← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaTA/206/2014allowed

Suman v. Sanjeev Kumar

2017-01-20Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik12 pages



    



 ! "!#$%$&'  (  

     '

)* +  +,+  * -      

 

  

     

     +,+  * -./0

!"

#$"$  

 

%& ' '



  ()*+    



(, -  .

()// 01-

1  

#$   !#     3

    

  "        

  

 

      $  4

  

  "        

'

'   (5((%*(& #  

     

# 

  -     



6   

!"

#

 

."

 .

 .    .784 4    

.8



  # "    # %/*

 9 





" # $

 

 

.

  #$   !# "

.    - $ 

"

  

         !# "

 $   

 #

 

    ' "



"#     :

    !# "

 # .$ 

   -       

     .    -;#    '  &$&"$   %  1%  +/$2$  %.    3  +  3(.

24"56!&  ' 1!!&1%1$&7-46/. 33

*89      (5%%*(<    #$    '     :((     :

+4/$&"!/0-4/1%/62$ +$&5;

.      



#  #  - #

  

.

# " $ 

" #$ '

   (,(*%*(/  '!3%%,, %*(/.  "

  !#   -;#  '    (,(*%*(/# $#$-;#   '

 

 %5((%*(/ - $      



 - .     

  #

.



       .

 .

 

     

  '   

    "

$



  

  

   #     

      #

    



#$   !#

#     4$    "

# . 

 .   #  '  

!"

."

 



 .      784 4  =   

  # "    # %/*- .  

'   

  

  

!"

" #

..  

.

  #$   !# "

. .            4  #   

 

  

    "     

         

 6         !#       $  

.

# "  

      







   -" 



. #

     

    #

  $       .        . 

 #$        

    # #

  -" 

  

.  #  # $    

# .

. # 

 

 

 "   



     #:    





#  $ .$



. "   

 

  

 



  "  

  #$

-1#  ' "64%4&"/&"& ;!/1%+  !

6$0"4&" ;!/%.8 +:88.&$& &"$1%6/$ *0 &#;&"&" ;!/%. 8 +(:.+  ! /$%%1% "

00$7%. 

+(:+  ! 2% ;&1+&!%;$*0.9  +:88 >

 "   

     #

$

#

#$ -;#  '  (((%

.  = 6 ;  0 2 



 "  

6  ; 0 29

$; 0 2 "

#.

$

"     !

((?(%@ 

   

 

     

     

       

 

    



       



    

      

       

  

  

  

               

       

!



   

"      

   # $%    

"

      



   

      

  "   

#$% 

 

   

   



#  $%    

    

     

     

 &   



    

              

     

    

         

     

   

  '   (          $)*)  +

  )

 ) ,  + $-./0)(/12%

3    +  4  4  +  $-../$/%)((11%          5        



  

 

   

  

  6 7 8

 $-.9-%(1.:$;8%" ; 8(  

             

 

  

  " 

  

5

     

    5   

 

  ' 

 

 

   5

         

        ' . 

 



 



  # .        

  

.

$         6           

 $   

 

#    ."4 $ #$  6  " 

 #



# "  



   #$  6  # "





"

  " "  A 9

$ 0%**<2(''

%5/  %+%  (% -<  -:=( 

        

    



    

   

  



    

         +     ( 

 

   

       

 

   

  5 

       

  5  



   

 ( 

                  

"

             "        

    

 

  

 

   5  

    " 

      



    

  #

 

    8  >  4 ( 8

?;  $-.:-(2@2 2/-%"8 

,4    *$-1(!4% 

 "   "

 

 



   & " 



              6  



       

      

 

 

  



A -/; + 4  B

( $-.29$<% <.1%8   $ <.2!

%"A8   

                  

        '  '         A," )   ;  8

? )

$C <%$-.2-%-&8-9/<   *$ -<21 !%A+  "   "        

8      6 A   "    ;     D

  D  $-.2<$<%&8:@2%8  ,  *$ 2/-%     

 

 

    



 

     "   



  



 



    A

-2(  5 " 

   

                 4                      -:    

 8  4



   

   

 *$  E  ("-./<)(/09 A   

 

 

 

     

 

         

   "    "



 

      $ (  F % 

     

   

  

 "    

  "

    

    

 A A6 

       





  "   

  

  

        



  , 



             )  3        ?)    8  ,  "

$<991%@)((2:"0@!01" -:!-0A 9 " #    





# .     

# $ 

  

 #

"9   #  # "

"   

$ 

     

#

$    $     

$ #   

  

    "

  

 

 



   9

  





  

  :        



#$    

  4#  " #$ '  

  

"

..  -1#  '

"



 - .'

 ' !



           

!"#$ %& '(    )    * + 

, ! " -.

 / ) & 0   +/ ) %,,,,!

1$ " '   +/' 

     %,,%

!- # 1 + 2 /  



0/' /  %,,-,!

%$, #3    4 *'  5 2 0 6 44   %,, !

-

   )  / 7  )  %,, !- " $/') / '5/') '7   +/  3

'7  8'   %,,$ ---

. & 

 2  9  +  %,1-! :#$ ,

   %,%!*:-" 

  %,- :/  !#1 %9 ;  /' %,, !  0!%$# - '

 %,#!  0!% "/ & 05/ /' 5/   * (   +%,%$!  0!$" 4  #

#$ -1#  '

 (&

. -40<$&"!/-4/=-40<$&"!/4/#;/&

+$&5;1 0 2 "

 #.

$

"    

!

?



         

  

  !

   !          "  

     5 

 "       )   <1 <:



 (  

            

"                   ( 



              

#           

    

 

 

  #

  

  #     

  

 



  

   

    #    '                    

     #       

       " 

  "          

               

'        " 

    "  "             5       

      

        "

(  

  

      

(          "    

 "

  

(     G .  

#

.      

        / +4>/6&$6+<670 2 -1#  '  !

?

'   5     





     

        

5     



  



 

   

   



(  

  "

    



(  

    

 

             

     

     

5       







      (       

    



 

   

              6 " 

 "



(  

     

   (  



    5  



     & 

       !    

  

 

! 

  





   

5      

         '  

5   D

                

     #   

   

  

   "



    

  

                       

      H     

  

    

 $  %G  4   

 :

  "

%&

'



 '   

 



      .9  

 "  ' 

      ' 

   

  

 

  

  

    #   

   

  .#B  

  



 

 

.  



" 

#

$    

.          

  =

$

    "

1



  "

 #   #$ ' "



 .



 



   

$

"

" "#$ -1#  ' "

 

 - .'

 '



.

$  

!"

 

 .

 



(, 

     #    

.

"



.$   

  !#9 

 

 "  

   $ ##

    #9 

"

   .    

"   



 4 

# # "  

"

 " 

 #



   .

 "  

 '     " 

"  #  :      



(, 

    3 . "  '   





    #  "

  

 '  

  "   

 #



 #$

"



(, -

 #$       #        #          

 .

$ 

7.    

 

    



(, -

   

7.    $

 # $ "

        



  $  4 

7.    



 

  

 .

        

  $

 

 "

 " >

 # #

 

 

 

   

" "



   +,+  * -

 %*(%*(5 E)  &

 I  B IC &

  * B IC