← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5087/2017dismissed

Rajan Kumar And ANR v. Bhupinder Singh And ORS

2018-02-14Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan8 pages



         

!"#$#%&'&() * 

!+!(,-.!/!($!("0#/ 11#22!("'

3#/'-'

/#''/0-1&($#/&(40"0/-405 '!($"0#/'

 #'1($#("'

 )  65  , 5 

/#'#(")7 /!1!(0&/8$9%!"#8/!11#22!("' 

 :0#"0#/"0# #1/"#/'2%!2(#;'1!1#/.!<=#!22;#$" '##"0#+-$4.#(">  =#/##//#$""0# #1/"#//(" ? :0#"0#/"0#+-$4.#("'0-2$=#/#1/"#$&("0#$&4#'"> 77 77 , 5    .1-4(#$&(1/#'#(" #4-2!/#%($11#!2&'"0#+-$4.#("

$!"#$  81!''#$=<2#!/(#$$$&"&(!2&'"/&%"-$4#8 5-$0&!(!8 !&/.&(4 "0#+-$4.#("!($ $#%/##$!"#$ *81!''#$=< 2#!/(#$ $$&"&(!2 &9&2 -$4# #(&/&9&'&( 85-$0&!(!89&$#;0&%0'-&"  12!&("&  /  '1#%&&%  1#//.!(%#   =< ;!<   !4/##.#("    '!2#  $!"#$

?;!'$#%/##$ -/"0#/$#%2!/!"&(;!'4/!("#$"0!"'!2#$##$ $!"#$*/#4!/$&(41/1#/"<.#!'-/&(4*'@-!/#<!/$'-""0# '-&"1/1#/"<#A#%-"#$$-/&(4"0#1#($#(%<'-&"=<$##($!("'   8 !($?&(!9-/$##($!("*&'&22#4!28(-22!($9&$0!9&(4( ##%"("0#/&40"'12!&("&!($&'0&"=<"0#$%"/&(# /-2#2&'1#($#(' $#%/##/1#/.!(#("&(+-(%"&(;!'!2'1!''#$8/#'"/!&(&(4$##($!("' /..!B&(4!(<!2&#(!"&(!($"/!('#/"0#'-&"1/1#/"<"'.#(# #2'##A%#1""12!&("&##($!("';#/#$&/#%"#$"#A#%-"#!($/#4&'"#/

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

/-($&";&"0&""#$&/( '0-""#/!2(4;&"0"0#;!"#/%((#%"&(!($'#;#/!4#8!''0;(&("0#'&"# 12!(!($$#"!&2#$&("0#0#!$("#12!&("("0&'/&4&(!2'-&"812!&("& 0!$%2!&.#$"0!" 0#0!$#("#/#$&("!(!4/##.#("'!2#"1-/%0!'#! '018.#!'-/&(4*'@-!/#<!/$'/""!2%('&$#/!"&( ' ;0&%0;!'1!<!=2#=<12!&("&"$##($!("'!""0#"&.##A#%-"&('!2# $##$ ##($!("'0!$!4/##$"  #A#%-"#"0#'!2#$##$ ( ?

2!&("&!//!(4#$/ 781!<!=2#"$##($!("'( ?

2!&("&;!'/#!$<!($;&22&(4"1#//.0&'1!/"%("/!%""4#""0#'!2# $##$#A#%-"#$##($!("'0!$1-/%0!'#$'"!.11!1#/'( ?-($#/ "0#'&4(!"-/#'(#$##($!("'!++!(,-.!/#/.'!($%($&"&(' '!2#$##$;#/#'#""2#$$-/&(4"0#;/B&(40-/'=#/#"0###$:/&"#/8 (!.#2<8!';&($#/&(408!"&'"/&%"-/"'85-$0&!(!8&("0#1/#'#(%# ;&"(#''#'8(!.#2<8/-/$#9&(40!($0-8#(&/ #'#!/%0 /#''/8 /#"&/#$/.  !($ !/.&($#/&(40'(,!/"!/&(408/#'&$#("

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

(+&"&(408 /1#/"<#!2#/0#/#;!'(/##%('#("$##($!("'" 1/#1!/#  "0#   '!2#  $##$  ;&"0  ""!2  '!2#  %('&$#/!"&(    '  7 ##($!("'$#(&#$"0!""0#/#;!'!(<!4/##.#(""1-/%0!'#'01.#!'-/&(4 *'@-!/#<!/$'/ 7";!''"!"#$"0!""0#<!/#.&4/!("'/.

""!/ !/$#'0 0#<!/#;(#/'"0#'!&$ 1/1#/"<8;0&%0"0#<0!9# 1-/%0!'#$ =<'!2#$##$  $!"#$  ?    ##($!("' !/# ;(#/' &( 1''#''&('!&$1/1#/"<;0&%0&'&("0#(!"-/#/#'&$#("&!27%-.7'01 ##($!("' 0!$/!&'#$%('"/-%"&(";'"/<#$ =-&2$&(4("0#'!&$ 1/1#/"<0#<0!9#"!B#(!1#/'(!22!( '88 7/.!(+&"

&(40'(1!2&(408/#'&$#("0&.2!1-/&85-$0&!(!8=<12#$4&(4 "0#&//&4&(!2'!2#$##$;&"00&.!(+&"&(408 /1#/"<#!2#/84"'.# =2!(B1!1#/' "0-.=.!/B#$!" "0!""&.#   ( / !=-" .&$$2#  !/%08?8$##($!("'0!$1!&$=!%B '8 7"'!&$!(+&"&(408 1/1#/"<$#!2#/ 2!&("&%("!%"#$$##($!("'"0/-40'!&$!(+&"&(40

7*7 &(-2<8?!($!4/##$"1-/%0!'#1/1#/"</.$##($!("'/!'!2# %('&$#/!"&( '88 7 /"0#1-/1'##A#%-"&(!4/##.#("

  '!2#  (  ?8  12!&("&  !($  !(+&"  &(408  1/1#/"<  $#!2#/  "B $##($!("'"#;-/"'85-$0&!(!8;0#/#12!&("&1!&$ ' 88 ;0&%0;#/#"!B#(=<1/1#/"<$#!2#/!(+&"&(408%2!&.&(4"=#$-#/. 0&. ";!/$' 0&' =!2!(%#2!( !.-(" !($  &("#/#'"   !%%/-#$  "0#/#(

2!&("&!($!(+&"&(4081/1#/"<$#!2#/8&(%('1&/!%<!($&(%((&9!(%# ;&"0#!%0"0#/$&'0(#'"2<&('"#!$4#""&(4!4/##.#("'!2##A#%-"#$8 4"1/#1!/#$!'!2#$##$'!&$1/1#/"< !($=<.&'/#1/#'#("!"&(!($ /!-$8="!&(#$"0-.=&.1/#''&('$##($!("'-";0#( !/!.+&"

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

7";!''"!"#$"0!"12!&("&&( %('1&/!%<;&"0!(+&"&(4081/1#/"<$#!2#/8/4#$"0#/#%/$

77 1-/%0!'#'"!.11!1#/' " %.#' -" "0!"  9&$#/$#/ $!"#$  C8 12!&("& ( !%%-("(=+#%"&(/.$##($!("'8;!'!22;#$"!.#($"0#12!&("8 '!'" %(9#/""0#'-&"&(""0#'-&"/1''#''&( =<;!<'1#%&&% 1#//.!(%#  !($  !2'  %2!&.'    $#%2!/!"&(  /#4!/$&(4  '!2#  $##$  $!"#$ *8/#4&'"#/#$$-/&(4"0#1#($#(%<'-&"&(!9-/ $##($!(" *("0#'!&$!.#($#$12!&("8'.#!$$&"&(!2!9#/.#("';#/#.!$# "0!"'!2#$##$$!"#*8&'#A#%-"#$=<$##($!("'

 8!($?

&(!9-/$##($!(" *$-/&(4"0#1#($#(%<'-&"!($0&" =< $%"/&(# /-2#2&'1#($#('!($&'2&!=2#"=#'#"!'&$# ("0#!.#($#$;/&""#('"!"#.#("8$##($!("''.#/'!-2"#$!($ %.12#"#2<   %0!(4#$  "0#&/  '"!($   (  "0#  !.#($#$  ;/&""#(  '"!"#.#("8 $##($!("'$#(&#$"0!9##A#%-"#$ !(<!4/##.#("'!2# 0#<!2' $#(&#$"0!9#/#%#&9#$!(<!.-("0#<!2'$#(&#$"0!9#!4/##$" #A#%-"#'!2#$##$;&"0"0#&%#-= #4&'"/!/85-$0&!(!";!'!2' $#(&#$"0!""#/.'!($%($&"&(';#/#'#""2#$ -/%0!'#'"!.11!1#/'

;!'!2'$#(&#$0#'"/<$##($!("''2&11&(4!;!</."0#&%# $##$;/&"#/;!'!2'$#(&#$("0#!.#($#$;/&""#('"!"#.#("8$##($!("' .!$#%.12#"#$#(&!2"0#!%"'.!$#&("0#12!&("

/."0#12#!$&(4'822;&(4&''-#';#/#/!.#$)7

 :0#"0#/$##($!("' "?#A#%-"#$'!2#!4/##.#("$!"#$

?&(!9-/12!&("&@-!"0#'-&"1/1#/"<>

 :0#"0#/$##($!("' "?0!9#/#%#&9#$"0##("&/#'!2# %('&$#/!"&( 7>

 ? :0#"0#/"0#12!&("&&''"&22/#!$<!($;&22&(4"1#//.0&' 1!/"<"0#%("/!%">

7D7 * :0#"0#/  12!&("&  &'    #("&"2#$  "  "0#  /#2&#    '1#%&&% 1#//.!(%#!'1/!<#$/>

 :0#"0#/"0#'!2#$##$#A#%-"#$=<$##($!"(' "?$!"#$ *&'&22#4!2(-22!($9&$!($;&"0-"!(<%('&$#/!"&(>

D :0#"0#/12!&("&&' #("&"2#$""0#/#2&#$#%2!/!"&(!' 1/!<#$/>

 :0#"0#/"0#'-&""0#12!&("&&'("2#4!22<.!&("!&(!=2#&( "0#1/#'#("/.> 

"?   :0#"0#/"0#!4/##.#("$!"#$ ?;!'("#A#%-"#$=< $##($!("' "?&(!9-/12!&("&>  C :0#"0#/"0#12!&("&0!''-11/#''#$"0#.!"#/&!2!%"'/."0# B(;2#$4#"0#-/"> 

 :0#"0#/   "0#  $##($!("    *  &'  !  =(!&$#  1-/%0!'#/  / %('&$#/!"&(;&"0-"!(<("&%#!=-""0#/&40"'"0#12!&("&@-!"0#'-&" 1/1#/"<> *



#2&# "#/4&(4"0/-40"0##9&$#(%#!($"0#$%-.#("'12!%#$( &2#8 "0#"/&!2-/"$#%/##$"0#  '-&" 0#+-$4.#(";!'-10#2$&("0# !11#!2 0!9#0#!/$"0#2#!/(#$%-('#2/!11#22!("'!($0!9#!2' %!/#-22<4(#"0/-40"0#&2#!($"0#2;#/-/"&2#!';#22 0#"/&!2 -/" 0!'"!B#(&(" %('&$#/!"&( "0#!$.&''&(' .!$#&("0#-(!.#($#$;/&""#('"!"#.#(";0#/#$##($!("'0!$!$.&""#$ "0!""0#<;#/#!11/!%0#$=<12!&("&"0-40"0/-40(#!(+&"&(408 1/1#/"<$#!2#/!($0!$/#%#&9#$!'-. 88 78;0&%0"0#<0!$ 4&9#("!(+&"&(4081/1#/"<$#!2#/0#<!2'!$.&""#$"0!9#"0-.=

77 .!/B#$"0#;/&"&(48"0-408&";!'%2!&.#$"=#!4/##.#("'!2#!($(" '!2#$##$0#<0!$12#!$#$.&'/#1/#'#("!"&(!($/!-$&("0##A#%-"&( '!&$'!2#$##$("0&';!<8#A#%-"&(!$%-.#("8;0&%0&''!2#$##$8 ;!'!$.&""#$8"0-408.&'/#1/#'#("!"&(!($/!-$;!'12#!$#$0-408 &"  ;!'  %2!&.#$  "0!"  &(!%"  "0#<;!("#$ "   #A#%-"# !4/##.#("    '!2#8 0;#9#/8!""0#'!.#"&.#8"0#<0!9#'"!"#$"0!";0#("0#<%!.#"B(; "0!"&"&'!'!2#$##$!($(" !4/##.#("'!2#8"0#<$#.!($#$=!%B /#.!&(&(4!.-("'!2#%('&$#/!"&( '88 7!'"0#<0!$ !4/##$"#A#%-"# !4/##.#("'!2#/ '88 7!($("/ '

88 7

/#'#("12!&("&&'!1/#''/=<1/#''&((/$#/"1/9# #A#%-"&('!2#$##$812!&("&#A!.&(#$  !/.&($#/&(40 

: !($ -/$#9&(40

: 8.!/4&(!2;&"(#''#'(-(!.#($#$;/&""#('"!"#.#("8 12#!.&'/#1/#'#("!"&(!($/!-$;!'"!B#(!($!$.&''&(;!'.!$#"0!" "0#'!&$$%-.#("8;0&%0&'&(!%"!'!2#$##$8;!'#A#%-"#$0-408&" ;!'12#!$#$"0!"$##($!("';!("#$"#A#%-"#!4/##.#("'!2#!($/!-$ !($.&'/#1/#'#("!"&(;#/#12#!$#$;#9#/8'-%0.&'/#1/#'#("!"&(!($ /!-$ ;#/#(#9#/1/9#$  0#'!2#%('&$#/!"&(;!'!2'!$.&""#$

2!&("&    0!'"0#/;&'#1/9#$"0!"""!2'!2#%('&$#/!"&(  '

8 7;!'1!&$;0&%0;!'/#%/$#$&("0#'!2#$##$ 2!&("&0!'

!2'1/9#$"0!"'"!.11!1#/';#/#1-/%0!'#$"0/-40(#"0#9#($##' 0# #("/</#4!/$&(41-/%0!'#'"!.11!1#/' ((#A-/#7 !2'=#!/'

"0-.=&.1/#''&((#$##($!("'8!++!(,-.!/0#/&4&(!2'!2# $##$ A :D

=#!/'"0#"0-.=&.1/#''&('!22"0#$##($!("'0#< 0!9#("2#$!(<#9&$#(%#!'"0;/!-$!($.&'/#1/#'#("!"&(;#/# %..&""#$;&"0"0#."&''1#%&&%!22</#%/$#$&("0#'!&$'!2#$##$"0!"

77 #("&/#!.-("0!'!2/#!$<=##(/#%#&9#$ 0#2#!/(#$%-('#2/!11#22!("'0!'"/&#$"/#2<-1("0# '"!"#.#("!$##$;/&"#/8;0'!<'"0!"0#$#'("B(;"0#1!/"&#'!($ 1!<.#(";!'(".!$#&(0&'1/#'#(%#;#9#/8(#"0#;&"(#''#''!<' "0!"1!<.#(";!'/#%#&9#$=<'#22#/'##($!("'0!9#!&2#$"$&'%0!/4# 0#!9<=-/$#(1/9&(4 .&'/#1/#'#("!"&(!($/!-$12!<#$;&"0"0#. 0#/#/#8"0#/#&'(&22#4!2&"</&(&/.&"<&("0#&($&(4'/#%/$#$=<="0 "0#-/"'=#2;0#&($&(4'!%"'0!9#=##(/#%/$#$2!;1&(" !/&'#'#(%#8&('"!(" #4-2!/#%($11#!2&'$&'.&''#$&(2&.&(#

, 5   

*  '+B' :0#"0#/'1#!B&(4 /#!'(#$ ) #'  :0#"0#/ #1/"!=2# ) #'