High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5710/2017dismissed

Vaishno Devi @ Biaso Devi v. Union Of India & ORS

2019-01-15Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih4 pages

# $%&%!'( )) *

!" #$ "%&' $

+++

# ))*,' ,& '&"& ,& "* # -.

" # /(,*,0

& & 1,&"

))*,' ,&$ ) ))*,' ,& **&2"

* # -.

" # /(,*,0 '&"&"

# ))*,' ,& '&"& ,& "* # 3 " # (,*,0

& & 1,&"

))*,' ,&$ "!*# !))&"

((," %, ))*,' / ))** $ ) ))*,' ,& **&2"

* # 3 " # (,*,0 '&"&"

**0 & 5!"01 "' ) "

"",,& *

,%,* 6!"0 7,&

,%,,&8 9& " "

: - 24# !, "'* ,& )("

))** /)* ,,(( ))&,1 & '&1) ,& 0&!"

,0 , !4 "

,4! 4* & ,*, # %,' "$ (&$ ,*"

))&,1 & )& & (

-3 ;

-- 2, ** 4(, '"

& %,' *&0 2, , -< ) !1 ,*"

& =/0 , ) #1 &! 1#

* >*( !"

,& *

(' !"

*&0 2, , 1 " &# ,5!',& * 4(, '"

& %,'

2, ((' (&1 " ))&,1 ))** /)* ,,(($ ",1,"

*,0 ( ' '* ,1 ))&,1 & '&1) ,& 0&!"

1 " &! & '&?!, * 4(, !'

( 1,*# ),& " / '!1/,1 0 !,# % 4 * "

& ))** $ 0 , )("

))** /)* ,,(( 4 ",1,"

,,' 6!"0$ 9& %," 5!"01 " "

@ -;

'&,& * "

'&!* !4 "

2,* & ',% "!# 4' ! '!14*,0

),** $ 4!,"

!*,0

,$ (&$ ,*"

& '&," ,& ))&,1 & '&1) ,& 0&!"

4' ! !4 "

"!,0 ',% "!# 4 ,4!"

& ,*, # %,'

, (! '&,& ,*"

& =/0 , 4(, !" 1#

* >*( !"

,& *

(' !"

,& 4 1 "

&! 4*&2 % ))', "

'&' )&,,& 2, 0 "

+ !',&$ ))*,' 4* "1,"

)&"

A 5!"01$ (&$ ) "

&! 4*&2 "% & 4 ,"

% '&,""

!41,,& 1 " * "

'&!* 2, , '$ % 0& &!0 ,1)!0"

5!"01

A & ",)! 2, 0 "

& ( ' '* ,1 ))&,1 & )& & & '&1) ,& 0&!"

"! & !4 "

'&,""

& " '&,!"

,0 "

"?! ,,#

(' 71#8 4! 5'"

& '&," ,& *,0 ( ' 2 * 0 !14 ))*,' ,&$ 2 !41,"$ 4,0 *,1,"

!14 )& % ,* 4*$ ' '* ,1 2 "!*# '&,""

&$ 2& 2 1& "%,0$ 2 &(("

))&,1

A '* ,1 ))** $ ) !* !',& ))*,' 4*$ '&,""

& &'' ,& 4! & ** &'' ,&$ '&!*"

1 9 0 "

A * 2$ 4 * ,"

"&2 % ,&! 5!"01

&!$ 4 ("

& * "

))**

&! 0 "$ ' & 4 ",,0!,"

))*,' 4* & '

A '* ,1 2, 0 "

& 0 =/0 , 4(, & 1#

* >*( !"

1 " &! *,0 ( ' ) !',&$ 9, 2& ' 0&, &*", ,*"

0 !'

=/0 , $ & 4,0 & 2& 2 9,**"

',& 7 * ' ! *,,8 (&1 ; !0!$ 3B & : ),*$ 333 '&"

4,0 & 2& 2 9,**"

',& 7 *

! *,,8 (&1 #$ 333 &2 " ,'*!""

&) ,& ,5 #

0,*

A !4 "

# 33@ !(&! *#$

, "& ( ** !" # '&",,& &) ,& 4' ! ( ** ),** *&!0 &) ,& * ' & 4 1"

4 * ' ! *,#

"1,"

)&,,& 4,0 0 "

" /'!1/,1 0 !,# ',%,0 ( 1,*# ),& 2**

%,2 4&%$ ) 4,0 "%&,"

1, ",1,"

'- ./ 0 *

> ) 9,0C &" DC & > )& 4* DC &