High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4683/2017dismissed

Narata Ram And Ohers v. Harish Khera

2019-05-03Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

"#$#%&' "#

((''

)# *

+# ","# -#

#-##./ #"((''

#),0 '. #/1"

#&(' ./ #"# 3#'4 . " #"(' +# "

,"#"5#*6" *6

$#%&' 1''

" 7/ % " 5 8 "/'99*5# :

* # "#*6" (# # $# % &' 7/ &'

#/ 6 # # # (#% 7* # # 6 " (#

6* #"%#% ## 6 %

# (*' (

74% (' ## 6 # 6

54(' *( ' % *# 6 9 !%#' %(# #$

!88. */''6 *9"#.;"

' #%5' "1 54'# 3<=>

" ('

(#/# "(' .""(*#" 9

!%#' ' #%%) "'&*'1"06%"

&*'.# +* $ !8!.%5'<4 ",%'

&*' " "#7 &*' ",# " ?' &*'.

# +* $# .%5'<4/#6 # '

# *%

' " / # "(* "% (

9 !%#' ' @"%*

$ !!" 5 /*#"(' @"*6"" / # "A*" '*/#* # *%5# .

5**'(

9 !%#' ' /''6*9"# ;"

' #%5'"5 '/#(' "% A* ' " "(' " 5

" ' @"" "(*#" 9 %#' ' /''6 *9"# ;"

' # %5' *1""."4" ' 9 %#' ' ##/ 6*# "#* ## 1

9 .

"14" 1#'1" '49 %#'' @ *"9 %#'' ." "

#* 61 /# 9 %#' %#'' 1 '4 6/ @ " "'

(*#"

9 %#' '

/''6*9"#.;"

' #%5'.1""1 # 9"1 # #%"' B* @"" "'#4#

"' (*#" 54

"%##/ 6*"# "/'

'"' " #%(' 1"*6 6(#%

"##%"## ;1 <* #4 -'

6 1"* 6 6 4 ' # 6"(' ."#B* " #% "#''6' ## (*'(

" 54# 6

5* #% % .6/ 6# * "(' 5# 6" * . " ((# ' 1#

% 6 " * 9 6 /#* '6' 57

"'' 6 6% 5'4" *''6 6""(' 1

6*'4 '% @"" *1 5# 7 #

#4(# # A /'#%<*# %# ." 9*(('""(' "' " *54% #(# 6. ' 6 *((#

6"#* %#' @""(' "/"("4 '(

4 (# 9" # $

!88.

. /''6 *9"#. ;"

' # %5'@ " " (' ''6'4 (*#" " ' #% 6(#/#* # *%5# /''6*9"#.;"

#%5' (# '$

9"$ 8 !.9" #$

88..

88 8 .

888% *# 6

%#' .9" 8.9" # % *# 6 9 !%#' .9" 8 .9" #

88 8 .

88 8 . .

88 .

88 8 .

88 .

8 . 8 .

88 8 % *# 6 9 %#' .9" 8 8

.9" #

88 8 8 .

8 % *# 6 9 %#' .9"

8!.9" # !88 % *# 6 9 '.9" !8

9" #

88 .

!8 % *# 6 9 %#' .9"

8 . 9" # . . % *# 6 9 !

%#' 9" 8 #

888% *# 6

%#'

(#% *# 6 9 !%#' @ ""(' "''6'4(*#" ' #%%) "' &*' ",%'&*'.1""#'#(*#" "' #% %' " .%/ .8" 7,*%# ) ,*%#/#6 # '$!

@" 5"

"#6 # ' $

. '

'4 "(

9" #$

!88.

% *# 69 !%#' "5 6/ @" $

"(*#" "' "#*6"6"# #6 # ' 1

%*"(##" ' $!

"41#

("4 '(

"9" #$

!88. (##%"# 9" # *%5#@""(' " ''4 %(' "# "### "' (*. *"" * 5#

7 #

#4(# * 6"#% 6''6

" (#4# %

'" * "(' "(# .''1 6

* 1#

C""#"(' '##(#% 7* (#4#D-- C""#" *"(' % 5' " (# #%D- C""#" * 5# 7 #"(# D- C""#" *" 5 (#(#'4/'*#"(*#(

<*# 7*# D- ' 3""(# '/ # ("#'%

*# 6"*# " / ."(' 6"

% ## -C 5 A% 6 ",# &'

-C ." 7/ 6' -C."%$1 -C."-1

66#1' -C ") '"# -C ""#" . $ F"$#% ((# C #"# 6"'# *

'#"(# ."#'

<*#

*$ /*#" 6

" .

* $ 6

"(' /*#" *' '4. *"(' 1 %

;" 1

/7*6% #

;"(' 1 66#/54" 7*6% # ""' (('5#"<*# #0*6.

%5'.1"/7*6% # !

(" (('. "7*6% #(

54"#'<*# #" *"(' "# 8

1## # #% ## 6 "(

"(('' /#" *' #% ## 6 # 6

54 "(' "# *57" ""(' "''

5''1# 457 "(# (#

1"#6#"

"/ 65 # 54"% #% # 6"6#* ""(#*'#' 5A'*#%(#

$11 *# " '

"4"'"(# #6*'# (('5#" <*# $1

*# .1"(* ((# "#*6"

:"/"#'# *

'#"(# 5 6 "#*6""## : ""# %# "((' ;"*6""#'<*#" %

" *'54" 5*"1 * ## * #(# *'

'6'( +1/#." #0*6.%5' #6"" 1# 6 %% 54" #' <*# 54(#(# ((# ' *' ( ## #(# '1 % " '* "" * #/5# #" % 54 6 "7*6% #(

54"#'<*#:

" 5 5 #/54 #0*6.%5'""(

/#" *' (#/#%/#* ># '4. 1 % "#'" '

=A- A*54%' " /*#/ # " %'4%) "'&*' ",%'&*' '

=A- A*54%) "'&*' ",%'&*' /*#"(' " '=A-

1 '

% "(

" *' "5

" /#54"/ "%;"/'*% 6

*" "#'" '

5* # % #% 6 194(/ >*#"#%#.'/#4(

5' "#% ""/ # "(' "6" *' %# 5#'/#4(

%# .1""1 ##* (*# * ##

(

54 " #' <*#

*((# *"('"(' *"#(#5 6=A-;"

"# %

54" $ " #

1" "6" % ## C " 9 %#'

' %(# #$

!8 1 '4 6/ 1

*##* 54 6" 1# ;"( *1# "

"(' ;" $ $#% '

"1 "/ ' /#* (' * "* 9 ' "

#/ 6* #

"5 #

%(#

;" $#%"/ 6"% ' '' "#%(' 1"

5 6# "# % #' # %54"% " #

A% ."

57(' % 6 (

" *' # 6

/#"#?# #0*6.%5'"

###"'6'( " *57 '1"'##/ 6 " '* ""(' "5 5'%9* # 6# 7* " /*#;" $ "% '"

#/*' 4/#"# " (

5'4 # # " (' #% # 6

?# #0*6.%5'#### 6/#* 7*6% "

*57" #6"'45 #/"

. 4.# 54" " *' 1*' %* * # 4 "##

#1*'"/'* *'4"(#(#45% " ?# *

' # " (('' " ### 7*6% !"! !# $% $ &'()*)+,

* - .,/01 . 2 !#$ !"! $3# &''(*),

* - .,45(# " !"! "6(51( &'4 7(5('78&''0 .% #.9$#$% !$! :$% ! %;

%%7$()('&'((<=# !7" 75'478(550 .% $% : $3# !!

$$% !%;

%%<=# !

7" 7$&1)&'(0 7)0'(78&''5 .%7# $% $3#

!"! .9 $% $3#$%7# !%;

%%<=# !7" 7$

! +(&'(' 7(+1(78&''& .%.. $3#$% !

!"!2."$% !%;

%%<=# !7" 7$((&&'(/ $ 7$ 78$% $%7# ! !"! !- 7>767"!

$37;

=% $%7# !&'(4*&, * - .,0+:6 !"!

%= ? (550*4, * - .,()'@! 77%7 !"!@!

2$ A 7 6$= $% $7# (55+*), 0&+ $% 3

$3# !"!39$ $3#&''&*&, * - .,5) +1/#. " *"# ((' " (# *# #*% " A

1"" *"5 #/

"5 % : 4%# "(# ((' 4# *#5"'6'./' 1''# 7*6% (

54" #0*6.%5' $ *5 'B* '1# " (('

;"((' %

# 6'4

*, 3#7 ?## !7$%@!6B $3 !@7 ?## 67 <.

!@7