High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4852/2017allowed

Joginder Singh & ANR v. Sohan Singh & ORS

2018-12-10Mr. Justice Amit Rawal10 pages

"#$$%&'&()$%$*+$, - .&(/$,&(.0"(#0$, 11$22"(#'

3$,'4'

0"(&(.0#0$,'

$'1(/$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

,$'$(#) ,01&(.0-/5%"#$- ,#0$"11$22"(#' ,6"&(-/5%"#$- ,#0$%"5$"#,' 77777 +*,&-( #&%$*#&( ,6"&(-/5%"#$-80&'(#0$%"5$"#-"%%$1#'(#&%$( +$0"2#0$,$'1(/$(#' 0$1,$'$(# $.42",$%(/11$"2 &'/&,$%#$/"."&('##0$ %(%4,,$(#&(/&(.'"%#"(/2"8-80$,$+9#0$'4&##0$,$'1(/$(#: 12"&(#&','1$%&&%1$,,*"(%$#0$".,$$*$(##'$22/"#$/

+9,$;$%#&(.#0$12$"#0$"11$22"(#':/$$(/"(#':'4+'$<4$(#5$(/$$'( #0$+"'&'#0$1,$5&4'".,$$*$(#/"#$/ -0"'+$$(/$%,$$/

$'1(/$(#:12"&(#&''4.0##0$'1$%&&%1$,,*"(%$#0$ ".,$$*$(##'$22/"#$/

(#0$1,$*&'$#0"# ";&(/$,6"4,:

/$$(/"(# 0"/".,$$/#'$22#0$2"(/&(/&'14#$*$"'4,&(.+&.0"' +&'8"',"##"2'"2$%('&/$,"#&( -

-=:"."&('##0$1"9*$(# $",($'#*($9--=: 8"'>$1#"'#0$'#&142"#$//"#$

,$?$%4#&("(/,$.&'#,"#&(#0$'"2$/$$/( ","#0$12"&(#-&#8"'

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

, "(/#0$,"&2*$(#'$$(/"(# "2(.8&#00$,'(",;&#&(.00"/ .($# #0$1$#,2 14*1 5#", &(.0 "(/ 6$0",&(.0- 80 8$,$ ,$<4$'#$/#.$##0$.$($,"218$,"##,($9$?$%4#$/&("54,0$,'( ","+;&#&(.0"''0$8"'4("+2$#2>"#$,#0$1,1$,#9,$*$(#&($/ 1$,'('"''4,$/,$?

5&'&#$/#0$04'$/$$(/"(# "(/+,4.0#'*$'#"*11"1$,'80&%0 8$,$'&.($/0$",$*$(#&($/1"1$,'0"/+$$(,.$/"(/%(5$,#$/&(# ".,$$*$(##'$22"'#0$,$8"'(&(#$(#&(#'$22#0$'4&#2"(/5$(" %*12"&(#&(#0&',$.",/8"''4+*&##$/##0$$(&,41$,&(#$(/$(#

2&%$- "#&"2"-+4#("%#&(8"'#">$(#8"'"22$.$/#0"#/$$(/"(#

0"/"2,$"/9'2/#0$2"(/#.&(/$,&(.0'($$#&(.0#0,4.0 "##,($9 0&(/$, "2'(60","&#&D"25&/$'"2$/$$//"#$/ ,"##"2'"2$%('&/$,"#&(@-A-=: $$(/"(#&2$/"'$1","#$8,&##$('#"#$*$(#"(/11'$/

. #0$'4&#+9#">&(.(4*$,4'1,$2&*&(",9+;$%#&('"(/1,14(/$/#0$'"2$ /$$/ &( <4$'#&( 80&%0 8"' ( "%%4(# ".,$$*$(# # '$22 /"#$/

&(%$#0$1",#&$'8$,$"#5",&"(%$-#0$#,&"2%4,#,"*$/#0$ 228&(.&''4$'):

# #

$ % "

2"&(#&'-&('411,##0$"5$,*$(#'-$?"*&($/ C:

6$0", &(.0"##$'#&(.8&#($''- C: 0&(/$, "*- C:B'0>64*",-

$.&'#,"#&( 2$,> #0$ &%$ 4+ $.&'#,",- $," "''&- C: "0"(5&, ",'0"/"&(-$$/C,&#$,"(/ C:3&5$>"&(12"&(#&"(/ +,4.0#(,$%,/? -? B"(/? F-&$-%$,#&&$/%19#0$ $(<4&,9,$1,#/"#$/AB-'"2$/$$//"#$/ "(/;"*"+"(/& ,#0$9$",:B (#0$#0$,0"(/-#0$/$$(/"(#'$?"*&($/C: .&(/$, &(.0:/$$(/"(# - C: "*$'0 64*",- C:B ("(/ "+4 ?:

",1"(%0-C: 0&(/$, "2"(/+,4.0#(,$%,/,&.&("2".,$$*$(## '$22/"#$/ ?C ="(/,$%$&1#/"#$/ ?C = 0$#,&"24,#-80&2$/&'%",/&(.#0$12$"#0$/$$(/"(#'# +$02/$,1,$5&4'".,$$*$(##'$22-/$%,$$/#0$'4&#+9'$##&(.:"'&/$#0$

'"2$/$$/11$"2#">$(+$,$#0$D8$,11$22"#$%4,#8"'/&'*&''$/ ,01&(.0-2$",($/%4('$2,#0$"11$22"(#:/$$(/"(#' '4+*&##$/ #0"# +#0 #0$ %4,#' +$28 0"5$ %**&##$/ &22$."2&#9 "(/ 1$,5$,'&#9-1",#&%42",29#0$D8$,11$22"#$4,#+$&(.#0$2"'#%4,# "%#"(/2"8&((#(#&%&(.#0$%"#$.,&%"/*&''&(#0$8&#($''#0$ /$$(/"(#'-800"/"%>(82$/.$/#0$".,$$*$(##'$22/"#$/ $?$%4#$/+9/$$(/"(# ";&(/$,6"4,&("54,#0$"11$22"(#:

/$$(/"(# "0"5&, ",'0"/"&( C:B8"'(($$2'$+4#"#0$, 5$(/$$ 3&5$> "&(- ($ #0$ 12"&(#&'- 80- &( $?"*&("#&(:&(:%0&$ "/*&##$/#0"##0$'#"*15$(/,'8$,$14,%0"'$/,*3&(/"&(#"*1 3$(/,-808"'0&'/"4.0#$,-+4#,$.&'#$,#0$#"*13$(/,0"'(# +$$(1,/4%$/-*4%02$''#0$/"4.0#$,"#"22-#0$12"&(#&'"%#4"229 $(#$,$/&(#"(".,$$*$(#-#0$9842/0"5$>(8(#0$+"2"(%$"*4(# 80&%0842/0"5$+$$( -

-=:"(/(#@-A -=:"'1$,12$"/&(.'

&( ",".,"10#0$12"&(# #8"'($?#",.4$/#0"#&(5&$8"/*&''&( C:

6$0", &(.0- "11$22"(#:/$$(/"(#' +$&(. '4+'$<4$(# 5$(/$$'- ",$ +("&/$ 14,%0"'$,' , " 5"24"+2$ %('&/$,"#&( "# "22- #0$ 80$,$"+4#'

";&(/$,6"4,8$,$(#>(8(,'0$0"/.($"+,"/-#0$12"&(#&''042/ 0"5$'4**($/#0$,$.&'#$,,*#0$&%$#0$$14#9**&''&($,- +4#($,#8"'*"/$#/'#&'(#($%$''",9#0"##0$".,$$*$(##'$22 /"#$/ ?C =!8"',$<4&,$/#+$/,"#$/(",$.42",'#"*1 1"1$,

$,%(#,"- ,6"&(-2$",($/%4('$2"11$",&(.(+$0"2 #0$,$'1(/$(#:12"&(#&''4+*&##$/#0"##0$%(%4,,$(#&(/&(.'"%# "(/2"8%"((#+$&(#$,$,$/8&#0"'#0$"11$22"(#:/$$(/"(#'%"((#+$

1$,*&##$/ # #">$ #0$ 12$" ,$"/&($'' "(/ 8&22&(.($'' 0$ %,'': $?"*&("#&( C:

6$0",&(.00"'(#+$$(,$"/&(#0$#$(,"(/*/$ 8&#0#0$1,$5&4'%,'':$?"*&("#&(%(/4%#$/+9#0$%4('$2,/$$(/"(# 0$'"2$/$$/8"'/4,&(.#0$'4+'&'#$(%$#0$".,$$*$(##'$22

$"/&($''"(/8&22&(.($'',*#0$/"#$&2&(.#0$'4&#0"/+$$(8,&# 2",.$0$,$8"'%*12&"(%$#0$1,5&'&('$%#&( %!#0$ 1$%&&% $2&$%#0$,$%$&1#$",($'#*($9--=:0"'+$$( 1,5$/#0,4.0#0$#$'#&*(9 C:

6$0",&(.0$'#&*(&$'C:B ("(/"+4?:",1"(%0"(/C: 0&(/$, "2",$(0$21##0$ /$$(/"(#'+4###0$%"'$#0$12"&(#&'"'#0$".,$$*$(##'$22/"#$/

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

6$0",&(.0-( -8"' %,'':$?"*&($/ +9 %4('$2,/$$(/"(# -("*$29-0,&642/$$1&(.0"(/0&'%,'':

$?"*&("#&(8"'/$$,,$/-80$,$"'4,#0$,%,'':$?"*&("#&((+$0"2 #0$"11$22"(#:/$$(/"(#8"'("2"#$,1&(##&*$-80$,$&(1$(&(. 2&($-0$"/*&##$/"'4(/$,):

/ E'( )

) *

' "

+ !

!,-(

+ ! )

(

( *.& 0$",$*$(#&($/'#"#$*$(#-80&%08"',$"/4#&(#0$%4,#- 0"/(#+$$(%(#,5$,#$/+9#0$2$",($/%4('$2,#0$12"&(#&'-+4#"( "##$*1#8"'*"/$#$?12"&(#0"#&#8"'(#&(#0$%(#$?#".,$$*$(# /"#$/ 1,14(/$/+9/$$(/"(#-+4#&("%##0$".,$$*$(# &(<4$'#&("*","&/-#0$",$*$(#&($/",.4*$(#&'*$,&#2$''&(5&$8 #0$2"(.4".$$?#,"%#$/"+5$

,5&'&(' $%#&( #0$ ,"('$, ,1$,#9 %# $*+2/$(#0$#,"('$,$$'#"22$.$+("&/$14,%0"'$$%#&( ,$"/'

#04'):

" #0&(.%(#,",9'4,"%$//$'1&#$$?#$('&5$%,'':$?"*&("#&( C: "*$'064*",0$#$(,"(/*/$#0$%,'':$?"*&("#&( C: 0&(/$, "2,$2$%#'#0"#,$'1(/$(#:12"&(#&'0"/#0$>(82$/.$ #0$".,$$*$(##'$22/"#$/ "'1$%&&%<4$'#&(-0$"/*&##$/ #0"#".,$$*$(##'$22/"#$/ 8"'8,&##$("#0&'04'$ ,* 1$,4'"2#0$;4/.*$(#'"(//$%,$$'+#0#0$%4,#'+$28-&#,$5$"2' #0"##0$,$&'(,$$,$(%$"(/"/5$,#$(%$##0$%,'':$?"*&("#&(#0$ "##$'#&(.8&#($''#0$".,$$*$(#/"#$/

$$,$(%$"*4(#

@-A -=:&( ",".,"10#0$12"&(#-"%%,/&(.# ,"&(-8"'/4$ #&("/5$,#$(%$"(/"##$(#&(#0&'%4,#8"'/,"8(##0$1,"9$,%2"4'$ ,$2$%#&(.#0$+"2"(%$'"2$%('&/$,"#&( ("/5$,#$(%$ %"((# +$ 1$,*&##$/ # +$ ,$+4##$/ 80&%0 &' $5&/$(# ,* #0$ %(#$(#' "," B #0$ "&/"5&# 6$0", &(.0 '4+*&##$/&($?"*&("#&(:&(:%0&$ $2$5"(#1,#&(#0$'"*$,$"/'#04'):

E/ 0! 1

2 1

"2%234

+ !,1 .

1 "

+ !

! %2

"52672%34&

C: "0"5&, ",'0"/"&(-$$/C,&#$,&( ","'B"(/ 0&'"&/"5&#'#"#$/"'4(/$,):

E / ' 1 "34 ! *"

+ ! 8 *

"34

! *"

+ !

! %'

(

!( / ! :

)

(

! ;12 1

$ !# < & #8"'",.4$/#0"##0$/"4.0#$,0"/.($"+,"/$#0"#"'&#

*"9-('#$1'8$,$#">$(#'4**(#0$'#"*15$(/,,$.&'#$,80&%08"' /$1'&#$/&(#0$&%$#0$$14#9**&''&($, $,0"1'#0$12"&(#&'

8$,$","&/"'%$,#"&(*$(##,4#05"&2"+&2&#9$?1,$''&(E"/5$,'$ &($,$(%$G%"((#+$,42$/4#5$( C:3&5$>"&(12"&(#&&( ","B #0$ "&/"5&# '4+*&##$/ &( %0&$ ,$$,,$/ # #0$ +"2"(%$ "*4(# "' @-A -=:0$'"*$,$"/'#04'):

92 0!

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

80$,$&(#0$1,1'&#&(",'$"'#80$#0$,&(5&$8#0$ 1,5&'&('$%#&(@

! -1,5&'&('$%#&( #0$ 4(;"+4,#'

%#- @ 842/"1129,#0$"11$"2&$ 842/+$&2$/4(/$,$%#&( /$&5&2 ,%$/4,$"(//$%&'&(#0$,$%42/+$8&#04#,"*&(.#0$ '4+'#"(#&"2<4$'#&('2"80$('#&#4#&("2$(%0(H+2$41,$*$

0 4,#0$2/#0"##0$/$%&'&(&(!"# ! $ "

(

("112&%"+&2&#9$%#&( @

! &'(#"%,,$%#2"8-&($''$(%$-#0$1,5&'&('$%#&( #0$ 4(;"+4,#'%#- @ 0"/+$$(,$'#,$/+"%> ,#0$'">$+,$5&#9- #0$,$2$5"(#1,#&(#0$;4/.*$(#&5$2$",($/4/.$'#0$(H+2$ 41,$*$4,#&( "(>";">'0&H'%"'$ '41,"!,$"/'#04'):

* !

< 0

21 =2* 2 !

/! 1

? @ #!

$) * +,- ./ , 0 -

!1!

AB 745C& E7D1 < %# ! #!

* !

#!< 51

1 ! 22

! * # ! '

* <E1 '

<25%2

? '

E1 '

<25%2* 5'

# ! '

2< 5%2

E1 '

<25%2 !

#!<

# ! '

1 !< 7,.# ! '

2< %# ! '

! * !

!1 !< 7# ! '

2 < 7,.

! ! 1

* 57,. # #

!,< .<2576

* !

#!<2 !

& 0$,$,$-/(#&(#$(/#,"*$#0$'4+'#"(#&"2<4$'#&(' 2"880&2$/$%&/&(.#0$"11$"2-",$*$(#&($/

,#0$,$"'('*$(#&($/"+5$-#0$;4/.*$(#'"(//$%,$$' #0$%4,#'+$28",$0$,$+9'$#:"'&/$4&##0$,$'1(/$(#:12"&(#&'&' /&'*&''$/11$"2'#"(/'"228$/ 1 23- +*,&

245 ()16'

,575489 :4

;4:

,575 73"

;4: