High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4615/2018allowed

Boota Singh And ORS v. Puran Singh And ANR

2022-12-12Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

! !"

##$$ %"& '&" ! !"

# '"

(!)&#*+ "!##$$

,$*+ ""# .+"

////

"$0*!"!#$ '&"

!!1"& !+$& ! &"!"( # , "#$- .23&"

3"$ & +$$ 43 * 5!$ 6 " * " 7&! &$$0"1 !! !#$ 1 "+ " " 3 "0 8& " 9

'& 81 '," :"#" 7 !" " """ ':':7"3+$"03" $$$$ $$0 !

3 !#$ &"!"#"0 !" " #"3 8& "" - "3 ""0 & "& 03

" !#$10!3$+"

!"3#$0*1# +&"!#$ !

#"!+" !#$ *!1$&, " !#$ &!+ #&"!"3)+"

3 ;

<=2"&3 <. $0>!+ # !#$ !1 ! +"!#$ !+"00" 3&

,$ " ! 3 ! 3 "$ !"+ &"">!#$ $!#$,! 1& "0,$$ "&!" $!& #" !#$1 "& +" !"(# ! 3$>

6 &"0* * - !##"!!#$ "?& !3$$,!3&3#" !#$ $ "(# !" 3$ !@&!!"!"

(# 3$,& " "& >!#$ #"3! - &#" !#$,! $"

& " !!0,&$&!#" "(# !"

3$ $0 ,&$! +"!+ # ,! +"

!#$ "?&">!#$ !$$, -

2 &#" !#$ #&$ ,!&" " ! #"#"0 ,!& ! +" @$&+ # !3> " ,#10 - ! #$ #$ !$$,!3&!#$ & - 1 !$"$+>!#$ !1

1" !@# &""3 !#$!3$> ! 3 !0* *!#$ "?&! + !#" !#$ !"# "!" !!0! 3#$! "& 3$! !#$, #10!31&! "&*"!"!0 ("1$# ! "#$> 6 "

! !" ! ! , #$ "+* ! ,&$ 3#$!#$ 3$*!(!3+ !#$>!#$ ,"!"&"#"( ,! - ,!3$ "1!#"#"0!#$ ! $$ $"03" ! 3 !#$ !1 3$ 1"&3 >!#$ &13 3#$ !" " *'':7*!, *6 " 1& !3", "3+>01"$ !&*! - !$$1&$ 3"$!# """0& "& !#$>!0,"##"3 10!#$ $ ,!!"#" !1&"! ,! "&$0 A$ !" *!#$ 1"& !!&

* - #& ##" !:&" $," 3 !&"

#"$3 "0 18 ! & ! #$ , $ "+$& !1 $,! &$""3+>#"+&$0 & & $ B4$ ! %"& '&" !B $"0 # !:&" ,!!!3" "+"0"$0 &1 $$0!3 +$+ !#" &*!""* !#" &"+10& " :':>!& !#$ 3 1$ 1" 8 "

"0#" 4$ ! 7(! !+$$ 4 ! 1 8 !1 *!&

1 +$0>!&! 1 +$&#"#"$0"! #&"#:&" 8&" >!&1"38 " #"

3"*! !!!& +$+ !& # 6 " !1" '$- .* 3&" 9 3, "!#4$ !+$$ 4 *5!$6 " ,#&"!104$ !+ +0 = <= &$0 @& 10 5!$"

$*7&! " " .>! +0 ,$$,1033$+"0# 4$ ! 4$ !*,!!, "!!& &> 4$ !!## 6 " ! !$,&$

0+" "#,""

0 =

<< >4$ !"$ &3 #" "3 #$ "3 > ! 1 6 " ! - $( " 3 !!&4$ ! 3 !3>6 "

! $ ,!!3$0!1 #& &#

!!& !&#$> $"03"- = ==, $$ !!& &*,!! ! 3 9 !*,!"$1"!" 6 " !>! $"03", $$ $$0

10!#$

+ ,!!#,""#" $>$ $ ! 1 & "

'':7$"" $$ !3"> "!!&!#$ "

*!3& !,"

!!&4$ !>!#$ $0

$$3+"!!&4$ !( & &+ !!3& !1 +0 +&" 4$ !, +" $0 104$ !

"+ &"">!#$ $"0 (& &+ ! 3 &" ! $&3 , "!# 831 #" 2 .= ! !" (!" - => ! #$

# !!& "&10!3 !"

! 3 !"+ &""!#*,!!& ! ,"

!!&4$ !>!#$ ! "

,!!!&4$ !*!,+"!+ &"

"0*!#$ "0 "1!!&4$ !10 " !$$3!"& !!#" & " " ! +0 3 10 ! #$ * ! #" !&4$ !*"!""$, !&#$ *,!!&

!,"

!&4$ !>!!& #&, "&104$ ! 1$ #$

@$&+# 4$ ! 6 " !

$,&$"

04$ !

& !"3 " * &! #"0"3$!&

!#"," 3 $10 (&##"$3 "018 !#$ ! $& $!& &!&$1$10 1& !"&$B4$ !%"&'&" !B,!! #"" 3$"0 # !:&"6 "

(+"&!"18 *,>!#$ ! ##"!!:&",!$ ! ##10!,

& "3 $ ! #" &

3"* &!

! !$!&$ B4$ !%"&'&" !B ,!!!$$ , "!# 4$ !+"!#&,!" - " $+

5!#$ ! $$0 34$ !#"0

!#" & 5! ! $$

3 ! # !!& 5! $ 3#$ 10#$ 2

"3+$!$"03" 3>!

6 " ! ! $ $ +$ & " " #"3 8& !#0"

04$ !$B4$ !

%"& '&" !B 0 ! "3 $$ * &!

$#"0"3$!&

#$ , $

!#$ !#"* $$, &,""3

C!!"!#$ $""# ! &#"#"0, "D ''

C!!" ! #$ $ " " 3 "0 8& #"0"D '' C!!" ! #$ $ " " #"3 8& #"0"D '' C!!"!&$1$10& " :':D

' C!!"!&#$ 3 1$D ' C!!"!&! 1 #"#"$0+$&"!#&"# &" 8&" D ' = C!!"!&1"38 "!#"D '

C!!"!#$ ! $& $!#" &D '

< C!!"!#$ ! 3!&",!$

! !##10!, &"3 $ !#" &D '

$ !!#"$+ "#!"$3

&" ! &" + * ! #$ ! 3 ""'C ! " + !+ E@ ' ##"! F$@3 !& ! 4$ !'C ++E@ ' #$ !'C2++E@ ':

C!!!+ ! #$ $

;

"1&$ ! @3 $ !* 433*,"

*6 " !CC+!"

+E@ E@ : E@ C."#+$0 !

$!"+ "!" !$"

& $"!#"*!"$ :&":+$6& 6"

*6 " +8& 3 "

=3!&,!

5!#$ , "+10!8& 3 " !!$ ##$1"!:&""6& * 7&! * ,!! , $ " 6& * 7&! *,!+8& 3 "

# !##$*!8& 3 "#10!"$

< :&" "!&!#$

A$ "+ 10 ! 8& 3 "* - !+$!#" " &$" ##$

# #$ !$$+#

;!+!"$"

& $"!#"1

!"& !!""

5!"$:&" $0+ $ !! "&3 ! 03" !& !#$ "8!3 5!"$:&"!1"+ !!#$ 10,0$ !&,( #

#$- 2$3 !!,, "!3*,!"! +" ! ,!!#&#"#"01"- *,!!,$$ 4$ ! ,4$ !*,! !## 6 " !9 !$,&$"

0* ,!$( " 3 !!& & C $ ! ! "@3 ! ! #"#"0 , $$!!"4$ !*,!"C 43 ! !!"!"4$ !!$#"#"06 " !

C2,"

!""@3 !"$0! $ ,$$!"!" ! !!3,$10!"

!"6 " !

F,+"*! !"$:&",! +$&!#$ !#"+! ! ! , $ !

(!+ !,( !

5!#$ !3$##" 'C ! "@3 !3!"(!"- =$$ !310!)+"

3 !# !! "& !!&+"!"$$!31" (!"- =1& 0"1( ! # !!& &*!$,!!

"& !!"!$*!&"!" !$

" !"$:&", & ",!0'&"

!!$&"# ,! " !3!

# #$$$!3 (!"- = 5!""* &- , !#$ 1"+ !!!,

$""# !&#"#"0 ;& - 2,"$ !3!$ !#$ $"3 "0 8& #"3 8& #"0 "

$0 !1! &!#$ ! 1 310!"$:&"

-, 3 ! 8& 3 " " 10 ! A" ##$$ :&" $ " 6& * 7&! * ,! 1"+!!##$$ .#$ $3 !3$1, "

3"$ $ 1" - .2* ,!" " $3 !"" !+"#"#"0- .*,!!3&" !, "!#4$ !10,0 +0 = <= 4$ !!@&#,""

+&"6 " !

5!$"

! 3

"# !

'C'&" !!3 ! "@3 !"(!"- =,!!,$$ !310!)+"

3 * !# !! "& !!&+"!"1&0"1( ! !

# " $!&*,!! "& !$! #" !"$$!3 'C !& !!3 !"@3 !!! 0&3 " "

, "!#&$ "!( ,1&!$$3 !$

C $ !*C 433*C2,"

,!" !$" 4$ !!+!4$ !$+

5!",!!3, !!+$0 !3 $"6& # !##$ " ! &!#$ ##"1!!#$ .##$$ ! #$ ""#$ E@ ',!" & "#$ , #"+ + 10!"# C,! !, #$

E@ '!!#&#"#"0 &31"! #&#"#"02*,!" &31"#"#"0$$ 4$ ! 5!&3&!#"#"0 #&1" - 2 #$ "" " # 7"

$"6& *7&! !", " !$ , 104$ !!"! $ , 10##$$ *,!! !#"#"0 #&!, #$ E@ ' 3 10C6 " ! !"@3

A"!" *!

##$!1 #

A$ "+ ! - !+ ##"!!:&"10,0$ !#" " &$" ##$ %""< =

<* "

5!$"6 " , "#&33# "+ &$3"! #$1" - 2$$"# .#$ #" !1!!" + & &13"#" ;

3#$ ,! !* "#" $ ,!

@&" ! 1

"!" $"

& $"!#"

!"& !!""*; !!3 10#+ ,!!3 1#"+ C! #$ '&" ! &" ! &" ! "@3 ! "$$03 !"@3 ,!$##" 'C!!"4!"- =*,!!,$$!310! )+"

3 !# >!! "&!!&+"

!"$$!3 (!"- =1&0"1(

# !!&*!$!#" 3 "" $ #&"# !$"!" $*!$!! #$

5!"$:&",8& ", ! $&

!,! !,&$#$ !+$&"#

! 3#$ ! !0 " ," &$

2 # !!&$ 5!$3!#$ , " !$0"810!"$:&" &!A"##$$:&"10 3##"$!+ ," "#" $, $ $ &$# "!&!#$ *,!!

1& $ $$0 "!"$1$1 10,0# !##$

&$ $0 ! 8& 3 " # 10 $"6& *7&! " !8& 3 "#10!"$:&"3 !&#$ """ 5!""*!&!#$ 3

5!##$ $$," $0,!

! #" ##$ $$,* ! 3$$ &##$

* 0* #" $0

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#