← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4233/2018dismissed

Gurkirpal Singh Chawla And ORS v. Deepa Duggal And ANR

2018-08-29Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal10 pages

   !      

 "#$ %$&'(')* + 





 ,,$--")#( 

 $(,)%$)#( * ./ /0 / 









!"



#

  !"



%%%%% 

   





 "

  "" $ "

!

   (    "$"

$(

)*   " , -

" .

  

 ! "!'

/ -0

1   "

'

"2

( "

3 "







&

   

6  -  ..

7 (   &  $

 $ 

8



  

 ( +  ..)

" , -

" .

 

! 9"

!

! (





$





6!

 " (







!  " $   

$ &

    

   !

"

'



$

     

$



! (

 

 

.

 ):

--;

! (

"

  " 

  (

!

'

 ! 



$



6!



!

--;

3

!



9 "



 

     

  ! "#$  %& % % # %"  !! (   " !!!  %  )   " !&!! ( )   " ! * $+ % !!! 

  )   "  ! ' *!!  )   " !'

)!& *%"

(  ,   !*%"   )   "

! 

&  $   -. /  "

) !  0     !    1  &  

%& % % # % 

 " 

 

& & #  ! % %

!!  &    & # $ '

 !! ( 2  " ! !! !$ 3", 4

5    

  !  

 1  "#$ 3", 4

    5  & #  

    &

 % "& $!

    

! %   4

= 



 

( / 0

 ('

 

" --;

/ )0

1   "

'

"2



 



( / 0



'(  ) ):

=$ ! (



 )+  )



9"

   !

.

 ):



 

$





'( / )0

(  

'(

 ! / -0

/ 0



  

.

 ):



 $

$

'(

9"

$9

) + )   '

$ &  ""



$



.

> )

 

  &

" 

 ? '

? '2



! # 





< # 

(



 " --;

"

 

'

"! / -0

(

? '

   !

? '

"

/ 0



(









7 $



)*  9" &

  ,   "  

6 , -:

" .

  

 

" / * )   / 0

'

<



'( / 0



"

$

 ( 

9"

""

!



9 "



67"  &  

"& "#&

  

  973 " :66;%-6

9-&    #<$2 3 #7 973 " 6;6;%-

9-&    <#2 3 #7 971 %'

 . !! -=

9-&>!#2 3 #7 7   ?   !   @5 "$ ? :66; A # % 3 93",   7 %>3  @7   ?   !   5"  ;5 "$ ? 6;6; A # %  3 93",    7 %>3  7      "    :5          %   -=

9-&>!#2  #7"  "# &

  %  &  -=6  

"& 

  %'

 . !!

9'



 

7     #   $!

-=2 '

&!! 

 $ &  %& 

 !%" !: # &

 $ % 

 



$ &

 & & & # ?

&%" ! &  # $! 

$!  !% !      %&  5 "$ 

1 " 6;6;0 % 

   %  . !!   #  $!-=2  & 

"  $ : #$3   # 0



?  

   %    %           

%!  :5       

 $    " 

    %#    -=

 9-&  >!#  2   #70  % 

 %? 

!    @5 "$ & #



 $ &:6B #              9-  27        &!  $! %%"  #     @        

 "  

     ?   !      5  & & #$   ! %'



.  !!   '

  &  !!  

     ,# 

&   "  ! 

&# % " !

 # &  # $!  !  

4   

  

  ( (

.;

)> ) @9  :

6!

!

)*    

$  '

  "

&   

 

"

   " &<"    "



$



$

$ 3(  3

  "(("

 

 (

2 $ 

  "$"

$(

-  )

? 

$ 9 ( !" ! $  $ 



 $ $

 ! ! '



 $( 

 " "

 $ $



   ( +  ..)

 "$"

$

.

 ):

 $

.

> )

" 

 

 

? '



7   

  "







   <(

  

"



" 

 A

  (

! $ " "( ! "

$ $ (

$

 A

 "

 

  " 

" -: (

" 

/

+.)

?

)* $ 

 

" 

 A

 & "

 <(

B   "



 &( "



:;

 9"

  )   > '  @ C$$" $ "  





3 "

( & 

6 &(  " ( "



"

"

&( (

  

6 &( "  " "

 9"

 " :;

 9

$

( &  

  "!

7  " &(

 "

:

B( " .+- 

 !

 !   & 

"

:

9 "



&       

% % % &  "!

  <  & 

&  % 

   #      ?     &  %     ? &  &  %     

 -

9 "

&!



 9"



 " :;

 )   > ' 

  "

   (  " .;

(  $ !

)> )

6" )> ) 9"

 9 > '   $ 

"

 9"

9

 ) +

?'



) +  &    "

( 

$     

   !

 9 "    ( 9 "



 10*1-1'00 -103 3<<0 >3<>> 1>3<<0 >-C 10*1- 33/)> 03 >-0<0 1><3- 12>   %&!!    ) 

  ! :5  &  "  & : 9' !;;;B # 7  

  !  & 

#& &",   +"#  -$    $# "?     $  & @ 6; ?       &  5 $  * + &

!   %)!,.    % ! <

>3  C  !    "-!   C  !  -!   C3 - 6; * :

6;

 >  - 6; * :

6;

  1 &#    %&!!      

  !   % <

>3  C  ! 4 8 !



'

"  " 9"



 " .;





" 

'

"  ! ?"    " $ 



+  

8

'



!

"

8  ""( "    $ & $

(

  "





"

 !

  " 

  &

 

3 

 &  &   !

A& '

(

  "

 "  " "

$   &  $  $   & 

,

"

&!

'

& 

A& '

  

'

"  (&  $ 

.;

@!   

)* 







# 

 !   $ 



$

 

.

 ):



# 

"

--;

$

( $    "$"

$(

( &  ) + 

;



+;

9"



  

 " ) :

 $



$

3( 9"



7 "   &

! :



 "$"



"(



 ('

  $$

 (  $ 3(



# 

<$

"

! ('

"

(

@!  '

 " $

! ) > @9  -

  

"(



$  



" ! ( !

.;

""

(

9"

" "  

8 !

&

$

7 $

""

 $

" 

( $  &  &3

7 <$"



$  

8 ! " ( 

&!  "  $" "" $ "

!

 

 ("



"

$

'

  

""

( " / 0

/0 / + 

    ?



D   0  E , D /  E ,