High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4267/2017dismissed

Bhim Singh v. Chameli (Since Deceased) Thr Lrs And ORS

2018-07-30Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan5 pages

!"#!$%&%"'()**+ ,%-%'., //!00'

1!2&3& ,-!0% &%'$!4!$!&!4 ,2"3., 5* & ,!2&* !&/"'4!' &

2!&!' (

2*'32.%'647"$ !#"2 ,!//!00' *

0%' %##- *,-!0%9%4"9"#2,'4 ,2"3.,,!25* & #%0!4&3% #"24!$02 %"' " ,!!##!$ , ,!:2!"9'!2&%'/"&&!&&%"'"# .2%$30 3200'4 " 0-!&32%'.+;'0&-20&'4&4! %0!4%' ,! /0%' &% 3 !4%' ,!2!7!'3!!& !"#1%00.! ',!2%6!,&%0%& 2%$ ,%9'%'4 , -3 %"''"*)<&'$ %"'!4"'+**==%'#7"32"# 4!#!'4' '"*,%-%'.,'4&3>&!?3!' 2!7!'3!2!$"24%'$034%'.00 '4

"' ,!>&%&"#&%4-3 %"''"*)< &0&"&0!4!!4'"*=+4 !4+*=*!@!$3 !4>:4!#!'4' '"*,%- %'.,%'#7"32"#4!#!'4' &'"* "'-!0:1!4 2;&,6 2;&, '43'%0A3-22!.%& !2!4"'+*=*2!'30067"%46>&!4"'#234'4 -%&2!/2!&!' %"' '4 9!2!'" >%'4%'. "' ,!2%., & "# ,!/0%' %##&*

32 ,!22!0%!#"#%'B3'$ %"'9&&"3., 2!& 2%'%'. ,!4!#!'4' &#2"- %' !2#!2%'. %' " ,! /!$!#306 $ 30 '4 $30 %7 %'. /"&&!&&%"' "# ,! /0%' %##"7!2 ,!&3% 0'4*3% 9&4%&-%&&!4>: ,!2%0"32 7%4!"24!2 4 !4*<*'4 ,!$"3' !2$0%-"'>!,0#"# ,!4!#!'4' & " ,! !@ !' , ,!:9!2!%'/"&&!&&%"'"#<;'0&=-20&"#&3% 0'4'4 ,! /0%' %##&2!2!& 2%'!4#2"-$2! %'.':4%& 32>'$!%'/"&&!&&%"' ,!2!"#6

9&00"9!4* %7%0 //!0 ,7%'. >!!' /2!#!22!46 ,! 0!2'!4 44% %"'0 %& 2%$ 34.!6,%9'%%' !2-&"#B34.!-!' 4 !4)**,&&! &%4! ,!B34.!-!' "# ,!2%0"32 '4 ,!&3% #%0!4>: ,!/0%' %##,&>!!' 4!$2!!4*

!&30 ' 0:64!#!'4' ,%-%'.,%&%'&!$"'4//!0>!#"2! ,%&"32 *

2*'32.%'6$"3'&!02!/2!&!' %'. ,!//!00' 6 ,!7!2: "3 &! 6&3>-% & , &2!.24&"9'!2&,%/"# ,!&3% /2"/!2 :,!9"304'" ,7!-3$, "2.3!* "9!7!269% ,2!.24 "/"&&!&&%"' ,!2!"#% %& $"' !'4!4 , ,!5"9!2//!00 !"32 ,&!22!4%'"7!20"";%'. ,! !7%4!'$!443$!4"'2!$"24'49,%$,9"3042!#0!$ , ,!//!00' ,4 >!!'&,"9'%'$30 %7 %'./"&&!&&%"'"# ,!0'4%'?3!& %"'* %&2.3!4 , %' ,!#"2 ,!:!2@* <&9!00&

@* +$2"/ "//!00' 9&2!$"24!4%' /"&&!&&%"'"#+;'0&-20&'4&3$,4"$3-!' &$22%!4/2!&3-/ %"' "# 23 ,>!%'.4"$3-!' &"#2!$"24"#2%., &* %&$"' !'4!4 , ,!!' 2: "#/"&&!&&%"'%'&3$,2!$"24&$"304'" ,7!>!!'>23&,!4&%4!>: ,! 5"9!2//!00 !"32 * !0%'$!,&0&">!!'/0$!43/"' ,!B34.!-!' & "# ,!/!@"32 %'

! '4 "#

# $% &''( ') "$"' !'4 , %#/0%' %##%&'" %'/"&&!&&%"'6 ,!'6&3% #"2-!2!4!$02 %"'9"304'" >!-%' %'>0!* 7%'.,!24$"3'&!0#"2 ,!//!00' 0!'. ,'4,7%'. /!23&!4 ,!$&!//!2>"";6-"# ,!$"'&%4!2!47%!9 , ,!%'& ' //!0%&9% ,"3 -!2% '44!&!27!& ">!4%&-%&&!4*

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

2! 32'!4 , # !2 ,!4! ,"#-2% ,!/2"/!2 :9&%',!2% !4>:2 ,'4'4&%'$!2,'44%!4432%'. ,!/!'4!'$:"# ,!&3% 6,!'$!6 ,%&9%#!,-!0%!7%9&!' % 0!4 "%',!2% ,!&3% 0'4* ,%-%'.,

//!00' ,!2!%'

#%0!4$%7%0//!0.%'& ,!B34.!-!' '44!$2!! 4 !4*<*==+/&&!4>: ,!2%0"32 >3 ,!&-!9&4%&-%&&!4"' =** >: ,!%& 2%$ 34.!6,%9'%* 7!' ,! !.302!$"'4 //!0/2!#!22!4>:,%-%'.,9&4%&-%&&!4>: ,%&"32 "'*=** ,!B34.!-!' &/&&!4>: ,!2%0"32 65"9!2//!00 !"32 '4 ,%& "32 %' !.302!$"'4//!09!2!430:/0$!4"'2!$"24'4!@,%>% !4 &@* " * 9"304>!//"&% ! " ;!'" ! , %' ,!/2!7%"3&2"3'4"# 0% %. %"',%-%'.,F/2!&!' //!00' ,40&"&"3., 2!0%!#"#/!2-'!' %'B3'$ %"' "2!& 2%' ,""0/ %6,-!0%!7%'4" ,!2&#2"-0%!' %'.

,!&3% 0'4%'':-''!2'4 #2"-$2! %'. ':%' !2#!2!'$!%',%& /"&&!&&%"'"7!2 ,!&3% 0'4*7!'&3$,2!0%!#,4>!!'4!'%!4'4 ,! #%'4%'.&/!2 %'%'. "/"&&!&&%"'9!2!0&"2! 32'!4.%'& ,%-%'.,'4 9,%$,,7!&%'$! %'!4#%'0% :* 7!' ,"3.,6$"3'&!09"3040:-3$,& 2!&&"' @* < '4

@* + 9,%$, 9!2! &3>&!?3!' " ,!

B34.!-!' '44!$2!!/&&!4>: ,!2%0"32 .%'& ,%-%'.,'4 9"30432.! , ,!&-!2!#0!$ !4/"&&!&&%"'"# ,!//!00' "7!2 ,!&3% /2"/!2 :6:! 6 ,!5"9!2//!00 !"32 ,&2%., #300:2!B!$ !4&3$,/0!>: ">&!27%'. , '"!7%4!'$!,4>!!'443$!4"'2!$"24 "2!#0!$ & ""' 9, >&%&,!,4>!!'4!0%7!2!4/,:&%$0'4$30 %7 %'./"&&!&&%"'"# ,! &3% 0'4# !24! ,"#-2%* ,&>!!'$"'$!4!4>: ,!$"3'&!0 ,

"2 ,4'" >!!'/2"43$!4%'&/% !"# ,!

"9'!2&,%/>!%'.%'#7"32"# ,!/0%' %##&F2!&/"'4!' &*

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

< ,!%'& ' //!0%&9% ,"3 -!2% *"?3!& %"'"#09-3$, 0!&&&3>& ' %0?3!& %"'"#09%&%'7"07!4%' ,!/2!&!' //!0* ,!//!0%&4%&-%&&!4*

03$;:

E,! ,!2&/!;%'.F2!&"'!4( !&F"

E,! ,!2 !/"2 >0!( !&F"