← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4403/2018dismissed

Tannu Tools Pvt. Ltd. & ANR v. Haryana Ispat Udyog & ANR

2019-07-04Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary6 pages

     

!"# #$%&%'( )*+ ,

-  



   .#/&)& 

   ! (01 2 222  "

# $ % & '

))))) 222, 

* &(+ + ,+

+& -

 /012/130% 

!+

% 5+

-

3217/132%

$+&+

!+&++ %5+ 8+(('

'(  - '   * +(((+  + '

& 9%2:%;99*

 </=> .  + +(( , + 6+  .  (   6  6+  + +(((+.+  + , +  (

#+ (+  $  %'

% + ' 6.+ ++  ''

'

6+

+,

%



%+ +  (, + '

(+  $   ' 



6 ,+ %, +((+.. +

'+ (.  ' 6 ,+ +((     +((%  +  +   %  .+ +     ''

(  

'

6+ +,



+ +'

 (, + +((

6 .

( 



+' + &+  '? ( 3%11%111* . %6+'6% 6&% +  ,# !+    .   ?  %  .  6  

 .   , '%  + 6(+   + 6 +

@+  +.+ ,-'

6 #+ 6+

  +  

,

6

+ +((

,

+((

,(

(+'

 + +((

(+ ,+

 ''





A' +



+' 6+' +(( +++ ( (+ '

+. +. 6+

+((% &

 (+

 6+ +(( (+

 3%11%111*6

+((%6+'6

+&, 3 6&% +((.+*  . (+

'

. 3 & % 3+  . 3%11%111* +(( +

.  6    .   +'       +((!+.+  + 6

  6

(+



6+ + 6(. ,+ "* + B  +((+

'

& 9%2:%;99*

6+ +   C  ++B   + +((+

+, +  .C !

+++B   + +((+, .+*- 

*- (' +C ! +&B   + +, +.+ C !

&  +(  &+ '  6   ,  ,

   +  +    + '

+&'

+.   '

+ + &+ %('

 '+' . '   ' '

'

+((  ''(

 & +' ,+ &+ ''

% + 6 ' &+ +. -

3217/132  (+

6 +.+

!+

%5+ &+ +. -

/012/130

+& ( .% , (+   '

 (     

*   &.

 +((.+, (+ &+ ' 

+ &+  6 .

6 &  6  +&       (  6+' 

  +(   ,.+

,

''

,

6

 ((+'+ &



' +(( ('+. '

9= &+ ' '

 +(   ''

6

+ +(( ,

# + .++, +&+ '  + + ''

,

#%+  %6&

' ,( 

 $   B+    +       -

   D,  .$ + 

  %+ +  '

'  ,

'  '

 +%

 % ,

6 -



' (,

$

6, +  &

 &



(+ 6+ ++ '  +.

('

&

'+(+'

  +  , +     , 6     +((  

(+.  (+ & , + , 6

+((

(+.'

, +  +(  .



('

&

.

'+(+'

'

+' (('

. 6 &6&    , +((    +.(    +'

'

  ++

,&  +'6 +&+& + %6+'.

.++ 

(' '

9= &+ ''

,  

+ ( &+ ++  &+

  , + 6

 (+'+

+((  

 .+

&+  ++ ,+ ''

 ' ''

6 6

9319/133% . 9%2:%;99*6

++  &+ '

 6 ''

+'

'

 (,+' 

 . 3%11%111* 6+  ,6 ('? %6+'6 +  ,(  ,# #, + +

6+ +((%(+

  &

 



3%11%111*6 +& 3,6 ('? , . 6.+*  +(( '

. 6(+ 3 + + & 3+  .

3%11%111* +(( ' (',+

+'

, $

6 '

,&

  '      ,     +((  '

 6+    #  , 

6+

 ('

 . 3%11%111* 6+ 3 +((%+ ' +,+ 

'

6+    +.

('

+ &+ '

 .+

, + %

' 

' + 6  &+

.

6+

+((6 + (

 ('+

,  .   ,   

 !+  4

%  5+

    B*/   (('

,+

  AB/39 

AB/326( (+'

+ ,+

AB/39

 AB/32  6  '

+   +  ,    (  +  +   % . ?  ,+

6'

 

&  -

 D,  .$ + 

'  ,

 '

 (     

  +  

  +',     ('

  

'+' . ' ( '

 '

  ,

6  &     '

'  (+   (  ('

    

      6

 .      '+ (&+ 6+'6  + (' . +  ++ % ?  6. '  , + ? 

6++&

& + +  

 ,+ 

+ , 



%+(+.+ &+ ++. -

3217/132%

$+&+

+ !+&++ % 5+

-

3217/132%

!+

%5+ %'

+& %6+''

( + (', +$ +'

 ''

% + +.+ + +.+6+  

  +(+

'+ %  ? +

, +  %+(

)*+ ,

- 222  +

 B #+  "

E

B  , "

E