

+( "

( )

()

! ++

+ 8 +

+ *

B$ !

C *

C 8 "

)

$ <,

& '

(

! "

( ' =

8 "

(

& *

( )

+ +

! "

( )

( "

( )

(

! "

( ' =

" )"

= " 5 '

(

( "

( )

+ (

! 8

" +

.+ (

)8 "

8 '

(

)

.+ (

8 + 9

" '

" )+

! *

(

)

8# "

( 5

)

+ !

& !

(

8 "

(

+ !

- )+

' 8 +

() '

8 " !

! 8 "

(

+."

(

( "

( )

(

' (

) "

( "

+ 8)

" '

" )"

= " .

(

! "

' !

)

" '

(

+002

(

+ !

" '

" > "

) .

( 8 !

(

8 # " > +

--'

+ 8

(

+ (

)

" +)

! 8

(

) ' 8

+ + (

)

/..> "

(

)

% ++ "

"" 8)

)

(8 8 (

) .

8 % 8 '

+ "

, !

" 9

(

8# "

(

5 '

8# "

! #

! (

)

(

! (

(

8 '

1 5

! (

(

% 8)

(

. ( "

( ) ++ "

' "

*4 -1 +1

*4 -. +2' + 8 +

* "

(

( ) !

( '

(

( "

( )

8 "

! "

( )

) $

8 +

8 "

" '

+ '

( *43-1 +1+ 8 +

* ' ""

() +!

% " )

+ 1 ' %

. "

' "

! "

( )'

(

( "

( )

( "

( )

+ !

( ) " ) "

= "

(

! ! "

( 8 "

8 "

( ) )

(

" )

8 "

(

! +

! "

( ' +

+ "

' "

(

+ 2 *

)

) !

/) '

) "

" '

( "

+ " "

(

) "

" !

(

) '

8 '

+ "

5 '

)

8 %

8 +

)

(

' (

() +

8 (

" +"

(

8 '

) #

' '

()

(

8 " ++ " ""

(

( !

)

! '

(

)

() + "

> )

9 "

! "

B& *C !

" 002

( "

" "

(

8 +

8 9

8 +

" 8

) (

8 )

9 "

(

% 8)

& !

+> "

( "

( '

(

++ "

(

+ 8)

8 "

(

) +

= "

+ '

+) '

)

' 8 "%

(

5 "

) (

(

# 8 !

(

! 8

)> '

8 +

'+)

' "

* (

(

+ ""

(

(+ + "

! 8

> )

9 "

! "

B& *C !

" 002 "

(

8 "

(

( 8

% '

(

" 8 8) '

8 8 (

" 8 8) '8

" 8 + (

+ "

) (

) .

8 "

(

! "

(

8 '

(

( "

( )

' !

8 (

+ '

! 8 (

) '

8 "

) !

--'

! 8

(

8 "

% 8)

) .

(

)

+ +

) " 8)'

%8 '

1 '

()

)

BC ""

() 4/$5 -

B, (

/!/

>&%&#'2(/0#! 9J#0! >&%&'!%- 9J#0!