High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/8310/2014disposed of

Shri Ram General Insurance Company Ltd v. Krishna Devi & ORS

2019-01-07Mr. Justice Arun Monga14 pages

!"#$% "&'

)$* +,$- **&& .

$/" !

0 -!"

# * -

!"#$% "&'

)$* +,$- **&& .

$("0 -!"

# * -

$("0 - !"

**&&

#1/($" -!"

# * -

2$ !"$ - !"

**&&

#1/($" -!"

# * -

$/" !

0 -!"

**&&

#1/($" -!"

# * -

"#14" 5!6-06 "

" 10%+&6-06

"!**&&

" !7!86-06

"!**&&

"" * -

/" 1/("6-06 "

"#0 -"&76-06

"!**&&

"" * -

"# 5&6-06

"" * -

.- ! $$ "-"6

&-: !"#$% "&'

)$* +,$-0

$/" !

0 -!"

&-: !"#$% "&'

)$* +,$-0 $ ("0 -!"

&-: $ ("0 - !"0 #1/($" -!"

&-:2$ !"$ - !"0 #1/($"

- !"

: -

&- : $ /" !

0 -!"

0 #1/($" -!"

:" 4 - * -

)$$ "4 5 - ;! 0!(&" - 7 *&

3& #$ & 5 8! 5! - - - <+ ,& - -8 $ 5 "$/("(7 !"3!8 "( = ";!"8 4 5-"0 4+ 5!4(

368! !+"!- "*"&*($* !" 0&&5 '

-4"6! "$ " ! - 5&5 $

"8!!

8 4 5-"0 4+#1/($"-"0"0"+!5! *- - ! "- !- !" "$ 50"8" 5 -

! "- # (& &+6 3& #$ (

"- $(&*& "(

1(" 5! -<+,&& "0- "( 1("

0"( *" 4-+;!- 8 8

-4+< 5! -;7 5!8!7!! 1("- !! *& - 5! -<+,&8"-&"-4-- '#8 "5 "-5

!-"0" !

- ";!;"4( &---

( 0(" &$ -&&8-!&$* &-4+!&$

!"! ;! **& ! 4 *" ""- 4+ ! '

)$* +5

!8"-*

- 0(" !&$

8!"4+ $( # 6

>8 8"-- ! &$ ( -! 5!

- (

& " ! **&& ! " ""- ?@3 - -- ! &&+ ! 4 '

$ )"

(- 4+! ;!

&-"6;! "6 $ ! - 5! 8 "- 4 # A6

> *"

($;!"8 ""4" ! " - @* -" 5 " - -($ 8!( @$ 5 ! ;!

&-" ;! " - " 8

(- &+ " ! *("* -( ,"

- (

& ("!" (4$- ! ($

5 -!( #

> "$-"+

"$ 5(&- 4 4& !-;!5"(&("& -"$ - 8!! $&+ -0 "-!6!" "6 ! @

5 5"(&(" $ 8

8!&5&"B("$ ;! - !**&& >'

)$* +8

" (-4+&"

& "!&$ !5"( -! *"*"

$ 8 $-4+!"- )&$

;"4( & ! 4 $"& ""- ;! $ " ?@3 8

(- !4 $"&0&4& ""-<$4 - "!+"

?@3 8 7

-" 4+!;!

&-"8!&

5 !& - 0&4&8!!- - -! $-"0-!" "$

*" &--?@3 6! &*+ - 8 4& !- !!-*("! -!( $ (" 5

B("+"- " 62"4 ?

6/("(7 !"0- & ----

;! &"

5*+ -8 4& !- ""-4+8+ ( $*!4& 0- ""- !$ -" 5 '

$)" ?@3

41 8 " -4+!**&& '

)$* + ;! -($ 8" -"- 4+ &"

- (

& " ! &$ 4+ $7 5 $ 4 " ! " - )&$ ;"4( &6 /("(7 !"

- !" "6 &"

& "!&$ & -!0- 4!&

!&$

& 3"( & !""-8(&- !8!!$

@!4 " --($ 6 41 8 " -4+ &"

& "!**&& -!-($ 8 -(&+ @!4-3"( & "

@$ 3C8(&- !8! ! - - 5!8 0"" (-4+! '

)$* +**&& (55 8 50 ! 8

!!- -8 "

5 $ *"1- 4+!&$ ,"

& "!&$ ("!" (4$-

$ -8 !4

4& !-$-

$ -"(& >5(-& "$-4+ ! ,"

- (

& 4+ " "" 5 <

!+750

(4$-! D"+ 6;!

&-" !$* (!"+

( 5 $" A

;! $ " ! 4

(- !4 -&" &-4+ ! **& >5("- ! (- ;!" *"-(" "

5 *"

8!! !0 410$! $;!*"-("! 4 "$& -

" *

( 5 $" C! ! - !- 5 4"-6 ! $ " 8

*"*"- "- 8!&8!$ @!4

$ " 6 (! 41 8 7 4+ ! **&& '

)$* + ,"

&"&-(* #$%& %'()*'+,,- ./ %01,,. )*&%2 %0+ 3#,2/ !!4 5 46.6'5 78

%/0+#% 609#./:%'%& 609# 88745 46.6'5;8

%$% #%0<%2 ./ &3 %=#6 %0+ 3#,2/ 8

4''%#%>%+5;

#*1%2 609#%0+%03#,2./%/0+% 609# %0+3#,2/ 88745*22,03 %?*20%' @>%' 609#./

%03<# 609#%0+%03#,2 8 4 *01%>5;;

063,+

0+6%0/*2%0=, 3+./ &3 6-2%2%#&%%0+%03#,2

88745%' 2%0=#%0%9,2 26,03%'0/*2%0=, 3+./,,0%%06%%0+3#,2/ !; - --! 41 8 " -4+!**&& 8! ?@3 8 -"- -"0- 0- 6!" "6 !-($ ! "5!&+4 7

-" -8

@!4- 0- "- 8!&8 '

8& "&5 & 6 &+ B("+8!"! 0- 4&- -4&0-!!" !&- " *"-(" "B("- 4 &&8- **&& 0" 7 41 " * -$

4&+ ! -($

(55 8 *(!&$ 8! !**"- 3C ;!41 $- *" @( !-($ 8 0"7 4+!**&& *"<

!+750 6! D"+ -

*& "& 8!" $ "

( (!"+ A

8 !8 4)#;!

&-";

- ;! 5(-& "$- 4+ ! " !

$ $ " ! *("*

( 5 $ " 8"-(&+ &&8-4+!;!

&-"?0 !$"& ! 4 4"(5! ""- "$ 1$4 - - & -- !8 &*+ - - 5!

" ! "

""-- !" 406 ' -$ **"*" - $

&- 4+ ! '

)$* +

!"!

4**"- &5!

! !!- -8 A+"

5!$

-!D8 5"(&(" -8 & "(

5-"+ "$ D $8

-4# A6

>*"$ ! *"

$ "

(- 4+ ! ;!

&-" * - + 8

7 4E -$(&*&" 8 **&- '

08 " %360%' 0/*2%0=, &-%0$

6&63,+./ 2%0%$ ,3#6 %0+ 3#,2/ ! 45-,A *23 *+9&,03/4 5 (("*" * !@

& $*&+-*"

4**"- ;!;"4( &!

-$ !&+ -4# A6

>*"$ !(("*" * ! (

F 4---! " -$ !&+ $ - ! 8+6 $( # A

> "B("-4--- !"4+ $7 5 # 6A

> $ !&+ $ ! - !&+-* - + -8(&-$ ( 4 # 6A > " --( 5 E 8"- *"

& @*

;! - - 8 A +"

56 !" "6

$(&*&" 8(&- 4 1( - **"*" 08

&3 %2'%B,2&%./,'#62%0/-232-2%360 !!845

46.6'577'

! 8+6$*

8(&-$(4 # 6 6

> A @

@8!! $( #

> 4---(*8"- 0 &!- *"%360%'

0/*2%0=, &-%0$ 6&63,+ ./ 2%0%$ ,3#6 %0+ 3#,2/ =%/, 4/*-2%5 ;! & $( *+4& # 6 6

" !$( $*

8(&-""+ " GAF*"

($ "$!- & 5 &$* &&

& "&H ! $( "0"6 8 " - '

)$* + !

- 50!&8(&-41 &+ - 0"&&+ &4&

8"!&$ !$*

!" -

"$(&-4+"- )&$ ;"4( &6/("(7 !" 8(&-"$ ! $

7"! '

)$* + ! *" ""- ! **& 5

!8"---

-4+"- )&$ ;"4( &8!"4+ $( $*

! ( # A6 6 > 8 8"-- ! &$

( -! <+,& &+5"0 !**&& ! - <+ ,& 8 8" 5&+

- ! 4

$@"("

8!"4+ $( # 6A 6A >8

!8 *"

& $ -#

> 5"(&("& $ "- 5 &"

- (

& " ! **&& 6 5"(&("& $ (&- 4

-"- ! & - "$ -8!! $&+ - ;! )(" $*"

-4+!"5($ "! " !&

( (*"0 -

! # A

>*"$ !'

! 8+6 &$*( "8 (*"0

- &

! #

>*"

($ ;! &+ "5($ " - 4+ ! **&&

( 4& !+ &8 -!**&- "0 4 - $

- '

08 406!" * " "

-! $ - - $

/7!;%0+7!7"! " -**& !04 *" ""-4+!"

<+,& " ! $ $*

! 4 &-4+("0 -3$4" !"$ "

! $ $*

C-8 <+,& $&+(" 0! **"- !8

4@ 3C2$ !"$

-$ !"$"$""- -3$4" !"$8

(- ! "&0 $ D 8 ( $""- (" 0 8-8 -3$4" !"$( $""- 8"!&-4 -* - (* ! $ <+ ,& - - 2$ !"$ -$ !"$4 5$""- --(5!"

-<+,&8"!&-4 -* - (* <+,&<+,&8 5-A +"

-! -8 - 5*"*"+-&"4(

-5"(&("& 8"7 '

$ <+ ,& 8

- 4 # 6 > /* 5 08! $* $&+6 --( ! @ > "- 8 **&-8"- *"

&@*

! 8+6$ !&+-* - +8

-4 #

6A >8!!$(&*&"

8 **&- 08

&3 %2'%B,2&%./,'#62%0/-232-2%360 !!845

46.6'577 $( # A6A 6 >8

0(" ("0 -3$4" !"$8!! $( #

> ( &@*

!"5 8 --- - ($ #

>8 8"-- 8"- &

"($ - #

> 8"- &

! 8+6# A6 6 >8 *+4&("0 -3$4" !"$ !"

F !8"-- $( 8(&- $ ( 4 #

6 > 8!! 8

*+4&("08-8 -!"$ 5 F 8"--$( # 66>8 *+4&3$4"

!"$4 5-* - (* -<+ ,& 3"( & !""-8(&- !8! $( !

-8"- (("*" * -;! -8 AA+"

5 -8 & $*&+-'

08 %360%'0/*2%0=,&-%0$ 6&63,+./ 2%0%$ ,3#6%0+ 3#,2/ ! 45 -,A *23 *+9&,03/ 4 5 ((" *" * !(

F 48"--7* 5 08 !5 -'

-- ! " -68"- $- ( -" 0 & !- ! 4 "0 -

8! ! " %360%' 0/*2%0=, &-%0$

6&63,+./ 2%0%$ ,3#6%0+3#,2/=%/,4/*-2%5 ;! " -@ 6 "

" 4$-

!$*(5 -8"- " *

&-4+ (" 0 - 3$4" !"$ !&+ $ ! - 8

- 4 # 6 >

F ! " - $8(&-$(4# >--

! " - $( 8(&- $7 $ !&+ $ ! -4# 6 >"( --

# 6

(& $ 8(&- $ 4 # 6

> *"

/* 5 08!$* $&+6--(

! @ > "- ! 4 **&- 8"- *"

& @*

! 8+6!&-* - + 8(&-$(4# 6AA6

> '

08 &3 %2'% B,2&% ./ ,'#6 2%0/-23 2-2%360 !!845 46.6'5776$(&*&"

! 4 **&- 8!! $ 4 # 6 6

> 6AA6

8!! #

> ! 4 --- 8"- 0 & !"5 !&- %360%'0/*2%0=,&-%0$ 6&63,+./

2%0%$ ,3#6%0+3#,2/=%/,4/*-2%5

" !$( 8(&-""+ " GAF *"

($ "$ ! - & 5 &$ * && & "&H ! $( ;! $

" **" $

!8 4+!"- )&$ ;"4( &8(&-"$

$ * -

7!7"!

! 4 &- 4+ 2$ !"$ - $ !"$ 8! 8" !&- &- "

$ 4 5$""- --(5!" <+,& (

!**&& 4 5$1" -$""-

4!&-4

-* - (* - +$

";!"

4 + @* ! - ""-- 4+ ! ;"4( &**&& " &-$*

!+ 8" -* - (* - ;! **& "- 5&+6- $

4 5

C!!" *7 5>" - I >

C!!""*"4& I >