Noor Mohammed v. Ram Karan & ORS
!"##$%&%'(!)* +,!--#.
//#00!'"
1#+&2&
!-3!+!' ",#+& #&/'.#'"& !
"#$%& '( )* & *)+%
+#&#'"( +&,%&,2/"!*.4$!"#* +",#!//#00!'" 55555 *)+%,'
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
#.#-/"%' !'. +#$0&2+#
#720!"%' A=8!&.#$%.#.'A ,#.##'.!'"//&#.",#&2%"*92".%.'".#')",##<#$2"%'
",#-+"7!7#.##."8!&!00#7#.",!",#%&%''$#'"!'.%00%"#+!"#/#+&' !'..%.'"C'8",#$'"#'"&",#-+"7!7#.##.!'.'"%-#8!&%<#. ++#.#-/"%' %'$#",#/!+"%#&8#+#!"4!+%!'$#*",#"+%!02+"+!-#.",# 008%'7%&&2#&(6 D
!
"
# #
#
# $ %
& ' (
0!%'"%& #<!-%'#. E6 !- 3!+!' /0!%'"% !'.
9+27,"'+#$+..$2-#'"&< "< =*%#*;!-!9!'.%#&*-2"!"%'& !'. $/) +.#+ .!"#. A* 8,#+#!& ",# .##'.!'" ,%-� !//#!+#.!&E6 +&,%&,2/"!*0#!+'#.$2'�+#/+#&#'"%'7",#!//#00!'"6 .##'.!'"&29-%""#.",!"!7!%'&"",#+.#+.!"#.A*%4%0 #4%&%'
A %&/#'.%'7!.;2.%$!"%'%'",%&2+",##'"%+#9!&%&@ 7#'#&%&",#&2%" 8!&'",!"+.#+,#-+"7!7#.##.8!&2'.#+
- $,!00#'7#!'.*",#+#+#*",#/+#&#'"&2%"$20.'",!4#9##'.#$+##. #$+#"!0",#&2%"+#&20"#.%'"-%&$!++%!7#;2&"%$#,#-+"7!7#.##. ,!&!0&'"9##'/+4#.9)#<!-%'!"%'",#!""#&"%'78%"'#&&#&*",27, %"%&!+#7%&"#+#..$2-#'"*",#+#+#*",#/+#&2-/"%',!&#++'#2&0)9##' .+!8' ,!4#,#!+.",#0#!+'#.$2'�+",#!//#00!'"6.##'.!'" !'.!//+!%&#.",#/!/#+9C ,#0!88%",+#7!+."",#+#.#-/"%'",#-+"7!7#,!4%'7! "%-#0%'#+%'%"&!9&#'$#%& '0'7#+
%'4%#8",#+!"% .#$%.#'.%$200#. 2"9)'F90#",#2/+#-#2+"%' . /01
2/ /%3433 / 0
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
,# /+4%&%'& ",# !'7!0 B!'.
#.#-/"%' !'. +#$0&2+#
#720!"%' A=.'"/+,%9%"",#%'4$!"%';2+%&.%$"%'",# $%4%0 $2+" !'.* ",#+#+#* ",# !+72-#'" +2/"! +#7!+.%'7 -!%'"!%'!9%0%")",#&2%"-2&"!%0
+",#+#!&'&!+#-#'"%'#.*.'"%'.!')%00#7!0%")+ /#+4#+&%")%'",#%'.%'7&2'.#+$,!00#'7#7+2'.+%'"#+#+#'$#%& -!.# 2"* -2$, 0#&& %'404#-#'" !') &29&"!'"%!0 :2#&"%' 0!8
#&20"!'"0)*",#!//#!0%&.%&-%&&#.
5, *)+%
03/ '(16& +/2/37.
83
938
+/2/ 2:!
938