← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4700/2017dismissed

Prem Krishan v. Ram Singh And ORS

2017-10-10Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina9 pages



Vimal Kumar 2017.11.27 11:02     

!" #"$%&%'(

 

      

  ( ) *  +     

  

 +,  

-./

  

 !  "  

-/

#    

   ! $ " %& "       

-0/

#    

   ! $ " '() " *      

& +  ,    , !

     %& &) &-..

          / %(%    &%*



01 )))2*

0) )))2* + 



  " 

,  "

 

 3, 4,4   , !

 

   ,



 ! ,!

  4"

 

 4"  

,4

  

 + 

 

 

5

 4  6, 4!4

    ,  4"!

" 

+ 6, 

 ,   "4"  "

!  , % +    !  4"

         0) )))

 !  4" ,  

    %0 &) &-..

  7          %)8'9   

&-('

 

    ,4

     4" "   ,



 

+     4    4" 

 

 / %&0(&.   &:

&) &-..  6 ;

 6

 '

          ,  <   ! 

 "8< 9

= 

!   

 && )- &--1 + ,!

4,   " %)):    3

 !

   5 "

 >4

 $ , "

 

 ,  7

    !   

     

  

      , "

=  

       

  ,   

  !   !

  4"   6 6,   )0 )1 %))0   + 

 !

 ):

)( %))0 %1? ,   , 4 

  8   9     



 "    5>$   ,  $

 / & * 

 < =          $

 / % !

   ,     

 ,  ! 

 / ' * 5>$  "       , " !





   *  / %(.-  )( )% &-.1       !

    4"  6 "

!

  , )'

).

%)):  

, ;, 



   ,

, 

 !

, %'

&% %))- @  

     

 ,"



/ %A 3  !

 %( )- %)):

5! &:

)( %)).

   B,   

   4"   " 4  

 ,4

    &'

)( %)).      3  !

 !

    "

  

 +    

44  5>$  

( ,,

 ,           

 ,   

  

  7

5>$ !

, 

 4  

"       

   ,          

!   :

@   * 

 

 / & A 

   4, !

 

 

4   4

1)))2*

    

  <

 5                     "    1)))2*  5     ,     "  01 )))2*  / %   "  

 



  !



0) )))2* @     ,

          &:2

 5 

< %&2   ,

= 

   

,     C %)2    "

   "

$

  " * 

 

,

"  ,  .

+  " 4      6, !

D !     

 !

 0) )))2*  01 )))2* 

 4"  



/ &   "

+  6,    , !

  4 !

@ !       01 )))2* !       / %     / %  &(2

     0) )))2* ,

 " # * " 1)))2*  <

 - +    !

  

         $0  $:

   ,4

  "    4"

!

      " , +   

  

!  4    , B,    

          , 

 &-..  , ,   , %)):

 

 "

+  6,         

     

  4     

!

0) )))2*!  !

  ,

 "  

 01 )))2*     ! " !

  

     



     

&) +  

       ,      " , ,    5>$  



  

     

       !

   

, 

!

  

, +  6,!     4  ! "  !, 

   &-..%)):4  ,

    +  

 !

       %1?    

,  4

 ,     4"   

  " 

 

 !  "

5   6, ,                   

  "  + 

4    



 <

 

 



 !

 B,    ,        =   " 



   

 <

&& ;     " 

   4

 

"



4" 

 





   !

,"   

>  ,      ,

  , 

  "   ,    

 +    6, !

   

" "    "

    

  !

 "

!   4

    

 !      " 

        

     4     

" 3,   

   

&% @!

 "4 6,!

4, 

 "4

, ,  , ,  %)  

  ,  6,B,     "  ,

!  4 4" 3, ,



   



 ,

 

4  ,       

 "    " 

       ,   !    "       ,

 4,  , + , ,   

 4

 !  

     5>$ ,4



"

    0) )))2* 01 )))2* +  !  

!

!      

 !

  !

 ! 

 " ,  ,  

+  6,B,   ,6,3,   ,

= E   !   /,4  ,, E 

 &-.: ,  66 '0)   F  

   

       

               G &'

C   , 

4"3,

  )% )1 %)&0   6, ,  0) )))2*

,  ,   %:

%0.2*   4"   

 !

     ')9  5>$

 +   !

   4" =  

 <

,  

 "

/ &*     , ,    

  4 ,         , H

  

, &0 

E  6,    

$ =, 

4" 

 4 3,     

,     ,   + ! 6,

," 6 ,0 



4" 



    4  4,!

  

   / &    "         

 6 , 0       2

 

,

 "

       ,

2





      

  , 

  

 ,

  ,4  4,!

 

    "   !

    !

    



  ,

2

 &1 +  !  6,

   

         , !

  4" 7 % , % 66  + 

  

,

 ! 6,      ,

.

=   , ,     4< 





 ,  < %&2   ,4" 

= 

+     ! 6, !

          , !

,4"= 

 " 



  "4  

 C    ,!

 ,4" 

  ,  =           , 

  ,  ,        

     

 4,   

    

  , 



     ,  4"7%,% 66 &( @       .     , 4!  =  

  @    

       

! 

8 

9       / %(%    &%*

 

  ,  &)

   5 !

 4,"

  

 

    

  <  4"   

!

 && )- &--1 + ,!

  " %))& 5

@ "   !       4" 4    6, 4!       &:

   ,  



4" ,      ,6, = "



  ", 8%)&:9 1 66 &:.   "

    

 

   !, 4 3,

 ,  

D

 "

 

 

, 3,"   

 4"   6,   

  ,43,"  

 4"   ,    0) )))2* I %( )))2* !    4"  



"     

 &.

@    ,

    

8, 9  

   "

    4      

  +   

      !    



  " 4,  !  , !

 4, 4" !,   4         

     

 ", "

 " , &)  

 () )))2*    "     =,  &---  !     , 6,    3,  

&1  4   ,   

 4  ,   &- +  " ,

  

!, 3, "  , ,

 !

 

 + 

  "

 4"     4

  ,

  , <

"    " 4"   ,  4  

*

!,

   ,  !



   6,

!

"  

   

"



"  

&-..%)&:

   " !  3, 

!

" 4  ,  

!  ,

 ,  !

 

4"

 " ,  %) @ ! 

@ 

"   

,   

3, " ,  

,  ! 



  !  B,  ! 



 

  1 +2     



 

!  "