← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4611/2018dismissed

Bal Kishan v. Keshav Kumar And ORS

2024-07-17Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja14 pages

   

  

  

   !

 " !# $% &'(   



          

 " ) $% &'(   



          

 * " !!

$% &'(              



'

 +, ' " - "' 

 !"  !   !"  "

#    $%&''()*+,-,*'.  / "  "

#    -%%0,-,*'. 11111 - "' % ./0(

'

)!

 !" !!

$

2            #  3     

         # 

$'-  

 4  

  #   -        #   "2 

  !

"

35

   5 

         

     ,  # 

     

   3  

           # 

$' 

 # 

 

 '//1%1( ' 7    5   #        #  3





  2   8  #! #  9  

"   

#-%&''- ,*'. :( , 2 !2  #      "  

   3

     

5 

'+*',*'.

32 

; <

"

 !"! 32" $'"

 

          5 

'+*',*') 

32 

 =<

 ; " ! = $,%0#,**+" !

 > 7      !    $)+-"  >%)8?

"

 

7! " !

 2$ 4 $)+-"  >%)82  

 

7! " !"

 2$7        2   

 3   3 "        !  

  $'    ,@ ##   A       B

5

 2C    

D ##E#

#  32 !2#



3

   

'''*,**&





   @

 $'A C

  #  

D

 $'EB!

 

 

" 2$! 

 32

-

 $'

     >%)82 F'+"***@- 82  ## 

$'- ##$'!,*'',**&3     #') !



32 

  2B! 

   "    

  



 ## 2##2 3 "   

 !

F,'",)*@- 82 B  "2 !

# # # 2$ ## ##3 

!   

 $>    %@

   $,    >  A         

 2C   #  

D

 $, >E" 

3# #2 

3

B !# 

    3   2 !  



"

#!   32 

"

 % B    "!   #!  !

#

 ##

 $'!



 $, >

 2B !  #

 3 ##

 $'" #

 # 

'''*,**&8 2

 GH"3 



#  2   !

  

"!

" 2   !

!     ## $' !   2   !  #  # 

 

     

 8  3 2 8 2

GH" !

 2

 " ## !  6 

 B        !   " 

   $,    >



# 2#2 3

  2$ B 

 # 

   #!  !

#

32 =3 !

-  



   !"! !

!

 !$%$&$!

'

' !( '!

'!

'    ) **  



  $ & 

"! !(  !

'!

') **  # !





!(



%) *+      



   !  !'#  

 ! 

    # ) *+ , 



 !'#!

' !

!



 # ) *+   - ) 7 7=

5 

'+*',*')   

  #   # #  ## $'   

 #

'''*,**&"!

"  -

  

   

 #     32  !2  #  



8 2

GH#   #



3  !  #

 8  "

!

"!

      

# # #   # !  F+I   #2 8 2$"  =  

       !    

   

   

#"#! 

!

#

-  .!/   

    

,      .!/                .!01!!%2' !

/       

   & 7     =  

   5   

'+*',*'." 2



   $' 

 D 

       E"  

##   32!2#



8 2$"!

   

#  8 2$"!     #2 3

 2" $,"



             "! !

   

# # # 2$32

 $' 9 "  -35

 @   $>"  

      

  "!!

  ##  #   2  ') 



32

 $'  #  

'''*,**&J  ## #

 3   !  # # 

 0 ;

 $'3   

#5 

'+*',*'.

  $' $,#

! 3  -%&''-,*'."

    

  E -)*+,-,*'."  

           "

 2"  ! 32   #      #   #   2  $    !  

 ## ##!



 $, >B 

 "

-%%0,-,*'."

 

    ! #

 32   ##  3    

 #       #  

-35

 @ $>"! 32"  2#') 

   

 

'''*,**&" !

  3

## 

 . B   5 

'+*',*'.

32  #     ="  

           #! 3  -

' $ # ## ##!



  $, >   # # 2$  

  

 #  32!2#



#

  

#  ###  #"#

 ! 8

#

32 

    ! 2  

 ,) '#

 =   "'.0, #"D'.0, E3

  8           #   #   2  $  3

   #2 3

!  #

3  !3  !

 

    " 

 

 5 # :  4   =  

                 

    

  ! "#  $%&"

, 

        !           

*>'*,**+ K6 -'*!

## 

,*'',**&

K6 -.     

 3 #    3-   3      # 2$! 

   2    "

     



 4  3 " ##$,     2 

 

 $' #   2

GH  3# 2  

 

> 

          3     

   $,    >  !

   3

#    #    

 #2

3 "!

"  !  3 # 7="

2

 2 #2 3

 "

    " #8 2$! 8

  4  #   3           

 "      #

  32  !2  #           8    #  #    5  !#

 3 ## ##

 $, (>  

 $'8 2$"!  "      !



 !! !  '''*,**&  "  2   # #2   3   !2 

"!3



% 

    #  #

 

32

 $' ;L-'%"!

 

###  2$!  

32#! #  "

! 8  # 2#2 3

8

  +

  "3   

#

# ##  32 !2  #  

    8   2 

   GH    !

   ##   #     2       ')       

  

 

 8  " 3  $-%%0,-,*'. # '!!%2' !

0.!"3



 3 ##  ##- 

$' ,   "

     

3

  # ##



 ## ##$'@

!      !  !  8

3

"

2"

!

 # 

!

32

 $, > B 

 "

  3#

 #

   ##$'

L-'" 

8 !

 

!    2



 ! 2 3

#),      !   ##

#3- 9 "



  3

 !    # ##$'!

 

" ##  #  2



32#  =!!2 

# 2  '* B  

  #     

 3 !



! 32

   B 3

# 3

3 

 3 ##   

  '' 7   

32 

    

!   #!  -

'''   $'

-    32#  # #  32!2#



8 2$  #   32##

 "23  

    

35

 ! 

32

 $' !

 K    ##

!  

323 #

=3 ! "3 

 # 

  "

   $'     3   

      2       

   35

         -     ##  

   $,  (  >

 2"  2 

  35

 3



  

#

 $'   ## #!  "

 !  3

 ##

2 



 2 9  " 2   #    2 $ 6

 

-

4  % 5 (

$ ' !! !

%$&$!

'

' !( '

"!!$

#(!  '#$  (  !

 

   .!  %  !

   

  

"(     /($6

$% 

7!#!





 !

!(    "

    .!! 

'



 !

!(      !"8'# !

!

  

"! !$(  !

 

.! %!





  7!# ( '!

 !

!

"( !    -   #! 

  

               #2   3

      8  2$"

2 #  !

"

35

 

 3 ##  ##"3 

 8  3

2

#"  3  

#  #  ##!



 $, >"  !

#

     #2 "

 !   

#  

2

2   

'', 9 "    3 #   

 3 # #

 =   

 8  3    #

3 8 ## 2$  3##2   #

 ,)# '.0, "  !

 

 B  "23  

 

 8           3      #2     8  2$3

  #  

#  #   ## ##!



 $, >8 2 $

 2

!

 #2 

   3

      8   2  $      3     

 

3 

# 

8



##2 B    

"   

 3 ##

 $'!

   

 

 ,)# '+0, " 

 

 

''>   $, -$   3 # 3  

 3 ##

     ##

   



 *>'*,**+  K6 -'*J         ##  

,*'',**& K6 -.

# 3 " 2   !    

 8   #   #   2  $      3  #  #2 B  "23  

  

*>'*,**+ K6 -'*"! ! 

 

 $'32 ## $'  ## 

,*'',**& K6 -.# ##$'

# 3-  #

 

    "!

3          !   !     

 #  

'''*,**&"! !

 2 8



   

 #  

   #  #     32  !2  #  



 4!

"    2 

 #  # #  #  2

GH"! 23

 #2 "#! "   

 3  ! ! 8

"  -   # 8 2 GH   

*>'*,**+ K6 -'*"## 

,*'',**&

K6 -.  ##    2  

 

  $'   # # 2GH!

 3  

#

 # ##!



 $, >"! ! 

2  3# #2 

''%   $> %3    



!5 2

  #

! #

 # !

"#

 3 ## ##!



 $, >8  2GH"! !3

     !! !  '''*,**&  2!  2



'''*,**&

K6 -'!

 



    

        #2     3

    8  2GH3  # 

32

 $' ## ## !



 $, >7  8

  2#   

  2 3 ##2 3



3

8 2GH#!

32! !#  '''*,**&7"  3  

#   # ##!



 $, >"

2"!

 $' 

   

'''*,**& K6 -' !   

  

      

#2 

3

8 2$7 "

 !

!   3 ##

 $'3   #   #2 8 2$ 

 

   

 ##

2

 "!

" 3

# 2 



32

 $'  # ## "  

32 =3 !       #   

3

3   

#=

 ##  !     B  2    3  

        - 6  "

 $'!  ;L-'%!

   # #  # 2

 ###   

#  !



#   !   8  

  "  ;L-'%     

     - 6     

 3

3

 !  

# 

*>'*,**+  K6- -'*    #  #  "  3"      2    

 !

 

32   ##

 $,(> 3

# 2

 !      3 #2  

 8      

 2#  # 

   





32 9  "

 #

'''*,**&!

 

" #! 3  ###2 3

8 2GH"    

   ##

  

K82 "

  ! 3

## # #  2





'''*,**& K6 -'"

 $'  3  

 3!  3 !

2  #2 

 8 2GH

2 #

 3 2 #  '') 3   "    3 # 3  

 3 ##

     

##2 

32

 $, >  !  3 #

= !  6

32 !  

L-') L-'&"

 2"!   2

2 



##2 3

8 2GH ', :   2"  3   #="  

   3 # !    

 3 ##  -  ##  $'             # 

  # 

  #

  

 8  32

 $'  !  #

-  !  8



 



 2" #           !

2 8 #

 '& '

# 

 # "'+&>"

!  5  

@     =#  #

   32!2#



3

  

    !  ##

  "3    " 2 #3

  

 3 !  ##! 

 



',' 9  "        # "            #

- ##$'! 

 

  3 





32 3

  

 "  #

  3  "  6  

#  

  #! 

23!

    

#! "   

- ##$'#



3

2  # 

 8  !



 '''*,**&!,*'',**&3     "

! " !#

 3 # # 

# 2  #   >*'*,**+ $ 3" !#

!    # #*> 

 !

  )%#   "'+&>"

!

"      

#    "

 #

   3 # 62#2  #  "  32

2     " = ! 2

     ## ##$'#  #

#







',,  "  #

 ##  #   23

    2

GH





'''*,**&"   2  2   3 #  J  ##$' #

 3  !   #      #     

      ##   3

 

2 



 

  "  23  ,*I#   

   H3  



"   # 5     H3  

  

  $' '> B  !#   

  3 #         "     #  



3  

"   32" 

 '%

   "# 2"  

# '0*0,*,%  %- "' (     

L   @ 

?

@$ L  3

?

@$