Parveen Garg Alias Ashu v. Pooja Rani





        


 




  





     

!



 





 

 " #

 

$ "

 %




 
 
 


 

$ "

 %&  ' (



  
 





 

!!"
#$
%!&
 
'(

  

)
#* 

(
+&
 

 
, 




 %'


 
'
-
 !


 

 
"


.






/
# 




01&
, 



'(

%, 

   

 
 

 
 
, 
 
'(


 

 
!2





 



 

 
 %'


 





, 
 

 

 (




'(

+


 

, 
 

 
-

'(
, (



 3
 
 
 



  4 



 
 
' 
 

 



(




 
'
% 


 

 4 

 
' 
 
 
 
'
 

 



 



3
 
 

'  
 
'(
 




 
'
 

 

'
 

 
 



, 
$  
'(

*

6

 
+
0
 

 
           

 

(
, 



'(

 
 - 



6 
6 
7



6

 




 
 
'



 
, 




'




 
 
 
8 !
 
 



47
,

'



 
 
'




 

 
, 
 
'(



 
'

 

 
, 
 
  
,
 

 
 
'

 

 

 
8 !% 
9  
9


 
 
'


 
, 
:

!"

;

/<;




 
=
 
 

:
, 
 (


'




 



 


 



  
 (

:
, 
 
':

 (

₹" >%

 
 
 
 
(
 

, 

 (



(
,

,  

 
(
 




 
, 



'(



 

=
;
7 
<
 
, 

 


" %6
++



 
 

 
 


 (


 

(





(

 
(
'
'



 
 

(
 


+





  
 
 
 

 
 

'

,



 


 
'

 




 
 


'
-

, 
  < .,

.1'


*

6
 
 
,

 


'  (

'







, 
, 
'
-
 
  
 


:

$ 
 ' ,%

  
    

         

       
   !   

  "

   !           #$  %   %   & '   


  "  !       !

  (
  $   $      #$ %  %!
   !   " 
"    !         #$ %   %  $  "

      ) $      '

*+,- "   )$ 
 !         (
 

)$ "

  !   !)   $ .

  "

)

   *+,- 
 /  

 *+,-    "
  ""

    /  

  "

  ! 
   / *- *,  "#*.* .

0 0
1  02    


.

  
         " !

 $
       ( 
  $ /*- *,0"""


"

 
 !

"  !    "  (

  "



  !       (   ! 3   $   $     
       ! "  
 

    3 ',  *+,,  
   
   ! "

)



 4 ! 

   ! 3  

  !

4      "  $    " !


 
# .

 0 "  5

.

0    4   7     
 

5 2  
""

8!              1!2 !   )$      
  
     0$   ! $   8 


   "    
   0  !   !$!
 
7
!$  0    
$   7"     !  
   
   2   ! 
   " 
  "

 
    1!2   !     "    "

  
   97
 5 : 
     !   !     
     $ ! 
   
    !     
       ! !0
 

1'2 (    !
  !

 1*2      
  !    


;!   
  
  ! " 
  $  $


!"$   !      " 
   ! 7 !


 6

*+ ( $     )$    

  "

" 
  #$ %  %   & '     !

 (

 "

   #$ %  %"


 
 " "   (   $    $    (   "

)  '

 

   *+,-  /   "

   

)$"

    

      ( )$ "

   $ .

  "

)

     *+,-    
  "        

      

  $ "


        4 "    $ 

  "

  # .  0
       ! !

 $
   (  0 "

     7   
  

 "

!

 ( 0 !   
 '  (   ! 

     )$ "

   

 ""

*


  ( #!3  



 " $        "  
  

    (      
"$  / $        
 



  !$  (  0  

  "  $       !

  $
 

    ( $
       0   ! 

  '* 08 4 "
    0 <#
$! *+,-   "
!    !

$
   4 $   4$   (   

 !  0'3*+-* ''

4 
 
    ) $  ! $   ! 3  # $ 33 :  "7
 !# $ 3 4

"3  3 '

4  "$ ) 
  
  7 "        $
      $  0 "
    $ !   7    " "  "  0  7   )

  8
 ="  "    
     $  !       
 0"!"")7 
"   *-  0           $ 7 )

'  ( 
  "       0 <#
$! *+,-      !

$
    4$  
!  " '.

 (
         ! 

 ! 0'3 *+-* 

:


.1'


*

6

'

:
'(
+%  
6

 
+
,




, 

:


.1'


*

6
 
  




   


,
3

 

?    
!"##   $% &'




%



, 
 
 

'





 

, 


, 
-
 



  
, 
 
'(

.


+
,


 


:


.1'


*

6 ;

.,


.1'


*

6


 


 

 
         ( 



*

6
)

 
+


 

)
!   %

  *  +  , -  *.

, 



 (
 
 ,
, 
 -
3
, 
 
 












 



 (


 

, 

,





-



 
'



'@ (


 

 

  
.1'


*

6


,

%
<  !

 

# .          >  1
 2  " ! !$   "   7"   
$ 4$   
$    
$      ( " !) 




  

 ! 
      ! 
      
  
   $
        $
  "   
   "

!   > 1
 2     $      
 

 $           4   
   $   !? $ " 3  #*-007 
"    (   7"  
$  !
  !0  !   

 !8  $ !   # ."

"     " 4$ !    7
$8   $
 "

       
    "   "

( !8 "!
 

 "  !

 
 # .  4 7$   "    "!
   ,

  $  ! $       $
    

 @# . $$    $!   
  
   7
 !$  0    $
   ( 
          !     

 !


   $ ! &"  

 
 

 
  "        $     $  /!  " !  !   $!$
7   $ (""    ! 7
 8 $ !$
   $! 47  . 7"     
$          ! 
 !0     "
 ""     !


  "

  (  " !
!

7  
  # .     !8  

+ (88  !! " $   # .     !   
"  $   $      7 "

08 "    !

 
      1    $  !2  
  7 ! 
    $  " 
  "!! !
$7     !8  =  7
$
 "
 
   
  # . 
  "          " ! 

  !8 $ 
   *  4         
 4 $          "

     
$ )  



 "$  # .
 !    
 !8  " !$ "    (             "     ! 

      "  ! 
  
     8  !

0

       
  

  
$   ) $    !  !     " 
     7  A  B #         "

 8 
   7$         

     

   " 1"   !)"

   

 2 "! !

 

 # .        $$"

   !  !    $ 
          "


   /   0 % $ /     1 * 0 
 2    $% $  2 #34
 %$   5

  

1  ./ - ** 4 $ !!!"

 $

 7$  $"         !   
     4 

   $      7
    4   
 
    # .  
     ="""
!1 $    $2$  "    $  !  4$!   8 !   !8   "$  

   

  

 

  !

   
    



 !7 

 

*< ( !

 
    

# .  "8
         

  4   
  
$  7
$1"    2 !8  ! !

  $ 
         $ ! *,

   !     "    
 $    $$    '. #
$!  *+-*  " "

    7   $ 
$"

 

 


 "

  "

"
  */! *+-* 4"

   $ "

 ! 
 !
  

 " )! 0 / "  "!  
"

7
  $$  
"  " "

 
$ $ (  0   ) 

      ) "      )    "   ( 
  ! $ "    D / 7 


 



 

 %'


 





, 
 

, 
 (




 

 
!2

. 


 

 
,
 


,
 A

(


 
, 




$
 




!!"



 
!!"
 

'








 




 

!!"


₹3,000/- were imposed which were not paid. In fact, the petitioner refused to pay the same before the Family Court, Karnal. For the sake of repetition, neither the written statement nor the reply to application under Section 24 of HMA were filed. To top it all, costs imposed were not paid and in fact there was refusal to pay the same. Under the circumstances, the defence was struck off. The case of the petitioner-husband would be fully covered by the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Full Bench in the case of 0
  

  
          # &








(



 
'(

* 

(
+
 

,   


7  

:    3
 ,


'
3


 
(
 



  
 


 

  (
  



'

$ "

 %(






 
+ ,

B
 - > 
C>8
B
 '


C>8