High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4607/2017dismissed

Narinder Singh And ORS. v. Balwinder Singh And ORS.

2018-07-25Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

!"#!$%&%"'()**+ ,%'-!,%'./" /!,& 00!11' & 2!,&3& 14%'-!,%'./" /!,& !&0"'-!' &

,!&!' (

,* **%-/35-6"$ !#", /!00!11' &*

1%' %##& ,!&0"'-!' &/!,!%'

#%1!-&3% &!!8%'.0!,9'!'

%':3'$ %"',!& ,%'%'. /!-!#!'-' &#,"9%' !,#!,%'.'--%&0"&&!&&%'. /!9#,"9 /!!;$13&%6!514#31'-0!$!#310"&&!&&%"'"# /!&3% 0,"0!, < &-!&$,%=!-%' /!/!-'" !"# /!01%' *3% 4&-!$,!!-6%-!-!$%&%"' - !-*)*0&&!-=< /!,%1"3, *$%6%100!10,!#!,,!-=< /! -!#!'-' & /& =!!' -%&9%&&!- =< /! >"4!, 00!11 ! "3, 6%-! :3-.!9!' - !-)**'-&&3$/5:3-.!9!' "# /!,%1"3, /& =!!'##%,9!-*

!&31 ' 1<5 /!-!#!'-' &,!%'&!$"'-00!1=!#",! /%& "3, * ,%!##$ &,! / /!01%' %##&&"3./ /!,!1%!#"#%':3'$ %"' &%901%$% !,"' /!01!-%'.& / /!<,!%'!;$13&%6!'-14#310"&&!&&%"' "# /!&3% 1'-*,1%!,%'0"%' "# %9!9" /!,"#01%' %##&'"*'-'- .,'-9" /!,"#01%' %##&'"*?'-4!,!"4'!,&%'0"&&!&&%"'* 0"'

-!9%&!"# ,% 9@3,593 %"'"#%'/!,% '$!4&&'$ %"'!-%'#6"3,"# 01%' %##&'"*'-'-# /!,"#01%' %##&'"*?'-"' /!=&%&"#' ",1A%11- !-)**B* 4&01!-!- / /!-!#!'-' &/6!'"

$"'$!,'4% / /!&3% 0,"0!, <'-,! /,! !'%'. "%' !,#!,!%' /!%, 0"&&!&&%"'%',!&0!$ "# /!&3% 1'-* 3% 4&$"' !& !-=< /!-!#!'-' & 8%'.& '- / /!&3% 1'- 4& 0, "# :"%' 1'- /"1-%'. '- 0, % %"' 0,"$!!-%'.& /- $319%' !-%' /!<!,B?'-"' /!=&%&"#4/%$/-!#!'-' &4!,! $"9%'.%'0"&&!&&%"'"# /!&3% 0,"0!, <* ' /! 01!-%'.& "# /! 0, %!& /! #"11"4%'. %&&3!& 4!,! #,9!-=< /!,%1"3, (

" #

0"'-3!00,!$% %"'"#!6%-!'$!'-# !,/!,%'.$"3'&!1 #", /!0, %!&5&3% 4&-!$,!!-*3-.!9!' "# /!,%1"3, 4/%1!,!1%!# "#0!,9'!' %':3'$ %"'%'#6"3,"#01%' %##& ,!&0"'-!' &/!,!%'

/&=!!'

##%,9!-=< /!>"4!,00!11 !"3, * "3'&!1 ,!0,!&!' %'. /! -!#!'-' &C00!11' & 6!/!9!' 1< ,.3!- / /!&3% 1'-4/%$/4&0, "#:"%' 1'-/"1-%'./-=!!' 0, % %"'!- /,"3./ /!$"90! !' ,!6!'3!$"3, 4<=$8"'**B?* !#3, /!,$"' !'-& / =&!-30"'0, % %"'0,"$!!-%'.&!6!'4,,' "# 0"&&!&&%"'/-=!!'%&&3!-'-0/<&%$10"&&!&&%"'/-=!!'-!1%6!,!- "

3,'%'./%*!* /!0,!-!$!&&","# /!00!11' &'-'!' ,<%' #

#% " /%&!##!$ /-1&"=!!'!' !,!-* 6%'./!,-$"3'&!1#", /!00!11' & 1!'. /5 /%&"3, %& "# /!$"'&%-!,!-6%!4 / /!,!%&'"9!,% %' /!%'& ' 00!1'- /! &9!-!&!,6!&-%&9%&&1*

? $"'$3,,!' #%'-%'."##$ /&=!!',!$",-!-=< /!$"3, & =!1"4=&!-"',!6!'3!!' ,%!&%*!*& '

;* " +&1&"

(

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

& 5%#'<5&/111&"& '--%&0"&!-"#*

13$8< A/! /!,&0!8%'.C,!&"'!-( !&C"

A/! /!, !0", =1!( !&C"