Arjun Singh And ANR v. State Of Punjab
"#$ % "& '$( '#) #* +# $ #*"& ,- . /.
0
. /.
.
10234 .......5566, 7,0, 8 019 ......,5
. /
0:;2234 266 <..5566 7,0, 8 019 <..,5 #= >%.)'$"% %%$"#& ???
!
"
#$ % &
'
() *%
+ ,
!
"
#$
-./ *
0 %1 /
???
%%$"#& @ ).
2 /(' / * 1*( 3 "
"
#
/4 $% 5-6
7
" ,
36 0*84 /
+ 3 9 :$*
%( 0!
1 / ' ' **((
4 4 ;
(( / 3 4( 4'**(( "4
($'> A&'#* "
!
" , -;
<= >
** *$ *' '
* /* '
' ( >' * ! 1 *
?
'** 4> @
(4'*/ *4> * 0 0/ 4 * ( /*'
*
'
4/ 2( '
/ *0 A (//4 * * '
. 2 * * *@/ * =* 44 '
4/ ' // ' = * 4 ( ( / 24' '
/*4> (@
'./ 24'( '
* * / % B= * 24 ''*/ /4 % B= 0 ((' 0 A ( *4 ** = >*0 A * * @/ *('4>'
= / *''* "# ;#>* / *'* + ;#>* - #3>*4>'
(' > ' / *(9 : 9
:
2 4'
> '( ; '
* /< 1 */ '( 5- '
* ' (* ( * , '
(4*' " , * '
( * (( / 3 ' *4 (
#
- @ ( ( 4 ' '
*( C@ (C@ D$
@ ( ' 0E
(> *
* *( / *
;
/
#$%#$"# ,
? '
(* <
* ( *4/4* * '
'* ( #"
/ (/4 4 / /'( / / ' /1* 5
< * 5("+'
<
' '
> 0 / *'
( / '* E" #
3 ( " ( F(( (/ 5-'( ('
*'* 4**/4 ' * * ( ( C@ ( ( < > *' *'/@
E ("#
" ,' * * - > *' * E ('
< > *"
" , ("#
" ,
( /'/," 4* ( 4/4 (*' ( 2 (4< > *E $/4'
4 ( / . (
' ' ( ( /4- =
? * ( C@ ( 3"
(' >/ *
+
= /4 ** '*/ * / 4' ( < * * '4('
2 ' * . 4 4 > ' ' 9(( . 4: /4 / '/ 4 ( /
%7$"##*#>+" 2 ' / ' *@/ *4>/* * ( 2
!
5-'
*/ ( * * ('*( #" ' .*'(( - . / ( #" (( C@ E ;5$ (' * / '
/ /* 2 4
// / 2 *( '* ( #" ( 2( 4( #" /'4 4 / ( ( / ( # '/ /
? ( E"
/ *0 $''
/ (( -@ ( ' ( #
3 ( " ( ( ;" * / '
/4 - > * **4/ * ' 5-C@ E ;C$ 4 * > #
3 ( ( '
# 3 ( * 446 "
2* * 4 *( * ' ' 2 % B ='
'> /
/
'*
"
' 4 C@ E ;
C@ E ;(( $C@ E ;5(( $C@ E ;%CD E ;< C@ E ;)(( $C@ E ;&(( $ C@ C((4$C@ !C@ C@ 0(( $' 4 / 5-6(/9
7:
E C@ E ;0$ ('
* / < 1 * / 6 "
7 '
5-/* (//( * * - '
* / < 1 * * (( 4>'
(*4/ * (' >4((C@ C$ 2 ( ' ' ( ' <' @ /4 4' '5-(/ (/ ((' (4 ('
* ( 2 / * /4* * - / 4 / @ /4'* *( 5-(( ' 4(('
* '
/* 5- /( *4/ 2<:/ (A 612234 550-,.
8 019@
' ( ' * '
/* 5-(/ '
((('' ( * 5- ( 4 <* * *(*5-(/(( ** * 5- ( 0C62,22-,.8 019@6.556#./ 8
! 3
"
" "" # 6-,.8 C@ 2 26 B A;6 23 -,. 8 019
2 26B .
#
* *(* ( 3"
'. ( '
!!
" !"!
# ! # # ! "" "! ! # ! "#
$ ! "! ! !!
" !"!
# ! ! !!
! " !"!
# ! %! # #
"
# ! !
!
%
"! "!
& !!
" !"!
# ! #
%
!''! "! ! "%
! ( !
#' !
""
! !!
" !"!
# ! !
!
!" "!) ) # !
"! !!
" !"!
# ! "!)
%! "!) !
"! !
#'
!
! !!
" !"!
# ! "!
!
) ""! * ""
!
!! "" +
# ) " ! ! * " " !
# !
!
! " " +
!
%
% " " !
# ! " ! ! *
!
!! "
%
( & ""! #' !
* # % ""!
, -%
!
. / ! !
01
01 2!
31(
31, !
! ! " " !!
" !"!
# !
"
% #' !
!
# * " ! "! ! ! 4 2 * 3"
"
- ' * ( * C@ 7 ( C@ (: *' (E
< > * ('
'
" , '
( C@ ("
" , ''
"#
" , 4 ( 4* (( C@ ( / ( 4 / B > ' <=. /( C@ ('," *=6 +
+
/46 ! 4 '* (
" ,/''
("
" ,'E
< > * ( @ 4 "#
" , ( C@ ( 6 <'
' *6 +'
/ ( 4''
4//4 4 (* * /( #2, 6 00-,.1 A0 @ !">
)223-,.8'.
.
2 26 !
'/ / ' .
C5("+'
''
. //4 * *'4 (' ./ '
* ( 3"
2
4/4 ' ''28"2 -,. 60:0,@
2 26B/ . ( 3"
*
/4 ')*!<:/ ('28 "2-,.>6@ ! 2 26B@ >** )2
2 >'
5 "
%
! 6
- -!!
7
2 !"!
!
8# !
! ! # %
! '! "! ! "%
8! ( ! ! !!
""! * % ""! 8! ! %! # %
# * #
8#'8! ( 8!
!
# # 9
:
" :
"
#
"
!
"
(
, 4
- ' ( (/ '/ * ''"-,.
>6 ,05.4 ')*!<:/ ( 3266-,.$8.
.@6.556#.!B8
)4 "" " >**)
'
.* / ( 3"
/4(' 2'*'
/
0 ; ""
" < ! 8! -278 ! #
!"
%
% ""! !
#
% ! !"! %
!
! " !
! % ! ! 2 !
! # %
# ! $ # " -728 ! #
# " ! -'" ! " ! ! %
! %
8!
,
. / ! !
01
/ ! !
"! !"
! " !
" #
! %
)"
"!
# !"! "!
%
" 4
, 26:2362,A6-,.8 019@
2 26B / ( /4 <:/ (81,-,.&0 2623@
2 26B '* 4* ( ( C@ ( /
. % = #
# ""
! % !
5( 51 331 " % ! ! /= 50 51
! ! /=
="
! " # "
% !
># !
#
- =" % % % " % ! ! /= # 5
?
=" # %
# ! # # ! ="
# ! ! % .
!"#" #$ ! %% &'! %
,
"
! ! /= @ !! ! %
" # "
% " !
#
) ! % !" @ "" % ! ! . " $
( !"#"
#$ ! () *
( %! + , #$ ( % #! !#
*) 5
) % " ! " % )" ) " %
# . !! !
! "" % !
. "$ '
- .!"#" #$ !/( &'! " % ! ! /= 1
% "! !
#
" % @ !! ! %
!! ! %
" ! " ! -
# " ! !
" ! " "
% " !
! A !
8!! ># ! " !
# " ! ! " ) !
! # # . ! "!" %
%
""!# ! " !
5
" ! ! /=
' ! " # " ! % "
% %
" ! " ! " ! " # "
% !
#
# "" #
!! !!"
(4 3"
'
/4 "
+ +' ('
"+
+ + 3"
"$$
'* (B / * =
3 * =6 +
. (B / ( / '4 ( *=6
+ +
+ + * = ( 3"
5 '' ' /' * (/1( ' / '( (' /*
+
2 4 4
* = /4 6 ! ( /<:/ (#3-,.8
019@ ! /@' ')*! >** )
!
(
B! 8 C $ C #
>
550 ( 8 0F %
! @ . ;! 55,
8
!
> ! !
!
! " 8
$ ! # #
# !"! % #
" ! " ! ! ! ! ! # # !"!
#
%!
%
! !
! ! # " !
B
%
" ! 4
( *=6
+
' 3"
"$$ ' *'* '* ( * = 6
+
'* ( ' 3"
'* ( * 2 * " + +* 3"
' ' ''"-,.>6 ,05@
( ' ( ./ ' * * *4/' 3"
( (( (
*=6 +
((/ / 4',"B 4* /1 (( -' ' '/4 <:/ (#3 ,05@ 60:0 ,05 3266 ,05@ -* * = / ' * *=6 +
*=6 + + * (* >*'*( 2 *= ( 4 . /
* 460
( *=6 ;
'
G
"
!
#
% ! " !!
#
"! !!
" !"!
# ! =!" ! $"
<? % ,
! !
!!
# )
"! "
"!) <!
# % =
)
" # "
"!
% ( & "
% ! "
# #
)
8'
8' 8'(
#
"! "
.
! # "!)
)
( ,
, .
" " #
%
" ! !! 2! %
!
#
" ! "
8" #
"!
># % 1
#9! G 2 /( * *' * ( * =6
+
' 4 *5("+ ' ( '* (4
"
- ' @ ( ' / 4 '
( 4' 4@ (** 2<:/ ( A2, -,.8 C" / /B '
/
* * ' (4
')*!<:/ (&:# , -,.8 2@ 2 26 . * /4/ ( ''' / 1* "
- * * - > *
E ( < ( (* * '* ( * '/> ( "
- 2 <:/ ( 9C ",5 8 62@ #2 "6623 00@02@$ 26#0-.13 B ! @ ( ( /4( ('* ** '*4 . ( 4 * 5'* 0! <*>60 ,-.$ 8D, 36 /
2 26 / '
4 * ( ( * * * ( 4 <:/ ( 3 23-.8 C !
/ ( ' ( * ( ( * /
* * ( * 5 */( 1 4(
""
/4<:/ ( 1C23 -. 8 2,3 / 2 26BB * / ' '/* *4(4( 2 *4@ 1 ( / '/
( 1 (
*4 "
2<:/ ( 8&01-. =96 .)0,2.. / / * 1 ((* ( @(
# 9 = "" !
/ 1*' -( ' / / (> >/ 2>/ /
/ * / (/ //( "#
)*/<:/ (- >6-.8 019" B >** )6 ( '*/ *
. % ! !
" ="
#
% I
;! "!
" % !!
! !
. !
! %
#
% % ! #
! !
" # # "% # " % "! !! %
! !
! %! #
.
%! # ! "
# " I ! #
# "" #
" # # "
!! # =!
" % !
# " 4 "3
)* / <:/ ( 72 A0 -. 8 2 6 ,
@ >**)6 /4 ' '>6 ,05 */ / '
! 9 !
! # %
=! # )
! =! "" ! 9 !
#!
!!
" ! %
% * >
" %
#! "
#
! " ! " "! ! &
"
! " !
"" " %
% * >
" ! #
# ! ! 4
2 4 "
# '
4* ' '>6 ,05' /4 <:/ ( 72 A0
,05 * * . 2>(4(* 2 ( /4 >*( ''
4(4 /4 / ' / #>'"# "7
-0, 23C-,.8D, 36@
//<:/ ( / ( 1 ( * ** .
",
2 1 / C4 * * * * ( < ( * * "
/( ( 1 * * @/(( 14 4( #"
+
/* (' * * *
"
- ' /
' 2 1*(
"
"
# /4 /4 $%
(4 1 *H ?
>'
*H! . * ( * ( 2/ / 4/ * "+
*( $ 4
2 4 4( 4/ ' @4( * $ // >/'
%%$"#& )'*&%
. /.
,02 E >*; >* I;6 E /; / I;6