← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5517/2017dismissed

Municipal Corporation Rohtak v. Magan Singh & ANR

2018-10-12Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu5 pages

  



         !" #"$%&%'(  ) *'%$%+ , -+- !%'./! 0 ++",, '! 1"-&*&  2 '%'2/ '# '!/"- "&+'#"'!&   ( 34  

54 -"&"'!( -%&/ 6/ *+! .#7$ !" -!/" ++",, '! 888   

 9: 4" -'"# $*'&", / & +-#*$"# $"-!% %"# $+; 

="!!" >!- !% %$ !%' %'#%# !"#   &@",, &$+; -@ -#%'2,"!!"-# !"#A > &@",, & $+;   !/" !% %$ !%' +*6,%&/"# %' !/" ="!!"  >!- .# !"# %'#% &@",, & '2,%&/7"-&%'%' *-!!# ; /"& <" -"! 0"''-"$-# : 4" -'"#$*'&", -!/" ++",, '!$'!"'#"#!/ !!/"B*#2<"'! !/"," -'"# %7%,*#2"-%7%&%'./! 0# !"# C C#"$-""%'2 !/"&*%! %,"#6;-"&+'#"'!D+, %'!%

 &@",, &B*#2<"'! '##"$-"" # !"#AE + &&"#6; !/"," -'"###%!%' , %&!-%$!*#2". /! 0 *+/,#%'2!/"B*#2<"'! '##"$-""+ &&"#6;!/"," -'"# %7%,*#2"- %7%&%'./! 0 -","2 ,,;*'&*&! %' 6,"&%'$"!/" *-!&6",@ %,"#! ! 0" %'! $$*'! ''F$<+,% '$" @%!/ !/" -"G*%-"<"'!& &!%+*, !"# %' !/"

="!!"  >!-  !% %$ !%' 9?DE F :.

: # !"#  /"-"%'

!"--"

"--"#! &H!% 3 +-#*$!%'   HF*"& %$ !"3 ! $, %< ">"<+!%' -< + ;<"'!  /*&"! > 9E: 4" -'"# %7%, *#2" - %7%&%'. /! 0 $'&%#"-"# !% +-7%#%'2 -">"<+!%' -<+ ;<"'! /*&"! > & ,&!/"'!" ++"'#"#!!/"& <"+-7%#%'2!/ !">"<+!%' -<+ ;<"'! /*&"! >@ & ++,%$ 6,"&*6B"$!!+-#*$!%' %$ !"3 /*&"! >!%,,EE )6;6&"-7%'2!/ !!/"!% #%#'! +-7%#" -+-#*$!%' %$ !"3 '#!/ !!/"-"G*%-"<"'!! +-#*$" H *"& %$ !"3 @ & !;+"# *! ' !/" !% 6",@!/"&%2' !*-"& !/"*!/-%!;%&&*%'2!/"& %#!% %$ !%'.!/"-"

-". !/"-"G*%-"<"'! +-#*$!%' %$ !"3@ &'! + -! !% %$ !%' 9A: / 7""> <%'"#!% $"-!% %"#$+; @/%$// & 6""'+-#*$"#6;!/"," -'"#$*'&", -!/" ++",, '! &@",, &$+;

-@ -#%'2,"!!"-# !"#A >/ 7" ,&6! %'"#$+; '!% %$ !%' & +*6,%&/"# %' !/" ="!!"  >!- F -#%' -;. # !"# %'#% & @",, & '2,%&/ 7"-&%' -< !/"

="!!"" '# < & !%& %"# !/ ! !/" !;+"# +-!%' 6",@ !/" !%

%&'!',;*'&%2'"# &/",#6;!/"," -'"# %7%,*#2"-%7%&%'. /! 0 6*! ,& !/ ! %! %& '! + -!   !/" !% %$ !%' & +*6,%&/"# %' !/"

="!!"  >!- F-#%' -;. # !"#  '- / & ';-"

"-"'$"%'-"&+"$! !/"$'#%!%'6""'<"'!%'"#%'!/" -@ -#%'2 ,"!!"- >'-/ &," -'"#$*'&", -!/" ++",, '!6""' 6,"!-"

"-! '; -"$-# &/@%'2 !/" *!/-%!; *'#"- @/%$/ !/" !;+%'2 -"G*%-%'2 +-#*$!%'   HF*"& %$ !"3 @ & < #" '# !/" +-7%&%'   , @ -", ! 6," %' -"&+"$! !/"-"!  4" -'"# %7%, *#2" - %7%&%'. /! 0

9E: $$-#%'2,;/",#!/ !%!@ &$," -!/ !-"&+'#"'!D+, %'!%

/ #'!6""' %'

-<"# 6*! '; $'#%!%' @%!/ -"2 -# ! +-#*$!%'   HF*"& $"-!% %$ !"3'-@ &%!"7"-< #" + -! !/" $!* ,!% %$ !%' '#!/ !' "7%#"'$"%'-"&+"$!!/"-"!/ #6""',"# 9: /" !% %$ !%'   @ & @%!/#- @' 7%#" '!%  >I# !"#

A  /"," -'"# %7%,*#2" *-!/"-6&"-7"#!/ ! "7"'5F/ # #<%!!"#!/ !!/"-"@ &'<"'!%'%' >I!/ ! --" -& @"-" -"G*%-"# ! 6" + %#. !/ ! !/" -"&+'#"'!D+, %'!%

 / # + %# /*&" ! > 7%#" > -!/";" -& F A '# !!/ !!%<" ,&'6B"$!%'/ # 6""' - %&"# 6; !/" #"+ -!<"'! -"2 -#%'2 " -,%"- --" -&. !/"-" -". %! @ & 6";'#$<+-"/"'&%' &!/@$<"%!/ #6""'$/ -2"#%'!/";" -  6;@ ; /*&"! >6%,,# !"#   >E$$-#%'2,;.!/"&*%! @ &#"$-""# 9C: /" ," -'"# 4@"- ++",, !" *-! /",# !/ ! %! @ & '! %' #%&+*!"!/ !-"&+'#"'!D+, %'!%

@ &$$*+;%'2!/"/*&"G* @/%$/ --" -& /*&"F! >@"-"#"< '#"#6;!/" ++",, '!6*!!/" ++",, '!/ # '! +, $"# ' -"$-# '; $"-!% %"# $+;   !/" '!% %$ !%' %&&*"# 6; !/"

7"-'<"'! -; ' &/@%'2!/ !+-#*$!%' %$ !"3 /*&"F! > @ &  +-"F$'#%!%' - &""0%'2 &*$/ ">"<+!%' '# "7"' !/"-@%&".!/"-"$-#-", !%'2!!/"/*&"F! >-"< %'"#%'!/"$*&!#; ++",, '! '# !/" ++",, '! @ & !/" 6"&! +"-&' ! &"" @/"!/"- !/" -"&+'#"'!D+, %'!%

@ &%' --" -& /*&"F! >'!/" -"<"'!%'"# 6 $02-*'#. !/" ," -'"# %-&! ++",, !" *-! /",# !/ ! !/" ," -'"# %7%, *#2" - %7%&%'. /! 0 / # -%2/!,; 6&"-7"# !/ ! -"&+'#"'! D +, %'!%

$*,#'!6"#"'%"#!/"6"'"

%! ">"<+!%' -</*&"F! > &+"- !/"!% !/"-+%'!/ &6""' -2*"#

9A: 9:  / 7" $'&%#"-"# !/" &*6<%&&%'&   ," -'"# $*'&", - !/" ++",, '! '# < !/"7%"@!/ !!/" ++" ,%&6"-"

! <"-%!.!/"-"

-".%& ,% 6,"!6"#%&<%&&"# -!/"-" &'& & -"-"$-#"#/"-"*'#"- 9): #<%!!"#,;.!% @ &%&&*"#2- '!%'2">"<+!%' ! @'"-&   &", F$$*+%"# -"&%#"'!% , /*&"& -< + ;<"'!   /*&"F! > @"  A )  !%  %&&*"# 6; !/" <<%&&%'"- '# "$-"! -;! 7"-'<"'! -; ' .-6 '4$ ,#%"&"+ -!<"'!@ &

-@ -#"#6;!/"%-"$!-. @' '# *'!-;, ''%'2. -; ' 7%#","!!"- # !"#A >4"!!"- >#%#'!$'! %' ';<"'!%' -"G*%-"<"'! !/"+"-&'&"'!%!,"#!">"<+!%' -<+ ;<"'! /*&"F! > 6"%'2-"G*%-"#!&*6<%!HF*"& %$ !"3"&%#"&.!/"'!% %$ !%'%'

%'#% &+-#*$"#6;!/"#"+ -!<"'!6"

-"!/"," -'"# %7%,*#2"$'! %'& !;+%'2%' '2,%&/-"G*%-%'2+-#*$!%' %$ !"3%'-#"-! $, %<">"<+!%' -<+ ;<"'! /*&"F! > /"& <"%&*'&%2'"# '#%& 6",@!/"&" , !/"%&&*%'2*!/-%!; 9?: "-*& , !%  &@",, &!% %$ !%'+*6,%&/"# %'!/" ="!!" >!- .# !"# %'#% &@",, & '2,%&/7"-&%'-"7" ,&!/ !!/"& <"#"&'!$'! %' ';!;+%'2 &/ & 6""'-"

,"$!"# '# &%&$'! %'"#%' '-/ &," -'"#$*'&", -!/" ++",, '!6""' 6,"!2%7" ';">+, ' !%'@%!/-"2 -#!!/"6 &%&'@/%$/ !/" !;+%'2 / & 6""' 2%7"' ' !%  -"G*%-%'2 +-#*$!%'  HF*"&$"-!% %$ !"3'-6""' 6,"!#%&$,&"!/"*!/-%!;@/< #"- *!/-%="# !/ ! !;+%'2 '- / & ," -'"# $*'&", 6""' 6," ! #%&$,&" !/" +-7%&%' , @< 0%'2-"G*%-"<"'! &*6<%&&%' HF*"&$"-!% %$ !"3 & "&&"'!% ,+-"F-"G*%&%!"!!/""'!%!,"<"'!!2"!">"<+!%' -<+ ;<"'!  /*&"F! > %' -"&+"$!   &", F$$*+%"# -"&%#"'!% , 6*%,#%'2 &%!* !"# %' *'%$%+ , *'$%,D <<%!!""&

9: 9:  ' !/" $%-$*<&! '$"&.  %'# ' "--- @/ !&"7"- %' !/" B*#2<"'!&+ &&"#6;!/"," -'"# %7%,*#2"-%7%&%'./! 0 &*+/",# 6;!/"," -'"###,%&!-%$!*#2"./! 0 &*6&! '!% , G*"&!%'   , @ -%&"& -$'&%#"- !%'%'!/%& ++" , /"& <"%&6"-" ! <"-%! 9:  $$-#%'2,;.!/""2*, -"$'#++" ,%&#%&<%&&"#%',%<%'" 5 ,%  *#2"   ) <%! 5/"!/"-&+" 0%'2D-" &'"# ( "&D 5/"!/"--"+-! 6," ( "&D