← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3685/2023dismissed

Mohan Lal(Deceased) Through His Lr'S v. Gurcharan Singh And ORS

2026-03-09Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal6 pages

 

    

 

!

"# !$%&!

"

'((##

)$

*%$!$

 &!

!$

' +

      

,$

$ -$.$  &!

/!%! +10

   



2!

3

++  (

++  $ 8%+&0 8# +!$0 .!$67 .!# ##.

++

(

/1# 8%+&

8% $ 1 0 ,!##%$0

($#7 +$+

9$

: 1  #$70

!## $$$+

!$ $&

%

!%

%##7 + $6+



%+

1##& 0 2!

# ,!##%$0  $ 8# +!$

!$ $ $$$+

;!

($($73 1$7

0 0

($+ 8%#70

= # .!

$ >  ?

( 

%&! 

$ 0

 

$ 70 & $

  0 ! &

%$ $ 5: #$

($($70

%&!

 

#5+ 0 .!

+

6$+0

A#% 1 .

$

$+

0 !+ +%+



 5 !#7

<0 .!!

+

$

7$

((+ (7 $ 8% 0

0

!%&!

!  %+ 47

!+

$1+ #&#

 %(

   +$ 

2$

$ ,$($7 0

 0 6% + ( !0 $%

1

!+ $!$0

!$ ! &  5$##7

.$

5 :

($#5 $7 64

$&$+ 5 6#7  

$+ !+ #+ $%



(#++

!+ #$+7 (+

#.

1$$+ ($$ #

%0

((+ $1 $!$0 !+ !$

&

1+ ##&##7

9$5 (#+

##.

%

.$ $5+ 

 C!!$

.7

,,

 C!!$

$1$7

0 0

>

5 !

.!

$ >  ?

%5 # .!

$ D

,,

 C!!$

($7+ $D

,,

B C!!$

($

5 6#D

,

 C!!$

5

.!

#

,

 C!!$

#%



# ($

%D

,

= C!!$

% 

# ($

%D

,

 #

,$

#+ !$ (1 1+

=

$# 5

1+ ++

E.1$0

+

##.+ ++

 $ 8%+&0 8# +!$0 1+ ++

 0 !$67 +$

&&$1+

+ +





!1 !$+ #$ %

#

"$ %

#

%65

&$1##7 $$+

 .##

$ (

$#

$&%+ 5(%&

(

/%$0

6

5 $+

1+

$&%+ 

($1+

$$+

B 6$ $# !+ #$+

$

+0 !% !$

&$%

$+$

$&%+

$# !+ $&!#7 $$++  !+

#+ ($1

.

$ !(

($($70 6%

/%$0 .$ &#7 $$++

$#

!( # +#$+ 

+5+0 !$

$F%$5 ($1 .

$ !(

(

!1

+$+

%65

5+

#$ %

# 0 6% 

5

+1+ 5$

/%$0 .!#



$# /%$0 %

$#

!( 6.

(%

.$

5 !+ +5+

# +#$+

%

$#$

+

0 + !+ +5+

%5 6 A#% 1 .

$

% !+ A5

$ 7 G%#+(  &!

,C0 .! $$+ 1$

0 6% !

$

A5

%

# +

$&!#7 !#+

1

!$. 0

% .

$ !(

$#1

# +#$+ (% $#1 A$

/%$0 $+

+$ 

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

$((%' %' .-"3.%'3 -"3 /$"-"/ 5$/&$$" /)$ +-'/*$( &-( "$1$' 3*(+2/$3 56 '$(+%"3$"/03$,$"3-"/ -( */ &-( -34*//$3 56 )*4 /)-/ (2*/ )%2($ &-( '$"/$3 %2/ /% )*4 56 -++$..-"/0+.-*"/*,, "#$'$.-/*%"()*+%,.$(($$-"3 .$((%' %' .-"3.%'3 -"3 /$"-"/ 5$/&$$" /)$ +-'/*$( &-( "%/ 3*(+2/$3 '$(+%"3$"/03$,$"3-"/ &-( $(/%++$32"3$'$#/*%" <%,"3*-"1*3$"#$#/ ,'%4 #.-*4*"8 /)-/ -++$..-"/0+.-*"/*,, &-( "%/ %&"$'%,/)$(2*/)%2($ $.*-"#$*"/)*('$8-'3#-" 5$+.-#$32+%".-&.-*33%&"56%"5.$2+'$4$ %2'/ %, "3*- *" #-($ /*/.$3 -( 0( -6-.

$"/ ?@!

&)$'$*"*/)-(5$$")$.3/)-/.-"3.%'3*("%/ '$72*'$3/%+'%1$A2'-.'$.-/*%"()*+%,.-"3.%'3-"3 /$"-"/ 5$/&$$" /)$ +-'/*$( -"3 /$'4*"-/*%" %, /$"-"#6 $*/)$' 56 .-+($ %, /*4$ %' 56 ($'1*"8 "%/*#$ 2"3$' $#/*%" >< %, '-"(,$' %, '%+$'/6 #/ &)$"5%/)/)$($,-#/(-'$"%/3*(+2/$3 %2'/ #-"+-((-3$#'$$$1$"*"/$'4(%, '3$' = 2.$< %, %&*"/)$#-($*")-"3-.(% '$.-/*%"()*+ 5$/&$$" /)$ +-'/*$( &-( "$1$' 3*(+2/$3 56 '$(+%"3$"/03$,$"3-"/ / )-( -.(% 5$$" 32.6

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

## %$!$0

!#+

5% B0

  ($+

B ##

#

%0

!#+ !5 $1

<# 5% + #

##

E.1$0

% 5

($

1+

!

$&$+

#+





$$++



+

%$ ##&#7 $ ($1$ 70

.$$ $$ !

($

B

1.

$5 



$%5  +

 5$

($

5

$+ &#7 5

, ((#

0 

!##



  

  

C!!$

(: &<$

H <I

C!!$ $($6#

H <I