← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26914/2022disposed of

Prit Paul v. Haryana Shehari Vikas Pradhikaran And Others

2024-09-03Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri15 pages

            

    !"# !$%&%"'( )* *

      

              



 ( + ,*--- 

    

  

 

!



 



 """""

--*

./ # $ 

 

%

      &&'(&&)

 *



+ 

 ,

  

    - ,     .,

        &/ 0) &0&&

2 #34 #' 0/ &0&&1

2 #54 %  

  ,    

%



  

 

 



         

 

    

      

  

 

  

   ! "!#$%

&  

'( 

  )!##*+,-

( 

&.

 /   &

         

    

  +-     % $!##% 

'   

   

   %! % % .



 ( '( 

 ) ) !)+,*- &  

   &

  .  .

 .

&' 0  1  2 

3  

  

.



& (  &  &  &

 &   (    (  

 ..    (  ..  4  & '  .

 .   



   &5& '67'8  .' .

5,  ( 5& ( ,$    



  , & ( & 

  &



'(  ,  ! '           5,  (  5& '  

 7 (  9!' .

'



  ,

 & & 

.

.  ..

 .

 .. .

.   # " *  # $ ! 



( , !!  

   

'8  '8

 : .

' .

' &   ; 

 

     &     

    ,  !' 

.

 ,!!'      & 5&  5,  (5& 4'

' .

 

'

&

# * +,!%-  

   &5& '678  .' .

' 

 ) ) !)+,*- 

 & 

   &

  .  .

 . &' 0  1  2     

  

 (   



) % <   .      

  

 

       

          

..  

& 8    (  ,  *'    

     &   

  &

  3 .             # *       9%  (  ,!%  (   '     . .





  

     & 

 ) ) !)     ( .

 

   4   ('

.



&   &

 3 

 &         

 

 &     

           

     

   .  .

 . &' 0  1  2    

    

( ..



        &



&

    

' 



.    .

(    .

  %! % % 8.

8 .   

 

. &

(  & .

   (  

  ( 



    (  3& =. 8  

  

  ; .

.

.

 



  (





 >         '  .   .    &    '

  

  

    %! % %





&    .

  & 

'  

 '



   

   8  & 

   ( .

 .

 

 

& '

 



 



  

 .& .

.  (   ,  2>'      

..  ?  

 +.

  

7 

 

.1  

. 9 

. - 

' !>=+ 

   @

@-  

 !! % !> 

!+%- 

'    (     ! !#$!  

(  

3



' ( & (   

( 

' ..

.  &



.

  & 

.;

'

 ( &  ( &(     ;

 



.



   

   &

.& .

(

 ( &   .





. (&

 &



.   

 & 

.;

4 



;

   & &



. . 



<& .

   

'

('

0

  ,  

( 

!  

..'      ( .   &     

  (   

 ) <   .       

 

  

  &

 &  & 



.



.  !!  !       &



 .

,%.

&

 &

& 

.

.

&



  &

    &



'  . (   

 ( & 



 &

  &  

  3     

.



. ) ) !) 

   &





. (&

(

   & 



& 



.    

.



.    

 

&   

      (& 





 ,   % .

    .



 



%  

 ,  



  

 6     

 



%

,   %

   ,     %

  ,        

         

  

   %

  ..   %.  

.,

  1

2 #34

%   %   .

  % ,

.

" <   .    &           



  &   .  . 

 &    

   .

       '

  . . .



 

 

 ..

 





( 

& (

      &



' .. ((



. (&  

 .





 .



 . &  .

    & ' '



 

.. * <  .  



 .



  

  .

 .

&' 0  1  2    '   .

.  .

.    

   &    

 &.

 / 

 (   

.  +,2%-'

   3 

  

.

 &  

. .

.

 & ..



   

 



1 $  .  3&  @. 8     

             



   

! 

  

"#$$$ % # 4 ( .  .    !     (.(  

   

  

       &       

  .   (     (  &

,!%

# *   

 &  

  &

 



  &

( ,* &

   



   . ,%.

     (    &     

  

.  



.   !!  !



     !>



% 

'

&



.   



.;

    .

&   ( &

 





!    ( 

 ( . &

 .. 

 

,   . (  .

.



 &

 ) ) !)  

  &



('   '

 &

  &

    &



  

  ( & 

  

   '  &

( ,* ) ) !)

  &

2 



'

 . ( &



 !! ('  &    .  . 



 

 &

   





 '

 

. 



  

 &  &   





  &

      

.



&       .   .      

      

(      .& .

((  

 

 .

'& 

    

  

' '

 

 4 ' 



   8  ( .



  (      .

      

  ..

( . .    

.

'

   ,   

 & 

  &



!   &     .  . 

 &  ( .

 

    



  

    & 

   ' . . 

. ( 

  ..

..



( 

    .  

5,  

 .



( (     

      

     ?



=   (   

   &



 

5(



       

        .    

  

' 

;  . ( 

       &   

.  



.     

  

 ' &   .  . 

 

 & ( .

  

     

.  @.    8     &  '    (  ( A

            

  

 ! "     "   

#  "       

"   $ ! "           %&        "

  '  !"

#$

#%# &'()*+(, ()*) +," -.

!/0 !#.'( *+,(

1 $!2#"#%#" #.', *+,     

  !3 44#5  #6%7

#  ''8, "$1 +  ,  (-' "'  ., ( ..

,     ' "  ) / "            

  00     )++.$!  ',( *+, ,8    

12 #.!-# ''9:+" "    ( ,"    0 33  0 4   "50 )"( 6" .. " 7 37,"       4   " $4!2$; 4##.<

< !'8' *+'   0 0   8      "/ "   %  &" "

  9)   %& 0

8  "  )  #          0 0 !   =1 .

   7#   6%     ''  >+  "      !

 ( 0'

:)* -( .. :) ;,   0 0   01 "''

0: - 9 < <( .7=:)" 73 , 8  5 >( )" 6 " .. "

,"<( )" 6  =. ,"

   <      -' "(= 6

..;"    ?

?

   ?

?

,"                                < +( )"= 6  ..;"

 = 3= ?,"  "                       

"   

  "            % &

    +" "                 "        "!  %&"    "   "          +     7

  8 .   ''8  =8,?''8



8 $# 4!''8 

8"              @  "         $ "    " % !>

 .

.

 



 

   

!

( # =. 8 . A % .

   0  > $ '''8 

 (?'''  =8

"                    

                     <$ >!    "     '" @           -$$ @;#! -!# 1 "

$##$'88  (?">'88  %#1  #,, @    

 

 <   *"  /    '

)  AB  "     !(

.=,"C C"  "     "

 $   " @     

4" !"  ! & !)

 .

 & 

  

     

.      .

( , 2%

  3 

  !" 

  &.    8   



..

 ( .

 

 5( '   & .

   '  .. .

.





 . & 

   .



+,!%- .

.   

 

 !* .  . 

 & 

&  .  .

  C8 . %! % %  &( ,!%



    

   # *  

  .  

                  %!!      

  &+,!%-  



     2 ' D .  

    

  

  

 ) 

 & 

 

' .

     %! % %   

         

    ( 



   

..



   & ( . ( 



&. & 

 .   ' 

   (

    (   9+ - + -

 . & 3& @. 8  )*  

(  8    . &  &  .  . 



(   & ( . 

..

.. & C8 7 &  (  

.



  



     (  5(      .    

      .( 

  

    &    

.

  . & 3& @.

8  )* & ' 

(   A %

$  "

   "    "!   # "        "    "        "  "  "D (,*<3$$$<3$E (50<050-0,

  (,*"   " 

(,*"  !  !"  

(,*   @   "  "     @ 

(,$ "  < "

 "@

  !"  @ 0  & !$ 4( 





 

'

  ..4&

, !% . .& ..



.  ( 2 ' D   



 &    (   ..& ..



.

  

 !#

 %! % %' (

  

   .









 ; .

( 3&

@. 8  )* & ' 

( 4  ' '

 

 (  ..



   .  

 0   ('  ..   , .



       

           , &     .D  

 

  .

 !

 



  &



 

 !>'  &



  (  ,  *         !)    ( .

  





.

 &.

 & 

                

   (    &



 '

 .. .

.      2)' D  .. 

            --   

)* *

  9    ,( 

:

(

9    %

:

(