High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4488/2018dismissed

Soran @ Swaran Singh And ANR. v. Ram Karan And ANR.

2023-01-27Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"##

$$%% &' ()#

$ *

+#,%-. #$$%%

/$"#-. $0

,%2-#$#.# $$%%#$%()#3'"#'4" $$ 5##'$$6#7.%' 3" 0

8 $%(2!$##$%() 0

#3#0"##." 5## +$$-!##("95#! 0 !"##3#:;'<

=#-0 !"#% $$%$"% 0#$$% !'#$ '"#'$"- %7.%>'" . -*#4'%:%)'"- $'$$$%""#$#$$26 ($%#:%)'"-$'.#$ $$$%'3("#7' *%()!#!.!## $ '3( 3+ ?

# $$()'"$#%(;'%2 #%$#$%#+'"( *%() # %%" # ! "# # ' % #' '$ )# 0 555

('" 4% 8(%-!##4#'(3#%% ##:;'##''32#$%# %%## "%2-:%)'"-$'! '((32#7'#(!# ###$#33'#! $'6#'"#(($#$$2 ""#'"##7'% =#3+!!#!32# $% =#- :% )'"- $' '3( % $

!# " # $

%'" # 3 =# 7' # =#%- *#4'%'3(#.%'$-!##!"%2 3'!3'$$32/%;*!-!##. #$!#'"."#$ @($ $-# !"#( 4% ?(%33 (%6#:;' 4% 9 (%33 (%-'##%#(95 # A##()$%%"!##3# 0"#(84%8(%3(%"# '" 5#6=#%-*#4'%#.%' 4# 0 555 ('" 4% 8 (% 4# 0 55 5 ('" 4% (% ?9-5$(%

=#$$%%#$%##2#' ##'3'2!%%4#0 555 55 5 32 $'"##%'$9B6#%!3 #'%#.3 %# -5$(%32# 7%%

$$%% "# # % 3+ 9 #.%' $

9 '3( 32 =#%#C#4#0 555 55 5 -!##! 3'#'%3'#6'#(' 4#0 555 ('" 4% 8(%-!###%% $$%%0 50 '#% 8(%#3

432*A , -/2'%"" !#' $2" 2 ($- #- # # ". $$%%0 %32 8(%6#$$'2!". $$%%#%%"#+3+32#(!# ".%'$

9-#$!"'$ #%!$!# =#( $'""32#D% 7((!( 3%''3+ ##%'$"# $.#$(%32#3#:;'- #2 !'% $2 '( -99- ( ) 0 "#5#%"%#!#!(#(##- %"!###2!'%3%32".( :;'

D7.%>'" . -*#4'%3.# #3+!""#.%'#$$2-!## #3".#$.$$#($ '"" 32 # D% 7((- # .%' # $$$#7%%(#=#%-*#4'% !%%$(=#%-*#4'%!.

!"#%3+#$% =#7' #3+33%3.# 8(% #%#3432/2'#

9 '4#0 555 ('" 4% 8(% #.%'#%%'% ?9-5$(% '(#.%'#%4# 555 ('"

4% 8(%-#.%' 4%%!###%%# # ! "# ( '

8 %4#

7"###$2"'2 %'%-%7.%>'" . -*#4'%%' %%!

%"&% %"

)

*+% %

!,)%

-% .% /'(0

) *+

%.&%&/'(% %

&% %-.'( - 0

!,)

1 2

"%& %&-'(

.%%&"&'(%

1 . 0

1 2

3 4 %

1 2

) *+

1.%%&"&'(

!, )' 6

% )

% 1% !

)

1 2

1 )

*+% 1

.%%&"&'(

!,)'

) *+*

1 2

0 %8

3) , -"

//& 9!:*+

;% 1

:%" "". 0 ! "# :;' $% ( ) # % $$$%"#+'"(

9 $327.%>'" . -*#4'%3'#$$%! (.+'"(?

32% >'"-*#4'%

%% %" - $$%% ! "#:;' 0 #.$$## 7'32!2%"#$"'%$$%- !##!'$$0 #$' $$#'"#'%

@#.#%'%#$3"" #'"##

D'%#$$%%## !#' " %% # 3# # 7' #. !"%2 #$$%%$2 -99- 5#$!# (#-!#$+2"## $##%

@##$ . " # # # + % $'" # $%(2$32#%7'

8 =# $'3!#$'"#$"!" '$ % =# % 7' 7.% >'" . - *#4'%%.#$'!($$/%; *!-$'D%7(('""#( $ # "%2 ! $ =# $%5$0 #%3+"#( $'""32D%7(("#D% 7(('""#($#3 ;'%2%#%". !"# ##%".$%()6'#%($ 4#0 555

8 5 +"# !#:;'0 .%'0

# '.4# 5 -#()-3+

8 #%.%'":;' !"# !# ( ! ' 32 :;' 3#% # ####()0"# !'%3".#('#!4#'(3#( "#$#+#%" :'#(-.% ';'#7'#$# ! "#0 '32### +#%"-#!'%3#."2"#%((" (()#%'""3".() '(3#(4.%' =#3+! 320 !"##%%""

#(3%2'#"#%#3$32 $"#$#$.$.#$# C####%% ! "##3#$%"!### ' #' 3'2 !%%6 # $ ". 3+()#$##%' #'#

=#:$$%%7'!#%$"#! $$%#3.#(%23'94%%!% $$( 8(%%'%E32# /2($#%!'(32#$ ."'$" #("%'

#$C-!##$#3 (#$-!##!"32#$ @! '#3.##$#(%.$ #%32("#$#C## (+'('"$#3( "# '%E 8(%%32#/2# $'$ ' # !#' $2" 2 ($-:$$%%7'#"#%23.#%%# $3''%($# $.#!#'$+'##$2 =#7' %#3+32()#%%% #(!2(#%.

%'##% %%## =#3+43#% ! "# # 7%% ?9-5 $ (% # !"%23$"#%F##F!#( !F3F#."('#%.%' =#:$$%% 7'#"#%23.#!#"$%$'$- '#'#'-#2#.' !#"2$%(23""3( ((%##%7'#4$(#$ %3$3%(3'#7'!%% #..%.(('%2'#$#!# 3+##"'!

,##+'"(;'% !%%$'%$$$$%$$ .$%! =#%%"%2 (2# 0'3%;'%!# $$%

:" ( # $$%- # ( ("%2

# ( $$% (- # (%%'$$% -2-$"%2

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#