Ajaib Singh And Others v. Harbans Kaur And Another
TARUN SAHNI 2023.01.06 14:18
$%&&'()(*+ ,
-$(.(*/0$*1%0&2) 33&44$*%) 5) $2.$*)6$72$*1$*%0&2 &)3*1&*%) "+8 9:"
6
!!!!
6
; " # $
% $ $ #
&
' ($ ) * +( $,
- .
$
/ #01210&113 4($ ) * $ )54 6 * * $ )5- .
7$8 # , - "
.9$9 $ :
7$ # ;* 9< 9$9
=> ( % $ 13 == =321
?@ A ( <* B7$7 @ 7=1 =1 =3A>-?@ "=.
5 7 <* B 7( # @ =& 1C =32=-?@ ":?@ "> ?@ "==. >
=>
$
/ =&:
#
/ : 1> =3A>-?@ "&. / :
# ;* <7 % &112 $ < $ $7 $ $ $7 7 7 $ $ # 7@ 13 == =321 <7
7 7
7
6 * 7
>
< @ =& 1C 32= $ 7&113
&27
7 $ <7
&112 % <7 $* * 7 <*
7
<7 7$ &
@
B 7# %
$ &27 7 <7$ 1> =3A>
$ 7
%*
<
* $7 #
=.
E 7F5 &.
E 7 * 7F5 :.
E
$7 $F5 D.
E
F5 >.
E $
F5"
C.
E
F5"
A.
E $7
F5"
2.
E
$ * * 7 F5"
3.
E
7 * F5"G =1.
E #
F5"
:
==.
< $7 ( 7$
$@ 57 7, $ E= E& # 5/ =& / : - @ 7
.
"E="E&"E: 7 E 7 $ @ @
% / =D $7 7 7 * H
$
I % >
% / C=1 #6
* =1 =1 &1=C$7 # , - "
. 9$9 $
=1
I $ #//91= 1=:DC3 &1=C $7 $7 "
, * :1 &1=3
==
< $ $
$ # $7
=&
-.
% $7 $ #
$
@ D
=& 1C =32=$ $7 7 &113
7$$7 % $ # 7 @ @ $ $
$ 7$7
@ 7=&7
$ $$
-$.
% # %
7@ B 7
" $ #
@
7# $$ $ $ -.
#
7$7 $
$ $7 <* %
$@ $7 <*
@ 7$7 DD <7 7
-.
%
$@ < 7 , >
$
% &112 $ $$ $7 <7$$ @ % &112$ $7 $ $ % -.
$ <* <* $ 7
7
@
# -.
$ 7
* $7# $
$7
=:
5
* ) $7# $
# $7 $ $
=D
% $ $ 7
=>
7$
% # <* B7 B=1 =1 =3A> ? $ # @ % 13 == =321 % 7
$@ =& 1C =32=
C
#
=C
% 7 @ 7$
5@ 77 7 7$ 7 % $
=& 1C =32=-?@ ":?@ "> ?@ "==. 7 $#
=A
( / : 7
$7 1> =3A>-?@ "&.
$@ $7# <
# H @ =& 1C =32= $ # @ 13 == =321 @ $6 7=& 1C =32=
7 $ $
$
=2
% !"# $ %&'
& $ ! () * $ + , $7 (
#
$
$ 7 7
6
$ 12 == =3AA
=3
%-! . )
"!
!
* A
& *+ $$7(4$ #
$ $
$
%$$(4$ # / & 2
:1 =3C:7 $$ $ - . J * 7:1 1A =3AD
=2 1:
=32= (4$ # $ $ @ * 7
@ 8
<
$ 7 * 7$7 =&7 @
@7
$$$7 C1-.8
&1
%
$ 6
$7 =& 1C =32= ?@ ":?@ ">?@ "== % > =3A> /: ( $ 7 /:
$ @ -! . )/ '$)& )732$# < $ 2
-
# .
$ $ &=
<
$ % $ 7$ $ ! !
! ! *0+1 $ 01 "
9 *$ (
#
!
3
"
!
#
$
% &&
8 -. 2 !! 03 +03
9 (
# $ $ 7
-$.
4 5 ! !
6 ! "!
! $ ! 1 $ 1+
$7 " % $77 =1
-. 7 87 2 9 1 $7(4$ #
&
'
(
'
!
)*+
9 $ %9 *0 *+ *00,
,1+ "/ 7 *001 1
+ 1 ,
,
!
)-
)-
)-
)-
)-
*
==
)" # *
*00 3
128)."
-. 7 87/ & 5 9 (
# 7! "! ! :"" "! ! *1, +,0
"
.
+'
/0
12
32
4"
5
% &:
<$ $7
( 6 7
$
7 7 6
$7 @
$7$ 0 (
H 6
7 $ 7 @ 7
$ $6 =&
-. -$. -. 7-. -. $ 6
7
7 7$ % 7$
$
$$$
$7 7$ 7 $ 7 4 $ ) 8"! : !7!!
!"! ) ( ; 0*
+*1 &D
8 # $ 7
7$ $ $
$ =& 1C =32=$ $ $ $ @ $7 (K$ # -! . )/ '$)& )732$# &>
$ $
$ 7$
(
$ $
=:
$
$
&C
% =& 1C =32= -?@ ":?@ ">)?@ "==. @ $77 $ # 7@ $ 7 $$ $
&A
I =& 1C =32= $
$ $ ) 7 @ 7 7
0 #
&2
< 5# == =321 $7
<*
<* $
@=0: % =& =32=?@ ":?@ ">?@ "== $@ $7 7 6
@ $ @ $7 $ =0: % 7 7
7$7
&3
/7$ D:<7=22& =D
<, = 4 ! 5 #! '
4 &'
554 62
&
"
( . 78 9
0 9
(
(
9.
9 % :1
% <* 7 $ 7 $ 7 $
7 <* 6
7 # $7 $
:=
% =& 1C =32= $ $@ $7 <* $ <* @ 7 @ 7# 7@ 7 % =>
<* 7 $
$ 7
$
$ % 7
$ 7 &112 7 %
:&
($7 7 $ 7 &112 7 %
7E=, 7 % #
=321 &112$ 7$ $
%.!
"! *0 13 7 $$ @ (4$ #
6. In Janki Vashdeo (supra), it was held that a power of attorney holder, who has acted in pursuance of the said power, may depose on behalf of the principal in respect of such acts but cannot depose for the principal for the acts done by the principal and not by the power of attorney holder. Likewise, the power of attorney holder cannot depose for the principal in respect of matters of which the principal alone can have personal knowledge and in respect of which the principal is entitled to be cross-examined. In our opinion, the failure of the respondent to appear in the witness box can well =C
be considered to raise an adverse presumption against him as further observed therein as follows :
15. Apart from what has been stated, this Court in the case of Vidhyadhar v. Manikrao observed at SCC pp. 583- 84, para 17 that:
17. Where a party to the suit does not appear in the witness box and states his own case on oath and does not offer himself to be cross-examined by the other side, a presumption would arise that the case set up by him is not correct...." ::
/
$@ 7 $
% &112 $ 7
$@7 @ $ $
$ $ 7 % / = / & <*
% 7 @ $7 @ 7# 7@ <* $ 7
$@
$ $
9 <* @
7 #
=A
< 7 7 <*
:D
8# $
$7
/ $
$
$
$7 8 # ' $7 .! "! 5 4 ! $ ! !
"! *03+ $:
3 $ $
:>
%
$ %
$
=&7 $
$ C> 8
=3C:
$ .! "! 5 4 ! $ ! !
"! 5 $7 "
9 (
#
: *
& ; *
/<3
& ; *
"
=
"
=2
>5 #
% :C
% % !
6 ! *+ +* 1 0 $ $7$(
#
$ 4 $
:A
7 > ?
&! ! %9 *01 %
! 30 (
# C> $ $7 =&76
$7 7 $7 $
=&7
$$ $7
I
7
4 $
:2
% 7
< $ =& 1C =32= @ $7 <* '7 # 7 @ <
) <* # @ 7 =3
7 =&7
<
&113$7 7$$7
:3
5$ $ $7# $ $
* 7$7
<
$7 $7
* $7# $
< $7 ( $
$*7$2<,;
6
# 2&*7 E 0 L0/ E$ L0/ &1