Krishan Kumar v. Mahesh Chander And ANR.

 ! " #$
%&$ '( ) 
*  #  ) "
) )+,+-  .





   

 

/ 





   

  #
-  0(1!
'$ #!1
 

" 


     







    

2
+34'    



! " # 

"    " "

 "
 % "  

" " & 

'  ()*

+) ,

"-

"" " 

!" '"% &" 



 !   





!" '"% " 

  ! -

." " " 

!" '"% %

   ""  ""%

 & 



-  ""% " " " $  /"%  " 

" "% $

+

+ "  "

'  ( 0) +) ,

"

""



% "  

"" " "

1 " " %

$

/

% " "   " 

!" '"% %



"

% $ !   "  "

 

%

  ""







)3 +))*

4 & "

% 4   " -



5  % ""



" "

 "  

$ 4

" "

 "  " 4"

 "

6" 

 ""



""%  " "" " 

!" '"%





""% 

5 " " /  " " "

'  ( 0) +) ,



  

""

 

'"%  

  "  "% 6

$

)3 +))* "



(+( $ " 

8 

 

%  "

 " " 

  ! " "

" 4"



 



   " "  % " %

%" " 

1

   



"

%

4  

 4"

 ! " "% "

% 

"

$   !

1

4 





)3 +))0 "

   $   



"

" " :

+(;



 

 

'"%

1

  

%  

 ""    $  

)))<   

!

 

'"%   & " %    

$    " "  

  ""%   -

= ""$<  !"

  4  %  

 

'"%     "%

"  

$  

$  $ "

 



>4



"

 4"

% 5  $5    





"

)2 +))0



+

)2 +))0?

!

 "

 ""% 



(

 ""

" "" 

'"%

% "



* )( +) )

"  " "





"

"% !

" # "" % 



""

 " "

 



 " 

  

'"%

>" " "   "



'"% "

 " "  /"% 

 "" $ !"  " !"

"$ 

/ 

"  




7 "

 

"  " 4 4

%"

 

(+( 4

)3 +))*

  

'"% " 

  

%      " 

"

" 4"

 " " $ 4

%"

 % 

%   " 



  

""

/"% 

  %





.

%"

1

4   $ %"

   

  )

)@ +))* 

"   

3))<   "



1



 "%

% 

)3 +))*   4"%

"" "

"% " $

@

A

 " "

 

 "% "   

 "



C

"" " "   $

2)))))<

% 

 
 D  " " E7

+

C "

"" "  " !

 E7
F

C

""  

"

 "



" "

 "E7
F (

C

"" "   "

"%  "  "  



E7
F

C

""   

  "

  E7
F @

C

"" " "  "

  '" 23 #
#E7
F *

" *

""

 4 " "

C   $"% 

%



)3 +))*

H4
 

  "% 

(+( 

/ 55  

4"!"  &!$ "- "

" 

"" & -

/ 

 " 4 "  
 > %

""% 4  .

 $ 

C+

" $ 

 "

" " " "

 ""% 4

%   " 

4"!" 

,

1 "  

'"% 4 " 

FC

 I



FC+   !%  

%" 5 "  ""%



)3 +))* "

4"!"

FC+< 

$  " 

"

FC +<9

 

4 "  "

>

FC2

"

/  F  &   -

FC(    "

A ""%

 "

 "

 

 "

""



!

 

'"%  

  "% 6

$

"

 " %"



)3 +))*



&H4 FC+< ! #-  

  "% 6

$

  "

$  " 

1

 "

 

!   "

FC+<9



  "    

'"%  

/

 "" " " FC+ I



"

 " " FC( "

 / 

)

=

% 







" 

" 4"

 "

 

""



" " "$ "

  

"   

@





"

%  

 "

)3 +))*

4 $  "



%

 

H4


"% '" 3( 
$ 

,,+ ""%

   " 4 %

"  "   "  "" " $    %" 



  



%"  " 

"

1

  " 

"

" 

  "



?

$  $ !





 " "

""

 

" ""

" !6

+

  "

6 $

  "  "  "

""% "



1 4

+

&

   "



-

""%



"% "

%
 > %

  

 /



 

'"%

" " $

H % " 4  / %  

% !

"

 

'"%   %

% &
 -

%" 

"

"%

 !

"

" ""   "  





= "  &- "% "  4 " "

" " "% 

! " 

% 6

 ""% " " "% " 4< ""% 4 4 "

""



    "  H4
C2<9  "%     "

" "%   H4 

, "%  H4 F

  " "%  

"" "

!" '"%

#6 $

 

)2 +))0 

'"%



!"

% H4


  " "



/ 595



"  "% " 4 "

+

1



 "

/9 "

 



 "  

"  "% " 4 "

"   

    



 "

  "  %"%  " 

J %  "   &" " /"% $-

%   " 

"





)3 +))*  "%      "  



 "



" 

%    

% " 

7!" $ ""%

%" "   "



 & "   "

!" '"%- " " 

 " 

  

% " 



 "%    "  

% " 

"  %

  

""

 $



%

 

$     '"%

J "%

!

""



"   $



% " :

0;



  "%   "

"% " "

"K

 !   "



'"% "



"

!



(

""

" $



" 

""

%   ""% "  " !"

"$ "

/ 

"  

""  

"  "

  '" 23 # #""



0),

 "

 $   5



 ""% "

""



 " 





"

   

'"%

% " %

 "



  &F"" 8% 8  -

 ""% "% "   "



"

 ! #

   "

"

  ""%





)3 +))*  

""

 B      "%

6

$  "

  $  

"

*3+3))<



  ""%

"

   

 "

  "    %

""



" " 4 "  "

  " "

4

4

%

  

 !%  

% &H4
 -

@

 %  "

%



 



 

  ""%

 " "

"

 ""%

%  " "%    
C2



 #""

8%

'""

$  

!



%

$  

$  

%

""% ""

 "



 

*

 % 

% " ! # H4


%" 

""  "  $ %

 F"" 8% " '"

* & -

%" 

0), 6" %"

  ""%

   

" !

$   '" 32 
$ 

,,+

6  %"        '" 32

J 

% ' #  
 &+) )- '## () 

 #  "% %

 ""% "" '"

*

(0

%"  ' #

%"   





  " '" (0 



 

"

"

   "

" ""  

J

 



  &" 
-  % H4
  "

% 6

$



%"  

/ "

"

,

J "%

! %



 "



  "



"

 



 ""



#"%  " "

 " 

!" '"% &

'"%- " " $ "

 



                    

 !"  # "!" $%  $ %

     "% $ 

&     $  '

  % $    "

($!!

    $)*+   , -## &$"+   &$

." & %

*

% !  " "& 

%&   !!% /0123 ! " " !% / 45   "!  !  "$   $! " " !$$&   &$"& "! "  &$% &

 6! " "        !                 " "  % !/

  % ! !/!."  + 

$& " "&  !  !"+ !""%

 6  !     "  % 

   ($       ! &" .

 ! % ! %$#"   "%

($ !$      !"!$ ! " "  + 

($   ""$&$%   " %

"  

 !  /$    %#"



%  


  

"/ " """   "  ,  " ."  .&

88

*

    %   " " 

 3&$&  $"+  &$

($&

6!."! 9  !  " "   " %   % !"! %:

;% " 

 4 $

<. "!  $ !"   !"!         

   ($  !        $! !  " "&  (       !  "      !      ""    ! %      !  !    " $    "       = !"   $%                         %  

.

 "&$%!  !$ ! %" >?

:

@ "

 # "$ $A,BB

@ &" "   A,B5 )

@         %        A,B5

@ &" "  !"A,B5 *

 ;



     $    $          !                   "&     %      $  !            %&   &   %$  /$   # "   "&    %" $    )

 &"   

($ . C ! " $



  /-$%($  5&$/ 5

5@ -< -  B@?

C "&

 !$"

&">   $> 0.

B " > 0.

B B " > 0.

B) B " > 0.

B8 (

88

*

> 0.

B*

(B> 0.

BC "  > 0.

( > 0.

BD    .   5@?

-B/ 5  5@? !$"

&">?

(B> 0.

 # $ > 0.

5  "> 0.

5)  0.

B@)E4> 0.

B  > /

$ 

*

> /4 "  > //0 8

" B$,"     "             /$  "&   "$ $&"%  "   "" "    !%

($&

88

*

" 
$ "  !%!

"    

B  & 

"%

"% 5-



% " ! #

" 

"%

 



 %

"" 

" "

4  

/

  "



 "% ""  % 

"   " 



"  " 

4"  + * 

" "  %  "

%

"

"" &- "% "  4 "

J !"%   "  " 

" %   "% "!

!

 

%  

 "  %< "  %"%    

" "   5  %"%        



1

 $ !"     

" "  & "

 

""

 " "%

/" "

  -

%  

="

$  "%

$ !$ "

"" " &

'"%- %

$ "

  "  " 

 "

 " $ "

"

% " 

+3

  ""% "

/ 

"  " !"

"$ "

"" 



  ! 

  "

% "   ! " ""% " " "  '"% '"%

""

+@

%







% "   ! 



 

%

  " "

 F"" 8%  "

  % &  





! "-

%    "

 "

""%



#6 $



" "

 

'"%

""

+*

%

 

    

% ! " #

   %





+,

   

 



 



&"   " 

""

!" '"% "



$ 



- " !"

FC+< 

$"%

% 

$  ""%

" " 

"  

*3+3))<

   

 %"% !$

 " 

J 4 !" 



" "

 " $

   " "



 "

  "

 "



*3+3))< 

  

+3+3))<

@



  " "$

 !"

"   "

$

"

"" " "

"%    

"



"  $  " %"

$  "

J "% !$ " 

 !



"$

   



  

 "%"% 

+0

I  

 !" "  !

""  " "

" 



8 )0 +) ,    



/   $    "  " 6"

%  "

"



1 4 " 



  "

"% 



/      "  "

2)

J 4 !"

% " 

 / $

/

!

 "  ""% " "

%  "%  "

"

  "

)3 +))* &

% H4
 " !"







$ " !   -

J  !" " 4 "

""

  

/ "  " "%

$"%  % 

$

  ""% "

=

% 

%



 4

"



4  %  

$   "   "   " & 



"

 > %

- 4 "  "  "!    

4 "



 !" 

  4 "

""

 &" " /"% $-

C 

" / "%  "! 

 

" "

  

'"%

  6



+2))))<

,*))))<

J !" " $ !" "% ""

  " "$ "   " $



  "  

 " $



""

 

% H4


5 4 !

5 "

"

   "

2+

 5 " 

""%  



 !   "  "   % " 4 " "

""% 4

%  "%  "    "%

% H4


1  "

% " !$ "% 





"  

 "% % "-   !"#
$%&'  +)))&(-

#

&#""

-

""-(        $)     '!  *  $ +  % #
 +)),&+-

#

&#""

- ()2

2(

J  !"

% 

)3 +))*

$ 

%"   %

 "

 

""    " !

$ 





))<  

/ "

"



4  '"

0+ 1"

H"  !"  

    ""% 

$ 

%  $ 

 !

2@

I $

%      

"   

'"%

   " 



)3 +))*



"  '" , 
$ 

,,+     

" %  &

"   

'"%-

"%

 % 

 

 ""

   "   ""



 $   

 $  

2*

     



 

 

   



 "

 !"  "  "

 



 "    " $  "  "

% H4
  "

%" 

""!

" %   "

%  "

 " "

% 

$  

2,



4 !"  

%

       





 "

!" '"%  <

"" &"  "

- 





J  $   

!" '"%





$   $

%

I  

4  ( " '" 0+ 1"

H" 

,*+ !"    $ "  ""%

$

%  " !    "

$ !6 

% ""%  "$"%     4  "   

6"

""%  %" 

 6""% %" 

 !"  



    "%

"   ""   % "

% &H4
- %"  "

" " 

 "" " '" (0

%"  " 

 

%" 

"% " !

$  "

"

$ 



  "

 

" ""  



!" 

    $"%  '" (0  " $ ""  

 "

 /"% ""  

  &

% 

)3 +))* H4
 -

$ 

""!

" "      

 " "% 



 "   "

" "% 

()

I  

4 !"  " 

!  "

 " " !  "

 "

+





%

 "

  " 

%

(

#6 $



!"

    "

"

"% "  "% ""% $ " !



 ""



(+

1 !





!" "  "







"   

" " "" 

 /"% $

/

% H4



" 

J  !" " /"% $ "



 " "

 

'"% &/"%

 

""- " $ !"  "

"

 !

" 

7  " 



4

)3 +))*



5 "

"" +) )* +) ) 

 "" " " )@ )0 +) ) "

! 





(2

#6 $ !" !





 

%

    ! "  !$

 "% " ""





" 

"" "

"""% " "" 



((

9

" "%     " 6"

    



"





  " " "

 !



%  

 %     

6"



  B"- C "% %< 

.

 



"

%

  " "%

 "

"

 !

$

""- C $ "  <

""< 

 " %"

"  

"%   "  

"  

"""- C    " 

  

" !

 "" "

0+ 1"

H" 

,*+

"- C " !

$ " 

"% " !

$    " 4 "

 6" '" , 
$  

"  

- C %<   

 

 " "



"

  $ "% "

"- C % 

 " "" "   < 

"  

(3



   6"



 &""- " ! " 

6"  "

  

% " 





"  ""%  "



'"%

"

! "

6"

"

6"



'

 &"""-

&"-   ""% 6" " 6

""%  6"

   ""% 

%  6"  &""- "   "  

 "

6"

"

"   



 "



  BC

% " 

  



"  EG

J 6"

"  



C    " 

  

" !

 "" "

0+ 1"

H" 

,*+

+

C " !

$ " 

"% " !

$    " 4 "

 6" '" , 
$  

"  

C

% " 

  



"  EG (@

 "   "  "  $ "

   !

"

% 

)3 +))* 

 " "  $

/



 $   " 

"   !  "



$





!" '"% "



)3 +))* &

$  " " "-



%

'  ( 0) +) , " / 

/

" "

(*



" !" "% 



  

"

!

$ "  ""% " 

*3+3))< 

"  "  "



 "

 " " & "







  "  "  

   -

L1    %





"    "

/ "  ""%   $ " "



$

"  " " "

" " 

 6"



""$

% H4


"  $

 

"

%  "

 "

M > 

$

 

 

"%    

"" 





*3+3))<

   " " 4"

%"

 



 

!" '"% 



6"  "





"  !""% 

%"

 

"

"

 "% " "

$ $



 ""% 

"  

!6 %"

%   4  

 !

 " 

"    & 

 "

" -

(,



$ "



 '"

0+ H"    

    ""% 

$ 

%     $ 



J    %

% " 

 "

"

%  

%"  "  ""% ""  "

 

" !

$



 

))< 



"?

 







  "

$ "  

%  $   

%"    " !

$



% " " "

% 



"



%  $ "  " %"

 

 !

$ 

(0

%

 

 

  

%  " ""



 4"



" 



"





  " ! 

( " '" 0+ 1"

H" 

'" (0

%" 

3)

 4 " ! "   

 ""

 "!  

,-)). 

 -)  )).% &

&&")  )/@ "" $     &% "  "

 "!" + % !% " "

 &"%$&

  """ $     "  ." "

 "&" ""!""&" % 

&%"

0."   .....

.....

.....

0.



"

+ "!" "" $   " "

"!"" "

 

0.

    @        $       $% &

0.

)   "

!& " ""  "   &" "

!728,+ 9+ 23 @   """ $     +  %!% " "

 &% & ""$        "    &"       $     %  %!  "       &              ""$ &$ $  %"$  > &9+,

 " % &!"! & "

 !"!  " $  '   "          $  !     

."  !" """$   F! G "  /"!

&9+, ." $ 

!""

 !""!    % & 6"$! &

  &$$  "



&9+, )   ."           $  " $" ""$%$   """ $     % &

&9+, 8   ."      "   %+    $ "  """ $ 

   % & ." "!" """ $    %!+ %!$ % $""$!" %$ $"



B&*C.....

.....

.....

3+,+4

 : !

  3+,+ 8,;8+<3+, H<"

+ %"

F% & B  "  II8 IIG %$H  "

&%  "

  % " !   "

%"&&"""$ "

 "$ " !  %$>          FB& $" "$

&%

 + % "B  "  II8  II %$ %"&&"""   ""  "  66( "" "

I

) I

 &"""+  %"%$  G; '"

*

%"  

     "  " '" (0 

6   4   "

 "!   B /  )8,    =+  3+,+  +,  >82,?

H   !$"

%$   !"  "!" &%."  !"  "< D6 IC8 6$

"  ICC 6$ "  I

6$

"  I

 "" " "  >H  .....

.....

.....

% ?  !"   " " $  .$  !     $  !&"$  &    ! 

&%

 '

" ?  !""/!$" 

      "    ""       " " $   ." "$ ' J .....

.....

.....

F

 "

"$""" 

&%   "*)  B  "  II8 II%$&% ." "

" $, !

  " 

 ""

 $ ""

"   &"  "*)

G <$" %" %?"

H & .....

.....

.....

& F"

"

 " %?"

G"$ "$ $$  $.$ $ $ &    ! 

&%   %   "$$ % "

!"! !."  " " $   .$  "$ ' &......

.....

.....

F0.

 "

 $ $""" 

&%  % + &

&+ $%" ""  ""  !   "  ) .....

.....

.....

22>,+,>>2++,8? >9+,+,4++,@832?

#""%

 "" %

 

 

   " !""



% !6

4""%   " "

""!

" " "  "$ "%"

  
" &(- '" 0+ H"    " "  

4"  

 B"  "    %   """ $ "

6" ""%  %"

"%

 "

%" G

& "   "



)3 +))*-

   " !

$



 

))<

6"

  " " ""% " " 6" %"  '"

*& - &!- &-

%"    !6 

%



" %"  "

$ "

3+

J 

"

&!$ " $

" <  

'"%

-  

$ "



$  "  

"

  

$ 

""

  

  $ "%

*3+3))<

$ "

"

  "% 6

 " "

  

'"%

$  

%

$"%  

$ ""  $ $ "" 

   " &(- '" 0+ H" 

"" 

  " &(- !

 "  " " &+- ""

 " 

J

% 

 5 "  " "  H4
 " "

""!

"

$   "

 "



% "  6

"$< "" ""

 "

%

 $ "" & " 

"

   "-

#"%  "

%  "



% "   "% ! 

'"% 

  ""% 4 

4 "

 %  "   " % "  "  $

 

'"% " " "%  !   " ""

""%  6"    & %



)3 +))*-  

 "

5

   E 3(

1 4   !  &"

5 "-  " " "

/"%

$

/ "



 /"% ""  

 



%

 "

     "   '" (0

%" 

1 "" " 

 " "

"!

 

 &!- &- !" & - '"

*

%"  !"

 

 "" ""

"



$    $ " "  "% 

"""%  4"%""%

"% &" "%

 "%- " !

$

!





))< "

 "

%" !



"   ""%

 &- !" &+- '"

*

4



 "%

 !" 

#

 &- !" &+-  "



$  "   <

< "%< ""<4"%"

$ "%  $ !  

"% !

      

 "%  6" %"

J 

 

 " !

 !  %

% H4

"

 "  "%

"%

5.

" !

$ " "" 

"""% "%

$   " $ 



$  H4

" "

  "%

"% !

 

4



 "% !" &+-  "

% 

%

 "

 "%   "% 

 

" !

$ "   6"  $ %"

 4

J 

%  

% H4
 "  "%   "% 

 

" !

$ ! " 

"""% "%

$   $ "

%"

J "" "  



6" %"

 " / !   '" (0

%" 

" 6""% %"

 "





  " !  " &H4
-



""

"%

$   " !

$ !$ ""

"% ""

!"

 &!- !" & - '"

* 

0),

"  

2 6"



    %  (3 " !

  

% H4


"  

 " "" " /"% $

/  

" "

   

%"  "

 "

6" %" 

 &!-

&- !" & - '"

*

%" 

 

 &- ! " &+- ""   4

!" &+- '"

*  '" (0 

3@

H

! 

"

 " $ !"     /"

% /

 ! 





"   "

   

  " /



)3 +))*

C

%



 ""%

  

$  !  $  

"" $

$    " %"

 

%  

"  

4 !$ $"%

"  $  

 6"



 6"

  !  !6

% " ""!

" " !

J  !" 6" " "

/

 " B 

 G

3*

1

%

    

)3 +))* 

%  



4 ""  " !" " 



5/

1

% 4 $ "

  %"



%

"  $  

"

%   '" +2

+( 1"

#  

,*+ "



 

5A,++<@,2= 824= H "%#"$ !   HH %%!'  "     !  & !'  '&&

 # 

  ' $

 

 %" "  6"" "%#"$  % !  0&$ !"%#""  ! & 

%. )!0)1 & N 1

$ 

"% "    ! 

$  

$ 

$  

" "

"% ! " 

 

% " "

& "

 " %"

! '" +2    $ "

 "

4 " ""

 " !"

"$ ""-

J

$ "

$

% " 

 / $

/  BG " 

$  "< " " "" " 

> ! !""

$   "   "



'"%  

 $ "



$     ""  "?

!  

5



""    " 

!""

$

  " "  " "

 " "

"4 !

 

3,

1

!

'  ( 0) +) , 

""%  #""

# 

>

,2 +) ) "" 

  #""

8% &8" F"""- %  )@ )0 +) ) "

  %

 

  

" 

" !$ """% "

#"% 4



""%  " ""





" 

!" '"% /"%

   ""  ""%  "

  ""%  

"

"" " $

"!

" "

'  ()*

+) ,

@)

1 "



    " %  

%  "

"







  "   "

" 5 





)3 +))* &"

   

! 

" -

7  !    

 ""%    

 



$   $ $

! " 



 



 " 4 $

/ % 

 " !"  

"%   "% 6

  "!"%   %  " ""

 ! " !

"% $

B     "%  "% 

= 

  



""%  





$ "   



   "  !"

"%   



   "  "

 

?

$   

"" "  &!$ !" %"% !$ 6

 % - " "



! "  4 

  

$    ""% 



@

 5 "



 " "

"%

/  " 

 





% !" $ "

"    

  " %" "



)3 +))* &H4
3  "

H4 FC+< -

H " " /

 "

%

  



"%  %""% " 4   

 

$   " " "





%  "

"  



@+

 $      "      2     $  

"%("IB  "  II ! "%$          " %

":  ; %$:" ;   " "#" $ &"! "("I " II  % !  &  "%!>?

:>+ ,  H7.

 "  

             !     !"" % $   $"  ( """  !     .  "" $ $"'  !   "" 

&% '  !     . "" $ "/ / %  !! $ &   !'  !  %"%"  " ." !%"   % "" % '   !                  $ "  " "" $/ " ;

  !"%/% 

  "E .  "  ""

$   &$""   " "     !" 



 % ""!%  6 "  &!"$     "%

    

  ! &%"%

   "E '!&  " &%&  "" $""%" %!! % &  ""$$""  " "    "%

    "           !"         !  %  

 

3"  ("  I          B   "    

"%   +  + !   " ""$!

@2

J   

'  ()*

+) , 

""%  " "" " 

" 

!" '"% +) )* +) ) &! "% #""

'" >

9(@(<+) )<+) +- 

  !

%   " "!

 %  !"

"%     



" "





" 

""  " 

   ""  ""%   ""% " " & -

$ "    / 

/ 



 & " 

""-





"

  " !

 

"  

$  ""%

" "



% &H4

" "

 

-  



"

  "

%"

  "%

$ "  !     $   

" 

 

""  ""% "   ""% "  

" 

 ""% "  

" "% 

J 

%  "  $

""

"" 6

$  

!  " 

 

    " %

 "%

'  ()*

+) ,

@(

#6 $



" $

  4

%   "  "% 6

  %   





"    

"



(+( 

)3 +))*  "

  

  "" 4



  "   

"" % " 6



 ! 6

   " 

@3

'  ( 0) +) , "

  %

 "

  

 "%



 

"

" ""  



5

 "% #""

# 

>

,2 +) )  #""

8% &8" F"""- %  )@ )0+) ) ""

"

 "    %

     



 

"%

? 4

 2
+3 &"$$E '83 A,>B+3C, -*, A><2 -*,