High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-LP/31/2016dismissed

Apoorva Kalia v. Baba Farid University & ORS

2016-12-028 pages

!" #

% &'

(

) * (+(

) ",-#-./ 0

123"4"5" 6115." ,!11-55" , 7-2/8/ "9" "2# 3-2/,:& 2/ 6 -/1 #- ,/ 0 ;95-28/,.-<<<"2 ;95-28/,.-<=->=-2="?"

2-/- ,0 2<8 5="#="@<- 2#3.",-?,= / "55"3< A=@#3.",-2,=- "115." ,!"11-55" , BBB <<<"2 @ =-2-3-?"115.", ="/9-- 5-#9:,=-"115." ,!"11-55" , 123"4"5"/--> A2-3-?,=-C8#AD- ," #2#-2#",-#

1"//-# 9: ,=/ 82,

(

) 5 A ?,= ,=- 2-3-? "115.",

="/9-- 5-#/--> A. # ",

) #":/ 5 A,=-2-3-?"115.", =- "115." ,!"11-55" , 5-# 35 *2, 1-,, +(

) ,=/82,2#2-., A"9" "2# 3-2/,:-"5,=<.- .-/@

"2#>,,=28A=,/ -A/,2"2%E 3-2/,:;2/=2,'%2-/1 #- , ' , . /#-2 " # A2" , =-2 "#D// , ,=- < 82/- "A" /, ,=- E2#-22-"",-A2:; ,-2D/=-2 2--#."5 ,2" .--/,% '

" > ,=- :-"2

)F 9-/#-/@ /=,!2-"55.",- ,=- /-",/ "55,,-# , 2-/1 #- ,/, ,=-E2#-22-"",-A2:;,- -2"5",-A2: "/ ,=-: ="# /-.82-# D2- D"2>/ ,=" ,=- 5"/, /-5-.,-# ." ##",-/ - 2-/1 #- ,/),G ,=-- -2"5",-A2:=-."/-/-,819:,=- "115." ,!"11-55" ,="/9-- ,=",2-/1 #- ,/,?=="3-9--

A2" ,-# "#D// / , ,=- < 82/- ,=- E2#-2 2-" ",-A2:; ?-2- ="3 A D2- 2 =A=-2 D"2>/ ,=" ,=- 5"/, /-5-.,-# - -2"5 ",-A2:." ##",-/ ,=--#."555-A-/ ,=-<,",-=-2-2-@,=-: ?-2-5"95-,9-/=,-#!"55.",-#/-",/ ,=-- -2"5",-A2:" #D">- ?":21-2/ /?=="#A3- 1, 2,=- -/-23-#",-A2:2#-2 2-" "..2#" .-?,=,=-"#3-2,/-D- , =-?2,1-,, 5-#9:,=-"115." ,!"11-55" ,?"/#/D//-# 9:"5-"2 -#< A5-8#A-,=/82,3#-2#-2#",-#

),?"/ ,.-#,=",,=",5"8/-

,=- ,.", ,=",?"/"115."95-?"/, 9- 55?-# , "#C8/, ,=- -/-23-# ",-A2: ." ##",-/ ,=- - -2"5 ",-A2: ."/- ,=-: ?-2- =A=-2 D-2, =- /"# 5"8/-

,=- ,.", 2-"#/"/55?/0

." ##",-2D 2-/-23-#.",-A2:/="55="3-,=- 2A=,,.D1-,-2"#D// 1- D-2, 2A- -2"5 .",-A2: /-",/ "/ 1-2 =/!=-2 D-2, ,=- #": .8 /-55 A" #." ##",-//-5-.,-#?55 ,9-.8 ,-# ,?"2#/"#D// ,=-2-/-23-.",-A2:I =- 3-2/,:-J15" -#,=",,=2--." ##",-/-2-/1 #- ,/ ,="#9-- A3- "#D// ,=- /,.8 /-55 A9: 5 -12.-// " # ,=-: ## , ",,- # ,=- 5"/, .8 /-55 A =-5# (! (

) =-2-2-@ ,=-: ?-2- , /=,-# , ,=- - -2"5 ",-A2: =/ -J15" ", ?"/ 9/-23-# , 9- 8 C8/,"95- 3-? ,=- "2-/"# 5"8/-

,=- ,.", "/2--22-#,"93-?-3-2@,?"/=-5# ,=", 2-5-.85#9-A2" ,-#,,=-"115." ,!"11-55" , "..8 ,,=- #-- .-,=- 3-2/,:,=",,=-1-,, -2 =-2E2#-22-"",-A2:; ="# 2" >-# ", ) " # ,=-2- ?-2- "98, ) /,8#- ,/ "93- =-2

=-2-2-@ =-2

, /--> "#D// ,=- 9"// D-2, ?"/ =-5#,9-8 C8/,"95- =-"115." ,!"11-55" ,"AA2-3-#"A" /,,=-/"#2#-2#",-#

)1"//-#9:,=-5-"2 -#< A5-8#A-5-#-,,-2/ ",- ,11-"5

(

)@?=.=?"/#/D//-#9:,=/82,

,?"/ ,.-# ,=", ,=- ." ##",-/ 2D ,=- E2#-2 2-" ",-A2:; ?= ?-2- ="3 AD2-D"2>/,=" ,=-5"/,- -2"5",-A2:." ##",-/?85#5>- ,12--22-/-23-#/-",/ ,=-.55-A-/,=-2.=.- =- 3-2/,:="#/89D,,-#" "#"3, ,-2"5"/,", A,=", #8- , #-2- .- -- /,28.,82- " # ",82- .55-A-/@ , ?"/ , 1//95-,D15-D- ,2-/-23", "AA2-A",-/-",/2",=-2,?"/D"#- .55-A- ?/- 9"// , ?"/ D- , -# ,=", 9-2- 3, A 5 - "115.", /2.8 /-55 A"55,=-"3"5"95-?-2-#/15":-#.55-A-?/- ,=- 3-2/,: ?-9/,- =- ." ##",-/ A"3- 12--2- .- .55-A-! .",-A2:!.82/-!K8," ", ,=- ,D- 55 A 5 - "115.", 2D/ , ?"/",,=",1"2,.85"2DD- ,,=",,=-/,8#- ,#-.#-#"/,?=.=.55-A- =-!/=- ?

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

" # 3-2 D- , - ,"5 55-A-@

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

*''+&,')+-,'

.+'+ +',')+-,' <2

55 "D- " #

",=-2;/ "D-

"2>/ " # 3-2"5 5 " >

55 "D- " #

",=-2;/ "D-

"2>/ " # 3-2"5 5 " > 55-A-

) ++

"3 "2A #! <= " =" # "2>/ )++

" >

( ) G() <=3"D < A5" /! <="2-/= 81," "2>/ )++

" >

3-2 D- , -#."5 55-A-@ ","5" "2>/ )G

" > ( ) )G( "212 # -2 4"82 #! <= 82D"5 < A= )

(

.=" #! <=

"C 48D"2 81," "2>/ )+

" > )

) <D2" -C" #! <= 7 # -C" "2>/ )G)

" > 3-2 D- , D-#."5 55-A-@ D2,/"2 ) )

<"=5 /! <= 5 48D"2 "2>/ )+

" > ( ) )+ A-5 = A2" /! <= 548D"2 = A2" "2>/ )G

" > ( 828 9 # < A= -#."5 55-A-@

"2#>, )

,>" "?"#! 4"D"5C, < A= "2>/ ))

" >

)

(

">/=" #/ #! <= =D<" "2>/ )))

" >

+ 3-2 D- , - ,"5 55-A-@

","5"

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

##",-/ -J.-1, 2 ">/=" #" ?

,>""?"=-/-/,8#- ,/,=-E2#-22-"",-A2:;." ##",-"2- ,5"95-,9-#/5#A-#9:"/> A,=-D,/-->"#D// / ,=- 1- 2 - -2"5 ",-A2: "A" /, ,=-2 12--2- .-/ , ?"/ 9/-23-# ,=",

5"8/-

,=- ,.", #",-#

) ="# 9-- "115-# " D" -2,=", , 5:" 1, /A3- ,,=-2-/-23-#.",-A2:/,8#- ,/ ,.D1-,-2,=-"#D// / 1- D-2,2- -2"5",-A2:98," 112,8 ,: / "5/ A3- , ,=- -/-23-# ",-A2: /,8#- ,/ , -J-2./- ,=-2 12--2- .- ,=- /,,8, ?=.= ,=-: ?-2- #-/28/ 8 #-2A A,=-2.82/-=/1, ?"/A3- ",,=-,D-.8 /-55 A =-"115." ,!"11-55" ,5-#< %' ))+

?=.= ?"/ #/D//-# 9: ,=- ;95- <812-D- 82, )G

=- 2#-2 #/D// A,=-< 2-"#/"/55?/0 H=-<1-."5-"3- -,, /#/D//-#I =- "115." ,!"11-55" , ,=- 5-# -3-? -,, %35' +

,=- "2-/"# < %' ))+

?=.= ?"/ #/D//-# (

=-/"#2#-22-"#/"/8 #-20 H115.", 2#2-., /" #2"5=-"2 A"2-2-C-.,-# *- ="3- ."2-855: A - ,=28A= ,=- 2-3-? 1-,, " # ,=- . -.,-# 1"1-2/ *- # D-2, ,=- 2-3-? 1-,, " #,=-/"D-/"..2# A5:#/D//-#I ?@,=-12-/- ,2-3-?"115.", ="/9-- 5-# ,=/82, 22-3-?,=-2#-2#",-#

1"//-#

(

) , / /89D,,-# ,=", / .- ,=- < ="/ 9-- #/D//-# ?,=8, "//A A " :2-"/ F,=-2-2-@ 3-?,=-5"?5"##? 9:,=-<812-D-82, 48 =":"DD-#3<,",-4-2"5"@%

' <)(@,." ,9-/"# ,=", ,=-2- ?"/ " : "#C8#.", D-2,/ ,=- ."/- " # "/ /8.= ,=- 12-/- , 2-3-? "115.", @ , / /89D,,-#@ / 3-2: D8.= D" ," "95- <D5"2 3-?@ , / /89D,,-#@ ="/ 9-- ,">- 9: ,=- <812-D- 82, ", "58/ A1<.-,:,#3<,",- "C"/,=" @%

)' <

(" # 85C,4"823<,",- 8 C"9" #,=-2/@

%' %35'

%<'F 9-/#-/@ 9: ,=/ 82, D"2 < A= " # ,=-2/ 3 <,",- "2:" "" #,=-2/@

+%' %35'%'% &' *-="3-A3- 82,=8A=,85. /#-2", ,,=-. ,- , / ,=-5-"2 -#.8 /-5"11-"2 A2,=-"115." ,!"11-55" ," #"5/="3- 1-28/-#,=-2-.2# =-2-/ #/18,-,,=-121/, ,=",?=-2-"1-,, 2 5-"3- , "11-"5 / #/D//-# 9: ,=- ;95- <812-D- 82, 9: /1-"> A 2#-2 ?=.= #-/ , "//A " : 2-"/ / 2 #/D// A ,=- 1-,, @,?85# , -,=-2",,2".,,=-#.,2 -D-2A-2/"/,/," # /89/,,8,-# 15".-,=-2#-218, //8-9-2-, 2 ?85#,9- " #-.5"2", 5"? 9: ,=- <812-D- 82, 8 #-2 2,.5- ,=- /,,8, 2,=-2-/ 5"??=.=="/9-- #-.5"2-#?-3-2@ ,=- 12-/- ,."/-@,=-2#-2#",-#(

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

/.=-#85-2,=-:-"2/,9-"#=-2-#,=-"#D// /"2-,=-:-"2

) ?=.= ,=- "115." ,!"11-55" , ="# /8A=, "#D// =- /"# "#D// 12.-//9- A3-2@ 82,=-2. /#-2", ?85#9-2-K82-# ",,=//,"A- ,=- .2.8D/," .-/@ ,=- 2-3-? 1-,, / #/D//-# =- K8-/, #-5": 5 A ,=- 2-3-? 1-,, / 5: "."#-D. " # ,=- /"D-/"5/#/D//-# %<<<"2 ' 8#A-

%<=->=-2="?" ' "D, 8#A- ,-0 % ' *=-,=-2,=-2#-2//1-"> A!2-"/ -#0 -/ %' *=-,=-2,=-2#-2/2-12,"95- 0 -/