High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4932/2014dismissed

National Insurance Company Ltd v. Sumitra Devi & ORS

2019-05-21Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta10 pages

! ""

#

$% &!'

!"# $%&'( #&% (# )%*' ( )" *!& + '

""

( $' %*!& + ( $,,*!& +

- &+,-,)+./$ ' ""

+ ! ./

! 0 1 ! ! ! 23452462 " ! ./ (

!

% .* !' 7

+

! 8'

.9:* 1'

./ %"

+ ;*32*244<= 1 1 ! %=

6 > + ' + (?'!7

+

!8'

!

!9:% &

!

1' ?.

0

0 =43= =3-@>7

+

!8'

++ 9: 2 '

/ && !'""

./+ 1

+ ++ !0 & 1 !

! ./ . "/ '

%+ %"

*!

!+ +'

.

0?""

!+ '

?

+.

&/ ; '

%"

1 !

! '

% ./ '

. 1 %" !+1A=

7: % !

(?'!

7: 0 !

BB 7: +

!

;445244@ 7&: % !

B644"

%' 7&: 6<>' + 7&: .& ! ! 1 ! "

C"

7B644=625B:D ;32B"

%' 7&: %"

! +

""/0 '

%"

+3 7;32BE62E3:D ;-5244"

% 7&: %"

1 ! + !

"

!

B444 7&: %"

1 ! +

% B444 7C: %"

1 !+

C"

B444

>

+ '

""

' 0 !''

. '

!'!

&0

+

B= '% * !

++ *1+?

* '*""

''& 0'

&

%+ %"

+ % !

+ '

++ ' 0' '! '& .

1 ! 0 1

+ '

++ !0 & ""

'"

&/+ 1'!

++ "" 1+ !!

$

6B2 +

+1 !'

C .'

% 1!% !"" +' '

'

.

& + "

C + !"#$

!! % & ' ("

$) )"

$#*+ B

+

-' 0 !''

% +""% +

B!

*1

++ '!

'!

&0

*1' '1&!/

! '!?

!

&0 +

B .

+

%"/0 '% !

"

&!

!*

1 &!/

! ./ " ++

* ' " 1

* "

"

!+ % ++

*

!?* 0 !

&0

1 ! + % ' ++

'

""

!!"

!

/1 + %++

+ * !?0 '+ &

+ !'

.+

!* '*./+

-%!

"/%+ %"

"

1 ! +, % %

#"

$) ) "

$ (! '

!.

&+ ! '+' + -

./0+1 23 +

(1 ! - '

F *1' ' + !

'""

* 1'

'

+ '

++ !0 & 1 " 0 &! !

&0

'

. 1' ?0 ' "

' .

! +1A= 4%

#5 6 7 8 33

8 3 90):#

! "# $

! "#%&

' !

() ! !

* !

%& "#%&

! * + *

!

* ! ! !"# $

*

! *& ! #

$ , -

* ;<= , % % > ' 8? ( "*$ ) ) "

$ (1 " $ $ , $! + . /$ !

; % ' ? 1/ - +#!

> & 3 > 7

$

; % & '? ( / - ( $ , -

*

7 8 3 @ > 37 > 3> > 7 8 3

3 @0 "#%&

!

' 0

*& ! $ &0

*

* **

! **

111112 5 G' %?0.& .

&*'

.'?

% + G=6('$ '0*1

++ *1' ' !''

'! %"/

B= '% *!

+

"

0'!

&0

*1' '1!

% !0 '! ?

+'

!

'

0'% C"

!

" ++

* ' " '!

! '

&0

+

B=

'% +

&

+/0

!+'"

&!

&0

'

& " + ' %/ ' ++

! " 2 + ' ++!&7C :

"

!

!+1A=

3 * + * - +& 4! 5 "

$

! !

! *

! &

! *

6 &!

&

**

*

! *"

# $ "

# !

! * * * * * + * *

& !

+ * * ! & + *

+- -7 * ! %0 5 8 9 8

- 98':)0+ ! !

! * ! ! *

! !& ! 111112 3 "

C +"

$'.

!" 24 +1A= 3 ; !

& ! 0 ! & !

*

&

0 * ;

! 0

*

*& < #=

!

*

* ! * - '8> ?>?>?0

*

0 *

& 0

*

*

6

&

*

@ *

0

* *

* *

-& = - +

= 7*= ; !*

& 2 @ +) 8 ) A

! "#$ 7 " $

!

"

C ! ! ' 0 ! .

!+1A= 3-

&

*

$ *

! &

0

$!

! &

2 64 + )

% > *" $

"B$(+ " 5!3*1 .

!+1A= 39 - - !, >

?

< : A ! B 5 0

* * * 5 "

9> ?>?'(C 9>? ) !*

>)A? 8(D C > 9? - 9 0

C 3@

& ! < ! * *

!

!

!! *

! ! !

< *12 E 0 * *

- '8> ?>?>? &

#

&

B

&

* <

) & ! * * 0 ! & * ! < *

!

! !

! !

! $

*

* < *

!

!

* * & &

*

! ! !

* !

- - !, >

?0

*

& &

*

* * 2 66

+ '

""

1'

+

0 .

& + "

C + "

$ ' 0 ! ' ./ + '

"

& '

/ +

1

+ '

++ '! !% !

!"

& !'

" ! ./ '% 1 &! '

& .

& + "

C " 66

C !+1A= 3 11111111 0

*

! :

! ! ;

! * ;

- * !

!

!

*

* * 0

* *

!2 62 $ + % + '

! '

% ' .

! ./ '

% 1

+ '

++ !0 & 1' ""

0 G=6'"

+ / !''

% +""% +

'% * '

'! / &

+ ! ' !

&0

. ' ?

' !+!'%.

++ !

* '*'

1

' ! ' ! ' !/ C" ' '

1 " ' " 1'

%"/0

B!

6; +

"

!0+ '

1.

&'& ? 1'

'

'

""

'! .

. "

& ' !

&0

+

'% *!

++ *1+?

'

0

'.

"

!'

" + " ++

* !? 7C =>:*1' ' '!

&0

5424'!.

!'

% +% ,$0'+ !$0'!1&!";4666@@3 '

" 1'

/ '

+

0

5424 ! 4@456@@3!1'

'

5424

+

!'

" *1 ! '

+ ' '

1 &! " ;4666@@3 %" ' 1 ! ;<B %

/ "

6@@31 1 C% ! "

& '

" 7C =>:'

" C".% ! %

6@>-4 '

% + $0'* 1' ' 1 &! " 4-466@@5

%"

+

" 7C =>:* &!

'%!

'

!

. ! !

0' /* !?.'

! % '

" ! 0'1 '

. '

0'"

"

' '

F

%1'.

0'!"

'

"

!'

.' %%

1'

/0"

'

" 1'?0 + ''

" ' % + '

0'"

"

' !"" /1++ !

!1

!!

+ '

++ !0 & '

0 + '

" ./

=

C%0 '

"

* 1' %!

"

! ++ + '

!

" % %+'

!

!"'

" 7C =>: .

! '! ' '

&0

+

B= '% * !

++ *1+?

*+ '

./"/ %+ %"

1

!

++ ' + !" !'!

&0

"

!+ C =B1 ./'

0' /*' " !1&!"2-422464'

1 !'

.+% !

" 7C =>: '

!.

&!/"

& !

!* .

!

1'!

+ '% 0/ !./

0' /* !? 1+?

!1

++ 11

+'+ + '

./'%"/%+ %"

'

%"/ 6> F + %/ .& ! * % + '

!

" ' ' ""

' %

""

' 0'

&

%+ %"

+ %1

++ % ! 1 /

&% (# )%*' ,? $%)# ;

& !6 F 65 ; F 65