← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4753/2017dismissed

Jat Senior Secondary School And Another v. Cap. Hawa Singh

2019-12-06Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan12 pages



     



 

!  "

 "# $%& '"

$"

((%% )"* +( ',  -$

(       

    !

 ""##  $

%&   !

 "  ''''

     ."%#    " $ +% ',  -$ $ % / "# 0* 

-   !  "

 "# $%& ! +%%- &

"

*1% 2$3

%,# +" -& '"

$"*-$  2" (%& 3 * "

- $( "*

 (

% 4(% /*"

5 #" *  ! +%%- &

"

*1% 2$3& '"

*%%# %

4"

%%, - "* $(  $ 6(  1 "7" "/ "

0* /

" & 1 "7 -" ("/ 0*  "" "/ " # "*

 (

" 6( $( 1 -7

 ("

7"

& $ $7 9 - # ' *

2"%*/ +"("

 #"

:

 '"& ,$$

  $ "*

* "

/ #% 4  9 "7 1  % ("(""

;$  "

<

' 3 %%#  1 $ " $ $ ((  $ 

)3"/  -$ $ (% "

# $ *$ "

# ,%% 7" ,$  = $ 3

$" $( $7 >

1*%

"

5 #"

" "/ 1* :

#" 1" % ;$ $ 1

(# " $ $( "-*%"%# ;$ ,  - $( 7 "/ & ,$$  *%

 %-%%#& *$&  -

 * "/ * (% +//& '"

$" ?+& '"? %"

$" /%$ $( ;$ $%% -



+7% +*"& '"& ,$" # ""

-" 

7*"

*" "%& 7 /(%  6 7 ;$ *%

% # 7 "%< $ %3%# 1 "& $ " "5* /"

;$ 1 (*% <

7 %-

-" ("(% @%/%#& ""7  1,

(" * "

,$$ -" -

, $( "*

(% % $( $7 <

% $

 5 #" ;$ "* ," A6+

 7% *& / (" ," "" ( ;$ $ /(% ,$ "/    7 $(& $  7"

(

;$

 /%$ $(

" %"

$" $(& @ 

.   ;$ - "*

, 1*% 1

"

$(

5*

;$ 1

, $*

,%# "* 1*%  * "

',7"& 

- "* $( /("/& ( "( "5* /  "7 %-%

 

*(

C% --"7& 1"*-$

+*"

()%"$  !

* ""

  !#

+  ,  %$

%"

#,

-).  "# !!   # $  !#$/  $!



"# !!) %$/$+ ,   )#  (,  $  !

    

,%+  $#-

$ 0   ,"!#$  !$  "1$ +     $      "# !!  )-    %,  !  &   2 $  # 3$4+

"# !!+ "

-%  %$#

#-5 "+  # "

     #"

+ ##

 !    ,%     ## "   -  ,  6  4

! " %" $  "# !!+     %  !  !

  5  ,   

 )  ,"

, 

 ,! !

+ % 



+  !



   " ##)%"# !!   + +   $  #  1$/ )$# %+  7  8   !  3   +   !  +   # 

-   $   )-    %,!& 2 $  #3$5) +  $%

 ! !# !"* 9: ;)$)$# %+  # "



  ) 

  "

,/   $ 

#-)

 $)-  %,) $ !

 #     $ - 

  $    #  5 + %

!

"

- !

, #!$ 5$+   % ##-!# %   !

 * )$ $)1$#-   ""# $  (

 $#

6  %) !# + +  ##+

+ ! +%%- &

"

*1% ($3& '"

$"*-$  2" & /(% >  > % ,"

/ &  *& " 7"* %-% 10 &  %  ,"

,2<6 "

$$ $# )!

 )-+ -!!#%"

$5 + %

!

+ "

-"

$$ +  ,"

,2<6



)  )+"

5 !

 $  !

 )$ )-$  ,"

,=$  ,   ,"

,2<6  "

*

" ! ##-   +" ##)  $ 

 , ##)%"# !!  ,#,+ !< !

 "$ "(,  $  !

    $

 )!# )- $#- $ 0   ,"" 3!

" 1$+  # "

     6 4

! " % "

$  "# !!!+      ! !

5 !

 #"

- !

, #! $ C"/ (% - ("& %%, * ," "/

 D$$"

% "% / "#

 0* 

("# "E 22  D$$"

>

*$"< "

A6+

("7* % +(

',  -$ ) + '"

$" 

 

:

+*" " >" "

F*"& 8 +7% !*-

!"

7 '"E 22  D$$"

(" 

1 % 6*

" 

 

:

 % +( ',  -$ ) + '"

$"

+*" " >" "

F*"&

8 +7% !*-

!"

7 '"E 22  D$$"

/  1%

(" "/E 2

 D$$"

$7

%*   "

* 

% (" *E 2

 D$$"

1

* /0 "

0 "

"# ("E 2

 % 2" ," " 5* (("*  % 7

*((" $"

"(7 %/

*" *" $ 7 & 6/ )3"/  -$ 2D 1  " 7"* */

"1*%& 6/  $ F*/" D

$""& % $"

7

"

$" "-*/ & "% +*" +7% !*-

!"

7 '"

 * >



7*"

-  &

* >

,"  -  1

(" 7 0*-/ " 

>

 

& " " / "# 0* 

(& " - $( "*

 (

% 4(% ("

B *"$"

" $ $%% "* $( ,$

(" #"

"/  0*-/ & $# % ("7 "$%# "* $( ,$

(*% ("& ,*% 1 %1% (# /( 

1 

1 (*% / "/ $ - - # "/  0*-/

;$ % --"7  0*-/ " ( "% +*" $ ("""

((% 1" " !*-& '"& ,$$ - % " !*-& '"& ,$ 7 0*-/ " 



/ ((%& $*-$& / "% -"  "% +*" 6 $  7"

17 "% $  

"* $(

7, /(*- 0*-/ & 

- / "* - 8% +// "

((  "/ "% +*"

$ 7 *%#&  8% +// "& 6(  "*

$"

 % $"- ,*% 1 "7"1% "/

%% % & $7 3  "

$ +*"& ,# % -*%"

 ((%&

 ,$$ -7

"(  4(% & ,$ $ (*

((" $"*-$ * %

 $7 $" %"

* % (" 1 - $"*-$ ""

.$ +*" 1%, $7 % ,$ /"

7"# ("("

(("(" /

"

;$ "% +*" ,$% %%, %/ $ 1"7

(" >  $  /  $ A62 " 1,

+% ',  -$ !  "

 "# $%& ,$$ - 6* )0#  -$& 2" (% !  "

 "# $% $ $7 $" $( 1" > 

*  ! +%%- & '"

"*% /("/& $ % $ $( % ,$    "

1$% &  >

("# $ /("/& $""& /

1  *(

& "% +*" $ 1"7 $ $ / $ ! $% ! +%%- " * $7 / -/

"%"

*& ! $% "("   2" (% A6+

- $/& $""&  

1  $ ,"

 %% "(" 

"%"

*"$"

"/  7

""&  %"

$ > $ ,%- /

"%"

;$"

$

"" $, $ # ("  - 

2" (% $ )0#  -$& ,$ $ " 7

3 "-*/ &   ("*/ $ >

$7 ,%- /("/&  ,$$ 

1 - " $  2" (% !  "

9  "# $%& ,$ $ - ;$"

$

"" $, $ $ )0#  -$   ,$* # *$"# "

$ # 

3

-  $/ / -/  *$& >



" (" / * $ ,%- ;$""& / 1  *(

$/  & $ 1

"

+*"&  (" 0*% % B

 $ "*% "* "

/3 ;$ $ 6/ /  $ F*/" D

,$

$"

" 6/ 

 $ 2" (% $"- $% !  "

 "# $% , "

$(

(*  "-"  

"

1$% $ ("("

"/# % 6*

((%

/(%/ 

A6+

% (" *& $,7"&

"%"

*&

7, / / 1$ (" A6+ $ 1

( > " $ ("("

$ ;$""&

6*

((%

*% $7 1

% ;$ $ $  7"

(

$(&  $ *" $/  "$ "*

$( $/& $""& $ 7"# "-$ 3 %-% 

-  ;$ A6+

1  *(

1$ ("

8"

% " !*-& '"& ,$% ( ((%& $ "/   - "" "% +*" ;$ "%7 (" 0*-/ " "("* "# "" G

 

 

    

    

; 







  

 

 



 

 

   



 



 

      

       



       





 

!"#

 $  %

 &'

!"(   )*

 



    

  

 



  

+ 

      

 +         

    

 

      



 ,

  -.

  



 /0-

 

       

 

 

   

  



  

 

1



     23, 4



       

 

,  

 



 

  

  

  56  







 

          

        

 6



 

   



   

 %6$"770  

"7

    

  8 

    

       





 

 6  

    



  



 

                 

   



 

!"



  





  

   

             

    

 

 9

 



       

      

          



  

     : $ !:

   

 



 

#       

  2;

   

    

  

       

       

< #

+    

    

   

 9(+    

  #

 (   

 

        

 

(   

   





 

 /0-1/+

    4  ,

 76



 

  '



 

    

 



  







/0:





!

  



       

      

 

   



 

  



 6     

  

  



 

  6

  =*# 

> 0 



  



 

 



6

 





0 

    







  

0  





  

6

 







 

  

 

0 

  



 

  

 

  





   + 

   



     

  

  

  



   /+

  0  6   

 6  



    

  





 

  

 

  



 

 



 

  



 

   





  



      



 

  

6 

 

 

 

 

 



  

  

 "%  

  

 





 /+

 

 



   



   

 

         :  /

    



   

       

      

 

 

 , 

 

      ?

8"

* % ((%% $ """ 0*-/ 

  !"#$%& '  !($ '  ! ) #*++,-./  0+1&  -% !*- $ +*"& ,$"  1"7 $ ,$

%"

% -7  "

6*1% " (

("7* *& 

3 "/  " % *15* ;$ *$"#

$%(*% ((%% * "  "*/  6

,$$ *$ 1"7  $ 1

/ @ "

"*/ &  $ ((%% " 1* A6+  "(  4(% $ *"" "

(

$" $(& ,$$

$ (

 &

%-$ *$ $( $7 1

/%$ ;$ ((%% " * "

1%-

" "* $( -7  "(  4(%

 ((%% "*  & *% -  "* - 8% +// "

((  "7"

 "/ ;$ $ 1

 " B ((%% +*" ;$ 0*-/ ( +*" 1%, " ,%% " & 1 *(

("("

(("% 7 "" "("

%, ;$ / 

*"

"/ # %%-%# "

"/# > *1 % 5*

%, " ;$ ((% * 1 ,$* /" / " -%#

>

;



  

  ? " %@    A * ? "

)# A *