High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4887/2018dismissed

Mahesh Kumar Mahajan v. Anil Mahajan And ANR

2018-08-27Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary6 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

!*#'*+,-!.!*!/!( 00#11!(" 2#.',' (&1!*!/!(!($!("*#. #'0($#("'

.#'#(") '##(!3'*&*!.-!4$5%!"# ."*#!00#11!(" 66666

*#!00#11!("701!&("&

&'!88.&#5#$ /,$8-#("!($$#%.##$!"#$

9 0!''#$ :; 1#!.(#$ &5&1 ,$8# #(&. &5&'&(4 !"*!(3"4 <*#.#:;',&" .0#.-!(#("&(/,(%"&( &1#$:;"*#01!&("&

<!'$&'-&''#$!' <#11!'/,$8-#("!($$#%.##$!"#$=

0!''#$:;1#!.(#$$$&"&(!1 &'".&%" !"*!(3"$&'-&''&(8*&'!00#!1

.&# !%"'(#%#''!.; .!$/,$&%!"&( "*#-!""#.!.#"*!""*# !00#11!("701!&("&

&1#$ ! ',&" '##3&(8 0#.-!(#(" &(/,(%"&( .#'".!&(&(8 "*# $# #($!("' .-$&'0''#''&(8*&- .-"*#0.0#.";&(>,#'"&(&#!'*0 ,($#."*#"#(!(%; "*#01!&("&

-!.3#$!' '*<(&(.#$%1,.&("*# '&"# 01!( !""!%*#$ " <!' 01#!$#$ "*!" "*# 01!&("&

:#&(8 ! "#(!(" <!' &( "*#'*0&(>,#'"&(,($#."*#1!($1.$'*&0 "*#$# #($!("' :#&(8"*#1!($1.$*#01!&("&

<!'.,((&(8"*#:,'&(#'' .#0!&.!($'!1# '0!.#' *#!5; -".' &( "*# (!-# !($ '";1# ?7' + ".'@ *# "#(!(%; !8.##-#(" &" <!' 01#!$#$ <!' .#$,%#$ &( <.&"&(8 &( "*# .- ! .#("$##$<*&%*<!'0,.0."#$1;&(0''#''&( "*#$# #($!("'"&''"!"#$ "*!""*#01!&("&

<!'.#8,1!.1;0!;&(8"*#.#(" '

7A0#.-("*""*# $# #($!("':,"<&"*,"!(;.#%#&0"*#.#("<!'0!&$,0",8,'"

<!' ,."*#. 01#!$#$ "*!" "*# $# #($!("' <#.# "*.#!"#(&(8 "*# 01!&("&

.%&:1;$&'0''#''!($#5&%"*&- .-"*#0.#-&'#'&(>,#'"&(#(%#4"*# ',&"<!' &1#$ ,&" <!' .#'&'"#$ :; "*# $# #($!("' <* &1#$ ! /&(" <.&""#( '"!"#-#(" <&"* "*# ',:-&''&(' "*!" "*# '*0 &( >,#'"&( <!' ,($#. "*# "#(!(%; (#!($*!.5&(8*<*<!'.,((&(8!-#%*!(&%'*0&("*#',&" 0.0#.";.#("*!$#5#.:##(0!&$:;"*#01!&("&

""*#$# #($!("'*# ',&"&"<!'"*,'01#!$#$:#$&'-&''#$ .-"*#01#!$&(8' "*#0!."&#'4 11<&(8&'',#'<#.# .!-#$)A B*#"*#."*#01!&("&

&'#("&"1#$"0#.-!(#("&(/,(%"&(!' 0.!;#$ .C

B*#"*#."*#01!&("&

*!'(%!,'# !%"&(.1%,''"!($& " &1#"*#0.#'#("',&"C = B*#"*#. "*#.# #D&'"' ( .#1!"&('*&0 1!($1.$ "#(!(" :#"<##("*#0!."&#'C B*#"*#. "*# 0.#'#(" ',&" &' .&51,' !($ 1&!:1# " :# $&'-&''#$<&"*'0#%&!1%'"'C E #1&# #'0&"# 5!.&,' 00.",(&"&#'4 ( #5&$#(%# <!' 1#$ :; "*# !00#11!("701!&("&

!($*&'#5&$#(%#<!'%1'#$:;%,.".$#.&'',&"<!' $&'-&''#$ :; "*# 1#!.(#$ ".&!1 ,." 00#!1 <!' "*#.#! "#. &1#$ :; "*# !00#11!(":# .#1#!.(#$&.'"00#11!"#,.",.&(8"*#0#($#(%; *&' !00#!14"*#01!&("&

<!'#5&%"#$ .-"*#'*0&(>,#'"&((

( !00#!1 &" <!' 01#!$#$ "*!" "*# !00#11!(" <!' -#$&%!11; ,( &" !' *# <!' ',

#.&(8 .- ";0*&$4 *# <!' !$5&'#$ :#$ .#'" .- E

9 "

9!($&"<!'$,#""*&'.#!'("*!"#5&$#(%#%,1$(":#1#$:; *&-:# .#"*#1#!.(#$".&!1%,."001&%!"&(<!'-5#$:;"*#!00#11!(" :# .# 1#!.(#$ $$&"&(!1 &'".&%" !"*!(3" "*!" *# *!$ :##( $&'0''#''#$,($#."*#8!.: "*#/,$8-#("!($$#%.##<*&%*&(!(;%!'#

<!'.#>,&.#$":#'#"'&$#(00.",(&";<!'!

.$#$""*#!00#11!("" 0.5#"*!"*#<!'&('#""1#$0''#''&(.<!'$&'0''#''#$&11#8!11;$,.&(8 "*#0#($#(%; "*#!00#!1.#8!.$&(8<*&%*"*# 11<&(8&'',#'<#.# .!-#$ :;"*#1#!.(#$$$&"&(!1&'".&%" ,$8#(F

)A G B*#"*#. "*# !001&%!(" &' #("&"1#$ " '##3 .#'".!"&( "*# 0''#''&(C

B*#"*#."*#!001&%!("<!'"#(!("&("*#'*04& ''&(%#<*#(C = B*#"*#."*#!001&%!("*!':##($&'0''#''#$&11#8!11;4& '" <*!"#

#%"C B*#"*#."*#!001&%!("<!'("&(0''#''&(#D%1,'&5#1;!($"*# '*0<!':#&(8.,(:;!($!.!5&(8*<*&''"&11<.3&(8&("*# '*0!'!-#%*!(&%<&"*!(!..!(8#-#("<&"*"*#(,'!($&' (1;,'&(8"*#,"'&$# "*#0.#-&'#' ."*#0,.0'# .,((&(8 "*#-#%*!(&%'*0<*&1#,'&(8"*#'*0 .3##0&(8*&',"#('&1' #"%4& '"<*!"#

#%"C E #1&# H I#!.(#$ $$&"&(!1 &'".&%" !"*!(3"4 5&$# &-0,8(#$ /,$8-#(" !($ $#%.## $!"#$ =

4 $&'-&''#$ "*# !00#!1 &1#$ :; "*# !00#11!("<*&1#%(%1,$&(8"*!""*#!00#11!("*!$ !&1#$"0.5#*&'"#(!(%; "*# $#-&'#$ 0.#-&'#' 88.&#5#$ "*#.#A .-4 0.#'#(" !00#!1 *!' :##(

&1#$ I#!.(#$%,('#1 ."*#!00#11!("5#*#-#("1;!.8,#'"*!":"* "*# 1#!.(#$ ,."' :#1< *!5# <.(81; $&'-&''#$ "*# ',&" &1#$ :; "*# 01!&("&

7!00#11!(" *# .#(" $##$ :#"<##( "*# 1!($1.$ !($ "#(!(" <!' &( "*#$# #($!("'4"*#.# .#4"*#!00#11!("%,1$("0.5#&"

" &' ,."*#. %("#($#$ "*!" $# #($!("A(&1 +,-!. B &( *&' %.''A #D!-&(!"&( !$-&""#$ "*!" 5&$# .$#. $!"#$ F

4 "*# $# #($!(" *!$ :##( .#'".!&(#$ .- $&'0''#''&(8 "*# !00#11!(" I#!.(#$ %,('#1 5#*#-#("1;!.8,#'"*!"&("*&'5&#< "*#-!""#.&"&'%1#!.1;0.5#$"*!""*# !00#11!("<!' .%&:1;$&'0''#''#$ .-"*#0.#-&'#'&(>,#'"&(5&$#(%# %,1$(":#1#$:;"*#!00#11!(":# .#"*#1#!.(#$".&!1,."$,#"&11(#'' "&'"*,'0.!;#$"*!""*&'!00#!1:#!11<#$4"*# &-0,8(#$/,$8-#("'!($ $#%.##' $!"#$

9 !($ =

:# '#" !'&$#4 %('#>,#("1; $#%.##&(8"*#',&" &1#$:;"*#!00#11!(" *!5#*#!.$1#!.(#$%,('#1 ."*#!00#11!("!($*!5#0#.,'#$ "*# &1# " &' ,($&'0,"#$ "*!" &'',#' &( "*&' %!'# <#.# .!-#$ :; "*# 1#!.(#$ ".&!1 %,." ( F

E "*#.#!

"#.4 !' -!(; !' '&D #

#%"&5# 00.",(&"&#' <#.# !

.$#$ " !00#11!("A01!&("&

" 1#!$ *&' #5&$#(%# <#5#.4(#5&$#(%#<!'1#$:;"*#!00#11!("A01!&("&

4$#'0&"#00.",(&"&#' !($#5&$#(%#<!'%1'#$:;.$#.0#%& &%!.8,-#(".!&'#$(:#*!1 "*# !00#11!("&'"*!"*#',

#.#$";0*&$!($<!'!$5&'#$:#$.#'"4"*#.# .#4*# %,1$ (" 0,.',# "*# -!""#. !($ #5&$#(%# %,1$ (" :# 1#$ " "*# &.'" &('"!(%#4&"&'":#("#$"*!""*#.#&'(',%*-#$&%!1#5&$#(%#(.#%.$" .# 1#%""*!""*#!00#11!("A01!&("&

<!'&(%!0!%&"!"#$(!%%,(" &11A*#!1"* . !11"*&'<*&1#5#(!'0#."*#!00#11!("J'%!'#4*#<!'!$5&'#$:#$A.#'" .- E

9 "

9 (!%"&( ( "*# 0!." "*# !00#11!(" &' %1#!.1; ,(#D01!&(#$*#!.8,-#(".!&'#$&("*&'.#'0#%"&'%1#!.1;(":.(#," .- "*#.#%.$ .8,-#(".!&'#$:;1#!.(#$%,('#1 ."*#!00#11!(""*!"B (&1+,-!.!$-&""#$"*#0!''&(8 .$#.$!"#$ F

,($#..$#.=F ,1#' !($ .#'".!&(&(8 "*# $# #($!("' .- .%&:1# $&'0''#''&(8

"*#!00#11!("&' (!5!&1"*&-*#'!&$.$#.0#.A'#4&("*#!:'#(%# !(;"*#.#5&$#(%#(.#%.$4$#'("%(%1,'&5#1;0.5#"*#0''#''&( "*#!00#11!("5#."*#$#-&'#$0.#-&'#'&("*#%!0!%&"; !"#(!(" *#!00#11!("&(*&'!

&$!5&"DB7%1!&-#$"*!"*#<!'! 1!< ,1%%,0!(" "*#0.#-&'#'&(>,#'"&(!'!"#(!("(!0.#A01!((#$ %('0&.!%;41%3'0,":;"*#!00#11!("<#.#.#-5#$:;"*#.#'0($#("'(

&( *&' !:'#(%# <#5#.4 1#!.(#$ %,('#1 . "*# !00#11!(" &' ,(!:1# " $#(; "*!" "*# !00#11!(" &( *&' %.''A#D!-&(!"&( <!' ,(!:1# " .#5#!1"*#$!"#!($-("* "*#.#("$##$5#(!0*"%0; "*#.#(" $##$<!'("0.$,%#$(.#%.$*#!00#11!("'0#%& &%!11;'"!"#$"*!"*# $&$(" &1#!(;!001&%!"&( .$#0'&" "*#.#(".#5#.

#."0!;.#(" .- "*#$!"# &1&(8 "*#',&""&11

9"&' ,."*#.!$-&""#$"*!""*,8* "*# '*0 &( $&'0,"# !11' <&"*&( "*# -,(&%&0!1 %.0.!"&(4 *,'# "!D <!' (#5#. $#0'&"#$ :; *&- 5&$#(%# !.&($#. &(8* !($ !1/&" &(8* 1#$ :# .# "*# 1#!.(#$ &.'" !00#11!"# %,." &' !1' ( !5!&1 " "*# !00#11!("

!1/&"&(8**!'%1#!.1;!$-&""#$"*!"("*.#!"<*!"'#5#.<!'#5#.-#"#$ ,"""*#!00#11!("&(*&'0.#'#(%#(&1+,-!.B4<*<!'!$#!1#.

*(##.#.!%". .-

4%!"#8.&%!11;'"!"#$"*!""*#'*0&( >,#'"&(<!'(#5#..#("#$,"""*#!00#11!("*#'!-#<!'&(0''#''&( !($*!.!5&(8*<*<!'<.3&(8!'!-#%*!(&% !.1&#.4"*#!8#(%; <!' &( !5,. *( ##.# .!%". !($ <!' 5!%!"#$ &( !5,. "*# .#'0($#(" # ,."*#. '"!"#$ "*!" "*# '*0 <!' .#("#$ ," " !($*!.!5 &(8*&(

4<*1# ""*#0.#-&'#'*#.#!

"#.4"*#0''#''&(<!'<&"*"*# <(#.' *# .#'0($#("' 0.5#$ ( .#%.$ "*!" "*# !00#11!(" <!' &( "*#'*0,($#."*#1!($A1.$'*&0 -&.*!($.#8!.$&(8"*# 0#.&$&($&'0,"# ,$8-#("'!($$#%.##'&(',&" ..#%5#.; '=4

.,'#!($%%,0!"&( "*#0.#-&'#' .- F

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

&',(!:1#"0&("," !(; >,#'"&( 1!< -,%* 1#'' ',:'"!("&!1 >,#'"&( 1!< <*&%* -!; :# &(515#$ .%('&$#.!"&(&("*&'.#8,1!.'#%($!00#!1 "*"*#&-0,8(#$ /,$8#-#("'!.#<#11.#!'(#$/,$8#-#("'.#($#.#$! "#.0.0#.!00.#%&!"&( !($%('&$#.!"&( "*##5&$#(%#(.#%.$ "*#.!.8,-#("*!':##(.!&'#$ +##0&(8 &( 5&#< "*# !%"' !($ %&.%,-'"!(%#' !' $&'%,''#$ !:5#4 $ (" &($ !(; &( &.-&";4 &11#8!1&"; . 0#.5#.'&"; &( "*# &-0,8(#$ /,$8-#("' !($ $#%.##' $!"#$

9 !($ =

0!''#$ :; "*# 1#!.(#$&5&1 ,$8#.&5&'&(4 !"*!(3"!($1#!.(#$$$&"&(!1&'".&%"

!"*!(3"4.#'0#%"&5#1;4<*&%*<!..!("!(;&("#. #.#(%#:;"*&',."

.#'#("!00#!1&'4%('#>,#("1;4$&'-&''#$<&"*(.$#.!'" %'"'

! '*<!. "#$ #$%&$'()*+%$',*$-./$+ , "#$ #$%%$&,% '01$./$+ ,