High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/31198/2019allowed

Love Garg And ANR v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2021-09-0723 pages

!"# $"

" %"& ' &() $"

,-.

/##0 ,

+"1,& &"$"

%. $ !&+0 ,-

, !

&()1"+ 2

* '

30 '"

, 4$

,"&$ !"#0 ,

"+ 2

1'56

78# 9$-0 , "

"+ 2 :13.

'&")$ !&-0 , "

"+ 2 ;

<<<<

=$ +"8"> +">"

+" 4" + "

& 4" &" """ "

?&$# ""

;

,A&" + )> 6

"0 &() '8-- 5&" 6A+" "+" 8"+ 2 0 4$$

"+ 2 $ "?& 3"$ #"0 3.

3" "+ 2 :

4-- +" &)8 B2

)( "B "8 &" /&- #"0 5 -0 $#"$ "#"# $8 +- 2 :0 $%0 C- 0 &$ 8"

1 3$&$ 4"

'- 8

1 %> >- 5&"

C&"$"

+">"

4" + 8 "

& " &() '8-- 5&" 6A+" "+" 8

"+ 2 6

"0 &() '8-- 5&" 6A+" "+" 8

"+ 2 ""

&" 1+- 2 :0 $%0 C- 0 &$0 &"

+"1& +&"$" +&"& & $ # . +- &"

=$ '&" *"& C- , 6"8 '&"> 5" ,0

$""

) """ D$ ',*C,6'5 ,E

=$ )" +" "

0 1 &"# 58+A0 - $ " C-> * 0 ;0

1 "8 "+ 2 :3.

->0 1 %> >- 5&" 4 !&""

$ 8"## +- 2 :0 $%0 C- 0 &$ 8&"#

?&" >" 4$ ).

C&"$"0 -"

0 "+ 2 :3.

$ "?& --# #>

"+ 2

8".

- '&" ,

;0 - & 1 &"# 58+A 4 -" 2 ""8# ,

;

0 "+ 2 :3.

$ & - &"

*&- '&)*&- @ " 4$ *&- '&">

6"8 *&-0

$""

) """ D$ *&-

E 4 4++"

A &

'&" ,

0 & 4 & )> "+ 2 :3.

4$$ +" $ 8 ) * 00 ;0

1 4$$ 4 &-8-> +

;

'- "

,A&" +#

++"

).0 4 & &"

*&- '&)*&- @ *&-

+"0 ># - '&" ,

58+"->0 '- "0 !"#$$%&' ( '#))*+&,! -,&.!/#!

!/& %0-%&0!*1&'20&. $$&! "#$ 3& ,4 +#.& (0&& (0-+ #)) &,'2+30#,'&$

,A&"

--> # ++"

).0 "+ 2 :3.

$ "?& 6

"0 &() ' 5&"- 6A+" "+"0 ""

'&" , &"

, )" &88"> # # " -0 4 - 8 -"

,A&" +# ++"

).0 ++- 4 8 )> +" 6

"0 &() '8-- 5&" 6A+" "+" 80 $#"$ "

"""# '&" ,1+- ?& 8 +"

=$ "?& 4-- + ,$"

" --" +&"$" 4" A 4$ ++-

=$ ""

0;1 )> 4> " 2 ;@

+# @ ++"

). 4 - &)8

;

,A&" 0 +" 4" &"+" " -"

"8 6

"0 &() '8-- 5&" 6A+" "+" 8"+ 2 0 4$$ "+ 2 :3.

4-- +" 4"

: "?& &)8 B2

)( "B "8 &" /&- #" 5 -0 $#"$0 4$ "+ 8 --# $8 +- ?&1'&" ,

" # -"0 +" -" 1 3$&$ 4"

'- 8 $ 4" -"

,A&" :0 +# ++"

). &() ' 5&" -+8 "+"0 $#"$0 +# & A !&- * !&-0 +"" 1 %> >- 5&"0 $ -" "-8

' "

/&- #" 5 -0 $#"$ ""

0 4$- # A !&- * !&- $ ++" +"# &"

' 2#)- 5"&8 ,0

$""

) """ D$ , E0 )" +"-8 4 "?&" ) & "

++" ""

4 + "

$8 +"+"> ?&

*- +" ""

"+"& $")-4

"# $ %

( C"8 ) ""

4-- "+" :

# ::

++"

).0 &--> -"

4$$"

+"+"> 4 &--> $ "

F4 "0 +"&- +-# 4&- $4 + $8 +& $&0 4 +" +" +"8 +"+"> ?& $

; " &- "

+" &)8 +" $ +&"$ +"+"> ?&1'&" , 6 & "

&8 * 00 ;0

1 " 8& +

=$ '- " - & + - $ "

*" 8 '- " ""

$4 4 +--> 8 &" 4 " "8 -- &8)"

" &- "

+" &"$"

"#& +" $ .4-# )& --# $8 > "0 4 +" ' : =""

"+"> ,0

$""

) """ D$ , E0 8"## $ # "

0 )# +""

--# ""

0 4&- $ +"" "

"#$ " -"

+" 0 4&- +" "#$ '&" ""

- &)?& "#$ " &"

& +&"$" 4$ $ +&"$ +"+"> "8 '&" ""

" &- "

+" "- &+ '

3 * "> ) 3."&+> ,0

$""

) """ D$ , E 4-- ' @ 6 ',*C,6'5 ,0 &)8 +"

0 ) & > &" ""0 " $ +""> -- $"

) -&# )1A1 ) + "- ! "8 "

' ! "8 "

-- &$">

C&"$"

' ;

',*C,6'5 ,0 , "" $"

-4

5 0 $&0 "#& ) +" "#$ " &"

@ +" $#$"

5 &"$"

&)8 '&" ""

"+ 2 :3.

$ - # " &"> $0 $" " " &"> # # - )> +--> &"# "

"+>8 ) $&0 "#$ '&" ""

4&- ) "-> )> > &)?& $8 )> > &"

5 - &)8 $8 & "

" ">

) &&" - +" - "

&" -

5 +" 0 -8 $" $8 &"

' "

"8- 8+- - &"

' , 0 $8 ++"-> "

+&"+ -> +"&"# +" & "

+&"+ " "> > )

5 &"$"

&)8 "

"$# "0 & -8 "+ 2 ;1 3$&$ 4"

'- 80 4 "( )> - &" $#"$ )> "&"# +- 8"

4 +# &" &$

5 0 $&0 &)8 8+&# ""

)-&-> --#- # -4 +" " "?&" . > B2

)( "B "8 > &" "+ $&- ) " ""

'&" ,1+- ?& &"

+" +" ) +" $"

"#$ +"+"> +" --#- 8"

" &- "

+" - +- "- &+ (&#8 + )> $ &"

"#$%

&'&()(*+,+),-*..G 4$$ &

/4 '#$

/ $ &$"

(&#8H +" ?&"-> " )> (&#8

2 8 4 & +"

'+" "+- $ - )> "+ 2 0

)$- " "+0 -" &- $ - ++" 8 $"

&)8

" &- "

"+ 2 :3.

""" $ "+-> +"

4$$ 8 "+3.

$ +" &"

',*C,6'5 , $> & +"+">

+" 4" -" '&&- 3"

5 &"$"

',*C,6'5 ,0 )# +- ,0 ) # +"" "

, $0 $&0 &++" +"

" '"

&- "

"+ 2

""" $"

4" 80 +"

4$$ &8 4$ "+ & 8 - +" +" 4" $#$ )"0 - 8

*" $0 $4 "0 8 -"

4-- ""

0 +"+"> ?& 4 "?&" ) $ 8"

+ ' "

$ "&8 8+&# -"1""

"?&"# ).

4-- +" "

## B2

)( "B0 4 &

" &- "

"+ 2 ' &() 8 &)8 +" $&- ++"$ &" /&- #" 5 -0 $#"$ # +"+">

"- "8 $8 -# +" 4" +

F4 "0 +"&- $" "+-> )> 4> - )> '+- '"">0 ! "8 &()0 +"8 5&" 88"0 )$- "+ 2 4&- $4 $"

"+ 2 -> +""8 +"> # +"> "+ 2

)( " &"# &" "#&8 . 4" 8 4$$ - )$- "+ 2

" &- "

+"0 $4 "0 ")& "#&8 &- "

"+ 2 0 &)8 +" "8 "+ 2 . > &$ )( 4" 80 $ &)8 +" " +"> $8 +"# 4 (&#8 + 1 98- 6#"#

'&+"0 $8 8 4> +" .# " "+&$" ""

+"+"> &"

+" $&0 +" $--# ""

$ $" -" &- "

=$ +" ' @ 6 ;

',*C,6'5 ,0 " "- "

(& +" $8 " "+"& $"&"

&.!

) *

+ ,*,

+- % "

, -

" *

% / .#

% * 0

- -

% -

# * 1 * 2)3$ - 2)4

# * " *

- "

*% - " "

# - 6 /0!1

- 2-

' # - & # --

+ , *,

+ *

+ - % "

* % #, --

"* # -*

+( , +"&- ' @ 6 ',*C,6'5 , 4&- $4 +--> 8 ) & > &" ""

$-- ) + +""> "

-- $"

) 4-- -- A11" +>)- "- ! "8 "

' ! "8 "

4$ - ,&$">

=$&0 +""> "#$ # &" ""

" "

C&"$"

+" ' ;

',*C,6'5 , , "" $"

-4

=$ +" ' : , 0 4$$ - "- $0 - "+"& $")-4 45!

"* -

% %%# "

, "

- ,

, "

#",

# *

=$ ) +" -"-> +&- 4$" " "#$ $ " &+ 88 )- +"+"> " 8 8 A0 $0 "#$ 4$$ $ " +""

8 4&- $ +"" "

"#$ " &)?&->

5 +" 0 +& 8"## &"

4 "

# ++"

). --# ""

$8 4 &

,A&" ; $&0 ) ) +"+- -0 "#$ &" ""

4-- &)?& "#$ &"

& +&"$"

+"0 4&- ) +"

=$ &"0 1 98- 6#"#

'&+"0 "

"# ) +" -- $"

"- +" 0 $ 8 -& +"

& +&"$" "8 ).

4&- ) - # +"+"> """ $"

&"0 ""+ > &1$8

*- +" (&#8 "+"& $")-4

- "*

- %,, # ,

82 2 3&

$ 9 .

# % & *3

&:&(4# +

,18!

19<<< 9 =8 >:

9 22 3

;

(4-# -

228 2"*:

" ?

"3:?'4

, "*?

*@--

3?@4

A ?

- 3?

4 " "* 5"

1 3

;1(

+ +

% -

%*"

$ -

*-# -

"*,

" *

+ +

# *

% * ?

)222222A

- -

, < = >#,

# * -

- % ?

,B ,-

82 23$4+

$ -

-# -

- 82C 23 4

7 # 8 >#, # ,% #

+ "

+ - -+,

%E 7

*"* -

- *

, # #

- ,

& F 7

"*:?'

*& $+"

" *

, % "*

,* *" "*

+ +

F 7

$ #

% -

F < ' ?

*& $+ + "5

1 +

" --

% -

, + %'

D" ,+

" +

%, *- , %

"- %

*% ,, % # #

- .#

% :

% +G :

"& , + "5

- & $

$1 ?

*& $"*

% -/

*-:

" +

3&% % 4 & 2) 3

;&% % & 2)(4 # % -

2A2A 2) /

$1 /

$ -

*& $

E 9/($!

!6+ , *, *

+- % "

, -

" *" %"* -

# *

* #

" .#

% / .#

% *

"* - -

% - # *1 * 2)

# * " *

- "

*% - " "

# - 6 /4!2--

!634/# #

3 4 # - & # --

+ , *,

+ *

+- % "

, -

* % #, --

"*# - *+

& 3 4' # -

, -

& =38-=4 /

& 83)$-84 HI'

- & )$ 38 - )$46 ?

1-& =3) -=4H

/ %

# 4 & =83-=)4 /%

# % 1-& =3$-=46 H% 6 &"

- "# + # %

- " - % - /

$1 + "

" "* -

% "

" .#

/ -

$ - ?

* & $ - %

, --

+ , *,

+ *

+ - % "

8 # /

& 22 +

% % +

)"*+*-

: /

=- &% ,& 2)' % + - # - ) 2

"* ! * -

% - +

"* 2 2 2 + /

C -

&% % & 22 + "

< C -

, .#

, -# ,

7 % % "

, ?

*& $ /

& 22 +

- /

$1 /

)

# * , "

# J#

/ .#

% #

& "

# - "*

- , +

- .#

% 3"

%,-D-

- 5,% 4 ,

+ "

"*-

* % # +

-# -

"*+*- /

$1- ?

*& $/

)- /

& 22 #

, --

- *,+ + # -

+ & "

, -

# *

## , - %

' -

* - %

,- *

;

# +

C -

- / % .#

% A

% &,

%%*

- -

, -

- "

, % "*#

% ,

+ *-

- %,-

%, ,

% -

- * -

- * %%"

- %, ,

% %%*

*- -

C- & "

& ) ,

- + , -

# #

- % 1 A #

* % ,, %

*+ "

"* ,

- - %% "* %

&"*

" 7 "

% ,,

" "* ,

, B "*

- %"

- % - "

-- *, ,

* -

-# / %

* +

" "* ,

% *

- % " "

% /

" % #

" "*# -

% ,, , - #, "

-# -

"* +

A% ,,

*- %

* #, "

* % H

,"% ,, % C86 C$+"

5,% ->G"

% :

1 A 1" "

222384/

)+ +

, ,+ + % %

* & $ /

& 22 +

$1 )

# *

E >+ #

* - " #

- *

' %% +-,

- B* ,

" 4

, -

* - " #

% ,,

+K ,-

% % +

,- "5

- L,

-% + + ,

+ - +,

- "5

=$ &, ?

8)$ "

-, 1-1

#/ -1

&?C/

2 "

"* , , - +

+ +% *-# - +

*- , "

, # "* +-

-, "*%,% *#"

- + + %- +

-* - ? "

+-! ,, 3' / # $=)4K

% .#

% "

"K( H% 6 '

% #

% # "* .#

% / % .#

% ,

- % - % ,, A

-# % ,,

, # "

"* +

< &:!:!1 -3

3 ,

5/ , ,

5/ ,

, 3 -

- 3 ,

5/ , !

!,!1

!! 5/, !

!,!

45 2 (55& 3

;

- -3 "

$%= )

- -

2 (>>/

2 &''& 3- -

- 3

- 32!?

3 -

! &:!5!@ 2 3 -

3 3

- A

! , +"&- ) (&#8 4&- $4 "

&# -- + 8"0 $ &" $ )" +"

+" ) +"+"> $ &"

' "

&$ +"+"> - &" )> " 8"## +""

+# &$ $8 ""

' "

+" 0 $ +""

"#$ 4&- ) # &" ""

" "

& 4$# $8 )> &" &"

' "

=$ --4# &"

" 4" # "

8 C"->0 "#$ &+ +"+"> $ " &"

&" ""

+""

)" +# ""

$8 &"

' "

$0 +"+- $" ' : , 4&- ) ++-)-

=$ " &--> ++-)- +"

'->0 $80 8 " "

8>0 &&" -8 8 +" - "

&" -8 + - -"

"8 (&#8 FI)- '&+"8 &" $% $%

%&''')0*,,.>4

5 +" 0 $8 &"

' "

& !&""

4 +" # +"# &"

' , 0 "

$ # ) +"+"> ?& 4 $

'&$ $8 4 "

+&"+ +"&"# +" & +" &"

' , ) ) $8 "

" "> > )

, > "0 ++" +" 8" $ >" -+ "8 --# $8

> &"$"

+"#0 8&$ -0 > +"# -

)> &" $&0 "8-> "#$ +"

=$"->0 4 $- +""

"#$ " "> "" &"

&" "" &"

',*C,6'5 , , 4&- $ ""# "

>$# 4$$

+" $ 4 ,

=$ +"+- 4&- - &--> ++-> +"

: C&"$->0 4 $- &" ""

4$ $ - # " &"> $0 &" "

+&"+ "+>8 ) $&0 "#$ &" ""

4&- ) "-> )> > &$ &)?& $8 )> &" "

4&- $ "#$ - & +&"$" +&"$# &" "8 &$ &" ""

=$ +"+- 4&- - &--> ++-> +"

=$ ) 8 4" + 4 & ) 8""& --4 "#->

=$ " -4 - 4 &--> ++- +" -- &"

=$ "#$ +"+"> &- "#$ $" &"

,"-

, & 5

0 +" $ +&"$ +"+"> & &-> & &"

',*C,6'5 ,0 4 &- "#$ +"

(> +"+"> &--

3> .# +" .

)( "B "8 &" /&- #" 5 -0 $#"$0 "#$ $ "#

" "0 +"&- - "

,A&" - $4 ""

4$$ 8 &"

+" " "8 -- &8)"

5 "+ > &$ $8 4 .4-# +" "

4 "

)"&#$ +" +""

+# 8+&# ""

C&"$"

+" 0 ) )> "& $80 >

$"# $ " +"+"> $8 4 -> &" +" & +" +"# &"

' , "

" "> > 8>

6 &8# > &$ $"# "0 $ 8 4&- $ +""> "

8"## &"

8 4> +"+"> )# """ &"

& +&"$"

5 +" "" &$ $"# "

=$&0 8+&# ""

)# --#-0 " )

3" 4 +" 4$ $ (&#80 4 4&- -. - 4$ )( " )> -" &- "

' +" $&- $ " ++"$ &" /&- #" 5 - # $8 -# +" "

=$ "#&8 " ) "( "

8" $ "

C"->0 $- 1 98- 6#"#

'&+"0 +"+"> $ &)?& 8"## "0 8 "8-> "-> "#$ - & +&"$"0 +&"$# &" "8 &" ""

'->0 +" " +"> +"# $"

$8 &- $ +0 "$"

+" + $8 ""0 "#$ +" "

=$"->0 +" 4" + - &"

,"- @ & 50 4$$ 4&- ) ++"+" "8> 8&$ +" 0 " +& &" (&0 $ &" 8+- +4"

,"- @ & 5 & "> "

"+-> $- )> FI)- '&+"8 &" $" 4 -" "8> -&# ")" -&0 F#$ &" 4&- -4> $ (&" &"

,"- @1

& 5 + 0 $" > (&

=$ FI)- '&+"8 &" +"

(&#8 - 7 ! 1 ,

"+" &'(()0*,,.>:0 )" &"

C & - % "# # B

- %"* - +

& "

% "

% * "

" # - + - >, /

% + ,

% *+ +"

%" ' #

"* !

" * + *

% "

"**

% * #"

3- 3 - %

% 3

- , 7

# +- >, + , #

, & "

% >, + -* + %

- 7 - "

-- ?

% *( =$ FI)- '&+"8 &"0 4$$ $" 4 ")" -&0 $ )" D5

+ #

+ % -+

# - E $&0 (&#8 F#$ &" 4$$ $ " + + $" )# ")" -&04 &+$-

5 +" 0 4 $ 8 -& (& +" 8&$ 0 $"

"#$ +"+"> - $&0 +" 4" + --4 8+&# ""

;

,A&" $")> ?&$ "+ 2

" " ""

&" 1+- 2 :0 $%0 C- 0 &$ &"

+"1& +&"$" A+&-> +)- > 0 4$ A 4. "+ " +> +" ""

' 8 0 ++- "

+"+8 )"# :

4-- ++- ;;

+"># "

+- +" +0 $ "" "&&& " + &$

,-- +# 8--& ++-0 >0 " + 0 4 ) (&#8

5 6 6

7877 +

/&!/&0$%&#9 ,410&#$-,&.:

&$1-

/&!/&00&%-0!#3)&:

&$1-