Didar Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
- - !*(#.
/*,01 ------ %$*$*&,%.
2%.+3+ /$#$% #.4#,# &$1%.+ ------
%+5&,(%,$+
6 7 -
/ /
.%+%,$ .-
#8%+1 #,+#9:
(;&)#$%
5%$*$*&,%.-
+- 5#+#,# !1#<#,:
#.4#,#- - - / :
-
7
- %$*$*&,%.
!*(#.
/*,01 '*9%( *,+$#,$ )*;*9 <.*$ 5%$*$*&, =%%, '*9%( .$*)9%+ > &,+$*$3$*&, ,(*#:
*,$%.
#9*#:
+%%?*,0 <.*$ ,#$3.% )%.$*&.#.* @3#+1*,0A&(*'*)#$*&, (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% 5#++%( &AA*++*&,%.:
A=#9# !*;*+*&,:
A=#9#
+1&.$ 6!*;*+*&,#9 &AA*++*&,%.6:
<1%.%=4
#.* C*+1#, =%%, .%*,+$#$%( &, 5&+$ 7#A=#.(#.
;*99#0% #1.*:
%1+*9 1#,%+#.:
!*+$.*)$ C3.3?+1%$.#-
- .*%'94:
&,% /1.* +1&?
#,+#9 +3=A*$$%( )&A59#*,$ #0#*,+$
#.* C*+1#, 1#( <.&,094 $#?%, &, #))&3,$ ).&5+:
<1%.%35&, &99%)$&.:
C3.3?+1%$.#
+1&.$ 6&99%)$&.6:
;*(% (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% :
.%A&;%( '.&A 5&+$ 7#A=#.(#.
;*99#0% #1.*-
- $ $.#,+5*.%+
#.* C*+1#, )1#99%,0%( 1*+ .%A&;#9 (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% '*9*,0 #, #55%#9 =%'&.% &AA*++*&,%.-
!3.*,0 5%,(%,)4 #'&.%+#*( #55%#9 '*9%( :
5%$*$*&,%.
!*(#.
/*,01 +&301$ *A59%#(A%,$ $1%.%*,:
<1*)1 #99&<%(- - 1% &AA*++*&,%.:
;*(% (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% :
+%$ #+*(% (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% :
<1%.%=4 .%A&;%( '.&A 5&+$ 7#A=#.(#.
.%*,+$#$%( 1*A 7#A=#.(#.
;*99#0% #1.*-
- , #'&.%A%,$*&,%( )*.)3A+$#,)%+:
5%$*$*&,%.
'*9%( *,+$#,$ )*;*9 <.*$ 5%$*$*&, =%'&.% $1*+ &3.$ .%9*%'
+:
,&$*)%( 1%.%*,#=&;%-
- 7%#.,%( )&3,+%9 5%$*$*&,%.
+3=A*$+ %..%( 9#< '#)$+ 5#++*,0 *A530,%( (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% <*$1&3$ #55.%)*#$*,0 '#)$ 1#( <.&,094 $#?%,
+- :> &, '#9+% 59%# 1#( +3''%.%( (3% $& (#A#0% $& 1*+ ).&5+ +&<, C1#+.#
&, #))&3,$ &;%.
'9&&(*,0 <#$%.
)#,#9- $ *+ +$#$%( *,'#)$ C1#+.#
=%*,0 3+%( $& (3A5 0#.=#0% 3,*)*5#9 &AA*$$%%:
C3.3?+1%$.#-
$ *+ )&,$%,(%( &,)% 1#( <.&,094 )9#*A%( )&A5%,+#$*&,:
$1%.%'&.%:
*+ ,&$ '*$ )#,(*(#$% $& =% .%$#*,%( 7#A=#.(#.
*+ 9*#=9% $& =% .%A&;%(- ))&.(*,094:
5.#4%.
=%%, A#(% +%$$*,0 #+*(% *A530,%( (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% - - %#.(-
>- , 5.%+%,$ )#+%:
.%A&;%( '.&A 5&+$ 7#A=#.(#.:
;*(% (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% :
5#++%( &99%)$&.:
C3.3?+1%$.#:
&=+%.;*,0 1#( <.&,094 $#?%, ).&5+:
1&<%;%.:
&, #, #55%#9 '*9%( :
+%$ #+*(% (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% :
5#++%( &99%)$&.:
;*(% (#$%( - -
,,%B3.% :
&=+%.;*,0
! " #
#
$%&%'&$% #
()*+,-
$).
#
/ #
# ()*+,-
0
#
1 2 >-
5%.3+#9 #=&;% %B$.#)$%( '*,(*,0 .%$3.,%( <&39( +1&< .%$3.,%( '*,(*,0 5%.
?1#+.# 0*.(#<#.*:
5#((4 ).&5 +$#,(*,0 %;%, +5%)*#9 0*.(#<#.* )#3+%( '9&&( 5.%5#.%( ;%.*'*%( .%;%,3% &''*)%.:
$1%.%'&.%:
+#*( ?1#+.# 0*.(#<#.* )#,,&$ =% *0,&.%(-
1% #'&.%+#*( &=+%.;#$*&, #55#.%,$94 *,(*)#$%+
)9#*A%( A#4 ,&$ =% <.&,0:
1&<%;%.:
#9+& (*.%)$%( $& .%$3.,
+- :> #9&,0<*$1 D *,$%.%+$-
- $ *+ #55&+*$% $& *,(*)#$%
39% >
* #.4#,# 7#,(
%;%,3%
39%+
+1&.$ 67
39%+6 5.&;*(%+ (*+A*++#9 %#(A#,:
<1*)1 .%#(+ 345 - 45
6 45
6 45
-
6 5
6 7
6
8
6
4 5
" *$ (
" *9 6 45
45 - 45 #
6 45
8 7
6 45
6 5/ #
:
! 4;: 5
6 4 5 #
6 45
6 5 -
3
>
-
5%.3+#9 #=&;% %B$.#)$%(
39% > 7
39%+ <&39( *,(*)#$% #$ =%+$ #99%0#$*&,+ 9%;%99%( #0#*,+$ <&39( '#99 )&,+*(%.#$*&,
39% >
**
' 7
39%+:
<1*)1 +$#$%+ %#(A#, A#4 =% (*+A*++%( <1%, *+ &$1%.<*+% +1&<, $& =% *,)&A5%$%,$-
- , 5.%+%,$ )#+%:
35&, )&,+*(%.*,0 A#$$%.
#55#.%,$94 .%$3.,%( '*,(*,0 )9#*A A#4 ,&$ =% *,)&..%)$ $1%.% ?1#+.# 0*.(#<#.* *,(*)#$*,0 +&<*,0 ).&5+ $& &=;*#$% #,4 '3.$1%.
*++3% .%0#.(*,0 <.&,0 )9#*A :
(*.%)$%( $& .%$3., #9&,0<*$1 D *,$%.%+$-
- , A4 )&,+*(%.%( ;*%<:
39% >
* 7
39%+:
$1%.% *+ ,& (*+).%$*&, ;%+$%( <*$1 #3$1&.*$4-
'
#,4 +*$3#$*&,+ +$#$%(
39% >
* *+ #$$.#)$%( $1%, (*+A*++#9 %#(A#, *+ A#,(#$&.4:
<1%.%#+ (*+A*++#9 %#(A#, '#99*,0 #,4 )#$%0&.*%+
39% >
** 7
39%+ *+ ,&$ A#,(#$&.4 )&A5%$%,$ #3$1&.*$4 A#4 5#++ #,4 &$1%.
&.(%.-
- , 5.%+%,$ )#+%:
)1&+%, $& +%$ #+*(% .%A&;#9 (*.%)$*,0 1*A $& .%$3., #9&,0<*$1 D *,$%.%+$-
;*(%,$94:
%B%.)*+%( (*+).%$*&, ;%+$%( 1%.
*$ *+ ,&$ +1&<, $& 1&< (*+).%$*&, %B%.)*+%( *+ #.=*$.#.4:
)#5.*)*&3+:
5%.;%.+% &.
=#( 9#<- - , ;*%< #=&;%:
(& ,&$ '*,( #,4 A%.*$ *,+$#,$ )*;*9 <.*$ 5%$*$*&, +#A% *+ #))&.(*,094 (*+A*++%(-
- %,(*,0 #559*)#$*&,
+:
*'
#,4:
+1#99 #9+& +$#,( )9&+%(-
/
!
- -
+8?+ 1%$1%.
+5%#?*,0.%#+&,%(
"%+
& 1%$1%.
.%5&.$#=9% "%+
&