High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6578/2023allowed

Mita India Private Limited v. M/S Yaskawa India Pvt. Ltd.

2026-03-18Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl22 pages

! " # $%

& '

" # $%

& ( )* +,

+ - ./0 - *%1 -2 31$!/- */ 4! 1516/- * $ 120%12/- * ) 1&

14 17/- * 301!/- * 1 !51 / 87/- * ) 1& '

) 1 &

! 19!&/- * ) 1 & '

:(;<

, 1775 1 & & , 8)=*$5 ! )1*

-5!

=17) ) 1 & &7)) '

-5!

=17) )1 & ) > -72 ?5 > , > , 1775'

,> , , -5!

=17) ) 1 & )'

, -5!

=17) )1 & &7))'

, , , > -72 ?5 '

, ! , 31& % !7 & )% *7 & 5)

% & & 1 ! 1) *7 / / %1*11 =)7=21&7)) /1*1775 1 '

& =2 1- 7( *.!5*!

5.!5/;@*7!

*7 !9!!5 /%1*11&&7* )7!0* )1 -= *7 -*/,>>%10* >,, =2 1 & ) 1 = 77 % 1 & 1 = ) -= 1 &7 1 = 6* 31 * *7

" /'

1 =)7=21)" # $% %1*1 *1775 1 , %1*1 1 - 7 ( * .!5*!

5 .!5/ ;@*7!

*7 !9!!5 1 1&&7* )7=21 & A)) &7*5 * 1%

=2 1) 1 1 =)7=2 1& ), 2 )

1 ) */%1*1 1 !& ) )75% *

*7 ! #

1 )7 ! ) * 2 ) ,//,,/>" %1 & 7 )!! ,B & 1 ! ) - 7 ( * .!5*!

5 ))*/ ;@*7!

*7 !/9!!5

1 !/" # $% % 1) 1&7/)*% C!

,> > ,%1*1% 1= =21) 1 &7))) 1&!& )&!*1 )#-04-D- = 7-,'' %1 # , 77 7 5772 * 77 D75 % !* 7 %7 % )!11* )1&7))1 1&7))1 !&!*1

, , , ,7 5 %1 * !& 1)) !&&72 ) = 7 1 1 )/ ) 15 * 1 &2 / 1 77 *

1 = ,>

,>/ 1 1 & !* 1 1! )1&7))-!5! ,> 1

$ !/1 != C!&5&1 /17 )1 &! %77 1 5 ! ) *7 51

!% %1*1 7) 1&!& )6!* )1& % &

&!11)% ,,

1 1 =% 572 , 1 &!5

, 1 =6 72 =) 1 !1 ,, 17 ) /&5/ ) '

)7=21) %77 1%5! &7* * &5,

-@!-", /1 ) * 1 ) 1 = 5172 ,, 1 ! & ), 2 ) )751% 1! /* !71)7 1% =)

*1* % =) 1

*7 ! 72/ 1 % &&7* !0* )1-= *7 -*/,>> %10* >,,% && , % )7

> ,

(!51&*2 )1 &&7* !0*

) 1 -= *7 -*/ ,>>/ 1 7 ) )75 1 % 7& 1 % % )7 1 !51 1 % 2 ) & *5 '

/ 1 &&7* )7=21)!0* )1-= *7 -*/,>>% 77 %1& %* = ) 1 = 5 1&7% 6* 31 % *1775=21&7))=2)75

% '

, ,, / 1 8*1 ) 1 ! %17 !5 * )

% 7 &7 21 & )1 '

31 , ,, & =2 1 8*1 & !*1=7 %+

## # ! $% &'

$&$( ) * "+, ! -* .

. /# ' .

011+ ! " # ! !

2 "

01 &1 $&0' ) * "$,

5. 6 # 5 # ! " ) , "

)7!, !

# . 011+

! "#$! #!"%"& !$"%"#% "'(#)*!"# "# "

+,+-.-+/&&"0(#"'123"

&"#13& * !4"

#3(#)*!" 5%" ! # )" & !3") ) "&!*#&"

*"#"& *" "#6! & )& &!!(& "# 0 8 * !

( "#*"#"5 57") ! &

& # "#"& "#6! 3#3!"

5 !(33"# & & 8( & )4&$"

9" # *"# )(6"& & !()*3#3!"

"#6 !* 5" % & *" "#6! *"#"& !* )&!

( " *" )63"

"& "0)(!%"!

"6"& *" "#6!& )& &!

*"'(#)*!"# "#1)& #) 5"

$""& *"3# "!

& . *! '(#)*!" # "#1& #) $*"

*"# # & !!("

$ * #" "#"&)" 8( &#3#3! !(33"#!*)&!

( " & "#))"3 &)"5 !(33"#!"03#"!! 6 "

*" "#6! & )& &! *"#" & 6 5" "% "&)"

5 #"

(#&&9 *" )4&$"

96"& #6 *"#" # )66"&)"6"& 3"# #6&)" )*&9" # 6 ) & & *! '(#)*!" # "#1& #) !*5"% (&"!!)& #6"

&$# &95 *"

( "#: 7! 9 0 : 0;

0& $&0' ! * :" 0' : ) * "(,

# ! 4 # !

7! . /< ! . = # : 0;

0& $&0' >/> ? 9

"5"

6"0'@01"&(A"5-B 0 &1 $&0' ) * "$, * C # : 5( 5 %# (" )(!"+/ '(#)*!"# "#;#(6 !"

" *" !3( "5"

$""& ( "#& *"(33"#$!#"!

#) "

# " (# <*=5 & *"#" $! & !

3( & #" "# *" 6

"# #5 # & =

" . /# # >

! # ! -* .

. /#

= . # !

0$ &0 $&$%

# $% &'

$&$( ) * "+, !

0+ $&$(D 31 2 1 = * !5 1 =

' 72 != =) 1 ! 1 1 &7)) % 1 = @ * @ =21)1* %)@ ) 5!

1 / &&7* ) &7*5 * 1 % % )7=21) 31

*7 !

, 1 1 &&7* 1 5 ! 1 1 % = )7 *

*7 &!%1 & ) 2 ) *1)1 !1 1& % 77 % 1) )7% != C!) 1 =* %5 &2 )* %1*11 ! ) =!1 & * =71, 2 )

1 ) * ) !

31 1 !=6* )*1775=21) '

(

)

)&%'*)+" * ! 7 ) 1 & &7)) 1 != 11

*7 !1 $ * 1 )1 != C!&!*1 , , ,%1777 %51 &&7* !0* )1-= *7 -*/,>> != 1&! 7 )1 &!*1 % !7*772 1 % 11 /%1*11=@& 72 1 &!*1 / % !7 &7 2 1 C!

!= 1 & *7! , ) 1 &!*1 / &*)*772 1 * ) 5 &! )2$/1 1 5772

1 =! 7 1& =% 1 =!2 1 !&&7 / 1 &7))1)/1 !91E= 72%77=1 *

& ! 7 !*1 &! != 1 % ) *7! , )1&!*1 /1= *7! 17& & 7 % !& "&7*=21 *7! , 1 *7! , %1*1% !75 151 )1& != 15 ) 1% *!

/1& & 75=21) 1 &!*1 =2 1 &7)) % !7 *772 1 % 1 1 = *7! % 1 1 % !& =2 *7! , )1&!*1 != 1 1 &* ) %2/1*7! / 1& & 7/% !& =21 != C!*7! 1&!*1 1! 5!1* 1& & 7 =$ * /1/7 1*7! %1*1 1= &*)*772 !& * 2 1*7! 1&!*1 % !7 5 151 )1& 1 *7! 1 &!*1 %1*1 % !7 5 1 7 1& =%1& )!15!1&! 7 )1& & 7% !

7 %11 )) =21)% 7 72) 2 1 &7)) 1 &! ) 1 1 &!*1 , , , / =2 1 & )2 /1! / 1&!*1 %1*1! % 1 ))1)*11 ))% **&=21) &!

) )&%'*)+"

, * ! 7 ) 1 & / 1 1 1/ 1

&& 1& & 1 != 11&!*1

/ 1 &*)*772 = 1 1 C!

,> > , = 57 & ) 1 &!*1 , , , 1! / 1 ) 1 C!

= 1 &!*1 != 1*7! ,/, )1&!*1 ! *7! 12 % !7 1 1 ))* ) !& 5 &7*5 1 *7! %1 &* 1 = %1*1 1 = &*)*772 & 1 & & 7 )!1 != 1 ! 7! > )1& & 7/1 *7! ) 6! * %1*11 = 1 &! % !7= !=6* 9!5 /F26! * *1& !1=)79!!5 /1 *772 1 % 1/ &1! 5 )1&7))/ 1 )1 & & 7%1*1% !75 151 )1& != 1 1 **!

* / 1 &!5 '

** *%17% =!&171&7)7=21 &7)) =6* )&%'*)+" > 31 ! 1 1 7 * ! 7 ) 1 & 1 &! 1&&=

$ )1 & 11 &!5 '

5 7% = 1 & & =77 %) 1 1) , 11& &7))1 & )1

+ 7 !& 1 & & 7 ,> > , %77 1 &!*1 , , ,%1*11=&7* * -@!

7 5%1

317& )1& & 7%1*1 1=151751& !*1=7 %+ > ?@;;;

-A *** *** *** +, B @ @ ? $ 3#% " $##&

# *" !

"61 "6! !(33"

$ 5" #"" #6 6&( ) (#&9 " ") ! # 3"# +. 6& *! #6 *" " &%)"

! # #

*** *** *** 1, 85EFE.E:9 /# =!

*** *** *** 00, 57E5 E:9 & !3( " # "#"&)" #!&9 (& "# # & )&&") &$ * *!9#""6"& #& 5#")* *"#" $*)*)&& 5" !"

5 #"& &"9 && 9#""6"& 6&9 *"3# "!!*5" & !"

5 #5 # & ! 3E9F ! ! ! #

. 011+ # E ? !

# ! ! GD 7! '*7! 1=7!& =17) )1 &7))*7! >*7! ,,1=7!& =17) )1 ) ,, 31 &!*1 , , ,/ %1*1 1 7 = 7!& =2= 11& $ !1* /1 =@

-@!

31 7 *7! ) 1 &!*1 & !*1=7 %+ 9:- 3:85 H8: E:9 9:

"5"

6"0'@01"&(A"5-B 0 F -F 01"&1"$&0' I :85 99-J85- > > 5- E9-/5 2 5 :K =E 85.= - :5F-5 9: 0'(&$ F -F 0;

0& $&0'

*** *** *** -5 I .:9FEE:9 :K :85 85.= - :5F-5 &"!! *"3(#)*!"# "#"03#"!! 3#% "! *"#$!" !6 "

*"!" "#6! & )& &!

"# *"#"5 57") ! &

& #

"#"& "#6! 3#3!"

5 !(33"# & & 8( & )4&$"

9" #

*"# )(6"& & !()* 3#3!"

"#6 !* 5" % & *" "#6! *"#"&!*)&!

( " *")63"

"& "0)(!%"!

"6"& *" "#6! & )& &! *"'(#)*!"# "#1)& #) 5"

$""& *"3# "! .*!'(#)*!"# "#1& #) $*"

*"##& !!("

$ *#" "#"&)" 8( &#3#3! !(33"#!*)&!

( "& "#))"3 &)" !(33"#!"03#"!! 6 "

*" "#6!& )& &!*"#" & 6 5" "% "&)"

5 #"

(#&&9 *" )4&$"

96"& #6 *"#" # 5 )66"&)"6"& 3"# #6&)" )*#9" # 6 ) & & *! '(#)*!"# "#1& #) !*5"% (&"!!)& #6"

&$# &95

*" ( "# *** *** *** 0', &)!" !9#""6"& # !3( " & 4& " *"#& *"# "## 6#"9"&"# & *"5(!&"!!#" &!*35"

$""& *" ( "#& *" (33"# *" # ")(# &<*=5 & $5")63"

"& )(# !"

"!()* !3( " ! * ! $##& ! ! # (@F # ! * ! ! 7! # 4 # # ) F#, # !

7! ? ! # & " ")

#5( "

" ") ! & 6 "# &( ) (#&9 & B#46&!*3 33"#&9 $ *&.>6& *! #6 *" " #")"3 (33"#!*#"65(#!"# #"3)" *"3# ! #"" )!

##"65(#!" *")!

#"3#! ) (

*** *** *** -::;<G;H-I3 GF-0; (;:

, (-3;(,", " , *** *** *** 0$

93@ 0$

# , 31 %1 &* C!

/ %1*1 = 57& )1&!*1 /1 =7!& =21)/ %1 *7! ,//,,>1=7!& =21&7)) ,

C! %1*1 ) * 1& * %111= *7! 1& & 7 !& " &7*=2*7! , )1&!*1 7! , )1&!*1

&*)*772& 11=!2 &7)) &*)*772 =6* 2 7 )) & & =2 !&&72C!

1 *!

12 !*1& & 177= 1 * 1&!*1 177* !1*

&7@*7! ) 1 * ) 1 &!*1 " * * =% 1 & % )!1 *7! 1 1 &!*1

" * * %11 ! %1 )* C!

& & 7 ) !&&7/ 177 * ! )) 1 **&* =2 !&&7 / ) 7 1 * 1 ) * !7=*=2!51*$ %75 )

% 5 1 *15

)* 1 &!*1 "* * 177=7!7 * ) %5=21=!2"&7)) ,'

% !7 = 7 1 1 72 ) 1 ))

& 1 & & 7 ,> > , % 2 1 &

" &!*1 % =2 1 &7)) ) 1 & ) 2 1 7& / , , , &! =) 1 ! 1 != C! 1 &!*1 , , ,/1)1 *!& 1 1 !&&71 = 1! /1&!*1 % !72 **& -71 !51 =2 ! ) 1 / 1 ) 1 C!

"& & 7=* 1& )1&!*1 =!5 )1 % *!

51 % !7 *772 1 % 1 * 2 1 != C! &!*1 @& 72 & ) 1 * * )) )

1 & 1 & & 7 " C!

/1/ 1 1&!*1 %1*1 1 !75 1 51 ) 1 & 1 1 & & 7 G *7! ,/ &*)*772& 1* ) 5 &!

)2$/1 1 &7* 5772 1=! 7 1&=%1=!21 !&&7/% !7=1 !

72%1*1% !7116! * 31 *7! * * @ %1 1= *7! / 1= *7! 7 & 12 &!

))* 5 ! * * %1 1 5 2 =*11 ) = 7=2= 31! / 1*7! , )1 &!*1 %1*1% !7&7 *7! ,, )1& & 7 , * ! 7) 1)1 151751*7! > ) 1& & 7%1*1 & !*1= 1 %171* % !=6* 9!5 /F26! * 1 5!1 1 *7! %1*11 = !& =2*7! , )1&!*1

$ 31 ! & %11 5!

16 5

)*7! > )1& & 7*7! , )1&!*1 % !7 1 % 1*7! , )1&!*1 1 =&!& 72) *

& 77 &! 1! / * *7! , &&7 / 1 *7! 55= % !7 5 151 )1& * = 1*7! ,/, )1&!*1 7257*7! / 1 1 &*)* *7! &*)*772 5 5 1 51 ) 1 & , - 772/*

& =%1%2*7! 1 & & 71&!*1 % !7 1 %11%2& % ,

1 )

1 ) *1& & 7/%1 !*7! ,> 1 &!*1 / * ) 2 )* =!7 1 )*

7/ !)*!5% $ 1&&&5%1'

1 )

1 )*&/1)% C! &7* =! 1 & ) )* 31! /1% ))*1 *7! * ! 7) 1)1 151751*7! , )-@!H-I )1 &!*1 1 %11%2 ) ,

1 72=! 1 *7! /% !7=&&11 & ),

1 )

1 ) *

5 )

1 ) *

*7! )1& & 7 31! / &&1* *7! 1%

)* "*151&!*1 1

)* " *15 %1*1 1 !7 5 151 )1& 31

*7 ! )77 5 =2 & &72 * !5 1

% = *7! 1! / *! 5 6! * 1 & =2 6*51&7)7=21

31 8*1 )1 !%17 25 1 & ) 1 &!5 ))* & 1 & *5 1 ! * ! 1 & *5 1 ! 1 * !1* %)@) 5!

, 8) &5%11& %1 &* / % !7 = 7 1 71 !51 ! 0* ) 1

*7 ! -*/ ,/1 =)

)75 & *17757 *! 2 =!1 8*1 )1 ! 1* )!

(4*"6)!& '#% " 6 "

%!#&! &9&""#! & '%

& .-.C ',AD+%1775%11 &* ) =721 = 11=!0* )1

*7 ! -* ) *7 &&7* & % !7 = &&7*=7 * 1 *7 )7 ! -*7 )1 ! )5 27 *! 2 )

*7 !1!-*7 )1 ! )/ 1F51 !1 1& % *7 & 5 2 7 *! 2 & =2 1

*7 ! 1! / !*1 & % =77 =7 % )!117 11& %!-*7 )1 ! ) 2% * 2& %/71 !51 =@* &572 72 && &* 31 6!5 )1 8*1 )1 ! 1 =!&17=21F J=70!& ! ,

& & 0&*7 -&&7 7 :

> > " 1 & * / 1 ! 1 @* & % ! -*7 ) 1 ! ) % ) 1 )* 1 1 &!5 = 7!7277575 7%* 1 /1/ 1 % !7*! &=77 1& - & * ) 1

*7 ! -* ,/ 1 7 *! 2 / 5 %1*1 =7/*=*1775&&7* 1*

*7 ! 5 1& /%1 55=21

1& * /1 2 7=7 1& * 1 &!5 77 % 1 % !7 = ) 1-= 1% !7= ** ) )7* = & =2 1

*7 ! $& 1 2 ) 1 & *17751 &!5 7 5%11& & &&7 7 31! /1&*!7@*& 7)* **!

* )1 & * /1 !) 11& & !-*7 )1 ! ) = &!5

= , -** 572/ 1 & & 77 % &!5 '

1&&7* )7! 0* )1-= *7 -*/,>> )&$"+)+% ,> 17751& & 1 , %1*11&&7* )7=21)/) &7*5

' * 1% /1 = (

) )&$"+)+% * ! 7 ) 1 ) 1 & * 1 != 11%@*& 7)* **!

* 1& * ** ! )%1*11% 1 !7=& = )7 ) 1 & ) , 2 != 1 71 !51 1 ) % ,, =! 1 ) && &&7* ! 0* ) 1 -= *7 -* ,

72 1) )&&* / > , 1 )7 1 != 1 * 1 &&7* % &5/1) )71% %1& ) , 2 1)% 2 5!11 &&7* % !7 =77 %)*1 &&7* % 77 % '

!= 11)/ *1 '

% 2=2 1 8*1 )1 !/1! /%1 !% 5)!1 /1 ) 1

&&7* ) $5 * 1 % %1*11 =775772 77 %=2! )1 &!5

, != 11)* **!

* ) 1& * @*& 71 **!

* /1) !7=& &7* * 1% (

)

)&$"+)+% , * ! 7) 1&7))1 != 1

* &!11% 1 =)7%1& ), 2 )

1 ) * / ,, & )1)*11 % 2 )& *5 % )17%7 %=21F J=7 0!& ! )1* )1!<& #) !& '%

%! *6&4# & #!

#() (#" '%

& *"#! & .-+D+..-+-/1)* =5151 )7% 1! /1 &!5 1 =5172& *77 ) )* )&$"+)+% 31F K=70!& !1* )1!<& #) ! & '%

!(3# 1 = 1 &! 7 ) 1 & )

*7 ! -*/ ,% !7 1 %1=2 , 2 )

1 ) * ) !

/1) 177) )151 )71 % 11 ) 1 ! 77 %1 % = $ * =2 1 & % )!1 = 1 72 =*! &&7* ) 6* ) 1 &7! !7,,1 =)7/1 * = H! ) 517 && !2 )71% I % ) 1 & & ) 7%/ 1 F K=7 0!& ! 1 1 &!5 1/%1*11& 1)1 )71% =2 1 &!7& ), 2 31 7& )1 6!5 & !* !+ ', .

. .

F .

F =# . $&0;

, $( 0& $&0; 5#&9&9& *"#$4")"# &6"& 6"& ! *" " %'#)"

(#"&# "#("+!(5E#("+ # *"!")& 3#%!

*" $&93#%!$!!(5!

( "

! ! ! ! ! .

# ! 5( $*)*!*& 5" "# *&&"*(& #"

$"&

! #6 *" " !"#%)" !(66&!& &"03# &"*(& #"

& $"&

! #6 *" " !"#%)" !(66&! *" " "& & !* # " *"#9* " *"$#

"&!

"6"& & *")(# !*& $ *"$#

"&!

"6"& 5" 4"&&#")# : -? ! # "#/("+ &"$3#%! ! ! ! ! ! # !

5( $*)*!*& 5" "# *&&"*(& #"

& $"&

! #6

*" " !"#%)" !(66&!& &"03# &"*(& #"

& $"&

! #6 *" " !"#%)" !(66&! *" " "& & !* # " *" #9* " *" $#

"& !

"6"& & *" )(# !* & $ *" $#

"&!

"6"& 5" 4"&&#")# : #"E"63*!="

5 #"E&!"# &9! # "#/ ("+-' @ !

. @ 6 ! !

? 5 0 5 1 3#"!"& *"!6"$ *& *" 6"3"#6

# 0"

5 *" (# ! *" )!" 6 5" *" (# !* 3#&(&)" 7( 96"& 9&!

*6 4 4 #

'#% "

(# *"# * &(# !*64"&# "# "0 "& *" 6" 3#% "

(& "#("+ *!# "# # &9 *"$#

"&!

"6"& :

! (& ! = # 1& ! # . ! !

+ # !

B* ! 9#" 63# &)"!

*" ) * 5"

& +.- ! #6 *" " !"#%)" !(66&! *"

" "& & !* # " *" #9* " *" $#

"& !

"6"& & *" (# !*& $ *"$#

"&!

"6"& 5" 4"&&#")# *!! (# *"#5(

#"!!"

5 *"3#%!&# "#("+-!

&9 *

*"(# *!& (# *"#3$"# "0 "& *" 6"5"

& *!3"# +.- ! *** *** ***

6 4 ! F =# . # ! )##") & %"$ *" ) * *" )&!"8("&)" # " &9 #9* " *" $#

"& !

"6"& F && "0 "&!& & (# *"# 6"F & *" ) * *" (# !* & $ *" $#

"& !

"6"& 5" 4"&&#")# 3& ! *" ) * *""#"#$ &# "#("+& *" &9 $#

"&!

"6"& (& "## "# ("+*!&$5""&!"

&(9* 0$, = # # ! # *&((6#&!(3#& *4* 675 (* (6!5!(3# $$ $A # % I 01 #

0(, 6 # @ ! !

0%, 2 # 7! ( (& & *"#), # "#("++5" #" &9*!$#

"&!

"6"& B"#" *"%"$

* *! 7( 96"& )&& 5" #" & *" 6&&"# !(9* # 5 *" "#&"

)(&!"33"#&9&5"* *"#"!3& "& !# "#(" ++3#)""

&9!#"& "3"& "& *" &9 $#

"&!

"6"& &)" !( *!5""& "

& ) 3#C * 7( 96"& #")# !G$"%"# $"6 *!

* *"5"#

"&33) & ##"7") & (& "## "#A("++')&& 5"6 "!#(!" ##"

#"%&9 *" !

33# (&

" *"$#

"&!

"6"& : *** *** ***

0A, . ! &;

0$ $&0A . .

1 * / % = 1 7=2 )7 &&7* ) 6* ) &7 ! !7 ,, * =

) 55

)7%

1& * / &!1 ,, 1 )% % C! )7% %1 2 1 !11& % @1& ) 1> 2 1! /1 7& ) )751% % , 2 / !&

- 72/1% % )7%11 & & 77%1 * %117 ! @1 & )!11! /17 !15172& 1 &!5 31 )* 1 1 ) 1 )7 &&7* !0* )1-= *7 -*%1*1 % * '

% !7 *

1 *! )1) 11% 2 2 )& *577

/17 77 %1*11% % =)7 2& )7%1 =151751=) 1 ! 1 %11% 2=5 )75% =21)!51&*2 )&&7* ! 0* ) 1 -= *7 -* )* 1 & 5) )75 )1% %1 &* *

*7 &! !

*7 ! / & ) 2 @*& 31& & )7% & & !=21F J=70!&

! 1 * ) 1! < & #) ! & '%

!(3# % !7 &&72 77) ! 1& * 7

- 772 % !7 = 7 1 1 *1 =7=21&7))=2! )1)*117

77 %5 1 &&7* ! 0* ) 1 -= *7 -*% 2=21 8*1 )1 !1 * %)@=) 17 !) )75!

1! /77 %51& & % !7*! 5&6!* 1&7))1 % !71 =

4&5 % 1 = )* **!

* / 1 &!5 , !&171& & =5 7 = ** 572 5&&7* /)2/ & )% )1 = -!# . (/ *0+& F L D11 &$5" # ":

D11& =7 # ":