High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4301/2017dismissed

Anil Jain v. Rulda Singh & ANR

2019-05-07Mr. Justice Amit Rawal7 pages

!"##$%&%'(!) *+ '%,!%'

--#,,!'"

.#/&0&

0,1!%'23 !'"3#/ #&-'1#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

/#&#'"( / !4%56!"!/%!*15$!"#* /"3#!--#,,!'" 77777 *)+%,'

3#-/#&#'" #20,!/#$'1--#!, %&1%/#$"#1!2!%'&""3# $'$0//#'"%'1%'2&!$"*83#/#9)"3#&0%""3#!--#,,!'":-,!%'"%/ &-#$%%$-#//;!'$#"3#!2/##;#'""&#,,1!"#1<=%'/#&-#$" -,"9#!/%'2<+*#$"/*!'&!#5%;-,#>*%&"/%$" !'$3?0,!

!2/##1"9#&,1/!""!,&!,#$'&%1#/!"%'<<**@:'"3#9!&%& !,,";#'"1!"#1A==*3!&9##'1%&;%&&#1!'1!%/;#1%' !--#!, --#,,!'":-,!%'"% !&&#/"#1 "3!" 1##'1!'" * 9#%'2 "3# !,,""##"3#!/#;#'"%'#1-,"*%'-0/&0!'$#""3#!,,";#'",#""#/ #'"#/#1%'"!'!2/##;#'""&#,,**"3023'"!/2#"1!"#8!&&"%-0,!"#1* 90"!&0; <*A*@:8!&-!%1!&#!/'#&";'#)3#,!&"1!"# -!);#'"8!&!2/##1!&< !'1"3#9!,!'$#!;0'" +*A*@:

8!&"9#-!%13#"#/;&!'1$'1%"%'&"3#!2/##;#'"8#/#&!$/&!'$" !'1"3#'#$#&&!/)-#/;%&&%'8!&/#B0%/#1"9#0'1#/"!?#'9)"3#-,!%'"%

##'1!'"3!1*' *"!?#'!&0;**@:!&"3#/# 8!& 1#,!) %' 9"!%'%'2 "3# # !$?'8,#12#1 " 3!5# /#$#%5#1 <*A*@:%'!,,!'1"3#"%;#8!&'""3##&&#'$#"3#!2/##;#'" "8!&0/"3#/!5#//#1%'"3#-,!%'""3!"8%'2""3#%'$/#!&# -/%$#&*1##'1!'"&#'"!,#2!,'"%$#1!"#1 $!'$#,,%'2"3# !2/##;#'"#$;;%""#1$3#!"%'28%"3"3#-,!%'"%9)"!?%'2!11%"%'!, !;0'"'"3#-/#;%&#"3!"3#80,19"!%'"3# *83#/#!&3!1!,/#!1) /#5?#1"3# 8%"3"3#&"!"# %$#* *83%$38!&#5%1#'"/;

"3#,#""#/1!"#1< ';#/%"&*1##'1!'"1%1'"1#')"3#8'#/&3%-"3# -,"3!5%'29##'!,,""#10'1#/"3#0&"##&-,%$)!'1"3#!2/##;#'""&#,, "8!&&"!"#1"3!""3#/#8!&#!/,%#/!2/##;#'"1!"#1 =83#/#"3# -,!%'"%3!1-!%1!&0; *A*@:!&#!/'#&";'#)%'"3#-/#&#'$# "3#8%"'#&&#&*"30&*"3#1##'1!'"3!1/#$#%5#1!&0;<*A*@:/; "3#-,!%'"%*83#/#!&"3#-,!%'"%3!1!2/##1"-#//;#'"%/#"/!'&!$"%' '< @< 3#1##'1!'"!--/!$3#1"3#%$#"3#09

#2%&"/!/'< *90"%"8!&3,%1!)3#/#!"#/*'+ 3# 8#'"""3#%$#09 #2%&"/!/!'1/#;!%'#1-/#&#'"*90"-,!%'"%1%1 '"$;#/8!/1,#2!,'"%$#1!"#1 8!&&#'"9)1##'1!'"

$!'$#,,%'2"3#!2/##;#'"*83%$38!&/#-,%#19)"3#-,!%'"%5%1#/#-,) 1!"#1< 3#1##'1!'"/#-,%#1"3#&!;#9)8!)/#4%'1#/& 1!"#1 !'1 &-#/"3#'"%$#1!"#1 *"3# !2/##;#'" 8!& $!'$#,,#1 !'1 "3# #!/'#&" ;'#) 8!& /#%"#1 3# 1##'1!'"!,&/#$#%5#1!,#2!,'"%$#1!"#1= /;"3#&"!"# %$#/*83%$38!&/#-,%#1'A 3!1%&&0#1!'"%$#1!"#1 ""3#1##'1!'"83%$38!&10,)/#-,%#1' !'1

$#/"!%' "3#/ $//#&-'1#'$#& ##'1!'" !,& %&&0#1 '"%$# 1!"#1 A ""3#&"!"# %$#//'""/!'&#//%'2"3#-,"%'!50/"3# -,!%'"%/!')91)#,&# %'$#"3#-!/"%#&8#/#!"5!/%!'$#*"3#"/%!,0/"/!;#1"3# ,,8%'2%&&0#&(:

!""

#$ %

!""

!"&

$ !"&

' $

!"&

() * + , !"&

+ -

,!%'"%*%'&0--/""3#-,#!1%'2&*#>!;%'#1 D:!&&) '!'1*$0;#'">-#/"* D:093!&33!'1#/* #$/16##-#/* D: '%,!%' -,!%'"% !'19/023"'/#$/1"3#,,8%'21$0;#'"&(: > D@

#-/"!'18/%"%'2!'1 %'2#/ /%'">-#/" > D@ 3"2/!-3%$',!/2#;#'"!""!$3#18%"3/#-/" " >-#/" > D@< > D@ ""#&"#1$-)!,,";#'",#""#/ > D@ -),#""#/1!"#1

> D@ -),#""#/1!"#1+= > D@ -),#2!,'"%$#1!"#1A

> D@ #$#%-":$0;:!2/##;#'"1!"#1<= > D@ 2/##;#'"1!"#1 A !/?: D/%"%'2/#2!/1%'2/#$#%-"-!);#'"

&**@:'1!"#1 '"3#9!$?&%1# !2/##;#'"1!"#1 = > D@ E#""#/1!"#1< > D@ &"!,/#$#%-"& " > D@ !/?: -),#""#/ !/?: -)!%1!5%" 0,1!%'23 !/?: !'?/#$#%-"1!"#1= ' "3# "3#/ 3!'1* 1##'1!'"& #>!;%'#1 0/ 8%"'#&&#&* '!;#,)*D:!&8%'1#/%'23*D:093!&33!'1*D: 0,1!%'23

1##'1!'" !'1D:#5%'1#/ !/&!1*$0;#'"&!'1!'18/%"%'2 >-#/"!'1!,&9/023"'/#$/1"3#,,8%'21$0;#'"&(: > -)!2/##;#'"1!"#1 = > -)9!'?/#$#%-" > -)!$?'8,#12;#'"/#$#%-" >"

#$#%-"&9!'?

>< -),#""#/1!"#1/#2!/1%'20#& #/"%%$!"#%&&0#19) >+ -),#""#/1!"#1 %&&0#19) > -)/#-,)1!"#1 >

&"!,/#$#%-"

&"!,/#$#%-" >

/#$#%-" >D@ -),#""#/1!"#1= 8/%""#'" 0,1! 9) >D@ -),#2!,'"%$#1!"#1 >D@ -),#2!,'"%$#1!"#1 >D@ E#""#/1!"#1 8/%""#'9)

- 1#-!/";#'"";"6!0&3!,)!3!/;!*15$!"# >D@ -),#2!,'"%$#1!"#1

>D@ E#""#/1!"#1= 8/%""#'9) #-!/";#'"";"6!0&3!,)!#5%*15$!"# >D@ -)/#-,)",#2!,'"%$# >D@ &"!,/#$#%-" >D@ -),#2!,'"%$#1!"#1A >D@

/#$#%-" >D@ -),#2!,'"%$#1!"#1 >D@6

/#$#%-" >D@E -),#""#/1!"#1< 8/%""#'9)-,!%'"% "1##'1!'"' >D@ -),#""#/1!"#1< 8/%""#'9)-,!%'"% "1##'1!'" >D@ -),#""#/1!"#1< 8/%""#'9)-,!%'"% "1##'1!'" >D@ -),#""#/1!"#1< 8/%""#'9)-,!%'"% "1##'1!'" >D@

#2%&"#/#1#'5#,-#& " >D@ >D@ -)/#4%'1#/""3#'"%$#1!"#1< >D@

&"!,/#$#%-" >D@.

#2%&"#/#1'5#,-# >D@F -)/#4%'1#/""3#'"%$#1!"#1< >D@

/#$#%-" >D@G %1!5%" 0,1!%'231!"#1< >D@ %1!5%" 0,1!%'231!"#1+ >D@ !,#'1#/"3#)#!/ >D@ #-/"$0;#'"&!'1 %'2#/ /%'">-#/" " !,'28%"3 3"2/!-3%$',!/2#;#'"& >D@A / !4%56!"!/%!*,#!/'#1$0'&#,/#-/#&#'"%'2"3#!--#,,!'": -,!%'"%&09;%""#1"3!"9"3"3#$0/"&9#,83!5#$;;%""#1%,,#2!,%")!'1

. -#/5#/&%")%''':&0%"%'2"3#-,!%'"%9)/#,)%'20-'"3#/!"%1#$%1#'1% $0,,#10"9)'H9,#"3#0-/#;#0/"%' * /0

1 23%4 5446 27 /

894, /:/ .*83%$38!& '""9#!--,%#1""3#-/#&#'"$!&#!&"3#$'"#'"&"3#,#""#/1!"#1 = /#5#!,#1 "3!" "3#/# 8!& $//#&-'1#'$# 9#"8##' "3# &"!"# %$#/!'1"3#1##'1!'"/#2!/1%'2'':"!,,)%'2"3#&%2'!"0/#&&-#/ "3#"#/;&!'1$'1%"%'&"3#!2/##;#'"*9,%2!"%'8!&'"3#-,!%'"%* 90""3#!/#;#'"%'#1$//#&-'1#'$#8!&'"9/023"""3#'"%$#"3# -,!%'"% !'1*"3#/#/#*"3#/#8!& ! ;!,!%1#%'"#'"%' %' "3#;%'1 1##'1!'"#"?"3#!15!'"!2#"3#,!8!'13!1$!'$#,,#1"3# !2/##;#'"' 9)&#'1%'2!,#2!,'"%$#83%$38!&10,)/#-,%#1 3#/#8!&'$$!&%'/"3#-,!%'"%"!--#!/%'"3#%$#09

#2%&"/!/'< !&"3#1##'1!'"$'$#1#1,)3!1'""!?#'!') *83#/#!&"3#,#""#/8!&',)&#'"'A 2%5%'2$!0&#9/#!$3 #'!9,%'2"3#-,!%'"%"%'&"%"0"#"3#&0%"' !; !/!%1* "3# !/#;#'"%'#1 !/20;#'"& 80,1 '" 9# &0&"!%'!9,#%'"3##)#&,!8D3!"#5#/"3#!$"&;!)9#*"3#-/-&%"%' /#,%#10-'%'* /0

#4 44 ,%&"3!"%'$!&#$!'$#,,!"%'

9)"3#1##'1!'"/%23",)/8/'2,)*%"%&9,%2!"/)0-'"3#-,!%'"%" $3!,,#'2#"3#&!;#9)&##?%'21#$,!/!"%'%'&"#!11%&$/#"%'!/)/#,%# 0'1#/#$"%'"3#-#$%%$ #,%#$" "%&!;!""#//#$/1"3!""3#'"%$#8!&;0$3-/%/""3# %,%'2"3#&0%"*%#* 5#'%"3#!/20;#'"/6!"!/%!%&" 9#!$$#-"#1/#2!/1%'2'':&0--,)"3#$//#&-'1#'$#/%'/;!"%' /#$#%5#1 9) 1##'1!'" /; * "3#/# 8!& ' $!0&# / "3# -,!%'"%"&##?&-#$%%$-#//;!'$#*80,1'"3#,-*/*"3#$'"#'"&

"3#,#""#//#!10"',)&-#,,#10""3#'':"!,,)%'2"3#&%2'!"0/#&*90""3# !$" "3# ;!""#/ %& "3!" %" 8!& "3# -,!%'"%* 83 &09;%""#1 !,, "3# 1$0;#'"&/"/!'&#/"3#-," 3#"#/;&!'1$'1%"%'&"3#!2/##;#'""&#,,/#!10"%' "3#$0/"9,%2!"#1"3#-,!%'"%"-#//;#!$3!'1#5#/)-!/"/9"!%'%'2 &0$3#5#'"3!&9##'-,!$#1'/#$/1B0!'':$-#/!"%'"3# 1##'1!'"$!,,%'20-'3%;"-#//;3%&-!/""3#!2/##;#'"*;0$3,#&& !--#!/!'$# ' "3# &"%-0,!"#1 1!"#* %#* < " /#5#!,& "3!" "3# -,!%'"%8!&'"/#!1)!'18%,,%'2"-#//;3%&-!/""3#!2/##;#'"!'1 8%'2 " "3#$!'$#,,!"%' 9)&#'1%'2 ,#2!, '"%$#*3#8!& /#B0%/#1 " $3!,,#'2#"3#&!;#%'!$$/1!'$#8%"3,!8 3#/# %& !'"3#/ !&-#$" "3# ;!""#/ 3# /#$#%-" **@:3!&'"9##'8%"'#&&#19)!')8%"'#&&

/"3#/#!&'&!/#;#'"%'#1*1'"%'1!')%,,#2!,%")/ -#/5#/&%") %' "3# $'$0//#'" %'1%'2&* 83%$3 !/# 9!&#1 ' /!, !'1 1$0;#'"!/)#5%1#'$#2/0'1/%'"#/#/#'$#%&;!1#0"*;0$3,#&& %'5,5#;#'" !') &09&"!'"%!, B0#&"%' #&0,"!'",)* "3# !--#!, %& 1%&;%&&#1

3,;

*)+%

749 '(1<& +98940/ =4

>4=

+989 82!

>4=