Union Of India And ORS v. Ex Hav Ashok Kumar And ANR
!"#$%&%%
"#"'#( !"#$%%
"#$ $%%& '
)$ *+) ,,
, -
*+) , ,, , ) )!(*+, & - --.!(-.
+/ .
0 0
2 & .34.(+.0/(3 5.1
,
, -
.
7-
!)-- .
8 '
/-'
9 :
(./ '
.+ 1
- ) . ( 1 -
(.( ; 9
<!
:/ . '. ( *+ - 0.
( =(
5 7 .0
(9- 1
-
5.00(. ->7 .0>:/8- *+ - 50.=
1
-) 1- 350= 1- ( .*0+'
8. .00 8(
/(0'/1/(23 "'#!
'
8. .00+
00( - =+ 9 00 + )= :
? ?
.
( ( 5-.
)( - 1
=
? .1 ) ; +.
/ =
- .
( (.+ @!.01+ ) 35/1
8-5-/-8. ) ( 35'
1
01 7- .1 /
00( 1 5 5!
+
9:
1
. = 1 +.
- = 1 -
0= /-((
' - 1
= 35 8.
( 35$ /(! A 8&(5.0.)
+9' =.
:1
-
(.)
1 B =.
+ $+'
C/ - 8.
) ( 1!
<
1 35.
(8. ( 5-.
)(- 1
=
.1
) +.
( (.+ 1 357-
8. 0( ( .*0+ '
5
) 1 35 0= .
( ( .*0+ 0= D; E.). E( .*0+81 ; $ /- 8. ) (( .*0+0= D E8-5--. *
(( 11
; E1
013(
(.(
'. (*+- =(
.05
( 0 ).)) 3(/
10(/*1
- =(
5 7 .05
(/1
) 1 35 0= ( .*0+'
7- .(/*5.=.00 8(3(
(.( ; 7- ' .3'.
1- .(
< .5(-
!"# $%!%
& '
() * $+%"$%!%,
0 ).)) 3(1
=-.1
.(
. '. (!'
-9 !'
.:/*+-0.
( =(
5 7 .05
(/- '
9 :
1 (. -. 10( - .). - .
8 '
*1
- 3'4 #0 "506 1 / # !("'#
15" 06 7 0808"# ; 7-0.
(5 01
!*=-.- 0.
( 7 .0 -. 1.0( -.
=
! 0+ - '
)!0.
/ . - .= .
0+ .''05.*0 5.05!0. '
5. 1'
08- 3.0(( !.
(
-
8- ( 5-.
)(
='0
1 = 1 ).)=
=
)
( 7- .()!0.
(
=.
(.'.+= 1* - ( .*0+0= .
( 350= /. * -.
(' 1.5-
(.
'.
.0+) (
='0
'535
(
5 .
+ .
- .= 7- '
)!0.
< .5(- ,
# 8"#
3'1/08"# 5" 49.%:% !+$ - .
/
- !0 , $##
12
,
# 8"#
3'1/08"# 5" 49.& "3 ) 1 - !0 ,
'
& '
4 12
'
, F 7-0.
( 01
!*=-.- .08-0.00 8 )-9 !'
.:-.(8
)0+ (-
3
9 !'
.:*+.G ))!0.
1-
)!0.
- =+/ F 0.
7- .( )!0.
< .5( - , B!35 6
0% .
/1
7
1
1
$% 1 $%
6
1
1 6 1
#5
#(
"5068 "' 0 - .( ).
(/ 1 . 3 (5
(*+-0.
(7 .05
( 5. F0(. 4 / 2/ 6'1 8/;
#8"#"5#!8/ (5((
? ?/ 8- . =0.
@!
8. '! 1
- *1
-7 .05
(/-.
7- 0.
(7 .05
(.1
( )- )!0.
* 3(-. = 1)!0.
1-
)!0.
1
- =+/ F /
!
/- .0.0 * 3(-.
;
7- .(3 (58.
5-.00 )(*+-
1 (.*1
-$
>*0!'
= .
( - .=8. !'-0(*+-'< 3 (5 ( 5. 0(. #8"# 5#!8/ ;
4 /2/ 6'1 8//(5((
!)! / / 8-5-30''.0 9.
+ F :*5.=. ) (7- '.
.) .'- /. 55!
- .( 3 (5.
< .5(- $8 0!0
1
2 1 1
!% $%$! 9
+
1 1
, ? 7-0.
(5 01
1!
!*= -. - 35/.= =!= 35 ;+.
8. @! ( .-
.
35'
/8- . /
-.( (
0+
+.
( (.+ 1 358--8- .1 /-8.
) (1!
<
1 35 $ /+- .(
(
1- !'
.@!.01+ ) ' ( 1 35 -*!8 !0(
( 0-'
/ *5 =.
.*0 5' 1-5 ='
1( .*0+ '
/-! 5
) 1* - 350= 1 35. 800 . 1-( .*0+0= 7- .
* )-./- !)--'
1
- 35 -/-! * )5
!( *- .''
@!.01+ ) 35/- !'
/- !)--8. @! ( * ='0 )- @! ' ( ;+.
/ .- 1
- *5 = ) 0(1
35'
$ /8- (!
)-' ( 1- 3 ) -/-.5@! (.( .*0+8-5--. * .(
1
= (
1=0.
+ 35
- .=* ). *!.*0
.)) .3.(*+=0.
+ 35/- *+ - .( .0= 1.
( .*0+/-! (!
)- '00 1-'
3 ) - /8- .1 -*5.=(*.
( *5 =) (.
+1!
<
- 35/ .- 8- -8. @! ( * 3.0((
( 5-.
)(1
= 35/. .'0+(
- .
5.
1 / 5 - .* 3 ='(= / (( 800 ' -
/ .- .
- @! ' ( 1@!.01+ ) 35/1
- *+ - *5 = ) 0(1
-.''
35 '
!5-/8- - 35 - *5.=< ((
8-
- *5 = ( 5-.
)(
)
( 1 = '
3 = 5
(!5
0+/8- = 0+
.55 1( .*0+9 !'
.:/. *5.= .0(!'
-=/-.
/3( 0+(!
)-'-. 1- ) =0.
+ 35/ -. - *5.= '
50!(( 5 ='0 - !'
@!.01+ )' (/ .- 1
- - *+ .
) 35'
/1
- ) 35 - !0.
0+/- .*0+ 1 -
='0-@!.01+ )' ( 1 35 - /-! 5.
.
( -8.+ 1- *5 = ) ( 8(-* 1
1 35'
/- 53 1
- = +.
/.
( (.+ 35 ( -/ .(0+= 0+
-'
= -.-
-.(
5 ='0(-.''
;+.
1@!.01+ ) 35 -
7- 1
/ = 1-<'
!0.
10.89 !'
.:
(*+-$
>*0'< 5. 0(.
!"
! #$%
.
8. 0(1
35 0= 1 35* ( 1-( .*0+0= - 1/.
.'0+(
*+-7 .05
(
!
/ 5 = 1-H!()= (*+- '< / 5. 0(.
"
& '(:1 )*+,!
+-.+ 8- /.(50.
.
=.( - < /-.-* 1
( ) 11/ .- -. *5 = ( 8( -5
( !0.
0+.0 - !
(1. *0 )- *5.= 3 ( - '
1
- G ) @!. - .''
( ) 11* )=.( - 1.3
"3 8 5 - (50.
.
1 0.8 =.(
3 (59 !'
.:=.G - .((50.
.
*.
<'
!0.
10.8 =/- *+ /-<'
!0.
10.8 =/. =.( 3 (5 9 !'
.:.0 =.G -- !
1
(* 1 3 .3 - (1 5 '
0 5
(/ /
/ .0 0 -
(/-! ..
+= G-) ) 1- ( 8= .
=.(- !
/.
(-.
/ -1!00 5 ='0= /. '0 !
/* (
'53 1-*.
/1.
+/ 1(0.+.
(0.5-
8#/1 !
"5068 "' 0
.1 =.-/- 1 (
= -8 '
(8- * 3.
.* 3/- .= ( = (
?
; 7-='!) (
/. '. (*+-0.
(7 .0
(/ =. . (.
(.11 =(
F '
( 1.0
)8-.00' ( ).''05.
9 :/1.
+ <,
, -
= <, , )= %%
H.06 -- '.G )2 .
( , I 2
-- '
.*0 , I 2