High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5163/2017dismissed

Chariman Pspcl And ORS v. Dia

2018-04-17Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan16 pages

!"#$

!

"

#%

&' #

! #

$

%%% & "'()"'(*&'&+,

# -

. -

.//.0 1

-

.

# / -2

- -

-

1 3 # / 3// . 0 4 / / / -/ $- / / -. / 5

/

& /

/ -

-.

-

& -

/ 1$ 6

/

'/

.

5 - -

-$/

/

7

$ 0 # -

0 '/

-

"

21

- 8

# / .

. -0 /

9 : $ ( ;;< < =7 $

.0 # 0 & / / .0 $

# / .

. 0

-0

-

.

0 -

. $ 7 /

- .

- /

/ /0

.

/ .0 0

-

#$ 5

6

" ! -> > ?

?& @ / -

- . - $ . . ? "$ !5 & -0

& 3@4 -

- . 5

& .

0 / - 8

- 8 / - ;

8

- A ;

8 &$

# . /$ .0@8 ?. - 0

& -

: * ( ? $ & $

. 0 )6 @=2 /

. 0 ==B @A ', ?

"5$ 7 0)6 @A2-

- '

7 0 /

$ 0(-$- / /

- # / :

/ / // . 8 0 -/ 0 -

0

/ /

. 5

& 5 -

.

#

/?

-0 $ . 5 :

- /?

-0 '

$

6 * :# ) . $ >" @/

$ < =- 0 .0

$

#

#

# /$ .

. $ / $

)$ #

. 6 . .0

9 @

/

-

( )6 $) - ( -

)6 $) - ##

. $ - -

?

-

$

#

/ .0"

?

-

#

#

.5

-

/ / 7 #

/

&/$

/ "

?"

?

"-

- < = .0

/

$ / $/

# - .

$ -.

-#

/

0

- 5

7 -

./$ 0 - $ - / -/ . 0

- - 2-

#/ .

.

'/

/

-0

/

.0 /

.

< =7 - $

/

- / .

. 0

'/

$

7 / $

: ;" / - 0 < =.0/0

0$ .

&$ -

'

#

./ $ $ 5 /

.0

- / $- /

-$ # - $. / ? - $ /

6 5

# 07 .

/ -

/ 0 . 0 - - 2

$ -.

-

-$ / 06 - $

.0 7 -

.$ 3

- / $

- . $ 4C # 7 0.

.0

/ - $ )*+,*+ - ./0

1* 0/2.) 3.34 54637,6,38 .79 ./9

3+47*

!$ !,:,5$ ;< / //

/ -

5

.0 - / $ / # /

- . 0

@ 0 -

/ / . 5

&

/

/

#/

- -

.

- - # ) 0 > / -

/ . / $0

6 0 -

/

/ .

-$ .0 -

/

. # / / 0 - - > . / -

.0 D

"5 - .

$

!

"

#

$%$#&

&"

' (

)

'

) "

"

* +

'

)

"

) "

* +

,-

./

'

)

(

"

* )

'

' &1#2

* )"$

* +

'

3

4 5" 6

7 8

* 7 " %

"

"

" (

"

'

* +

' "

(

* ) $"

* +

&0 - /"

"

+ "

7

7 8"99 9

* 7

* )" $"

0 /"

+

"

"

"

0 5

:

"

(

( '

"

;

"

3

(

(

!"

#$% & "

3

6

< 5

* )"$

= :>

* )"$"

* 0 ) * 7 7 8"99"

9% 9

+

"+

(

+

' (

"

@+

"

(

:

'( )*

# +,& $-.+."

< 5

(

=

$ !

/ * * # / # $% ++0 / 1&

2

#$% ++2

* +

(

(

$

* +

)

'

"

A

(

* +

'

)

( "5

(

?

"

'

"

"

* +

3

>

* +

$%9

B '/ / $$

) 0 $ 0

-

# $

. $

$ 6 -

&

/

/ -/ .$ #7 / -

- .>./ :

3.34

.78./. !$ !7,>,/.5$

!"$ '

0 " - / ? E

-$ D . $ -

; E 5

' .

/

.$

/ B

. 0 #

>

/ E

.

'/

-$-

:$

( $ - # D

0 /

#

0$

/ 0

F

CDE

0

* )"8$$#1

)20 &

)

"

-

"

(

"

0 &182

)0 & /3

"

;

* + @C

0

&

) =D :&12 )

"

) -

"

(

D 182 8

D 12 D 12

'

(

.

2

. 12

1#2

) -

"

D 12"

1

2

192

) -

(

1%2A

;

"

" (

"

"

(" *'

3

) -

"

"

"

;

( 12A

D 1%2" *'

3

D

"

'

"

( "

*' D4 "

' :

:

"

";

:

&7

* 7 %1 :

7 :2

0 6 /

(

* 7

=D :0

=D12*

"1

D 2

( 182)

D 12 1#2

'D

(

7"

D

"

"

"D

F:

D8$7 8"99"9% 9

* 7 %

(

+ @C

7

=D :8 # # * # * 3

** ** D12)

"

"

"

"

"

" (

G

" F 1820

"

G+ 0 FG

C * 5

F

"

1#2

G+ 0 F

:

'''''''''

99 (D 12 " * <

<

" * <

("

'

"

"

D

12 0 8

4 )" 9& 1# 9&2

"

" 1825

5

0

-

'

5

0 -

1#2

"

"

D

"

?

D 12 192

'D

"

"

(

(

9% 6

" G " F"

" " ( D 12 C

("

" "

;

' " ' "

" "

"

"

G " " F

G " " F

'

0

-

0 -

= 6

( '

5 -

"

"

5 -

0

-

"

!-

" '

"

" (

G " "

F

D (

0

-

182 C (

D 12

( F

96

"D1212A

"

'

1

2

0 -

1

"

5 -

"

"

5 -

12

'

"

'

F 2A

5

0 -

D 182

9) 120

;

"

) '

H) "

"

18212

0 -

"

"

2

"

0

"

"

12

D 182 7 9)

) '

H

"

G

F

= 6

= 6

9&

= 6

9 1#2C

"

:

&$ - 0 $

$ / - .0 !

! 7 . 0

88 !

"33

=D :

: :

@

0 * + "

) '5

< 5

3 "3

6

"!"I

- ;

@

;

@

* )" 8$$#1

* ) $"

* 0 )"9&

7

24 @

* :0 :

:0 :

"

(

;

;

@

?

"

=

#

.114$% &&

55 67 8

85 9:/5

1.3,

0 D0+ 3 < 5

$( 8 5

#:/5 .

3 1 D0+ 3 < 5

!"

#.1

.04.1 .&4$% &

$

2

#$% ++,2

+ 8

#$% +0 , ! ( *;

( %" ( ( #$% +0.

); +< :

"

( (

0

"

(

"

"

(

:

8#!

"3 3

=D :&

"

7

$#8$

@

C 9

@

0 &

( * )" 8$$#"

C

"

"

(

@

< "

@ (

'

(

<

9

"

;

?

(

"

(" "

4

"

'

(

)

"

@

(

"

"

:

#

89 (

" "

"

DC

5

''''''''''''''

#&

33

(

;

?

5

' ;

"

(

) 8

5

C

0 &

* )"

8$$# 7 8"99"9%"9

* 7 %

C

C

#$

(

C

I,

4

"

(

"

(

C

;

<

"

"

"

16D92

C 8$$

CB # $ - / $

80 - .

/

. .

7 0 #

- $ / 0

-

/E

' / /

. - $

/

/ - - -.

-

G

.

# / $ .0& D.

= >

; ?

5 !' # . &

% @

0 J

< 5

0 &

* )"8$$#1

)B2 7

* "%1

7 B2

K

( ,

0 J

< 5

7 8"99 9

7

(

0 J

5

"

"

"

B

0 * + 5

< 5

< 5

3 "3

6

"

!"I - ;

'

' ;

"

* + @0 5

D

(

)

"

0 J

"

(

0 J

< 5

;

5

< 5

3 ,

)

;

I 075 0 "0/' + L ">6075 (5 ">

5 E 6J 3 ; ) +

-

0

0

3,)B '

-.$

!

$ -

@?

-2"

H

@". H 2(