Rajesh Kumar & ANR v. Jagdish Chander & ORS
! "#$ ! % & ' ( ) * +),- () !+ *) () !" % #
#
.
/
* 0 # ) /1
2*0
* # 0# 3 2 )
*
4
( #
0 3
( (
# * 5
* ) 5
3 ( 6 3 # )03
(*)
0
3 * (
# # ( 0#03 * # )
2 # 03
# # #
# #
# 1 /1 / /(6
1
.- *03"#$ 0$
$# (0# 7 # 1
-
#* ( 77 .7 7.8 9( 7 81 9(
7 81 9( :8 1 9( 8 1 9( 81 9( .7 81 9( 8 1 9( 7 8:1 9(
7 8 1/9 + (; < ) # 3
# ("#$ 0$
$# ( /
; /
# ) 5 # )
(** *03
) :1
/ ;*) (
0
3* 0 # + ( #
# * $
!* # $# *
# 1
-
* ( 77 .7 7.8 9( 7 81 9( 7 81 9( :8 1 9( 8 1 9(
81 9( .7 81 9( 8 1 9( 7 8:1 9( 7 8 1/9 + (; ; 6 * )
') 0# 3 ( *
/ ;*) (0 0= ) 03 ') 5 = ; 0)1 * 0=
# 03 ') ) * (# = $# ;*) 3 3
5 ( 3
3 # 3( # * * # 0 *
( #
( * 1 /1 / /( # * 03 # ) 0)1$# (
( # 1 /1 / /*
#
# 1
- 2 = # * (.
(
71 > 3 ) (
71 3 # ( .(
71< *# # * 0 = #
( ** = 0.
.1 // + = ( * 6 < 2=$ $
< 2=
# #
5 # # (
)# 03
3 ,
)) 0 = #
*
3
< *
)
,*
1
// 6 *#)
#
* 0
( ) * , ) 6 < *
)
# ( .(
71 * 03
.1 // 3 3
# .1 //
3
') (
*
,* ') = 6 # 1
- ) # #
) $# ( 3(
*)( ( $ ( ( ( ( "# $ 0 $ .
/ /; 0*5.
/ /5 03 0)1# # ) $# 2
) *30 )* 3* # # = * = = + 30
#
= 2
) # ** )03 3 0 =
0
# # #
- 3 // 2
( # #
) $# = )
# # .7 #.:1?
- 503*3
1 :1 // ;*) ( ) 3 ) # ( 3 # = # )
# # # 7 (
1 ?-# # * 5 # # *
# # 7 6 5 )
0
/1 //< *
#
* 0 0
# # 7 )
$
* 0 0
( # ( * 6< *
* # = 0
/1 // 3 *
03 #
* ) *
/1 //
0#
(; = #
# # 7 2
(
01
#
/1 //+
@)
* , )
# = + # = )
.1 /1 //; *03
$
;)#0 *
,# 0 # # 0#0
03 ( 1
3#
) 1 2
*
#
0#0 1 1
> (= # *
5 # 0 % ; ' $ );+ # 3A 5 ) $) $
;
// ,# 0 3 0 * 03*3 ) +3 3#
$
# ) .1 // (
B
# .(* 0 # *
3 > # ,*
% 0
### )*
# ) 2 * 03 $
"# ; ) # 7
// .1 // *
*
$
+
* )> // 0 $
(* * 3
C$) )D03 $
2$
$) ) 03
( # #
'%( *
3 * # *
(
* 03 $
3*) 03
+
03
*
03 * /1 /1
//.
)
*
$
5
:1 /1 // 5* 3 1
// 3 3 = # 6 3 ) 3
2 = # 3 0 = )
) 0 # # * *
0 < * # 3 0)1 3 #
0 *
* # * 0* =
7 6 < *
. * *
3* * # )
* 3 3 *
2,# #
(
$
*#&1
E
)* # / / # # 7
# # ,
F>%% E
)0 3* #
F>%% . E * F>% E
) F>% E 0
$%$F>% :E 0
/ . $%$F>% E
03 * F>% E 0 03
*
. F >% / 2
) * ) # #)<
#' %*
3*= 03 #
) $# .1
/ / * 03 ) #
.1
// @=%..4
0 # * #
.1
// (@=% /5* = *
)0= 03 #0)1
*
* 0 < $ $
03#
* # = 5* 3
# ) 03
#
# (
$
03
;*) ()* #
$
# ## 0 ) )0 = 03 2 # #
* 3 )03
;* #@=
; # 6 * 0 )# ;*)
$
5 3
1
// # 03
5 3
# 6 5 0 = ;
0 3* # # = 5 3* )
3F;*)
3, # = //<
*
* 3* # # = 2
* = * # < 2=$ $
3 # ( (
03 # ) @) ( * 03
#
#3< 2= $ 2 )0 @) < 2= $ $
*0 03 #'% :1 1 //( * 03
1
//5
0 2*
*
&
3* # # = 4
$
03
0 10
E #*
2 $
(@=0 %.( 03
:1 /1 // 3 1
// (**
3 )03
// () @=0 :< 3 3 # =
)
;(3(
// 5*
) 3
3# # 2 0
.3 (* ( * 03
1
//(
= 3 ;
* 10
2
#
) * #
.1 // 5
0= = 3
= 0 03
(*) (* # =
(0 03 ;#$
%0; 3 E #* 2 $
)## ## )
#' %*
3
( # 03 0 ) # # 5 * ) # # ( (
) #' %*
3 * # *
# 3( * #
< *
*
# < *
) 03 3 3 ) )
## )# # 03
$
0 $
"# ; ;*) * $
03
E # 03
(
* $
# 03
$
(
# # 0# 10
# #
0# 3* # # = E #* @=0 %1 /( 3(= # = 3
) < 2=$ $
( * $
6 * ) # 0
# # # # 3 #
1
// ** 3 )03
// # # .
1 < 2=
7 @=0 %1 /( #= = < 2=$ )03 ( * $
* , # 0 # 2 3 0 2=$ $
;*)
* = ;( = 0 # 03 A %
)
)* * #
4
)# * $
#
* ;D0 $
A* $
) <2$
( 3 5 03
** = )#00 03 < 0 * 06 3( )0
* ## ) # 03 *
$
( # # 03
$
! * )
# )> # 0
#
$
##
# # 0 ))# 0 03
(3 )
# # 03 # 3 0 *
$
0 $
( #
# ;( # #
#
# ## 7
0
0 * )
# 303 #
* 10
; 0
03*3 @=0 %1 /
= = 03 # #
* 0 < 2= $
< 2=
$
# #
#
# = * 0* 3
2 0
3= 3) 3 *+ $
0 *) # ) 3 * 6 0
# = *=
* 3 30 # (3 ) * 2 # &
'( " )*+,+-+./-)00+*1234)4/3- +5-,6+572
&$&'+0( "
37+5 /5/58+5-3+-/58363+9/5 9-1234)40/+4+5- 9- *
= = = 0 )
= 3 # = $
&$$ '+0( %$" )88/0+0 :+,0+6+9 1234)4 159235+9/5+0 32-/9;5;+5-024 123225/58/58 9923-+, ) @=%1 / , 006
)
(
) 3* 0 ( =
* 3 )#
# #)# ) =
(
( $
0 *)* # 3
0
10
< 0
#
5 0
)
# 3 * 4 3(
1
# = )
+
# ) 3 0 < 2=$ $
;( * )0 0
#
7#
3# 2 =
# 1 :1 //2
5
= )
(
# < 0
03
#
7#
0
#
3( 0
.
1 < 2= 0 #
#
3
# #
3 )
0 < 2=$
< 2=
< 0
03
* 10 3 2 '
$( "
3/-/),5-/+20<, 9-1234)4 930+ 9- 1>0 , * 1 ( #
* 63 <2$ $
5 0 03 .
1 < 2= 5 * 0 03 G 6 * 53 # 03 01#
* 0 )* 0 #B0 03 *2
*
, #*
# ** )0 = 2 #
%'
( $ ",9
*/5/:+63+5-9*2341234)4226+=66+0" & ' #(# "
58+5+9*+51234)4 :+63+5-9*234+5- &#
',( $ +-+4*/>3+ +8*)5+9*3+ +5-2=+3 1234)4 5+5-3+ +8*)5+9*3++5-2=+3+5-9*234
2
#
# *
3#
(
03 ) 03 ) 0 0 10
< # # '
& %(##
"?+4+3+ +,?/.*+/+*7+.*+/1234)4+5/+399+,-+4 +0).*+/+5-9*23 2
0
30
30 = # # + * .
1 < 2= ( 6 ) 3 * 00
6 * ( * 0 #
5 .
1 < 2=
* 2
#
$
0 *)* # 3
* 3 * # # = 3 # * * < 0
03 6
6 * # )5 # = 5 # 3# # $ 7
0
@=0 %1 /( #= = 3 2 0= 03 *
2
0 # *
3 0 03 # ) # #
$
$
#** 032; ' $ ) ; + # 3( #
3
# # ) 3 5 # ) # * # 3 0 # .1 // 3(*) ( 3(03#
#
3 = 1 5* ) #
# 5
#*
03 35
#
6 ) ) 2 $
# * # *
2 #*) #03
( #03 # *
3 ) *= )0 0 *
36 2 ( *
3 )
3 # = 3
( ,@=%1 /( # #
30 $
# 03
# 0)1 # 03 $
5* * 0 0 # *
3 > * (
0
5 @=0 %1 / #03 2
(
0
0
# @=0 % :1 /1 // ;*) (@=0 %1 / # 5 #
,@=%1 @=%1 2
@=0 %1 / ) #5 ,
%
1 1 // 0 $
2
03
(*
# 3= ( (
3 3* 3 * 3 (** #
3
= 03.
/1
// @) # @=0 %1
//5 ) 0 03
5 @=0 %1 /
3 () * = 03
)
6 2 0
3 # $
0
) 1@=0 %1 / 03
< 0 03
#
6 >0) 35 5* 30 0 # *
* 3 303
#( *
;( ) 3 3 ,# # 7
0 # 4
5 * # @=%1 /503 (=
< 0
// ) 3 1 1 //
3* 3#3#
A #
3
2 # = = * .
.1 //
# =
// (
# 30 03
0 * )
// 2
) # 0 <2$$
2$
) # )06
3
(
06 *
0 # <2$$
( 3 )
* $
# $
0 *) # 3
* 3* # #
= 0
3* 0 03 $
# *
3* 3 * # # = 2 ,
= # *
0
* 3 * # # = 3# # 0 3 .
1
< 2= )0
10 # <2$$
.
1 < 2= 03) 0
03 ) # 4 #
'('/>/0(&)5?+.322-23 9- +?6)3+1234)43+.*))99+5-9*234
3 60 # < 2=$ ,
#
= 3 03 #
A A
# 03
0 *# # $ ( *# 0 6 * 03
&1
E # 03
0 *6
03
0# 0
) F
E .
1 < 2=
= # #
# (
3 F ;)#
#
(
( # )
* 0 3 # # 03
(0 0 *
) 3
@=% /(*) 3 03
7 )) 3 #
0 *) 3 # # # +3 50 # 5 03
)= = (03 3
03
6 )# ) < 2=$ $
< 2=
2
7
# 5.
.1 // 5 = = # 1 /1 / /(**#03
)(*= = 0)03 # # = 06 3
.1 // (**# 03 '% ( 3 2,# # # 1 /1 / / 0 ) #
( 30 * #
0 *
2 # ) ( .
.1 //
= (* 6 #
# = 5 #
&
3 # #
; =*
# 2
) #
# )06 # @=% /
.1 // (# *3* 3 = 5 3(#)#
#= ( * = #
0
2, 5 #
#
0 0
5 3)#03 :
<
* 0
A, #
0
5 # 6 # 0 # ( ,
( 3
*
3 03
#'%
# #
#*3* = = # # *= 2 # $
*
* 0 6 0
6 = 0 2 0#
,#
* # 3# 5 #0
6 * 3# # *
#2 )#03
<$
* *
* )#03 :
<
*
* 0
< # 3
3
*
*
0
#
3
3
* # 3 0
3# #
03## #
<
( # *
*
@) / )
, 5
0# (3# * ,
<$
> * (03 0
=
* 1
) # 6 ,
3
#
# # * 2
0
A ;#
# 3 0 6* 30*
6 # # # )
( #
#
(
3 = @=% /*
# 03 2
) = * # 03 0
'% ;*) #
0 4 3( '%* # 3 = .1
/ /5* # '%(( )0 *
3230 * 06 3.
/ /2 '% 0 0
#3 3 6
3 3( # # 6 *= 1 /1 / /
'%*= 0
53 '%
) # '% 0 ,
03 36 # *
3 ) ) # 03
03 ; )3 = = 0 20 $
( ( # 5** 03 #
5 # 7
# '% 2 3() , # '% , )#) , ( 30
3 *
# 5 *
#*
.1 // (
03 #
(**0) # # ( *
) # 5
3 .1 // # ) ) 0
# 2
* 03
(
3 03 7 ) 3 0
7 0) # # # 3 0 '%*
#
3< 0 '% *
)#3 0 7
6
3 .1 // 0 '% )3 3
.1 // ; 0 * 7
= #
.1 // 5@=%1 /(
0#
0 # $ * 03
* < # 0
03
:1 /1 // @=0 %1 / 5 #
,@=0 %1 @=0 %1 2 @=0 %1 / 0 #0 *
2
03 (*
# 3 = ( # (
# 03.
/1 // @) 1@=0 %1 / 3 03
3 ) * = 03
)
6 2 0
3 # * ( 00 (
0 03
06 #
6 >0) 35 * # *
#
.1 // ( * 30 #
.1 // #
# (*) #0
;
0 3 4
3 # 3
# 3
# 03
0 * #
7 0#0
03 #
#
5 #) 03
A 5* 0 0 3 2 0 *&1 3 ! 4
2 3 2 =
( =(*
20)1 ) 0 * > =
*
< ( =
* .
.1 // ;*) ( * 03
1
//2 ( 0
)#
=
#(
) @=%1 /5 = # #
*06 3#503 #
.1 // 5 03# # =
5 3
)
# #
)#0
< 2=
(*) 06 ## 0 0
#
6 )
5 <$
( 0); @=%1 / 0 ,= #
A
#
> * ( ) @=%1 / ,) , #
( )
0# 0 0
50 (
)#)
:1 /1 // 2 * 3 03 ) 3 1 1 // 3
3)#= 3# )
2 3 * )03
// 2 (35 *
#
// @)*
0
@=%1 /5 * 5 3
) )*
A 5* ,
7
# #
#
# $ .
< 2=
* 10 3 ( ( )
6 0 < 2=$ $
.
< 2= 5 * =
$
0
(* 6
(
# ( (
)
( # 0
) 0 (3 3 ,0 < * 0 )
< 2= &1
.
2493/<9/54 5 328/493+9/5 93+54 234 /,,>+.02 6362397/5<239+/5<+424 9 * #3 # 3 * 0# (* 3 6 0 #
) 89 89 01 8 9
<#
/ 8 : / 9(
(#( ( = # # 3
$ 3
3) ) , (
# #
# 3 ( #>
89 )
3 = # 0 @=% 2= / 8 / 9( +% 2= /8
/9( << 1 = /
8
/
9( E 1
= /8 /9( @= 1 = /8 /
/9( '
= / 8 / 9( % 2= (
/:.8 /:.9( $ 8% 9
= /:8 /:9(
809 #
* 3
) 3 3= # 0 3 3 92
6 01 8 0 03
01 0
3 0
0 8.92 ) 01 8 9 3*
01 3 ( 03( 0 # 3 ( 0( + 3( 0 * #( 3 0 >
'B
0 0)1 , (
( )# 10 ( 3 ;*) #
#
6 # <#
2
% 63 , 3
* 3(
* 6 0 # 89 89 01 8 9
<#
2 0 # #
3 ) #
( ,= =
) 3 #
(
6 0 # 3 - ) ( .
#
) 5
=
03
#
( ) 6 * 6 0 # 89 89 01 8 9 #
20) 0 #
.
< 2= , 0 #
* #
.
< 2= )
#
= # 5 6 03 A ( 0 # * #
5 .
< 2= 5 6 #
0 $
5 *
# *
#
) )#
)0
3<
( 0 # .
* 0 ) 3
#
#
# 0# 03 $
;*) (0 # (
( # )
0 #2 (
0
# * 5
) )
.
< 2= 2 *
, =
,
0 #
30 * < $
(#) ) #0# # 3 )
* #
#
# # )
( # * 0 # .
< 2= 3 )
;( 0 ) .
< 2= )
= #
#
2= # $
#) (# ) 0
# 03
03
# # 3(0 #) # 6 = # 5
3
H 0 2 )
) =
)
#
(*0
03
3@) (
1
$
#
> * (
$
* 6
<
)) # #) )
2 ( * #
# # #) 7 6
3** 35 3 * 03
3# # ) 7 2 = # $ 3 < 2= $ 6 ( # .
* ( #) 71 = 6 0 = (
( * # 03
<2 H 0 20 .
< 2= *( # = # #
= 0 3 ) #) # #
0# 2 ( .
)
<2 0 03 #) <
(
3 3<2
#
* 303
* '%)0 3* *03
) 3
* 0# 3) <2 .
< 3 *
5 3 )
* > *
0 <2 $
0 ) * )2 < 2=
* *
# ) #
#
*
) 0
( 3 #
* 0 $
- )
( #) * *( *503 < 2=
& 4
# ) # # < 2= 5
#* 3#3 0 # # (
0 #
* 0 *
0 < 2= $
( 0 0 3 0 2A 0
= =
2 0 0# 6 = = 0 0= 03
)
## ;*) ;D0 $
'
&($% "*,+-+*+..-)0 )00+ 1234)4/./?+5+5-9*234'
%( $#
" +-/5+28),+5- 9*2341234)4*/> )39/3+4+-+5-27+5-9*234
= =
5 0 C$ D< C$ D # *
#
2$
-2</-2-5 %
9/902-+412-+3=+4*>4 +*25-23+5- 9*234
= # #= ) # ) = = ( 0 , =C$ D 3 ) *0 # ) )
# (( )#
* 0=
#
< ( * 0
# < * =
# = ( (
) # ) 5* ) 3 )
( * ,
#
#
0 = 2# 03 * ( #0 3 ) )#0 # < 2=
)
* , # #
2 # $ $
) #* # * 3) # # #
0# 0
# #
*
3* # # = ( )(0 5
* # # 0# 0
0 0
* 3* # # = 50 30 * #
* ;*) (
) )# 3 # 30 0 * #
2 (
0
0 # 0# 0
# * #
2 #* #
,
# * #
< (
) , 3
# # * #<
3 *
5 = #6 * ( * ,
#
# ) # * 03 $
<)* 0)( # (
( ( # 03
$
0 * 8!(
"
4> E ,#7 I7 E
0 FI7