High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/527/2017dismissed

Gurnam Singh v. Malook Singh And ORS.

2017-01-31Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul6 pages

!

"

#$%

&&''

( ) ' +$% (%

*& (*

*(

*%-%

.

/!0 (

( &&''

'(%&

*( (% / ( 1 1 & ** 2 '

( '*( ( $!# (*

.% 2%* *((%/

( 3 3 & ** 2 '

40' $ 0* !/ !.

**#** - ' *( (! (%

' *

(/ ( *((% (* *&(

$

%*(

( (0''

$

.(%(%5 '

(%* #* (($(%% &'

6%* (*2$

* * 7% +% 8+ *+

* ' %+ # 9( * '

# (% ( (% &

'

(%&'

*% ((% . *%&

#%*

:2$*(('! (

&

'& **** (!(% (*% 0 $%( (('(%

- ( *('' .(% (% %'& # *' & . *! (% (* .

( ( *& ****(%&'

2' ''$ ''

#(%* :! (%* ;

((*( (#(% *2 '2(% $ (%

(* ( ( , '#

2/( *

$# ( 2'(!' **( !

( !*( &&'

'$(%* (! '$# (

(*!

(*(&'

&'

0 # & **** % 02&' : .0 ! # (*!(%

#(*# (%&'

(% 02 (%2 ** &' $* (%&

(*! '' .$** *.

#2'

(

( ;%(% (% &'

* ((' ( (% ' & ( / ( <,, ;%(% (* (# ( 2'<,

;%(% (% &'

* $ ( ' * *(

( <, = ;%(% (%&'

*% 0 '(%# (

(*

(%+ .'$ (%*

(<,

;%(% (% &'

* *( && 2 %* . ( (<, ' 5

(

(0/ (3 3 *#**(%* *(%&'

0(%

'

(%* 6%(

* 2* 0

!"

# #$ "

# # %"

& !

" #

! " "

#

' (

)* + +

$ #

!"

# , -"

(

.*/ $ $

$$0$ $

")"1

" #

2()

"

# ! , )*& " (

!

!! "

#"

, ,"

"

! 1

$ " !

,

! 3"

$ #,"

$ "

! ! ! !

!!

# ! !" 1" !

, " " #

!" > $$ 0 *((%

* / & **2 (% ( ' 4

(! (%

' ' 2

(% ' .

( 4

( .%% .

'* *#** 2 '

( ' *( ( $!# (*

0/ (1 1 *(%&'

+

$(0( & 0(%&' ( +2%#(% 9(*(%

* #*( *!(%

'(%&

6%

((% '' .$* 2*( ( ?

*( * . ;%(% 2 (%(%

(*2' .% 0 (''$ '' ( ( '' #* *(

(%

(* 0 .%'*#**$(%* (< ;%(% 2 (%(%

(*2' .( ( '' #* *(

(% 0 .%% '

' *% .* (% &'

* & **** ( & (

' $ % *

$ %* 2 *** *''$ (8%+ *& (*% 0 $%( ((' 0 (! &

(

' .% (%*

( * #(( 2 (%

*& (*

$ **@ # ( < ;%(% ' . (

' ( *

( (% "

# ,

( ( A3= 0 .%% * ( & ( .

* $0 ( (%

2(%"

$%*2 ***< 0 ;%(% & **$ / * 2 2 (% (%

(*2' .% * '(#*

$ / *(< 5

*'

(% ((%

(*2' .% 0

'( ((% (*& ****

' $ & ( (* (% %

(.%%.

*$02(%"

0 ( A3= 9(* *?

(% (*

$%* *** *''$ %+ # ( 2 *(

($ *# '' . 7% +% ( & : % * *&( $ ( *(

( 6% & ( * . 2 (% "

# ,

% 2 $0 ( (%

(

%*2 *** %*& **** * (

#

6%

# *'# .

((

2'*& **** (% (

#(%* :%

(% (; 7 *%# $%% **( (%* **@ # ( (% ((%

*

$ *% & %+ *''$ (0''

$

#'

'!;

' +$%% '* #(( %* **@ # ( (% ( (%

* ( 7% +% ( & 6% *! & ****

* *( 2'*% %2$&

'& **** ( ( 2*& **** (* (

%*&

& **** (%* & * & **** & ( ( 2 *& ****

2' ''$ ''! @&(

'

.

6%

( A3=& **2(%"

% * ( 2 * 2 (% 4

(* 2' . .% 2 (% "

# ,

( % $0(%* (( (%

* *(

%*2 *** 6%*

(.

* ( (2(%' . (4

* (% (.

*0 &' 2

(%(

9% 0%

'

*'

6% 0 '* (% ( ( * ( (% &'

(% ( (% * ( & ( .

* $0 ( %# 2 (% "

(!

(%

$% ( ( A3= ! (% &' (*(%

' 6%

#** *( .%(% (%&'

*(('( (%

' & (/ ( (%&'

0% .(%

'

$ **@ # ( !(%

4 &'

*!

! #(((% (%% (&

% *(%* ('

% % * (%$ ( & 0 (% ( % * . ( '

6% &' &'

(%

' % * (2& 0 6% &'

* ?

( *( %* .'$*!2 (*%% * (' 0* %*&' $*!(%(

$%('*#**%* 6%* 2*?

(&'

*2(%

2.

&&' ( = ' 4,4 * * ( 2 $ (%

( A3=& **2(%"

'* ( * (%*0 !%%#*'

!.%'

$ (%.(**2 @ *,;!% #(((% (& *(!(%

& **** * ( '

6% *! (% 2* $( 0! (% ' . (4

$%('*#**(% '2(% &'

- (% (% 4

(* 2' . % 0

( $*

( * 2*( ( '?

*( .*0 '0(%&

* 2 (% (% 4

(* 2' . % 0 ( ##(( # (

( ''$ '( .%% # .

( (

$'! (% #& $/ $#(* *& **2(%4

(*2' .

#

(%&

'**#**

!

" $ (( ;%(% *& +$8 * B* ;%(% & 2'