Kuldeep Singh v. Zile Singh And ORS
!
""""# $%&&' ( !) $*'+,- ./01&&2 !3+ %+&*( """220 '$!%422&00$!%( 5&*(/( 6 0& !3+ %+&*( """!$220 '$!%4 &(2!1&!%(
!"# #"$ % !&'
*&(&!%)
*"/! 0+$1+$,&! *17'$%&8 %+
*"+&%$!$!($0,17'$%&, *%+&$220 '$!%$22&00$!%(
*"*/!$ !,&! *17'$%&8 %+
*".+/(+$3*$ $+$9$!,17'$%&, *%+&!!$220 '$!%4*&(2!1&!%("
::::: #"$ % +&$220 '$!%$22&00$!%(+$7&$22*$'+&1%+ (/*%(&&; !3 *&7 &8%+&1&' ( !1$%&1""*&!1&*&1 ! &3/0$*&'!122&$0 "#1 *&'%&1$3$ !(%%+&9/13<&!%($!11&'*&&(%+&/*%( =&08,8+&*&=>%+&20$ !% (+$1$ 0&1%(/''&&1 !%+&(/ %(&&; !3 2((&(( !%+&0$!1"
+ (/*%,8+ 0& ((/ !3!% '& !%+&*&7 &8$220 '$% !,+$1 *$ (&1%+&008 !3%8?/&(% !()
!
" #
$%&'&() **%
! !
! *'+'! !!
%, +&%+*/(%%+&'!%&!% !8$(%+$% !*1&*%&(%$=0 (+%+& *&0$% !(+ 28 %+1&'&$(&1$*$= !3+,%+&<$%%&*+$1$0*&$1>=&&!1&$0% 8 %+=>%+&!@=0&/2*&<&/*% !()**+,) --.
/)+ 01 ,2 , 31+4 5+4676 '7),8 01 ,2 31+46% 1&' 1&1 ! A"B"$!1( !'&%+&1&&!1$!%(+$1%$;&!$20&$$17&*(&2((&(( !, %+&*&*&,%+&>'/01!%'0$ <%+&% %0&!%+&=$( (%+&</%$% !"
&20>%%+&*&7 &8$220 '$% !+$(=&&! 0&1$!1$!=9&'% ! +$($0(=&&!%$;&!8 %+*&3$*1%%+&<$ !%$ !$= 0 %>%+&(/ %/!1&* *1&* /0& $(?/$2((&(( !0$!1<&$(/* !3-C;$!$0(,%+& 20$ !% (+$7&0(%*<%+&/*%(=&08=/%(/''&&1&1 !%+&!@=0& /2*&<&/*% !%+& 7 022&$0$*&<&!% !&1"
*"/! 0+$1+$,0&$*!&1(&! *'/!(&0$(( (%&1=> *"+&%$!
$!($0,17'$%&,*&2*&(&!% !3%+&$220 '$!%$22&00$!%(,8+ 0&1*$8 !3%+& $%%&!% ! %+ ( /*% % %+& 2*7 ( !( &'% ! C %+& !1 $! 7 1&!'&'%,(/=< %%&1%+$%!&7 1&!'&+$(=&&!0&1=&*&%+&/*%( =&088 %+*&3$*1%%+&(/ %(&&; !32((&(( !0$!1<&$(/* !3-C ;$!$0(,%+&*&*&,%+& !1 !3(3 7&!=>%+ (/*%*!%&(%$=0 (+ !3%+& '0$ < => %+& $220 '$!%$22&00$!%( $*& !% (/(%$ !$=0&" + ( $'% 8$( '!'&1&1 => *"*/! $ !, 0&$*!&1 &! * /!(&0 $(( (%&1 =>
*".+/(+$3*$ $+$9$!, 17'$%&, *&2*&(&!% !3 %+& !! $220 '$!%4*&(2!1&!%(, %+&*&*&, 1&&< % $22*2* $%& % &D2/!3& %+&
9
!1 !3(3 7&!=>%+ (/*%8 %+*&3$*1%%+&$*&<&!% !&1$'%" *1&*&1 $''*1 !30>" (*&3$*1(%+&0 < %$% !,%+&'!'&1&12( % !!*&'*1 ( %+$%%+&</%$% !8$(&&'%&1 !%+&>&$*-,8+&*&$(%+&(/ %+$1=&&! 0&1 !-(&&; !32((&(( !%+&2*2&*%>"+&0 < %$% !%(&&;%+& 2((&(( !%+&2*2&*%> (%8&07&>&$*("+&1&&!1$!%(+$7&(&%/2$20&$ 1&'*&&1$%&1"",8+ '+,$''*1 !3% *"+$1+$,+$(!%(&&!%+& 0 3+%%+&1$>,=/%1/* !3%+&'/*(&%+&+&$* !3,%+&*&+$(=&&! *&&*&!'&%%+&1&'*&& ! $*$%+&20$ !%,8+ '+*&$1($(/!1&*) E) % -
*% .%*''+
%/ -
+%**%*'+' -
%, +/(, =%+ %+& 2$*% &( 8&*& $0 7& % %+& $*&<&!% !&1 ( %/$% !,%+&*&*&,%+&!/(8$(/2!%+&$220 '$!%$22&00$!%(20$ !% (% 2*7&%+&1&'*&&"+&>&D$< !&1 F,8+(%$%&1%+$%%+&*&'*1*<$% .$ %+$0 (/!'% ! !3!0>*<-!8$*1(,%+&*&*&,%+&!/(+$(!% =&&!1 ('+$*3&1=>%+&20$ !% ( !!%<$; !3&*%(%(/<<!%+& *&'*1*<%+&'!'&*!&11&2$*%<&!%*<8+&*&%+&1&'*&&8$(=%$ !&1" +&$'%/<</%$% !D"
+$(=&&!!% '&1=>=%+%+& /*%(=&08,2$*% '/0$*0>%+&G8&*22&00$%&/*%$!1$0(%+&$'%%+$% %+&$*&<&!% !&1 </%$% ! 8$( ($!'% !&1 ! $0($&$$<$!1 !%+& 2*&(&!'&$*$= !3+"+&&!%* &(+$7&=&&!<$1& !%+&9$<$=$!1 &( D",D"A,D"B,D"C$!1D"*%+&>&$*(-C-,##,
-
#C#,$!1C"+&!$<&%+&1&&!1$!%('!% !/&1 ! %+&'0/<!8!&*(+ 2$!1$(8&00$('0/<!2((&(( !"7&!%+& 20$ !% (+$7&$0(!%(/3+%$!>*&0 &1&'0$*$% !" !<>7 &8,*&(%%+&3*/!1(*$ (&1 !%+&2*&(&!%*&7 &8 $220 '$% !=$( '$00>%$!%$</!%%*&+&$* !3%+&<$%%&*,8+ '+ (!% 2&*< (( =0& ! 7 &8 %+& *$% 1&' 1&!1 '/00&1 /% ! ",:),27 "+4:,3+2;7))":+"+:* 4,4< # :*) <++666 =,3 5+4676 > <%"1+1,4:,% # #2,,2, 31+4%
#9 -"
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
*%+&*&3 !3 *&$(!(,%+&*& ( ! <&* % ! %+&*&7 &8 $220 '$% !"+&($<& ($''*1 !30>1 (< ((&1" ,4=1 %
.
#"$ 4,:+61 !&'
$1+31+46*+,?0@4+,6 +2 A+6@ $1+31+4+* 43,8)+ A+6@