← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4910/2018dismissed

Anu Dhindaw v. Ram Mehar

2019-03-05Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

 

              

         



       



              

         !"#$%&'() %%*!)(($     ! "

## +++++ %*!)(($,& $"##%  "  

# " &

!  %  !!'

%! &("$')"&('

  &( )( 

*!"&  %*

! #

,! -.

-*' %-+ /'*   /'(  ' "0&12'%) ! &( "  # $'

 3'

%*  ! 4

,   

#

  &(''!! '#  

##" )

*  &( "

#5  !6'

%2''%* 7" !  '

 &(  .

# 

 " " 

## %   ## " '

(   # # !

   ,

.8    '*   -

.8 )

 )   *(. !*( "&#!*')% &

 "  *   9!'    #    & 

 : ) # %  " 

## "## &   5' $

! * ;05   9!'    #

 " )'#  & ( !"% #  &(

;05 * "## &

 &( "    :     &( " "  ) ( %* #  , 4

## 

!"  "    *  " " ) '

%# 

.8" ( /' :  !* # " # "   %   ( " 

 *'  

.8  '  !"/' & %  ++

4

)2'%2* <= "

!)*  "  % # %*  " ) %   " 

##  7" 

## !" "!"/' "!# !*'.*(

&(" "

## 

.8: '"  "" #)(*   ( ) % *"

 "!!&'"

##  ##(

 *"  "!!"

'#  

"*   "

! '&% 2'%#%) "&#!#!

&'"

##

!* ;%"

!*= &  "'&% 2'% 7" )""

!!" "! # /'  )"!= =)""'

#  !%'# "  * &("

##&'   %'#"  7"   !*  '!" ) " " 

##   =) % "

 #

 )""!  "

##&'"  #' #  ' # & "

##% "! " # ) ## ) & 

.8  "    9!'   %   # ) ##&- ( & %  * 

  : "

 %  

## 9!'   

  

   *    " 

!   '& % 

- 2'%#%) "&#!#!

!&'"

##

!*  /' "

##

#(  

*   ) " ;05     !#'    " %*  ##    " *   "

 *  *#( * "#  " %" *" "  "

##

#    * 

 

# !

!( *   ) %  &( 1 

! ;05

 **

,

 '   *        #%#  !

4

/' %"

##%"# 9!'  %  ) ' "'%"!'#&'';!"'  7" 

##

#  " )  *    '#( !   #*   "    = 

*!  %*   #  ;)  " "   " ##%  " "  *    (   ) %  * "

   " %*7"

##

## ';05 &  >5' $

!?  , 4

  7" # ) !%'#  "  &' #

' *!  ;05  *    & %'# &' %  

#  #!*  7"  ' "

 ' #( #( (*&' " % '! " !;* "

##=#  # *;05  '!" " 

#   #  # 

  " #)( *   ( ) % *"  "%*&'"  )  "  (  ) %  * "

   " %*) "%  (* &#!#!

* "#  " %"   ""'

  ! !  "   %  

 # ( (  "'%" " 

 " %& (#%'% '!

%" !

.8!' % # -

.8"

####"* # *

# " &  ) " ( 

* # '

 7"  # $' * '  '!  ,   " 3'

%*  7"   ) *   

'! 

! '

 "  ! ! ; %" !'# "   " # %"   * #  !  "  # $' !!   !# *   " ) "% "

 #*=

*! %*

 !!

%#(  ! 

*! %*## 

) "

! 

## 9!' " #   !

   &#! # !

   #*195 &)"  & " # !) "

)*" *"  3'

%* # %)"

!"" ) # # &(%"# 9!' "'%"$'"&  !  " &  " 

#    &(  ' 5"

) )

*  &("



##$' 

 $'# "

##" # !!'

%

! &(   ) '&*    :  %'  "

 '&#( " %*   #

 

'    & 9!'  &( " 

##

 )"&( " # !

) '! 

.8 #!  ,

.8:

%' "*" "

!9* 

"  ""! ! )  *'#'#(!!#"

 !   :  %'  ) " "*! "  ! "

 ! %*##

 !!## " )  !!  " $'  ##) 

*!   "

%* "   !!##   "  *   !  ! 

 "'&*  * &(!'# " !  '  !( '

#*) &) "  

195: %' ""  

 !* #"! ) * !

!  " #* 195 " 

 #* !*     " '

 ) /'

 &

% %" !'*195: %' ""  # $' " ##)  

*!   %*  ##

 &' &#! # !

     &

   #* 195    &) "   &  " # !  :

'"%' "&#!#!

 #*195 ! % &#

%*

)'# &#"" !%

%*

 $'# )'#  %' " "  

  "  '

!

 '  

!"% "

 # & # ( '  " %*   # " "$'" !**   '&("#

%"" #)(*   ( ) % *"

 %*  7 & % "* "

 !  " "   ' ) * !!'   '! ! )"

!"")" " ) ) "'    '

  " !!'     



'# "%*)##

"   )"

!"   ##% #( 

  " 

!   '& %  - (   

 ) 9!'  &( "

##

+ :" " !'# "

## ' 8&=  !  $'# "

##"   % *  !  ! 9*     * "  "   " " ! ! )  *'#'#(!!#"

!   '!

 !# !

 !9*   *" % &'-( 

"" ' !  #(   " ! "!9*  ""  9 ! #%# "   :    " !   "      " 

## " %*##) !!## &)"  "*) '

  &( %*

 9!'  &( " 

## 1 ")  '# "

% 

=# %"" % #%*

)!!## &()( 

*= 19"!(

19 *=  !  " %*

 " ! )% & '! 

.8" #" "&

' & %'#&'"%*)9!'   @

#!!

%  #7"



*= ! !!##  " % #%*

:"%  ! "

##! ( %"! * " 

* !9*    "

%"# %" &( "!'# '#  !'* &'%"  !  &( " 

## *= 

"" # /' )!%'#"&  ##*.

 # ' &(;05  ' "

##&' # ) ' & %'#" 7"

##!**' !

) " ;05  "

 %    *   /' 

#  # # ' #% &# 7"

 19 # !##( !  "

!   "  "

## %    '! " !  

.8 #!   ,

.8 % ##(  5'  !(   " '

    #*

195 *(&*= 5A )"&(  ) %   ##  # *'

 /' (

9 *#( 

+ /' *  "   -

.8  *'   

.8 # ( !  &( " 

## ) !=)# % :)#% " !(     " " ! ) ## ! '   " !* *  ) ##  & !! &# :

 '&#( " #   " &    #*

)9!'  * !

 #* "* !/'! 

%$'!) !

'" 7" #  # 

   " 

##  " &     /'* ;05'" )#'  "&  /' *  &( " 

##  7" $' " ##)  

*!   %*  ##

 &' &#! # !

&

) !'*195

 :

))='" ! #*' %-+ /'*    /'( ) !#

195"*)'# & * " " ! %   &

   

9!'  &( " 

##  7" 

 *

 " *   !

   %*

 #(   ! 

! #% &# 

 ! (



 /'  )" !#!'#   " &   ! %    195 )'#  & * " )" ) %   &

 

!'#  !!  !    " 

## " 

3'

! " & !'   " &!'   " $' "

!

(*  &#!# !

  #*195 @88 @

"

##" %  '!" ! &!' #& % %'# #! " . @") " #  "

##!" %"=&#! #!

"&  %*

 7"

 & % " $'  #   " 

## " " ) () "&#!#!

"'"   #

*! %* #:"&    !  &( )(   #  !'*( 

 " " * "

  " 

!   '& %  

 %   % % " #  9!'   ; %  )  " 

!   '& % 2'%

) )")%  "

$'# "

##" #   '('!" !# !

 !9*   *"""

  '

!

 '   * "

 &# %   ( &#! # !

   9    %   ! 

)""" %"

! '&%  %"

!*= ""!(" 

!

'! &( "

##"")  "

! '&%  "



7"* !"'

%&#! "&=!!' *" )"

!"* !!')%

'!  &( "

*  * " '  )  '

!

  *

&# %    * "  ( &#! # !

  !' 9  %   

'

!

! 

%" ")  '

!

 ' * %"

&# % " 

'#  

" )""!' 

! "

! '&% 

:"&   ! " #*195)"&( #) ! 

/' (    # !

 -

.8 * " %

  ) ( & % + +  +

*2'%2* <=$ ' /'&#!#!

 

.8   *'   

.8 '   -

.8 # (

 "

! '#( #! "* !!'

'! !  : " # &    " " (   ) % !!## &(" # 

.  &')*"  *&

<""$'"  ! ""

9  !

19     !& " ! "   "  

9 *#( 

.8  ,

-    ,  .8  ,

  7" $'  # !

 "* #! "  %"#(  !!#' "" .

# 

#)(*   (   ) %  * "

   " %* "'  #  = 

*! %* #:)'# "

"" %*) 

7" 



# *'

.8

!"/' 4

;

 "

!   '& %  2'%   % "

! *=   " 

'#  

7"* %*  ! # !

 ) *

 

  

" % !' 

! "

! '& %  %"

!*= #%# ! 4

) '  !## % '

 " 

##  % " #  9!' %   " '

 )  '   - -

  7=  !

" 

* #

!'#!! !  "

##"! 

%! &("$'" ! 

 ) %  .&' )    " "&   : ) )""&

!' " & 

% * "

# # !!

%#(

*  # *        

 >52'# ?        B"" = %.  (. B"" &#  (.