High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4575/2018dismissed

Harnkanwalsingh v. Surjit Singh And ORS

2019-09-09Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary7 pages

!" #$

# %"& '( )* (( +"

,"- )* *"

"# $% %%% ."

" *!*/,$0

%%% & (( 2(

))"0 -,) "

!3*("

40(5,)5, "0 $ ,3 '*"!3* , "(" (!3* '

'((

-,) "

!3*("

( "5,)$% *","$'*"!3* ('

"3 "-, * "** 2(

( , & )(" *

*( $

( * ( $ * " "3 ""3 * (

**(

" "

! '"

7,!3* *"

,"- )*2 .(' ".( )*(

!"*"! )(()($ * "

'*,

0 9,*")*

9, "( " -,

( ,)*: (**(

)" *" (3"0( )*

!)*, & ( ; .& $'**' "(""3 "" *, "3$*(

)" :

<* ,""3! *"""3' (( (, ( ( !3"0( )* .& /" *"

2/,"

" )* *0 ,* *"8 !3'3

,"( ,

"** /," " )*$,"- )*$

*"* ,""3:

,"*" *,"- )**"0*""3 3

=" *" "3 (3'*

' !"

( )'** *" )" *"

,5 % ," "3 <*" "$*(

* *" ,""3*(!3,"- )* !30", ! ) !" *" "3: (()*' "

'" )!3 "( !"*"

" (

"<* "

" ( !'*, 3()(

3$*" "$

0 9,*(

,""3 "(" "3""3 *" &

,""3% $ ,' ( <* ,' '**

* /,"

" )*0(0,

,"- )*2 9,( *" ") "'((

7, !3 /," " )* <* (

0 "

""?

( " * ""3$'**** *" " /," " )*:

$* , ""3 ( ! "($*(

* ")** , ""3$'** ((* *'(( /," " )*:

" *"0( )*' !)( '

" ; .& "

@ ** )":

""3 (,*" ' ((* : *,"- )*2 $ *"

*"*""3 =" *" "3 (3 <*"

" ( !0( ()(, 7,!3 (, "0 " "!3 * $ ! (0

" * * "("

7,0(;((

, ) <* "

" '" 7, !3 '3

!, ,

( ,' "3 " A((' )

, '" " !3*("

"(4," ! *( ) ;**"*(

(*(" "3

"C..

;**" (

( " -,

"3 "C..

@ ;**" , (

!(C. ;**"*(

" ( )* ,!3*

,C.

;**"(

, (,

(* ,C. > ( D0 ' (!3!**" E"

"( 4,"

" ) * 0 "" (,**(

("0* 0 ($

9, (3* ,'

( (!3* ' (

!3*("

( "5,)$ % *","0-,)

))"0*" " $" (* ! ( E"

0* (3"), *!*

*("

," !('*0""

)* , (!3* 2(

: ,! ** ," ""3"

"( " "3$0 *( *""3 /," " )* *0(0, *(( * ( !3'3 ;((: * "(3!, *(( " *( *""3

)" *"!3'3 ;(($

"* )* ," *"*( *"$'**0(0, *","- )*<*(( ( *" *""3'**0(0, *","- )* '((: ,"*" * *;((

' 7,!3,"- )* 2.(' ".( )*$*7, *"

)"0

", : $*, $"3** (! (('$ ,) -,) "

!3* ("

40(5,)5, "0 $ ,3 '(( -,) "

!3*("

( "5,)$ % *","$ ! , ( !3 * (( ! " *",)*, :*0*"("

*0", ('** !(

(

*!' *" ,E"

, !( 3**""3 /," "

)*)" *"

* *"

2,"- )*0(0, *" (( 2 (

* *","- )* 9,( *" ") "'((7,!3/," " )*,"- )*2(

7,;((

!9,* )* *( *"

*" <*" "$ ' "

'"7,!3,"- )* " * ""3

$* *" @B,)*"

,"- )*' (3"7" ** & ( *""3 9, <*(( $ 3

" $* ( "0* "( ," ,""3: ( * ( , (

*""3 9, "0! "( ," 00 ($*

!" , ! <*" , *"' (3$ ,*0 *

! (!3*(( <* ""3$.;

B" " )**

**""3 /," " )*0(0, *(( 2 (

* *"B,"- )* ") ";(( /,"

" )* .(

2 (( * ( $ '*( ) .;@$ )"((3 0(, *""3 /," " )**

)" *" 9,( *" , * * *" B ,"- )* @$*(

*"!"*" ) 3 *" /,"

" )*8 ""3 .;@ ,"*" "0( * * * ( ( ," )&( *3"#," )*( ,"- )*%$ *'0"$! '" "

3 ,)*" " *

*","- )* * '" "

3$ ('

7, 0," '((: ")*(3*(!3!**("

!('**(

("0* ,""3! "( " "3""3 E"

, !( , 0 """0*"

" ,(

> 3 "," "" 6**("

," !('$

,( "7 * $*0")*(3

* , (!3* 2(

6* * ("

," !(' *0 " " ,""

) )

* (( '*( ""

" 0 ""'**'"" "

" :

" $ 9, (' ,*(

(9,

('$ 0(0 "

" * ( *" *" 3)", 0(!(*(( , " *., -!4," $## <*% 8!(," 4," '()*+,)-. !/0% 123(1'1%3.)* ,)-. !/0% 1 45 !

"0 , "

F ;" *%)*4," '*( )* ( "

*4.4$ "

!( "*%)* 4,"""*0 "" "

"'* ) ""!3*4," !(' ?"*A"

((4," *A"

((4,"* 7" " -,(

! ""

" ) " """ *" (' "

",""9," ) "

" (G E"

, !( , (()(3$

" 3""0"

3 ,) -,) "

!3*("

40(5,)5, "0 $ ,3

'(( -,) "

!3 * ("

( "5,)$% *","'**(( " 3 "

" !3 * 4," ( <*" (3 @3 "B ( )

= ) 0'* ** "* ! " $ *9, (3 ( ) * (* ! " "

( $" )(3 *""), * ! "

" )(3$* (

'* "" %,1*,66!

!" #$

# '7-3 "

;**" & )?"

H ? ;**"""!(

H ?