High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4234/2017dismissed

Sewa Singh Th His Lr v. Taranjit Singh And ORS

2017-09-13Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar7 pages

!!"" #$% &$' ($ !( )$

$*(! )( $+(#

$ !!"" $$($,%*$-( $+(#

$ .#$

& !!" "(/0( ( '%(*

$#$" 1% "" $ $!( $

"(%"* ( ( + + $ "( *%$ ," $"*!$(23444 4 52(,"" %( #"" %+ & " ( $ 6%( ( (!!(( ( 7$") $

$0#($$(((((

2 & 7$") $

$0 "($ "( "( *%$

80$( %

234444 4 #( " (( ((

2 $ ($ 9+

451 ! !" !$!$0 "( * (*(/%($*( "(( :# !" $$(* /%($ % !$!$0" "(( 1 !"+ *( /%($*( "((; #$+ /<!"( !" %/8%"0 /%($ %"( ( *()$5 !"1 %$ $+"*(/0 !"

! "( ( $$ "((

1 %$ $/!"(( ( "(( 7$") $ $0 "($ ( ( ("( $!$ "(" * $!$& !"

'0 !$!$0; #$+ 0$

3 ( ($("* !$!$0!%$ (/0 !"

(

$!$!$0 !& $ $+ ( ($( $ !

;+ !$% $("$ $ ! %!$!$0 /%($*( !" % # ( ( ( (<!$(+ $ $ 6 "( $ $* %1 !"((/0 * "("( !"

= $23444 4 +*( "((+(= $ 2344 $ !"

=!1 %$ $+!"(( /0 * #$!!(( ( ! $

$0$! "(*!$(2344 & $ $+# 7$"

) $ $0 "($%"( #"( "(*!$(= $ 2344 :# " #%$ !"

(( /0 ( ( & !$"( $#( $!!$ #( "$($"%$(*( % "(/0 !"

5$!( $%( !"

%"( #"*( !$!$0*!$( = $%*/$ $ *( "(( 1

%$ $$$((/0 $".%$ ! $ $0 "($ ( % $0"" !$!$0= $2344 $#( ( !"

4$!( $

"(!!"/ $ (("$>%(+6%( & " $ !!"".%$#( '%(*(($(( 3

"" ( !!"(($( % "(/0 !"

? "($ % " $!!"".%$$$(( ( = $2344 (%"0*( ! $ $0<%( #%$ ( ( & $ $+( ( (#$0% $0"" !$!$0 %(= $2344 1 %$ $ "(/0 " $!!"".%$ /%($ !$!$$*("((( /%($""0 !$!$0, $2344 ( !$!$0*!$(, $23444 4 + $ $+ !$ "((8%"$ !$!$0%( = $2344 ((/"( !"

&%!!$ "% " $ !!"" .%$ " $"( %! '%(* ;@/"%!$*.%$"(

6$(%"!!$ $ !!"" "$% %/*( 3 ! " ! ""0 !$#( $*= (( $!$0*0 %( % # $%* $ ( & $ $+"$( %" $ !!""%/* !"

(#$0!!$%0 =$ "(( = $%*/$ "(( $$( ; #$+ " % $ !%$! 1(+ "( % $("$& ( "$(%" $ !!"" "(( 0$

2 & !"

"!!$ (*( $(#$

"((& $ $+$( %" $ !!""+ !"

= $* / $*= "((& $ $+ %"( # "( %**("0; #$+ "( % *% "$+ */$$( .%" $ #$5$!( %/*( " % = $%*/$ !$!$0 $"0*( " ((/% !$8%"$ !$!$0"( $% "(( !"

#/ ! %!$!$0('0" %0 (%$/+ $ $+ ($/"# $ !$!$0"( *("0 %/* "$( %" $ $!( <!$( *% "$ $ <% "((;( !$!$0/"( !"

+ %"( # ""( "(( #%$ !"

$ !+( 6 #$ "" (( <%(/0 1 # $("$(%" $ !$(!$%( $$( 1*$ "(( = $%*/$ *( #/"( !"

23444 4 ; #$+ /%($*( "((( !" ( *="$ !$ ((""

"( = $%*/$ $+ !$ "" !$!$0/%((/0 /%($*( "((( "$ (/0 !" ( "((

% 1# %+ !"

"( !$% "*("$ !$!$0"( * !$!$0

/%((*( !"(* $ = $ %*/$ "0 *= & !"

*/"( ( "0 " #"%+ / "(/0 ;@/"%!$*.%$

!" $"""0 " % $("$% :# $( 3 ! " *= "$ !"

+0% $ $%($ $%*%+"* !"( $%*/ $ (1 !$" !"

* %"* !$%"$/%($ #/"( *( = $ %*/$*( "((& $ $+

+ = $ = $%*/$"0"0 + 3%/5 " # ($ .%$ + % "( $ $ %($%/ .%$% $( !$( !$ / #%$ $ *= +$($ $ *=%/' ( !$'%(%( $ 8%$(/0 $(!$0 1 !$ $(!$0$ $ #"#(& $ $+ $ $ ($$((/0 " $!!""%$ *$ $%* $( /0 "$( %" $ !!"" %/ 3!$ /$ $"

$ !$0 %" ! ""0 "*( /0 !$0

& ; #$+*(/#+ '%(* ;@/"%!$*.%$ "$ 0"0 ! # ! ""0"*(/% $ "$ $* "*%/( /%($+ .%$ $ $" !"

+ #

$ *= & $ $+ "$( %" $ !!"" "/$'( $ (!%$$(/%($$(+# ( (@ (*( /%($ #/"( !"

:# ( (5!!"" $+?9 * + (*( !#$ %( !$!$0"( !"

+!$ /%($+ %(/%( = $2344 (= $23444 4 & $ $+ $( <$( ( <" !$!$"( !"

+ .%$ $ "0$( $" ("$ #%$

/% $*$( / !$ $ !"$$("*$(+ $%* "$(%" $ !!""%/"& !"

#$(%$/(8% ! & $ $+ $$/"# (/"( !$!$0 $ /%($*( "((.%" $ $!( "$ $$( "(( $+ / $ (("" !$!$0 /%($ *( "((& $ $+ !"

%"( #%

"0 +<!$( "((+(!%(/0

$ ( ( "$ $* +!"((/0 !"

( !$#($$(+ $ $(/0 ( ("0 0$

3 $%( (*= "((& $ $+ % / "(/0 !$!"

& $ $+ %/$$(/0"*;+ $ $

($$((/0 "$(!!"".%$ ! "" 1# /# (+ $"""0$!$#$0

($$((/0 " $!!"".%$( '%(*( ($!(/0 " $!!"".%$$%! "( 1# /#+ !$!!" "((*(/ (#( 0*$ # '()*')+,)-"#$

? $!=4$( A4 ? $$!$/" A4