High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13418/2014allowed

Sunil Dutt & ORS v. Railway Board & ORS

2019-02-287 pages

#$#%&#'

) ! !

+,# '#-.$. ( )

! !

/0(.1

0,, ,2#%$ !!!!!!!!

#,.,. (#%$ 3#%$0$ +.14+5

+%'

,2% 062 .,$ 2+.%7+(8 &#%(7#(, ('.+8 +.1

2+4+(8 #4

#12.8 ,2#%$ !!!!!!!

#$9 ('#(,$

) :

; !

/ 3 /

; !

/ <;

/ %#$#(,) %!

+7+( /2+%7+8

'& -+,#8 9#,.,. (#%$!

!!!/!

01$.8

'& -+,#8 %#$9 ('#(,$!

! ! <;

/8 !

#,.,. (#%$ $##= >0+$2.(6 ?0'67#(, *! !

((#@0%#8 9+$$#'

2+('.6+%2

'7.(.$,%+,.&# %.A0(+18 2+('.6+%2

#(-28 2+('.6+%28 42#%#A5 -1+.7 %+.$#'

9#,.,. (#%$8 $##=.(6 >0+$2.(6 %'#%

!B!

((#@0%# B8

'.$7.$$#'!

#,.,. (#%$ "0%,2#% $##= '.%#-,. ( %#$9 ('#(,$ 6%+(, %+'# +5 $!

+991.-+(,9#,.,. (#% %+'# +5 $!

8 4!#!"!

!*!

8 *!!

%#$9#-,.&#158 +11 - ($#>0#(,.+1 A#(#".,$ ".@+,. (8 +%%#+%$

.(,#%#$,!

%.#"

"+-,$ -+$# +%# +11 4#%# .(.,.+115 +99 .(,#'

%#$9 ('#(,+.14+5$ 0((.(6 /,+""

+,#6 %5!

991.-+(,9#,.,. (#% 4 %=.(6

$$.$,+(, ; - .1 ,8 42#%#+$

4#%# 4 %=.(6

$$.$,+(, ; - .1 ,$

'$!

991.-+(,9#,.,. (#% '%+4.(6 $+1+%5 $!

%+'# +5 $!

8 42#%#+$

4#%# '%+4.(6 A+('

%+'# +5 $!

2+&# A##(

7#'.-+115

"% 7 -+,#6 %5 4!#!"!

!*!

8 *!!

8 %#$9#-,.&#15 4#%# +'?0$,#'

(#@, 2.62#% 6%+'# $+7# 6%+'# +('8 ,2#%#" %#8 +'?0$,7#(, ,2.$ - 0(, 9#% %01#$!

991.-+(,$9#,.,. (#%$ 7+'# %#9%#$#(,+,. ($ ,2#5 4#%# , 1'

,2#5 - ($.'#%#'

%#'#91 57#(, (#@, 2.62#% %+'# +5 $!

+",#% $##=.(6 -1+%.".-+,. ( "% 7 %#$9 ('#(, +.14+5

+%'!

2#( $ 062, .(" %7+,. ( 0('#% .62, (" %7+,. (

-,8

%#$9 ($#

%#-#.&#'8 ,2#5 ".1#'

+( +99#+1 0('#% .62, (" %7+,. (

-,8

8 ,2#5 4#%# .(" %7#'

&.'# 1#,,#% '+,#

!B!

8 !!

8 +991.-+A1# -+$# +991.-+(,$9#,.,. (#%$8 +991.-+A1# 0((.(6 /,+""

9% 7 ,. ($#1#-,. ( % 09 :

9 $,!

#$9 ('#(,$ "+.1#'

- ($.'#%

"+-, 9 $,

$$.$,+(, ; - .1 , A#1 (6.(6 %+'# +5 $!

A#1 (6$ % 09 ::

-+,#6 %5 +('8 ,2#%#" %#8 $+.'

1#,,#% +991.-+A1# -+$#!

, $,+,#'

$.7.1+%15 $.,0+,#'

#791 5##$ 4#%# 6%+(,#'

A#(#"., .%-01+%

#$9 ('#(,$ , = $,+('

'#-+,#6 %.C+,. (8 4#%# ""#%#'

9 $, +A$ %A ,2#7!

991.-+(,9#,.,. (#% 01,.7+,#15 +A$ %A#'

%+'# +5 $!

*! !

991.-+(,9#,.,. (#%

01,.7+,#15 +--#9,#'

9 $,

.,,#% %=$8

7A+1+8 (6.(##%.(6

#9+%,7#(, %+'# +5 $!

2# ? .(#'

991.-+(,9#,.,. (#% ? .(#'

9 $, +-2.(6 /09#%&.$ %

77#%-.+1

#9+%,7#(, %+'# +5 $!

2# ? .(#'

D!!

#$9 ('#(,$ "0%,2#% , = 91#+ +%# 6 &#%(#'

" 11 4.(6 %01#$ ) : .@+,. ( +5 '.$+A1#7#'.-+115 +.14+5 $#%&+(,$ ".@#'

+A$ %9,. ( +( 9 $, $,+6# - %%#$9 ('.(6 9%#&. 0$15 '%+4( 9 $, 2#1'

,2#7 %#601+% A+$.$ A#" %# +->0.%.(6 '.$+A.1.,57#'.-+1 '#-+,#6 %.C+,. (!

% $,+""8 ".@+,. ( A+$#'

9#%-#(,+6# 9+5E %#9%#$#(,.(6 #1#7#(, 7+5 " %-#!

$ +%%.&#'

' #$ - %%#$9 ('

+(5 $,+6# 6%+'#8 7+5 ".@#'

$,+6# 6%+'#8 7+5 ".@#'

$,+6# ?0$, A#1 4 '.""#%#(-# 7+5 9#%$ (+1 +A$ %A#'

"0,0%# .(-%#7#(,$.(-%#+$# 9+5!

+11 4+(-#$ $0-2

#+%(#$$

11 4+(-#8 .,5 79#($+, %5

11 4+(-#

0$# #(,

11 4+(-# $2 01'

9#%$ (+1 9+58 ."

+(58 6%+'#!

,59# -+$#$

6#, -+$#$ %#- 77#('#'

-2+(6# -+,#6 %5 6% 0('$ 6#, A#(#"., ,2#$# %01#$8 ,%#+,#'

,%+($"#%%#'

4( %#>0#$,!

'#-1+%#'

7+1.(6#%#% ,#%7$ ,#

.. A#1 4 9+%+

('.+( +.14+5$ #'.-+1 +(0+1

+1$ - &#%#'

,2#$# %01#$!

2#5 - (,.(0# 6 &#%(#'

9% &.$. ($ .A.'!

( / B !!*** $0A?#-, +A$ %9,. ( 7#'.-+115 .(-+9+-.,+,#'

#791 57#(,8 ., 9% &.'#'

%+.14+5 $#%&+(, "+.1#'

&.$. ( ,#$, % ,2#%4.$# &.%,0# '.$+A.1.,5 +->0.%#'

'0%.(6 $#%&.-# A#- 7#$ 925$.-+115 .(-+9+A1# 9#%" %7.(6

'0,.#$ 9 $, 42.-2 2# --09.#$8 $2 01'

'.$9#($#'

% %#'0-#'

%+(= $2 01'

$2.",#'

$ 7# 9 $, $+7# $#%&.-# A#(#".,$!

1#7#(, %#-= (#'

42.1# ".('.(6 9 $, '.$+A1#'

7#'.-+115

%'#% '#,#%7.(# $+7# '.$+A1# 7#'.-+115

#791 57#(,8 +( +7 0(, #>0+1 $0-2 9#%-#(,+6# 1.#0 7+5 " %-#8 7+5 +''#'

7.(.707 7+@.707

$,+""!

$ +%%.&#'

.'#(,.-+1 +1%#+'5 #@.$,.(6 $+7# 7+5 %#91+-#'

#>0.&+1#(, #@.$,.(6 9+5!:

2#%#" %#8 ., $,+,#'

2+$ A##( - %%#-,15 ".@#'!

# 2+&# 2#+%'

1#+%(#'

- 0($#1$ 9+%,.#$ 2+&#

+1$ -+%#"0115 6 (# ,2% 062 -+$# ".1#!

9#%0$+1 .7906(#'

%'#% 2+('.6+%2

'7.(.$,%+,.&# %.A0(+18 2+('.6+%2

#(-28 2+('.6+%28 *! !

((#@0%# $2 4$ +991.-+(,$

9#,.,. (#%$ 2+$ +1%#+'5 A##( %#".@#'

+",#% +''.(6 +-- 0(, +",#% ,2#5 ? .(#'

9 $,$8 42.-2 ,2#5 2+&# A##( +99 .(,#'

+",#% '# -+,#6 %.C+,. (!

1#+%(#'

- 0($#1 2+$ +%60#'

2+$ A##( +11 4+(-#$ 7+'# 9+%, 9+58 42#%#+$ ., $2 01'

2+&# A##( 7+'# 9+%, 6%+(, 2.62#% 6%+'#!

48 >0#$,. ( A#" %# ,2.$ 0%, 42#,2#%

B 2+$ 7+'# 9+%, 6%+(, 2.62#% 6%+'# % +''.,. (+1

% ,2.$ 90%9 $#8 1 = 01# 8 42.-2 '#+1$ '#-+,#6 %.C+,. ( %+.14+5 $#%&+(,$8 $2 4$ $,+""8 ".@+,. ( A+$#'

9#%-#(,+6# 9+58 %#9%#$#(,.(6 #1#7#(, +11 4+(-#8 7+5 " %-#8 42.-2 7#+($ #1#7#(, +''#'

9+5!

$+.'

01# "0%,2#%

1+5$ ' 4( ."

9+58 $ +%%.&#'

+,8 ' #$ - %%#$9 ('

+(5 $,+6# 6%+'#8 7+5 ".@#'

$,+6# ?0$, A#1 4 '.""#%#(-# 7+5 9#%$ (+1 +A$ %A#'

"0,0%# .(-%#7#(,$9+5!

1+(60+6# 01# $2 4$ +%%.&#'

+''.(6 9#%-#(,+6#

9+58 %#9%#$#(,.(6 #1#7#(, 9+58 7#+(.(6 ,2#%#A5 #>0.&+1#(, $#9+%+,# +11 4+(-#8 9+%, 9+5!

$+.'

%01# "0%,2#% ,+1=$ +A 0, +11 4+(-#$ 6%+'# ' #$ $+5 #>0.&+1#(, $#9+%+,# +11 4+(-#!

1#+%(#'

- 0($#1 %#$9 ('#(,$ 2+$ +%60#'

1#,,#% !!

8 %#6+%'.(6 - 79+%.$ ( (15 - ($.'#%#'

9% 7 ,. ( %#$9#-,.&# % 09 :

9 $,$!

&#( ."

., $ 8 ., $2 4$

#>0+,#'

2.62#% 6%+'# $,+,. (+%5 $,+""!

( $.7.1+% 7+,,#% -+$# (. ( ('.+ 3#%$0$ +( ?

/4+%(=+%

+%.$.(6 0, %., #,.,. ( D 8 '#-.'#'

.&.$. (

#(-2 +'25+ +%'#$2 .62 0%, 2#1'

D +''#'

7.(.707 7+@.707 ,.7# ".@.(6 #791 57#(,!

( $+.'

$-+1#8 7.(.707 7+@.707 6%+'#8

+''#'

6%+'# +-- %'.(615 -+1-01+,#'!

",#% - ($.'#%.(6 %01#$8 '.$-0$$#'

+A &#8 4# +%# &.#4 +''#'

".@.(6 6%+'# ,#%7$ 01# 8 !

($#>0#(,158 9#,.,. ( +11 4#'!

7906(#'

?0'67#(, 2+('.6+%2

'7.(.$,%+,.&# %.A0(+18 2+('.6+%2

#(-28 2+('.6+%28 *! !

((#@0%# $#, +$.'# #@,#(, %#$9 ('#(,$ +%# '.%#-,#'

".@ +",#% +''.(6 #1#7#(, ".@.(6 6%+'#

,#%7$ 01# 8 8 %#"#%%#'

+A &#!

##'1#$$ $+5 ,2#5 #(,.,1#'

$0-2 6%+'# "% 7 $0-2 '+,# ,2#5 ? .(#'

$#%&.-#!

2#5 $2+11 +1$ #(,.,1#'

+%%#+%$ - ($#>0#(,.+1 A#(#".,$8 .(,#%#$, +%%#+%$!

3 /

! !

$?=$

2#,2#% $9#+=.(6 %'#% ) #$ 2#,2#% %#9 %,+A1# ) #$