High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5485/2017dismissed

Jagdev Singh v. Shamsher Singh

2018-10-23Mr. Justice Satpal7 pages

#$% $& ''(( ) &+ & $& ' "# $% %%% ,

-*(' .("% /* 0("%

&''(( %%% & ''(( 2 $$ % 0*$+

4&( /%(#*$ % " *5 & .(( 0*$+

4 &( ( #*$" *5 & * '

(4&'(

2 ' 4.4

' &' ' 4 .(( * ' + 0* &' ''(( + $ 4

* *' ' 4 ( $& +.&*' . 4&( (* *'&(4&( ''((* 6

4 0* & &&

2 ' (&% *.&('( $&&

& & %(($6&*(( "7& ( *5 & 8 & & *' ' 4* ' ' 4. $ +*5+ + * $.5 ( 7&

(+&%39! & * .5 ( + (

". "& 9! & *

& ( '((' 4". % && $

* &'(.&* 4 &

:. * & '(&&''(( 2 .

* % &( * &+ .& &&

$& .&*' &( 7&'(

8 & '*& "&

. *.&&0 .

&' '

&( . ;* *+ + +&(+

&'(

*& < "& *. ( ''(( 2 & *= + .

("5 $% * ' (+ 40

:. &&'(

. &.

" & & +(4' .&( &' ' 4( $ $&'(

& & >* +( $& !

3 $& ' ".5 ( (

((& &

& >* +( $&++ *+ &

. @*.

& & <.% "& . $. ' & % **& +* &

'. ( 7&* "&'(

. .

39! & :. * & &&''(( 2 '* & 5 ( + ( 9! & +*

"A"

98% $ (

+>* +( $&>* +( $& +% 44

& + .

&'39! & + ( & 5& >* +( $&& ( .

& & "

(*(

'& ' &( = $

& ' . @* 4

>* +( $&,& '4 *+

& % & 4>* +( $&7& +. *(4 4&.

+''' 4 4 +*

. $% >* +( $&&+7&* "& 2''(( (+&%+ &.

&( 5& 7&( .&& . '* & 4& $ (. (.(4 $. ($$ 7& &'* && (%(( $& + &

' (5& & + /

* . $ 4 & &&'* & & + +

( *. ' 4

'( . ( B((. $

* . +4&( (/* &'( =&& '(

( '

4 .4

' ' ' 4( + * $ + ( *

( + * $ 5 ( + ( ( && " * & %(($6&*(( C,,

=&& & '(

( ' + 0*

$& ++5 $

* % &

* ' ' 4 ( $ & * ' ' 4 .&* ' C,, ! =&& * & '(

+ ( &

C, =&& & & + .

& * ' ' 44.4 . $

C, ( D% . ( 4 & & ' & '%

E (/*

$&% "

*+ (*&&'(

& *

' % $& .& & & (' %&&. .

& ( 5& 7& "& *

(4&'(

. ''( (4&''(( .

4&( ( #*$" *5 &% 0*$+

$$ %& +"' ''(&

( E *

( &''(( %&+ (4 $* && &( * (.&%$

(4 $& * (4&

2 ' : &&' ''(( & *(4 ' % && . ' ((& &

>* +( $&F>''

8 8 &''(( = $D@. *(4' %4&+ $ (.

= & " &( * (.

* : "&* "' 4&& ''(((."+'*$ 0*$+

4&( /%(#*$ % " *5 & .(( 0*$+

4&( ( #*$" *5 & /

;* (4 * (4&'(

2 ' +

& *$&* :&%& ( *

( &''(( &%' * & ( 7& * &''(( ?

*' &

&' &(

& >* +( $&( & '( *+ D@

'& '4 & (($ ++ *+ +(4 ' 7& ''(( *$&( 4% ' %& *+ D@ &$ * & $ (& 5'4&'(

(4'& '4".&& . $% & & >* +( $& '

8 2 & ''(( < ''( (

4% . ((.4&( (* !

*0' @ (

*+ : (% & $ & >* +( $& '

2 2 &''(( & &

.& (($&%& % &'& *+ &

@+ 4& (

4>* +( $& + (.

& @+ + (&''(( ?

(4 4&>* +( $&. . % 4& &

% & &' ''(( =G $& = # 5 $&.&&%

@+ ' % & '& '4 & (($ ++ *+

' D@ &% $% 4 ( .& % $ $ & '& '4 & .

% & & '& '4 D@ . + + $ ( 7& &

&+ $ .& 4 .&+ & '4 . ' ' *& 4 & '&'4 & ' % 7& "&( * (.&% $&(4&(&D@. *(4' % : & $&&( (/* & $&(4 &(&% &++ *+ ' 5

%(&''(( ( &( ;*

+ & *+ % "& & $ &.& &(($++ *+. % *' ( *

'& *4&( (/* B* & + "&''(( & (*' *+ D@!

&% @* +4.& (D@ .

D@! & & ( @*4>* +( $&F>' %* &''(( : & &>* +( $&& +.

5 (

4.4 +(4' <.% "% &"+ & 4 &(($ +(4' & + >* +( $&

&% (& + *+ "

98&''(( * & + & >* +( $& .*( $ & ( $ 4 $ $& & #$% $& 45 $'.

4 +&+:

">* +( $&. &.

( "

& .

4 & (&&.*( $& &

@* ( .*(5'. 4 & &

@* ( %* & 2''(( : &* " $&(4 (*4( * (.&>* +( $&F>' &+ ( . & .

' ' 4 ;*

& "& . ;* >* +( $& %4 $(& &''(( 2 7& * & '*&& 2 ''(( &'* & 5 ("+ ( +>* +( $&4.4 (D@ :

& * " $&(4 % 4&( (/* && .&4&''(( .*(

*' >* +( $&

* &@* ( (4 +& & &&'. 4 $&

( $ : '

(& +

"((& ( $

3"& .*( &%5 4 @* ( 6& & ( * (. &% *

& ''(( .&( + ' ' '' % .&&. :

' " ;* (.+*&(

(;*

(. %(% & ''( & $*+ .

E *

( &''(( * (' * (($(4

+4 +'*$ 0*$+

3 '

4&( /%(#*$ % " *5 &

.(( 0*$+

4 & ( ( #*$" *5 & .&& (( 4& /* $(4"& ''( +

.& %'()'**!

+,-.

=&& '5 $9

H 9 =&& ' (

H 9