High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4141/2018disposed of

Kishan Chand (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs And ANR. v. Vijay Kumar And ORS.

2025-11-17Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja7 pages

,*(

(/0$0)%

(/0$0)% B B B B

! ! ! ! #$ #$ #$ #$ # ! # ! # ! # ! " " " " --(..,)* --(..,)* --(..,)* --(..,)*$ ($-)3()* ($-)3()* ($-)3()* ($-)3()*$ % % % % '($()*% '

'* '

& " ! & " ! & " ! & " ! ,):!1;,',=,234/,*( *+(,--(..,)*$ ,:)0$+1-*,234/,*(,)3 ,/+0)1-*,234/,*( '($-)3()* 15+3((-0)6+234/,*( '

,';0)3('0)6+234/,*( '($-)3()* DDDD 2 ',. 2 ',. 2 ',. 2 ',. ! ! ! ! 7 8 +( ( -'($()* (61.,' (/)3 - --(,. +,$ 9(() 0.(3 ,6,0)$* :136;()*,)33( (/'((3,*(3

<-,$$(39 9=*+(.(,')(333. 0$*'0/* 36(2 !,'),. ' $+ '* *+( >*+( --(..,*( 1'*E2 ?

?+('(9= *+( :136;()* ,)3 3(/ /'(( 3,*(3

-,$$(39=*+(1'* .(,')( (3040. 136( ' 040$0)!,'

'),. ?,$$(*,$03(,) )3/)$(F1()*.=*+($10* '6',) )* -(';,)()*0):1)/*0) 0.(3 39= *+(-.,0)*0

$@'($ $-)3()*$ ,)3 ?,$-,'*.= 3(/'((3 8

'0 0( .= $*,*0)62 ?+0.( /.,0;0)6 *+(;$(.4($ 0) ,/*1,. -+=$0 0/,. -$$($$0) *+ +( ,6'0/1.*1',. .,)3 ;(,$1'0)6 A !,),.$ /;-'0$(3 0) !+(?

?,* B2!+,*) )0B 2(/*BB2!0.., 2A 2 C A2 C 2

AC < 403( :, ,;,9,)30 ' *+( =(,'

2 $0*1,*(3 0) 40..,6( !+,',G- -1'2

(+$0. ,)3 0$* *'0/* !,'),.2 '($-)3()*$ $ ,)3 @-.,0)*0

0.(3 , $10*

-(';,)()*0):1) )/*0)?0*+,-',=(' ''($*',0) )0)6*+(,--(..,)*$@3( ()3,)*$ '

'; 0)*('

('0)60)*+ +(0'-(,/( 1.-$$($$0)4('*+( ($10*.,)3*?,$,4(''(3*+,* $10*.,)3?,$'( (/'3(3,$+,;.,* (+,:5 '0)*+('(4()1('(/'3?0*+

,*+(' '($-) )3()* ,)3 @-.,0)*0

$ 9(0) )6 0) (I/.1$04( -$$($$0) $,;(9(0)66,0'

';,'1$0?0*+*+(()*'=0).1 1;)J,$K 0..,",6,) ,?

?,:, ,1*'H,)3*+1 1$2*+(,--(..,)*$@3( ()3,)*$2?+ ++,--()(3*9(*+(0'/..,*('

',.$ ?('( '(F10'(3 * * 9( '($*',0)(3 '; 0)*('

('0) )6 0)* *+( -(,/( 1. -$$($$0) ) '($-)3()*$ ,)3 @-.,0)*0

$ 7A8 - ) )*0/(2 *+( ,--(..,)*$@3( () )3,)*$ ,--(,'(3 ,)3 /)*($*(3 $10* ?+0.( $*,*0) )6 *+,* *+( .,)3 0) F1($*0) ?

?,$ '060),..= 0) -$$($$0) -'(3(/($$'C0)C0 0)*('($* *+(-,'*0($),;(.=+ +9+,,;9(0)66,0';,'1$0L?

?+ +,3 1'$)$2 ,;+,)32!0$+,)+,)32 + +,?,)0 ,$$,)3,;",.$ -(' '(/'3$2*+(,-- (..,)*$@3( ()3,)*$2+,--()(3* 9(*+($1//($$'$ !0$+,)+, $) +9+, ,; ?+('(,$ '($-)3()* @-.,0)*0

$ ?('( *+( +(0'$ $ ,; +,)3 $) ) +9+, ,; * ?,$ -.(,3 3(3 *+,* , *(' *+( 3(,*+ +9 9+, ,;2 -$$($$0) ) *+($10* .,)3 ?,$0)+('0*(3 3 9= +0$ 1' $)$0) (F1,.$+, ,'($ 0)/.130)6-'(3(/ /($$'C0)C0)*('($* *+(,--(..,) )*$,$?(..,$*+(3( ()3,)*$,)3 @*+ -,'*0($**+($1 10*?('(0)-$$($$0) *+(0'(I I/.1$04($+,'(**+((I*()* !,),. ,'

'.,).=?+('(,$*+('(4()1(() )*'0($'(6,'30)6-$$($$0) () )*0'( .,)30)*+(),;

;( ,;+,)3?('(?')6.= '(/'3(3*?,$2*+1$-.(,3(3* *+,* *+($10* 0.(39= *+(-.,0)*0

$?,$.0,9.(*9(30$ $;0$$(3 78 )* *(';$ -.(,30)6$ *+(-,'*0($ $2 ..?0)60$$1($?('( ',;(3 39= *+(.(,')(3'0,.

.1'*

K0 M+(*+(' *+( -.,0)*0

$ ,'( ( 0):1)/*0),$-',=(3 'N ()*0*.(3 * , 3(/'(( ' -(';,) )()* 00 M+(*+('*+($10* *+(-.,0)*0

$0$)*;,0)*,0),9.(N 000 M+(*+('*+(-.,0)*0

$+,4(6 * 0.(,)3;,0)*,0)*+(-'($()* *)./1$C$*,)30,)3/,1$( ,/* /*0) *$10*N 04 M+(*+('*+($10* *+(-.,0)*0

:0)3(' )(/($$,'=-,'*0($N

0$9,3 ';0$C:0)3(',)3))C 4 M+(*+('*+(-.,0)*0

$+,4($1- --'($$(3*+(*'1(,)3;,*('0,. ,/*$ $

';*+(1'*N 40 (.0( H 7 8 #03 3( :136;()* ,)3 3(/'(( 3,*(3

-,$$(3 9= *+( .(,') )(3 040. 136( '

04)!,'),.2*+($10* 0.(3,* **+(0)$*,)/( '($-)3()* $ @-.,0)*0

?,$ 30$;0$$(3 66'0(4(3 *+('

'( 2 *+( 0'$* --(,. /,;( * 9(

0.(3?+0/+?,$ $-,'*.=,..?(39=*+(.(,')(3 33. 0$*'0/* 136(2!,'),.4 403( :136;()* ,)3 3 3(/'(( 3,*(3

< ,)3 / )$(F1()*.=2 *+( $10* 0.(3 9= -.,0)*0

$?,$- ,'*.=3(/'((3F1, !,),.J ,'., .,)3L '*+('(;,0)0) 6 !,),. ,'., ,$ .,)3*+($10*?,$?0*+3',?

?)9=-.,0)*0

$231'0)6-()3()/= =

0'$*,--(,. 7<8 ;- -16)0)6 *+( , '(;()*0)(3 :13 36;()* ,)3 3(/'(( -,$$(3 9= 0'$* --(..,*( 1'*2 .(,')(3 /1)$(. ' *+( ,--(..,)*$@3( ()3,)* $ ,)3 3 ?+0.('( (''0)6 **+(3(-$0*0);,3(9=MC C +('0)6+O+,;$+('0) )6+2 ?+ +,--()$ * * 9( -.,0)*0

2 $19;0*$ $ *+,* *+( -$$($$0) !0$+ +,) +,)3@3( ()3,) )* ?,$ ,3;0**(3 9= +0;

) '(/'3 ,)32 *+('( '(2 *+( $ $10* -'( (''(3 ,**+( (0)$*,)/( '($-)3()*$ @-.,0)*0

$ F1,*+( $,;(?

?,$ .0,9.( * 9( 30$ $;0$$(3 "(,')(3 /1)$(. *+1$ $2 $19;0*$ *+,* *+( :136;()* , 3(/'(($-,$$(39 9=*+(0'$*--(..,*(1'*9(0 0)69,$(3)0)/''(/*,--'(/0,* *0)

(403()/( ,4, ,0.,9.( ) '(/'3 0) *+( '; ,3;0$$0) ;,3( 9= )( -.,0)*0

$+0;$(.

?,$2*+1$.0,9.(*9($(*,$03( 7B8 ) *+( *+(' +,)32 .(,')(3 /1 1)$(. ' '($-)3()* $ ,

@-.,0)*0

$ ?+0.

.( '(.=0)6 1-) :,;,9,)30$ '

' *+( =(,'

J IC ,

I IC $19;0*$ *+,* *+( -'(3(/ /($$'C0)C0)*('($* *+( -.,0)* *0

),;(.=2 ,; +,)3 ?,$ $+?) * 9( 0) ( (I/.1$04( -$$($$0) *+( ., ;(,$1'0)6 !

!,),. J ,'.,$2 *+1$ *+(0' ,- --(,. ?,$ '06+*= ,//(-*(3 9= .(,')(30'$*- --(..,*(1'*"(,')(3/1)$(. ,.$-0)*$1**+,*,-'($1;-* *0) *'1*+ ?,$ ,** *,/+(3 * *+( ()*'0($ '(/'3(3 0) *+( :,;,9,)30$ 0) *+( ),;( ( -'(3(/($$'C0)C0 0)*('($* '($-)3()* $ ,) )3 @-.,0)*0

$ ,)3 $0)/( *+( $, ,;( ?('()(4(''(91 1**(3,**+(+,)3$ ,--(..,)*$@ @3( ()3,)*$ ,)3 2,$$1/+ +) 0)*('

('()/( ?, ,$ /,..(3 ' ?0*+ *+( 0)30)6 6$ '(/'3(3 9= *+( .(,')(3 0'$* --(..,*(1'* *)$(F1()*.=20*?,$-',=(3*+ +,**+(,--(,.0)+,)3?,$.0,9.( (* 9(30$;0$$(3 8 + +,4( +(,'3 .(,')(3 /1)$(. *+( -,'*0($ ,)3 6)( *+'16+ -,-('95,$?

?(..,$'(/'3$ *+(/,$( 7J8 )* *+(-'($()*/,$(2*+().=30$-1 1*('(.,*(3**+(-$$($$0) -,'*0($4('*+( $19:(/*.,)3;(,$1'0)6A!,), ,.$$0*1,*(30)*+('(4()1(($*,*( ( 40..,6(!+,',G- -1'2(+$0. 0$*'0/*!,'),. -('1$,. *+(3(-$0*0);,3( (9= MC +('0)6 6+O+,;$+('0)6+2?++,-- -()$*9('($-)3()* @-.,0) )*0

/.(,'.='(/ /'3$*+,*!0$+,)+,)3@3( ()3 3,)* +,$,.$316,9'(?

?(.. ,)30)$*,..(3*19 9(?(../))(/*0)0)*+(.,)30) F1($*0)+(-(',*04(-,'* 3(-$0*0) ;,3( ( 9= MC +(' 0)6+ O +,;

;$+(' 0)6+ * *+( $,03 (

(/*2 2 0) *',)$.,*(3 ';0 0$'(-'31/(3+('(1)3('%C

KII II III IIIP)*+0$.,)3,*19 9(?(..0$,.$0)$*,..(3?+0/+0$0) ) *+( ),;

;( ,;($+C3( ()3,)* ( ()3 )3,)*C!0$+,) +,)3 +,$ ,.$ 316 16 , 9'

'(?(..0)*+0$.,)3*0$?')6*+,* ,;($+,)3!0$+,)+,)3+,4($ ?) (.

$*,*(3*+,*?(+,4($?)H -,3 33=0)*+(0'?)'($-(/*04($+,'($ 8 319*2 *+( ()*'0($ ;,3( '(6,'3 30)6 -$$($$0) 0) *+( :,;,9,) )30$ IC ,)3I C /,''=-'($1;-*0) *'1*+0) )*(';$ (/*0) *+(1) ):,9 ",)3 (4()1( /*2

B2 +?(4('2 *+( $,;( ( ?('( $1

0/0()*.= '(91**(3 0) -'($()*/,$(0)* *+(?,5( ,3;0$$0);,3(9=- -.,0)*0

MC +('0)6+ +O +,;$+('0)6+ +?0*+'($-(/**0)$*,..,*0)

*19(?(..9=)( *+(3( ()3, ,)*C !0$+,) +,)3 4(' *+( .,)3 0) F1($*0) 0) / ):1)/*0) ?0*+ *+( (.(/*'0/0*= 90.. '(/(0-*$-'31/( (39=*+(,--(..,)*$@3( ()3,)*$ $0)*+(0'(403()/(,$I C +( ()*'0($ ;,3( 0) ) *+( :,;,9,30$ IC ,)3 I C ?0*+ '(6,'3 * *+( -$$($$ $0) 4('*+($10*-'

-('*=?('()**9('(.0(31- -)(.0,)/(0)*+0$'(6,'3/,) )9( -.,/(3*,3(/0 0$0)'()3('(39=*+()E9.( 1-'(;(1'*0)/,$( K+ + + + +,) +,) +,) +,)

,.,51,*0.,)3

,.,51,*0.,)3 )3*+('$#$!'0$+):0 +, 3*+('$#$!'0$+):0 +, )3*+('$#$!'0$+):0 +, 3*+('$#$!'0$+):0 +,1', ', ', ', 1)3'( (,39="$ 1)3'( (,39="$ 1)3'( (,39="$ 1)3'( (,39="$'(-'*(3 3,$ K JJJ JJJ JJJ JJJ ,6( ,6( ,6( ,6( H ,',6',-+ 9(0)6 '(.(4,)* 0$ (I*',/ /*(3 +('(1)3('%C K *,--(,'$*1$*+,**+(,--(.

(..,*(,1*+'0*= /1.3)*+,4( -., ,/(3 ,)= ='(.0,)/()*+($19$(F1()*'(4()1 )1('(/'3$0),$;1/+,$*+(,--(.., .,)*$ +,3 3/)$*'1/*(3*+(910.30)6)*+(., ,)30)30$-1*(L*+,**+((.(/*'0/0*=9 90..$ +,3 39(()-,039=*+(;L*+,**+( ,)3 3 ?,$0)*+(0'-$$($$0))*+( ,/( /( *+0$ 0)30)6 ,/**+(,--(..,*(,1*+ +'0*=/1.3)*',0$(*+(-'($1;-* -*0) 1)3 3('(/*0) AA *+(/**+,**+( +(()*'0($;,3(0)*+('(/'3 '06 6+*$ ?,$ $/''(/*M+(), 0)30)6 ,/*+ +,39(()'(/'3(3*+,**+(,--(.., .,)*$ +,3 39(()0)-$$($$0)0*?0..9($*,'

'*.0)6*+.3*+,**+('($-)3()*?

?,$ +0;

;$(.

/1.*04,*0)6 *+( .,)3 +( '

'()* -,03 9= *+( ,--(..,)*$ * '($- -)3()*,)3*+(-,'*0*0)0)*+(0'

,;0.=+,3)9(,'0)6)*+(F1($* $*0) - -$$($$0) *+(.,)3,)3/1.*04,*0 *0)*+('( M+()0) ,/**+('091 1),.

;,3 ,3(./,.()F10'=9=$-*0)$-(/*0) ),)3+,3/;(**+(/)/.1$0)* *+,* ,--(..,)*$?('(0)-$$($$0)*+,* ,* ,/*'$+1.3+,4(?(06+(3?0*+ + *+( ,-- -(..,*(,1*+'0*=2-,'*0/1.,'.=0)*+ +( ,/( *+(,3;0$$0);,3(9= = *+( '($- -)3()**+,**+(,--(..,)*$+,3/) )$*'1/*(3*+(910.30)6)*+(.,)3 ?('

'(-,=0)6/+,'6($0)'($-(/* *+( +((.(/*'0/-1;-$(*1$(3 '0''06,* ,*0)6 .,)3 ,)3 16+* * +,4( +(.3 *+, ,* *+( ,--(..,)*$ ?('( /1.*04,*0)6 .,)3 )3),330*0)2*+(.,)30)F1($*0) ) ?,$$+?))**9(/1.*04,*(39= = *+( '($- -)3()* ,$ *+( '($-)3()* ?,$ '( ($030)6 )?+('( *+( .,)3 91* ,* , , ,' ,?, ,=-.,/(,)3*+,**+(.,)3?,$) */1.*04,*(3-('$),..=9=*+(?

?)(' ,)3 3*+(-('$)$/1.*04,*0)6*+(.,)3?

?('()*;(;9('$ *+(0' ,;0.= )' *+('

'(?,$,)=(403()/(*+,**+(,--(.

..,)*$?('($('4,)*$'+0'(3.,91'

1'('$ ) ?,6($,)316+**+,4()*+,* * 9,$0$+(.3*+(,--(..,)*$,$3((;

;(3 *(), ),)*0)'($-(/* *+(.,)3+(-'($ $1;-*0),'0$0)61)3('(/*0) AA AA /*0)'($-(/* *+(()*'0($;,3( 0)*+('(/'3 '06+*$$*330$-., ,/(3 9=* 0)30)6 ,/*'(/'3(3*+,**+ +(,--(..,)*$?('(0),/*1,.-$$($$ $0) * *+(.,)3,)3?('(/1.*04,*0)6*+($, $,;()*+( ,/( $1/+,),3;0$$ $0) ;,3 ,3(9=*+('($-)3()*0*0$30

0/1.* * *,//(-**+( 0)30)6'(/'3(39= = *+( ,-- -(..,*(,1*+'0*=,$,

0';(39=*+( ( 06+1'**+,*0)40(? *+(()* *'0($ ;,3 ,3( 0) *+( '(/'3 '06+*$ *+( ,-- -(..,)*$ /1.3 )* 9( $*,*(3 * 9( 9( 0) -$ $$($$0) *+(.,)3)*+('(.(4,)* * 3,*()'?,$/1.*04,*0)6*+($,;( H 1'

'*+(';'(20)*(';$ *+(()*'0( ($ -$$($$0)0)*+(:,;,9,) )30$ IC ,)3 I C 9(() '(.,*(3 * *+( -'(3( (/($$'C0)C0)*('($* *+( -.,0)* *0

),;(.= ,; + +,)32 ?+ 30(3 ?,= 9,/5 0)

2 /,))* 9( '(.0(3 1-) ,$ $,;($*,)30) , ,41' ,3(,3-('$)*+('(9=/ /,''=0)6)-'($1;-*0),**,/+(3 3* 0*(4() 7 8 $ ,'($1.* , '($,0330$/1$$0) 2*+(-'($()*,--(,.$*,)3$,..?

?(3 ,)3 *+( :136;

;()* ,)3 3(/'(( 3,*(3

< -,$$(3 9= *+( .(,')(3 0'$* --(..,*( 1'* * 0$ +('(9= $(* ,$03( *+('(9= '

'($*'0)6 *+( :136;()* ,)3 3(/ /'(( 3,*(3

-,$$(39=*+(.(,')(3'0,. 1'*,)3/)$(F1()*.=2*+($10*

-(';,)()* 0):1) )/*0)2 0.(3 9= -.,0)*0

$C'($- )3()* $ ,)3 0$ 30$;0$$ $(3

(/'(($+((*9( -'(-,'(3,//'30)6.= 8 ..

-()30)6,--.0/,*0)$20 ,)=2$ $+,..,.$$*,)330$-$(3 ! ! ! !

4(;9('

4(;9(' B2222

*05

M+ M+ +(*+('$-(,50)6@'(,$)(3 ($ +(*+(''(-'*,9.( ($ $@ $@