High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/25518/2024dismissed

Reliance Eminent Trading And Commercial Pvt. Ltd. v. Punjab State Power Corp. Ltd. And ANR.

2024-11-20Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj16 pages

"# $%&''

"$$( $%''

) *

** ) + )* '

, *% - )* ' ,+ ,'

' ....

.... + ,'

/ '0 )1

!! "! ##$%#$#&'( )*+ ,#* #$$%.- - /. 0 " 1" 2

3 0

4! ! 5 " !

! " 6 )3 . 1 . -! - ! ' 46 "7 1+6"( #38 /. .3" -"1 $%,##$$*0

.! 6 6 .- /. . 3"

- #9$&#$,% : 6 ! .6 1%,$9#$,*6 6! ) 1 ,,*;#,$< 3" ,#&$ 0 " ! ,;$$

- ! ,, 0- = -

" 6 &&; #%$>#$,* 0 2 6 *% ,?$?#$,* 6 -

! - "(. !

%$$&*#>#;& ! " 6 ,,*;#,$< " ,#&$ 0 6 -

4 .-

@ ") ") : 0<)% 8

,9@%9;,>@%9?,*@%9?,$,$#$#%A6! ! 6

)

$% & '

! (

' (

' $ !!

( () & (

!- " " 7 - 6 .- ! "" ,?##,#$,$#$#% ! "

#,?$**#,@) 2./ 6 .- ! "6

6 -

!6! " $#,,#$#%= 6.".- " " -.- " ! ! - . 7./! "

! . " 1-

" " "

! ! .

!2 ./ " 6

!-" ,$#>#*$?@) !! . - ,#* #$$%.-"4! ) 9$B 9,%,%99@)!6 C$9B " >$99$@) - !" .- " ! ! . - -

! - -! "

! . - - !

.)" ! 6 - -0 ! . @ ) . - ,# #$$%=6 " .! " ". ! .- )3 .1 " . !

- 0 6

!- " ##$%#$#&!6

6 .

#$$% " ,# ,& #$$% "!.)" !

" - .) . = .

,# - #$$% " . ! - " . - 6. " ,#,& - #$$%

"! 6 ! ! .! 6 - " -"4- !

.)" !

" -

7 - 6 !..

3 /. - ! - "" - #$#& " - - - - !

.)" !

6 6 ." - #$#&6 5 - #$#% 6 3 - #$#&"-. ! " . !" . /!" .- ! !" )3 . 1

." .) .! -

! - !%> - #$,&0 " ,#,& #$$%6 " .@ -.- 0 ".!" ".6 -5 !

- .=."

! !

- @.! "(@ ! "@ "" "(@ ! @" ! D4 -D

" >, #$,&!

/!" 0 . -= $?$>#$,9

++, -

' ! ./. ./0 '1

' !

( 0. 02 ($

& 3

% ! !

(

! 4

5 ( % ' !

63 7

( ! 0 4 (8

! !

( %

( ' (://1;'

! & 3

( '

& % ! !

(

0.02 (

' 1

++,* = " 1 3 . A

! " . ! .- ! -

@.!

"(@ ! "@

"" "(@ 9;@#$,> ,&,##$,>

! %>% - - = '

! -A

+ 7 1

* ,& #$$% 1 ! - .-

"4! -.6

! ! "" "(0

6 "- - " -= ." ". @- '+ !- "! -@ ! -6 ,& #$$%E "" " - #$$%

! " .) " " !

" !- 5 - - 3 . 1 . -@ . - ! - "! .) . -6

= 6 ! ( . .- 6 - 9; #$,> . 6 = - ." = ! !

" . 6 . = ( .6 ! - "" . F ! -G '

F G+ .4 - ! - . 6 " 0 - 6 " . . ..!= ""

6 - " - 6

. /. - ! - "" '

G+

- -

+ !#$,&'

F - #$,&G+ . .

" /.

! &#) - #$,& 6 - ! - ! ! >>

!>9 - ',, ""+ .H 2 "I !>9& )

' <) $

( %

' '

(

( '( (

= !! '

( ( < (+ '

' (! G I E 6" " .

= ! H ! -I 6

!>> - #$,&',, ""+F G

. " . .-

"4! -. 6 "" "( !>>#6

( 23'3 ,4 $4 ,6657 JJJ JJJ JJJ JJJ >># 6 !- ! !>>, "-

- * ,& 0 "- !- .-

"4! - . 6

6! ! '+ '+

"" "( '+ "( '+ =0 4 '+ !- " JJJ JJJ JJJ JJJI

- -= " @

"( !>* - #$,& ' ,, ""+ 0 ! 6 . ( ! . "

. "

" 6 ! >* 6 !

6.". "" "(6 " 0

! 6.- "" -(. -6!

.- - #$,*= "4 :

"4 - . ! -= / - !! - "" "

66 ! 66 6 ! 6 . ! 6 * ,& #$$% E .! -.- 6 " 6 7 " - .- 76...7 ,#> #$$% =6 6 - . !"-. @- .6

"- " 0 ! .

" 6. .- .!

" "6 H-I

#'*$+ - #$$% 6 #',9+ 0 " (

&' &(#&

>>> >>> >>> 6.?7 @ @ (

' '

( ' ( A ( (

( ( ' ! (

! !

( ' '

( B >>> >>> >>> 6.C7 @ @ ( (! (

(B >>> >>> >>> 6:C7

(

( ' (B >>> >>> >>> 6107 * !

.2B 61D7 *

' !

.2B >>> >>> >>> 6C/7 @ (@

(

( B

!# & ) *&

&+ ,"

#**$-"

$&-

67 (B 67 (B 67 ! (

(

.2 % .1 '& %,*

( A ' ( ?

( E

( ( .:

(( ( +( $

"! !

F .&+ $

( .?!

(

G 67 (

B 67 ( B 67 ! ( ( ( ( F + (

( (

(

( !

( (

( H (

(

F + &

I ( &

I (

F +

A ( ( ! ('

H F +

- J

(

6.7 1 - J

( .D20

H - J

( .D20 ( '

( F +

A ( (

6:7 .1. (

F +

( ! ' ( ' E !

' E

H ( '

! H( '

(

( A ' '

H !

( % F >>> >>> >>> ! - #$,& -6

" "

" " 6 " "4

= "( ! - "-..4 "" " =- " - " "

" !! 5 " = . 46

6 " " ) 1 7 - .

- #$,&

- * ,& #$$%

! - .-

"4! - . 6 ! ! ""

"(0

5 ..- " A

! "'( )&9 = #$,&+. ! .- 1 !6

- - " " K " K .) " 6 A 9; #$,> 6 .- 1 " ;$%);$*@

)*9 ,&,##$,> 6

. ! ! - ;, ;& -6 5 !3 .A

! " 6 " 3 . A

! " 1 6 5 .=6 ) " - " . ! - 6 "6.. 0 . - #$,>6 -- . - #$,*

6 "E " 66 "" .- ) 3 .1 3 ! 5 ! !

- "" "( . " @ -! . "

"- 6 " E . - @

" 6 . ! " 6 - -6

" - ! 6 - 6 .! . .

( #',*+ #$$%0 - . ( " .

!-!

.-" #',?+ #$$%A #'*,+ !6

- .) . -

-".!" .- ) -0 !" . .- 0 " . ( - - -".!" - -- 6

"- " " K !K

#$$% ! " . ! 0 .!

6 " !

.- E -

" 6 " . "

,# ,& - #$$% .! - 5 . ,& . (" " #$$% =

#$$% ...- 0 - 4 .- 6 6 . - . "/ ! #',9+#',*+#',?+

#$$%0 .). " " #',9+ #$$%.!6 - 6 - 6 " ! - 6 6 4 E 6 5

7 " .-"6

" "" "(E - 6 (6 .. " 6 " ( ; - #$,& !"!- -! " . 0 . 6 -.! "E .!!- E = " 6 !- - .- "! .- - ,#* #$$%

- 4! 5 " ! A

! " . ! "6 5

! ! " ! .- "" " 46 6 0 " ! . " ..-6 E!

2 . 6. 0 6 . - 4 !

6 6

!-" ! 0+ ,'

1 ''' &+/)&

= !

< = FK