← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4265/2017dismissed

Ishwar Devi (Since Deceased) Th Lrs & ORS v. Khan Chand (Since Deceased) & ORS

2018-04-25Mr. Justice Amit Rawal6 pages

 

     



  !

"#$$%&'&()*+&,- .

'/0"+$1& '&(%$2$%$"'$2!#/+34/5 '#/$+'

**$,,"(#'

6$+'3'

7/"(/"(2 '&(%$2$%$"'$2!#/+34/5 '#/$+'

 $'*(2$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

+$'$(#) + 7"#/3+&"-21%"#$+ + "8$'/$/+"-21%"#$- +#/$"**$,,"(#' 99999 +*,&-(

 

.:;

+"<$+&(#/$"**,&%"#&(&'+&=*,$"2&(4#/$5 ''/0"+ $1&;"**$,,"(#   -  0/  &'  '#"#$2  #  /"1$  2&$2  (    :  /$ "**,&%"#&(&''3**+#$2><"("&2"1&#

+  #/$  +$"'('  =$(#&($2  &(  #/$  "**,&%"#&(-  #/$  '"=$  &' ",,0$2'3>?$%##",,?3'#$@%$*#&('"(2#/$*$+'('=$(#&($2&( "+"

#/$"**,&%"#&("+$",,0$2#>$&=*,$"2$2"'5 '"**$,,"(#  +#/$*3+*'$*+'$%3#&(4#/&'"**$",(,<  

.;

+  #/$  +$"'('  =$(#&($2  &(  #/$  "**,&%"#&(-  0/&%/  &' '3**+#$2><"("&2"1&#-2$,"< .2"<'&(+$;&,&(4#/$"**$",&'

%(2($2  '#"(2'2&'*'$2



**$,,"(#;*,"&(#&'"+$&( $43,"+$%(2**$","4"&('##/$

 %(%3++$(#&(2&(4'"%#'-0/$+$><#/$'3&# %,"&=&(42$%,"+"#&("(2 ="(2"#+< &(?3(%#&(  %/",,$(4&(4  #/$  '",$  2$$2'  2"#$2  :  AAA  "(2 *0$+"##+($<:2"#$2 AAA#>$&,,$4",-(3,,1&2-/"'>$$( 2&'=&''$2 #0"'",,$4$2#/"#7/"(/"(20"'#/$0($+"4+&%3,#3+", ,"(2%=*+&'$2&(7/$0"#.A-7/"#(&A"(27&,,":BAB :;.!-

 .;!-

 .;!-  .;!- :B

;.!-##",=$"'3+&(4.8"(",' ="+,"'

"(27/$0"# A:=&(-7/"#(&- $%#7&,,":

 ;

!- :B.B  ;!-.B

;

!-AB  ;

!-##",=$"'3+&(4 8"(",' :="+,"'- '&#3"#$2"#6&,,"4$34"$+&-$/'&, $/"=-&'#+&%# /#"8$0"'",' 0($+#/$'/*"+$":

'C<"+2'$$(2"(#':"(2-&$-7"'/=&+& 5","(23>/"'//"(2$+%,"&=$2#/$='$,1$'#>$0($+'&(*''$''&( #/$'3&#*+*$+#</$%/",,$(4$0"',"&2##/$"+$=$(#&($2'",$2$$2' (#/$*+$=&'$#/"#*,"&(#&'",(40&#/=#/"(%/",/"2&,$2"'3&# '$$8&(4  2$%+$$    *$+="($(#  &(?3(%#&(  "4"&('#  7/"(  /"(2  /$ "+$=$(#&($2  '3&#  0"'  2&'=&''$2  1&2$  ?324=$(#  2"#$2   AA 0$1$+-  &(  **$",  A.    AA-  1&2$  +2$+  2"#$2   AA -  "

'$##,$=$(#0"'"++&1$2"#>$#0$$(#/$*"+#&$'-0/$+$&(7/"(/"(2/"2 3(2$+#"8$((##",&$("#$/&'*+*$+#&$'$@%$*#&(%"'$($%$''&#</$ ",&$("#&(&(1&,"#&(#/$"+$=$(#&($2"=&,<'$##,$=$(#0"'(# >&(2&(4(#/$+&4/#'#/$*,"&(#&'-#/34/*,"&(#&'"(2:/"2" +&4/#&(#/$*+*$+#<><>&+#/$$(2"(# 0"'+$C3$'#$2##+$"##/$ &=*34($2'",$2$$2'"(2*0$+"##+($<"'(3,,"(21&2->3#/$2&2(# *"<"(</$$2%&1&,'3&#0"'&,$2&( AAA-0/&%/0"'2&'=&''$2( A.0$1$+-&("**$",-0/&%/0"'2$%&2$2(: A-,&>$+#<0"'

4+"(#$2##/$*,"&(#&'#&,$#/$'3&#"+$'/#&'&(#/"#>"%84+3(2#/$

. ="##$+-#/$'3&#"+$=$(#&($20"'&,$2&(A 0  '$#'    0+&##$(  '#"#$=$(#'  0$+$  &,$2  /$  2$$(2"(#' %(#$'#$2#/$'3&#(#/$*+$=&'$#/"#2$$(2"(#-&(0/'$"13+#/$ *0$+"##+($<0"'$@$%3#$2><7/"(/"(2-0"'(($$,'$>3##/$ 2"34/#$+/$'",$2$$2'"(2#/$*0$+"##+($<"+$+$4&'#$+$22%3=$(#' "(2/"1$(#>$$(%"(%$,,$2#0"'#/$*+*$+#<7/"(/"(2-0/%3,2 2$",0&#/#/$'"=$&("(<="(($+/$0"(#$2/$*,"&(#&'/"2(#>$$( ">,$#*+1$#/$*''$''&(#/$'3&#*+*$+#< &(%$#/$*"+#&$'0$+$"#1"+&"(%$-#/$#+&",3+#+"=$2"' ="(<"''$1$(&''3$'&(%,32&(4+$,&$-0/&%/+$"2#/3');     



                

            !"#$   

$ %       



&  '  $   

  

 

 ()**  + $'



'     '& 

          ,          

- , 

 ()*. !  







$()*.  

   ',

 ,  ,

    

()*. / 

   ',,   ,   ()*. 0 

   '

 '

 , ()*.  1  /$"**$,,"(#;*,"&(#&'>+34/#(+$%+22%3=$(#'@

- @ D"(2@ -@ -@ -@ EB"(2$@"=&($2"'="(<"'3+ 0&#($''$'-0/$+$"'#/$2$$(2"(#'$@"=&($2#/+$$0&#($''$'"(2>+34/#( +$%+2+$1$(3$+$%+2-&$-@ #@ 

 /$#+&",3+#-(#/$>"'&'#/$"+$=$(#&($2$1&2$(%$- /$,2  #/"#  #/$+$  0"'  (  1&,"#&(    #/$  ",,$4$2  '$##,$=$(#  @   "(2 2&'=&''$2#/$'3&#**$",,"&2>$+$#/$50$+**$,,"#$3+#",'=$# 0&#/#/$'"=$"#$ + 7"#/3+&"-  21%"#$  +  + "8$'/  $/+"-  ,$"+($2 %3('$,+#/$"**$,,"(#''3>=&##$2#/"#>#/#/$3+#'>$,0">2&%"#$2&( (#+$"2&(4#/$%(#$(#'#/$'$##,$=$(#-0/&%/*3#"%,$"+>"+(7/"( /"(2(##'$,,*+*$+#&$'$@%$*#+($%$''&#</$"+$=$(#&($2+2$+ 2"#$2 AA *"''$2&(**$",A.

 (=$+&#'-#/$"**$,,"(#'/"1$(#>$$(">,$#*+1$0&#/ +$4"+2 ##/$>+$"%/#/$"4+$$=$(#/$"=&,<'$##,$=$(#+$"2' "' 3(2$+);

23   44 5

 6 &  6 & 5    5 6      5 6  4 8 6  4+  .'

 5 6   4      ,  '

 , 

  '     ,  '

 $  4 4

5   6      $  

     + 

  $      

  9 !!&4 '

- 6& 1

: $7 5     ,

  

     

  

  ;   $  45

 6 

 

  

:$

   6      $  

   8

   <   %

 =   



 =     $$$ $

%

  $  



,

   &  $ $   $ )

&   '     $  -                  $

$ + 



  $, &

   

$





   1)><6 <.

 ,3  & " 1

?

+=  #/$  *$+3'",    #/$  "+$=$(#&($2  "=&,<  '$##,$=$(# @ -&#0"'(,<0&#/+$4"+2#$=$+4$(%<"(2#+$"#=$(#7/"(/"(2 /$+$0"'($@*+$''$2>"++'$,,&(4#/$*+*$+#<->3#0"'(,<#/"##/$ *+*$+#<  03,2  (#  >$  0"'#$2  #  0"'  &(%3=>$(#  3*(  #/$  "**$,,"(#; *,"&(#&'#*+23%$(+$%+2'3&%&$(#*&$%$$1&2$(%$#$'#">,&'/#/"#

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

+#/$+$"'(''#"#$2">1$-2(#&(2"(<&,,$4",&#< + *$+1$+'&#<&(#/$%(%3++$(#&(2&(4'4+3(2+&(#$+$+$(%$&'="2$ 3# $'3,#"(#,<-#/$"**$",&'2&'=&''$2 /-0   +*,&

123 ()45'

,36327/ 82

 928

,363 6:"

928