High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4547/2017dismissed

United India Insurance Co Ltd v. Sarva Haryana Gramin Bank

2017-09-22Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi8 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

)

( * + ,+-

"# $ # % & " ''''

,+- +

& & (

) "

&) && % **""

*#%#" *

& %&*" &&( % #

% )

,-,.-.,/ &

&"& (

% )

01-.,2% ")"+ )

% *"

-&" )% " &&( # *

)" & & % 3,&" " &&(* # " ) * "&& % " "

4 )) # % " ! ) % # # & " 5&& &"* # #

# &&(* "#

) & & )

$" &&( *

) -.6

"5&& % )

"5&& 3,,,-..70/7.67.....-.8& 9,9-.,.

-89-.,,& "&

$" &&(* ,%61%8/27( & ))" & 5,,.-.,.% "* "&& # #" * &-,%.-%98-02

"5-,.-.,. 9,.-.,.%# " 50,.-.,.%#""

&"* # %# " "

&) ) % "

) #

)$" # " & " &-,%.-%98-02 # &

)& " &# " &$ #

) $":

& # ))* " & #

& ) %&"* #

,69-.,9& )"&$" &&(* ;

" & " & "

* 4 ;

#""& (

" & %" &&(* # &"

)

& &0.%.,%.9.7( )#" &

" &,8< #";

& " & & "

= )* %& (

& )# % ) " *+ &&( & 5 & ) & " %

& "&#)

( ,>?"" " &&

0.%.,%.9.% & @5 ->?"" "

*" & @ 54 9> &

* " "

) %*"" * )" "

# &&* )"

%#" "

& " &&( & " )

& " ))"

)"" * )" %"

" &&( "

** )) )

&" &&#

%) ) & -,%.-%98-02

& % )#" A/<%*"

% + )

,-,.-.,/ "" & )) &" &

&*"& (

#" &

&*" &&( # #% ) & & /< 21< " " " &

& & & " * * )&*"" )

" &&"

%* * )) ) ) 5 " " " % " )"& ( "

BCD4,>% & D ""

%#" ) "

BCD4,>

" %# )""**""

*#"

BCD4,>#

% "

* *"& %

#" # )

" %"

& " " "

*# # ##"" +

" )

" * "

) +

%" 4 E ) )"D %

& &"

# " * %

)&) *"

,1,6& )%#" " * " %

(

! "#

" #$% & ' "

& $() "

* % &+ , % - '

' " " . ' - % /" 0$ 1, %, 0 -

2'%-%

' ! ". 3 -"

0$ ", 4 ,

" "

' - " '

., 0$

% .

3 /"

/ #56 /'

' 2'

' "

"2' ". %'' ' - "'' %

.2 2' 7,'' - "#56 /

2' '

! "#

". " "

'- '

" '

' ' %-% " - % 8 / - 9,.0 -.%: ' " -

! "#

" #$. % .$ /

, % $.$;.5;$;

:.5$%;5%<(5.=> .8 % #5 ?.$;.5;$; /"%-% #@>.(.5;$5%1 $<.$.5;$<'

". 3% '

#$; " "55.$.5;$<

<;.?.5;$=.8, A 8 %$@B< .==

" "

' - - " % ' " "

" "

"% . %

/" 1 $<.$.5;$<%

"% " '

.,% .5 /

, .< %

8 / - 9',.0 -.%: % '

'1' B) * .

' - .

* , '4A /.A.%:,8

.$B5;5;$;% $@.$$.5;$5%6!

#1 C 6"6 '/ - ' ' - '

- ' " .

1 ' -

.3 " D -.8 ' - %6!

#1 C6"6 '/ ' @) '

* . % - " .6-%"

" ' "

$<.$.5;$<. " - ' " - .

% " %-% B) @) '.

% ">() % 1

- ' >.?) '

* .+ ?" & " # & #"" * ) )&) *"

)

" %"" #

)" % *) & & % (

)"& " & # ""

*# " &" % *& )"

&) && " &

% * & "

& #% #"

) " )

" * "%& "

&" )% & " & )

" &" ) + )

*# & ;

& #

* ;

& #%#" " ;

) "" &"

%#"D

)

,..&"&

" % * " # #*"F*

!./!'!'!0#'1.!'!'1!'"2#.3&+#4&25/!.0%'% !'1"2#.&6

) $%7%8 9: !'"&2!;!.%3& <.&2""!5 %=!.%6

> ) 3" ) # )"

*% #"" & %"

#" "

%* && #"

* $"

& 3

& & "

%#"" * * %

%"# %#" --6-.,2 ,+- ,

'DED