Jaswant Singh & ORS v. Sukhdev Singh & ORS












 

 




 
 !

"#$

$%&'&()
$%$*+$,
-.
 - "'/"(#
&(01

#1$,'

22$33"(#'

4$,'5'

5617$8
&(01

#1$,'

 $'2(7$(#'

!
 "

#$%&'
() *+!' +*
,&

,$'$(#) , "&
&(01
1"51"(.
78%"#$.

,
#1$
"22$33"(#' 99999







































 +*
,&-(

22$33"(#:7$$(7"(#'
",$
&(
$053",
$%(7
22$"3
"0"&('#
#1$ %(%5,,$(#
&(7&(0'

"%#
"(7
3"/.
/1$,$+;
#1$
'5&#

#1$
,$'2(7$(#: 23"&(#&
,
7$%3","#&(
"(7
/($,'1&2
(
#1$
+"'&'

#1$
,$0&'#$,$7
<&33 7"#$7
- =

.
1"'
+$$(
7$%,$$7
&(
2",#
22$"3
#"6$(
+$,$
#1$
>/$, 22$33"#$
5,#
/"'
"3'
7&'*&''$7

3"&(#&

5617$8
&(01
"''$,#$7
#1"#
+$'&7$'
1&*.
1&'
"#1$,

"*
&(01
1"7
#1,$$
*,$
'('.
&$.
7$$(7"(#
'
#
?
"(7
#1,$$ 7"501#$,'
7$$(7"(#
'
#
!
;
8&,#5$

#1$
,$0&'#$,$7
<&33
7"#$7 - =

.
1$
+$@5$"#1$7
#1$
3"(7
+$",&(0
A1"',"
-= :!
"(7 *$"'5,&(0
A:?
"(7
?A:?
+$",&(0
7&$,$(#
61"',"
(5*+$,'
#
/"' "''$,#$7
#1"#
7$$(7"(#
'
"(7

1"7
3"5(%1$7
%,&*&("3
2,%$$7&(0' "0"&('#
#1$&,
"#1$,
"*
&(01
"(7
#1"#
/"'
#1$
,$"'(
#1$;
/$,$
5'#$7 ,*
#1$
3&($

'5%%$''&(
$$(7"(#'
22'$7
#1$
'5&#
"(7
'#"#$7
#1"#
#1$
<&33
/"' '5'2&%&5'
"(7
1"7
(#
+$$(
$B$%5#$7
+;
"*
&(01
"'
2,&,
#
#1$

 ",$*$(#&($7
<&33.
1"7
$B$%5#$7
#/
#1$,
<&33'
1$,$
/"'
(
,$"'(
, 1&*
#
5'#
,*
#1$
'5%%$''&(
"'
#1$
%&8&3
'5&#
/"'
&3$7
"#
1&'
&('#"(%$.
+5# #1$
'"*$
/"'
7&'*&''$7
(
#$%1(&%"3
0,5(7'

3"&(#&
$B"*&($7
"##$'#&(0
/&#($''
",7","
&(01.
/1$,$"'
#1$ 7$$(7"(#'
$B"*&($7
"(#1$,
"##$'#&(0
/&#($'' 1$
#,&"3
%5,#
2",#3;
7$%,$$7
#1$
'5&#
"(7
0,"(#$7
7$%3","#&(
 /($,'1&2
&(
,$'2$%#

3"(7
*$"'5,&(0
A:?
(3;.
/1$,$"'
3"(7 *$"'5,&(0
A:
"(7
?A:?
1"8$
+$$(
0&8$(
#
"33
#1$
5,
'('
&(
$@5"3 '1",$ ,
"&
&(01
1"51"(.
3$",($7
%5('$3
,
#1$
"22$33"(#: 7$$(7"(#'
'5+*&##$7
#1"#
#1$
C570*$(#'
"(7
7$%,$$'


#1$
%5,#'
+$3/ ",$
(#
'5'#"&("+3$
(
#1$
33/&(0
2&(#') !

<:
",7","
&(01
/"'
(#
&(
%(,*&#;
/&#1
#1$ 2,8&'&('

$%#&(
 %!

#1$
(7&"(
5%%$''&(
%#
$ $8$(
7&7
(#
,$%0(&D$
1&'
#15*+
&*2,$''&(E'&0("#5,$'
(
#1$
<&33F !

3"&(#&
1"'
(#
$B"*&($7
#1$
'%,&+$
,
"(;
"##$'#&(0 /&#($''.
*5%1
3$''
%*2$#$(#
2$,'(
,*
#1$
&%$

#1$
5+

$0&'#,",F ?!

3"&(#&
1"7
+$$(
0,$$7;
"(7
'#"6$7
#1$
%3"&*
&(
#1$ $(#&,$
2,2$,#;.
+5#
(
$8&7$(%$
&#
/"'
5(7
#1"#
3"(7 *$"'5,&(0
?A:?
"(7
"'
/$33
"'
A:
/$,$
"(%$'#,"3F !


$(#"&3$7
&(#
"%@5&##"3
"(7
#1$
'5&#
/"'
+;
"33
#1$ '('F !


"33
#1$
$8&7$(%$
1"7
+$$(
36$7
%5*53"#&8$3;.
'5&# /"'
3&"+3$
#
+$
7&'*&''$7
"'
"*

&(01
7$$*$7
#
1"8$
7&$7 &(#$'#"#$

. 
"*
","&7
#1"#
#1$
",$*$(#&($7
",05*$(#
&'
(#
'5'#"&("+3$ "'
,*
#1$
%(#$(#'

#1$
,$0&'#$,$7
<&33
,$"7
5#
75,&(0
#1$
2,%$$7&(0' 
#1$
%5,#.
#$'#"#,

0"8$
23"5'&+3$
,$"'(

7&'&(1$,&#"(%$

#1,$$
'('
"' #1$;
1"7
+$$(
3&#&0"#&(0
/&#1
1&*
(
#1$
%(#,",;.
#1$
23"&(#&
$'#"+3&'1$7 (
,$%,7
#1"#
1&'
"#1$,
"*
&(01
1"7
,$%**$(7$7
1&*
#
+$
"22&(#$7 "'
>"*+",7",
<:
C"00",
&(01.
#1$,
"##$'#&(0
/&#($''
$B"*&($7
+; #1$
7$$(7"(#'.
#,&$7
#
%,$"#$
'5'2&%&5'
%&,%5*'#"(%$'
1$
"33$0$7 '5'2&%&5'
%&,%5*'#"(%$

/537

2"3$
&(#
&('&0(&&%"(%$
/&(0
#
#1$ ,$"'('
"''&0($7 1$
"22$33"(#:7$$(7"(#'
1"8$
(#
+$$(
"+3$
#
%(#,8$,#
#1$ #15*+
&*2,$''&('

#1$
#$'#"#,
1$
<&33
"3'
,$3$%#$7
#1$
$B$%5#&(
 2,$8&5'
#/
<&33'
"(7
#1$&,
,$8%"#&(
#
&'
(#
#1$
%"'$
#1"#
$(#&,$ 2,2$,#;
1"'
+$$(
#"6$(
+;
#1$
23"&(#&'.
"'
(#&%$7
"+8$
(3;
3"(7 *$"'5,&(0
A:? .
"'
2$,
#1$
<&33.
1"'
"33$(
#
#1$
'1",$

#1$
23"&(#&' '
,$0",7'
#1$
,$*"&(&(0
3"(7.
#1$,$
&'
$@5"3
7&'#,&+5#&(

,
#1$
,$"'('
*$(#&($7
"+8$.

7
(#
&(7
"(;
&33$0"3&#;
, 2$,8$,'&#;
&(
#1$
%(%5,,$(#
&(7&(0'

"%#
"(7
3"/.
/1&%1
",$
+"'$7
( "22,$%&"#&(

,"3
"(7
7%5*$(#",;
$8&7$(%$

0,5(7
,
&(#$,$,$(%$ &'
*"7$
5#.
*5%1
3$''
&(838$*$(#

"(;
'5+'#"(#&"3
@5$'#&(

3"/

$'53#"(#3;.
#1$
"22$"3
&'
7&'*&''$7 / 012-2    +*
,&

034 ()/5'

,464378 93

 :39

,464
 61"

:39